What AEW's Second Show MUST Look Like

AEW would do well to take inspiration from a very unlikely source...

FTR Young Bucks
AEW

The deal struck in January, but withheld as a result of the ongoing/never-ending new world, Executive Vice President Cody recently confirmed to TV Insider that the "third hour" of AEW programming will "present itself soon," and that its imminent arrival explains AEW's recent recruitment drive.

AEW's third hour, as a minimum, must barely resemble Dynamite. This is imperative.

Dynamite, and recent trends indicate that viewership may very well follow the discourse one day, has become the most talked-about show of the week. NXT has declined and even before it did, Dynamite was too seismic to discuss within the parameters of a "War" for too long. SmackDown has quietly evolved into an actually worthy show - at points - but it's on the wrong night to light up the Twittersphere. Moreover, it remains a main roster WWE show with an attendant nihilism that renders deep investment all but pointless, to say nothing of the various tropes and scripted creative philosophies that will forever diminish a performer's ability to become a true superstar. These issues are amplified to the point of total parody over on Monday Night RAW which, to be frank but virtually objective, is a f*cking joke.

AEW Dynamite is special. It is appointment, must-see television that means something. Tony Khan in 2020 has perfected a superb blend of build and payoff, contriving to create immense anticipation for the pay-per-view matches and the weekly bouts alike.

Virtually everything you would want in a professional wrestling programme - great action, great promos, great storyline development - is folded into a vibrant and interconnected shared universe that spawns match combinations with breezy, immersive continuity. The range proves divisive, but that's the buffet.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Kilynn King AEW Dark
AEW

And even when the show isn't top-to-bottom great, individual greatness emerges. Dynamite must be preserved. Khan has perfected something very challenging in the streaming age - those who love the show face an agonising wait for the next one - and this appeal cannot be diluted nor overexposed.

The third hour must also barely resemble Dark. Dark is useful for stat-padding, but is it really? Often, when a new contender emerges through the ranking system, it resonates as a surprise. A run of wins lacks gravity and credibility, when it's on the lesser show and comes at the expense of some flown-in ham-and-eggers. It's nice that AEW goes to the trouble, but there's a certain dissonance that comes with, for example, Scorpio Sky's win/loss record and his visibility. Dark in name literally cannot be a TV show. It's a nice little earner on the side that doubles as an exercise in grading new talent and appeasing those who don't get much in the way of premium TV time.

AEW might have already piloted this third hour for a long, long time in the form of its superb 'Road To' series.

An ad hoc YouTube exclusive, it is phenomenal in how it deepens the heft of the matches it profiles. The Road To Saturday Night Dynamite very gently foreshadowed Cody's fall to Mr. Brodie Lee. Cody, who excels in the intimate sit-down environment as much as he does screaming fire down the lens, was all too eager to put himself over as the hardest-working member of the roster. He developed a hubris that made the events of August 22 that bit more coherent - for those who watched it.

The Lucha Bros., who don't get much time on the mic, were fabulous on the Road To Fight For The Fallen.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Arn Anderson
AEW

They challenged FTR to be "bastards, like us". Fénix brightened his aggressive tone to the point of sweetness when he asked his older brother for the perfect word, which Penta deadpanned. These guys are genuinely really funny. This sort of character revelation is explored wonderfully on Road To, but there's only so much TV time. And on a TV show that retains the most viewers in the ring, you are most certainly going to put the Lucha Bros. in it. Their former Death Triangle stablemate PAC got himself over in a big way on the Road To the Bahamas, too. "I excel at all disciplines of professional wrestling," he said, as the exclamation mark on an exceptional vignette that depicted him as a major star.

Beyond these neat character profiles, the marquee Dynamite matches are built as real, big-time occasions through the use of the talking heads trope. This is the absolute best use of Jim Ross. Removed from the live environment in which he has to feign enthusiasm for matches that aren't his sh*t, he expertly applies his authority and gravitas to enhances the matches he does give a toss about. Arn Anderson does this very well too, using his trademark soulful economy to illustrate the scope of the threat facing his man Cody. On the Road To Jericho, he did this by saying, simply, "Hell's comin'" to frame Mr. Brodie Lee as the monster he is.

The Road To is tremendous at deepening Dynamite's brilliance. In theory, it is the perfect template for a third hour that needs to complement and not detract from the flagship show. WhatCulture Wrestling's Adam Wilbourn devised a neat name for such a show, given its thematic purpose and link to Dynamite: AEW Fuse.

There's an inherent, age-old problem with adapting a series like this to national television; for as fondly as most of us hardcores recall a great video package, and like to delve as deep into a story as we can, they are ratings death.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Ricky Starks Darby Allin Brian Cage
AEW

The wrestling fan who chooses to watch live does so primarily for live professional wrestling matches. For the third hour to work, as the commercial revenue driver all of this ultimately is, it needs to promote big-time pro wrestling.

AEW, if the third hour becomes Dynamite lite, runs the risk of burning through its combinations. There are loads we've not yet seen - even undercard fare, like the inevitable Brodie Lee Vs. John Silver/Colt Cabana matches, are left to simmer and in theory mean more when they happen - but the novelty AEW has thus far preserved may lower in value. The longer 2020 rolls on, the more frequently AEW runs matches back. Cody hung a lantern on this trend last week, but his acknowledgment doesn't entirely excuse it.

A balance is required, and to manage it, AEW would do well to take inspiration from a very unlikely source: WWE Main Event. Not Main Event in its current incarnation, but the 2012 launch. The debut episode was headlined by a Champion Vs. Champion clash between CM Punk and Sheamus. The match itself was sold through promos and video packages in the first half of the show as a big deal worthy of your time and its own platform.

Something adjacent to this might address that balance. Certain Dynamite matches need more time than they are allocated. Darby Allin Vs. Ricky Starks from September 24 was awesome - a kinetic, details-rich war so tight in its grip of the audience - but it went 09:59 in the opening slot.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Jungle Boy Luchasaurus
AEW

Maybe it didn't need to be longer. The opener, free of commercial interruption, is a coveted and important slot. But that match had been built for months, and boasted a tremendous character dynamic worked with an authentic tone of animosity. What was great could have been even better, were that ace, hate-fuelled story profiled through the Road To lens at the start of a show dedicated almost entirely to it. An extra five minutes, to elevate it to true classic status, would not have hurt it at all.

Using this additional time to address good faith criticisms - how exactly are the rankings formulated, and what exactly drives the connections within certain stables? - can only further cement the bond AEW has forged with its ardent base.

Between the build and the main, AEW should, in addition to rolling out those excellent character profiles, promote matches that occupy the uneasy space between Dark and Dynamite. This third hour is the vehicle with which to get Scorpio Sky over and to keep those well above the Dark tier - like Santana and Ortiz, and Jungle Boy - in the rotation.

The balance is a challenge; the third hour must embrace and tacitly market itself as the secondary, supplementary show without relegating it to the diehard filler realm in which Dark sits.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Hikaru Shida
AEW/Lee South

Presenting a midcard programme under the lights of a featured main event can only illustrate how deep that bench is and measure who can really bring it. The third hour can continue to enable the meritocracy at AEW's core.

However the third hour manifests, it is imperative that it addresses the rot within the Women's division. This week's segment with Hikaru Shida was a joke. Upcoming Full Gear opponent Nyla Rose hasn't even won any token Dynamite squash matches of late. If anything, much as it's great to see a breakout star of her quality return, Nyla really should have mowed through a pair of jobbers in Britt Baker's place.

AEW didn't even do the bare minimum to build a match that is totally backwards - we've already seen the stipped-up original, this doesn't even work as a lazy sequel - much less plot a story advanced through angles and promo segments.

The AEW Women's division is a paradox from which there is no escape on Wednesdays: the women are largely too green to warrant valuable TV time, but they won't get any less green working so infrequently.

The third hour does represent that escape, and it will indict AEW, formally, if nothing changes.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!