Vince Russo's 10 Worst WWE Ideas

This I promise you: not once will you see the word 'swerve'... except here.

Vic Venom Wwe
WWE

The story of Vince Russo is wrestling lore nowadays. Once just a video store owner and radio host, Russo managed to land a job at WWE Magazine, where he rose through the ranks. With WCW whipping WWE in the ratings, Vince McMahon decided to listen to the young writer's unconventional ideas, and he was soon promoted to head of creative for the company.

Throughout the first half of the Attitude Era, Vince Russo's unorthodox style of writing, which emphasized a patented "crash TV" style, pushed the limits of what could constitute a professional wrestling program. However, thanks to the talent WWE had, it was successful, as RAW set record ratings and soared past WCW in the Monday Night Wars.

However, once gone from Vince McMahon's guidance, Vince Russo was exposed as... well, not good. His television helped WCW die faster, and squandered the promise of TNA in the 2000s.

But hey, why harp on the negative, you might ask. Sure, Russo fumbled outside of WWE, but at least the early Attitude Era was sunshine and rainbows, right?

No. Sure, WWE has success, but there was a lot of sheen over the manure on TV. For all the success that Vince Russo would like to take credit for in the early Attitude Era, there's a lot of garbage he needs to take blame for.

10. Vince Is The Higher Power

higher power vince undertaker
WWE.com

I know it might seem mean to say this was a bad idea, since, hey, this segment is technically iconic. However, all the appreciation for this moment is when it's stripped totally out of context. People love this the 'Higher Power' reveal because of Vince McMahon's facial expression, the way he says "It's me, Austin," and Jim Ross' exclamation of "Aw, sonofab*ch."

But the storyline which culminated with scene? Crap. And it's indicative of the "write week-to-week" crash TV style that Russo is famous for.

In mid-1999, Undertaker was leading the largest faction in the company: The Ministry of Darkness. Soon, it joined forces with Shane McMahon and The Corporation, and the merged forces were wreaking havoc on WWE - particularly Vince. They went as far as kidnapping a young Stephanie and holding her for ransom. Vince was driven to the point of begging his arch nemesis Steve Austin for help.

Promising start! However, 'Taker soon revealed that he was under the guidance of a higher power. Eventually, that was revealed as... Vince McMahon.

According to Bruce Prichard, Russo's original plan was to debut a then-unknown Christopher Daniels in the role. When Vince nixed that idea, Russo's backup plan: nonsensically contradict months of storytelling.

Look, there's being backed into a corner, and then there's having an idea you know won't make it past pitch, and having no suitable contingency plan.


9. Insane Clown Posse/The Oddities/Howard Stern

Insane Clown Posse
WWE.com

WWE are known for always trying to reach out to the mainstream to get that sweet, sweet exposure. Nowadays, the company plays it safe by having their superstars appear at some tacky awards show, talk show, or ESPN filler. To Russo's credit, in the late '90s, his finger was on the pulse of pop culture that was popular among the WWE's core audience at the time: Howard Stern, Jerry Springer, The Insane Clown Posse, etc.

Unfortunately, it was VinnyRu's attempts to reach out to that corner of culture that made this era of WWE age about as well as all those mentioned above.

The meeting point of all this weirdness was The Oddities, a ragtag stable that included two giants, Luna Vachon, and Earthquake in a mask carrying a Cartman doll. They were weird, awkward, and most embarrassingly, they were on-screen allies of the Insane Clown Posse. (No disrespect, as indie promoters, they've earned their stripes, but this alliance aged terribly)

In addition, Russo brags in one of his autobiographies about bringing the "Wack Pack" on RAW. The 'Wack Pack' is the colorful name for Howard Stern's gang of side characters who are/were known for their physical and/or mental shortcomings. When interviewed about the subject, Bruce Prichard considered the Wack Pack's involvement 'a joke,' and 'a pain in the a**' to deal with backstage.


8. Stephanie McMahon And Test's Relationship

Test Stephanie McMahon Wedding
WWE.com

So, disclosure: despite the many things that fans want to pin on Vince Russo, the decision to end Test and Stephanie McMahon's engagement via Triple H was not his idea. He was long gone by this point.

However, the idea of Stephanie and Andrew Martin becoming a couple was the brainchild of Russo. On his podcast, Bruce Prichard asserts that Russo, as he's been praised for in the past, was very keen on pushing new talent and giving them prominent roles. One of those talents was the newly-debuted Test. At the time, Russo allegedly wanted to push Martin as the new bodyguard of D-Generation X. After a while, he would eventually break out on his own after finding his groove.

DX apparently weren't keen on having the very-green Test among their ranks, and as they were in the ears of Vince McMahon, the idea was scrapped.

Instead of taking the loss and letting Test find his own in developmental, Russo decided to force Martin into a contrived and awkward relationship with Stephanie McMahon. The ultimate payoff of this angle (i.e. Triple H drugging Steph and marrying her before Test could) came after Russo was gone from the company. However, the decision to push Test into a no-win situation falls squarely on Russo, by all accounts.


7. Mr. Ass Wins King Of The Ring

Billy Gunn King Of The Ring 1999 Win
WWE.com

Billy Gunn was a hard worker throughout all the '90s. Whether it was his runs with the Smoking Gunns, New Age Outlaws, or his unfortunate run as The Honky-Tonk Man's protege (Rock-A-Billy, anyone?), Billy gave his all in any role, and whether it was it was his look or athleticism, he gave his all with whatever he was given. However, no amount of hard work can overcome such a ridiculous name as "Mr. Ass."

Basically, in the late '90s, Billy Gunn was given the moniker of "Badass Billy Gunn." Eventually, such a nickname was morphed into having a posterior-based gimmick. The appropriately-named "Mr. Ass" was not really received with the necessary cheers or boos, more just confusion or indifference. As a result, Billy Gunn winning the King of the Ring in 1999, rather than being treated as an all-time career accomplishment, was treated as just a matter-of-fact at the time, and a huge embarrassment nearly 20 years later.

After this achievement, "Mr. Ass" Billy Gunn was ultimately buried by The Rock months later at SummerSlam, and he slid firmly into a midcard role. Regardless of his trajectory after the incident, the fact that Vince Russo thought pushing "Mr. Ass" as King of the Ring would help Billy Gunn says a lot of what Mr. Russo thinks about what actually gets over.


6. The Artist Formerly Known As Goldust

goldust wwe
WWE.com

Goldust was one of Vince McMahon's pet projects of the mid '90s. A purposefully provocative character that played on the homophobic attitudes of WWE's audience, the early heel run of Goldust managed to be Dustin Runnels' biggest stretches of success. However, backlash from the network and LGBT advocacy groups forced the company to tone down the homoerotic tendencies, and the character was turned face in early '97. When that proved to be a non-starter, and with WWE deciding to buck decency standards and embrace Attitude, Vince Russo decided he needed to help Goldust find a new edge.

After breaking up with his then-wife Terri Runnels, Dustin re-emerged with Luna Vachon as "The Artist Formerly Known as Goldust." The obvious reference to Prince's former stage name aside, this incarnation of Goldust was completely alien to anyone who was watching. Coming out in strange makeup and various S&M attire, as well as reciting nonsense promos where he would talk in a camp voice and read Dr. Seuss, TAFKAG was Russo's attempt to find anything provocative that would get people to boo Goldust again.

Unfortunately, because they went so bizarre and esoteric with his incarnation, people were only really invested in Luna and her shrill voice. Goldust eventually just became her lackey and the fourth wheel in their feud with Sable and Marc Mero.


5. Beaver Cleavage

Beaver Cleavage, mother
WWE.com

In early 1999, Headbanger Thrash was sidelined with an injury. Given that the Headbangers had lost momentum as a tag team, and that Mosh (Chaz Warrington) was still healthy, WWE decided a gimmick change was in order. What did creative come up with?

Well, unfortunately, Vince Russo decided to take an office in-joke to a dark place. According to Bruce Prichard, Warrington was nicknamed "Beaver Cleaver," due to his resemblance to the classic TV star of Leave it to Beaver. Ergo: Chaz was repackaged as "Beaver Cleavage," a manchild with a voluptuous mother named "June" who made incestuous innuendo in vignettes.

Best as I can theorize: this was Vince Russo's attempt at recreating the success he found with boundary-pushing sex gimmicks such as Val Venis in 1998. However, the thing about Val Venis is that, aside from the racy pornstar gimmick, ultimately, he was a tried-and-true wrestling archetype: a sleazy, well-built ladies' man, not unlike Ravishing Rick Rude. People saw Val Venis and they understood how to respond to it, positive or negative.

With Beaver Cleavage? How does an audience respond to an incestuous manchild parody of a '50s TV show other than confusion and discomfort? That's not heel heat, that's "I am extremely ashamed that this is what I watch in my free time" non-heat.


4. The Downfall Of The LOD Storyline

LOD 2000
WWE.com

(Content Warning: this isn't our normal MO, but if you have dealt with the issue of suicide, be it with yourself or with loved ones, we sincerely suggest skipping this.)

In Russo's defense, 1998 was a year when both WWE and WCW decided to tackle addiction in really tasteless manners. Down in Atlanta, WCW thought it would be a great idea to turn Scott Hall's real-life alcoholic tailspin into heat for the Wolfpac's feud with nWo Hollywood. This included Hall "pretending" to be drunk in promos and "pretending" to wrestle drunk. Neither company came off looking well with these.

However, it seems as though more people remember WWE's attempts at capitalizing on Road Warrior Hawk's struggles with substance abuse. Probably because they crossed the line way further than basic decency would suggest they should.

Basically, the Legion of Doom were going nowhere in WWE in mid-1998, so Vince Russo's solution? Make a storyline out of Hawk's drug and alcohol issues "ruining" the team. Part of this involved Animal introducing Darren "Puke" Drozdov as a third member to help stabilise the team. The apex of this storyline came on an episode of RAW when Hawk climbed the Titantron threatening suicide, and Puke climbed up top attempting to bring him down. Puke "accidentally" pushed Hawk off, ostensibly killing him.

With 2018 eyes, it should be clear how disgusting this is.


3. Terri Runnels' Miscarriage

pretty mean sisters
WWE.com

(Oh, good gravy.)

So, in late-1998, there was a faction of some of the women of WWE. It consisted of Jacqueline, Ryan Shamrock, and Terri Runnels. This group was called the Pretty Mean Sisters (AKA: PMS, do ya get it? DO YA GET IT?!).

Anyway, Terri joined this group soon after claiming she was pregnant with the child of Val Venis. Val denied the fatherhood of said child. However, Terri remained steadfast with her pregnancy, up until an early 1999 episode of RAW.

In that episode, she was knocked off the apron by an unwilling D'Lo Brown (whom PMS was managing at the time), When knocked off, Terri feigned injury and distress, and in a backstage segment later on in the episode, she claimed she couldn't feel the baby moving. Simply put: Vince Russo and Ed Ferrara wrote a miscarriage angle. It didn't boost ratings, increase PPV buys, or even merch sales. It was completely pointless.

Worse yet? That episode was the same one where Mick Foley won his first-ever WWE title against The Rock. In a sense, this angle is forgiven by the fact that the episode is remembered for Foley's win, but to have this segment alongside it? Lord knows how many people there were who didn't bother to tune into that title match after seeing this terrible nonsense.


2. The Blue Blazer Repels From The Ceiling

Owen Hart The Blue Blazer
WWE.com

(Mother of God)

I don't want to blame Vince Russo for Owen. Even as I blast his ideas, I don't want to pin a man's death on him.

That all said: who the hell thought it was so vital to have a throwaway midcard act in such a situation? Who was it that pitched to Owen, a man deathly afraid of heights, that he should rappel from the ceiling and come down to the ring?

This is really uncomfortable to write, because I seriously don't want to write about how Vince Russo is a murderer or how he orchestrated the death of Owen Hart. However, from his own testimony, the events that led to such a tragedy came at his volition (i.e. he thought that Owen would be perfect to be the guy to rappel from the ceiling).

And even after such a horrible event? Russo, or whoever he was working with, decided that in TNA's early stages, it would be good for the company to have Roddy Piper to come out and confront Russo directly about Owen's death.

This was an era where Russo was claiming he was the Anti-Christ of wrestling. What's more devilish than tacitly admitting you were responsible for a wrestler's death? Not saying he was, but he certainly didn't shy away from that controversy when it was convenient for him.


1. The Brawl For All

Steve Blackman Mark Mero Brawl For All
WWE.com

It's a tale as old as time, and Vince Russo will tell it to you himself as he famously did in a KayfabeCommentaries shoot: once upon a time, JBL (then known as Bradshaw), was bragging to anyone who would listen that he could take on anyone in a legitimate fight. Russo, who was not a fan of Bradshaw, came up with an idea that would increase the chances of Bradshaw getting his head kicked in.

Now before the anti-JBL readers out there start praising Russo for his idea, just know: that idea was the Brawl For All. Roundly mocked as one of the worst ideas in WWE history, the bizarre boxing-wrestling hybrid shoot tournament wasted countless television time in 1998, bored crowds to anger, and hurt many careers. Obviously, there was the issue of shoving people of various combat experience in a legit fighting tournament, resulting in many midcarders (Godfather, Steve Blackman, Hawk, etc) getting injured.

And of course, being that it was a shoot, when the eventual winner of the tournament was a guy they had absolutely zero plans for (Bart Gunn), that meant there was zero meaningful payoff.

Oh, my mistake. Bart Gunn got a singles match at the following WrestleMania... where he was knocked out by Butterbean in a boxing match.

Bro, Vince, can I be honest with you, bro? Why?


In this post: 
Vince Russo
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.