Why AEW Has Just Pulled Off The Mother Of All Game-Changers

CM Punk and Daniel Bryan: the elusive bridge to the last lapsed fans?

cm punk daniel bryan
WWE

The word "surely" has reverberated around the pro wrestling fandom in recent months.

Surely, AEW Dynamite is on track to defeat WWE RAW consistently in the 18-49 Nielsen demographic and maybe even in overall viewership. The former already happened last week in the male demo, and there's a creeping sense that things are changing. Put simply: one show is too good, and one too sh*tty, for it not to happen. It's not just an incredulous, romantic, how-can-it-not notion, either.

With the wild news that broke yesterday, "surely" has never felt more viable: per Sean Ross Sapp of Fightful and Bodyslam's Cassidy Haynes respectively, AEW are set to bring in CM Punk and Daniel Bryan. Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter hasn't confirmed Haynes' report, but has said on Observer Radio that "all signs point to the deal being done". It was Meltzer himself who speculated that Bryan was AEW-bound a few weeks back before a firmer report surfaced overnight. Nothing is yet official. The Punk deal in particular is always going to feel more precarious from the outside looking in; it was reported in July 2019 that neither party was on good terms. Punk ribbed Cody for allegedly texting him in an offer, if you recall.

These reports do however align with Tony Khan's cryptic teases that he has more than one major surprise lined up over the next few months, and AEW is the listening company. He knows better than to tempt fate with a Christian Cage-level name, not that Cage hasn't slotted in very well subsequently.

But if it does happen, Jesus Christ.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Fiend Goldberg
WWE

The Wednesday Night Wars was always a misnomer because AEW was not at war with NXT, which, after a period of turbulence on Dynamite that unfolded in parallel with WWE stacking Wednesdays with main roster talent, wasn't a war but a massacre.

The gulf between AEW and NXT in July 2021 is enormous. If the war itself was a bloodbath, NXT is still stained with a dark, browny red, its once hallowed reputation spattered all over the canvas. The idea that NXT is an alternative has haemorrhaged, with every fire unscripted AEW promo, and now that Vince McMahon himself think it's in the mud, it really is in the mud. WWE positioned NXT as a siphon in fear of AEW mounting a challenge to RAW, and this is now a reality. John Cena and Goldberg brought the boost on Monday, but how often have we been here? We've been here so long that WWE almost created its own competition. Years and years of creatively bankrupt part-timer entitlement hasn't done anything but create long-term resentment, upon which Tony Khan capitalised.

And do you know what is the truly impressive part?

Despite this incredible, game-changing news breaking hours before AEW Dynamite aired, not a single soul in the Curtis Culwell Center hijacked the show and chanted his name, even during the quieter moments - and there were quite a few on an uneven show. Frankie Kazarian's in-theory-awesome Elite Hunter gimmick just didn't connect, the Andrade segment was long, confusing, underwhelming, and Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Nyla Rose took a considerable amount of time to get going.

And still, the crowd did not demand some dreamlike projection.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


CM Punk John Cena
WWE

Even if they were not going banana at the action, they were polite about it. There was absolutely no sense that they were waiting for some saviour figure in the wings, in contrast to recent protests for Becky Lynch on WWE shows. AEW doesn't necessarily need CM Punk or Daniel Bryan to satisfy their base because the base is incredibly enthusiastic about the existing product. Punk and Bryan are bonuses to a roster that has established itself as a legitimate #1 hit on cable. MJF, Darby Allin, Dr. Britt Baker: all are 'homegrown' AEW acts that have proven themselves capable of drawing quarter hours. Allin has generated three of AEW's best four quarters in 2021. CM Punk and Daniel Bryan aren't desperation signings; they are complement pieces to a puzzle WWE just can't seem to solve, irrespective of how much they counter-programme or how many part-time superstars they exhume.

Moreover, it was thought AEW needed something to pop ticket sales for the ambitious Grand Slam Dynamite at Arthur Ashe stadium. This wasn't the case; without a single match announced, with tickets going on sale weeks before these rumours emerged, a hot product sold a show on the strength of itself with the tacit promise of something big. That at time of writing 15,999 people trust AEW to deliver something big is a robust indicator of the company's brand value. This company is trending upwards.

Just to temper expectations somewhat: neither CM Punk nor Daniel Bryan were consistently strong, needle-moving TV draws when they "enjoyed" their maximum level of exposure. Punk, a massive merch-shifter who performed well on pay-per-view as WWE oversaturated the model, toiled against the imposition of the third RAW hour when it was introduced in 2012. Bryan in 2014 was resisted as the top guy, despite such overwhelming support from live crowds, because ratings actually dwindled on the road to WrestleMania XXX.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

But then, neither man - to considerable, era-defining protest - were presented at the tippy-top.

WWE never positioned Punk at John Cena's level and were so weirdly intent on knocking Bryan off his perch. Vince McMahon never put the entire marketing machine behind either, and this, in parallel with the total failure to launch the Roman Reigns babyface act, is when the rot set in. As brilliantly mapped out by Brandon Thurston of Wrestlenomics, while #CancelWWENetwork did not result in mass subscription cancellations, the dire events of January 25, 2015 were a major factor behind WWE losing its TV audience at a level that accelerated beyond wider cable trends. The convergence of several nightmarish realities was the impetus behind WWE's shocking decline.

In the early-to-mid 2010s, CM Punk and Daniel Bryan exemplified the WWE that WWE fans wanted WWE to be in an age of vocal defiance. When that vision did not materialise, millions, plural, left WWE behind. Several years have elapsed since then. Those millions are not at all guaranteed to hop to TNT if and when Punk and Bryan debut. Many of them have likely moved on with their lives, and those that did not in all likelihood make up much of AEW's core base. This might just be the ultimate dose of fan service rather than a real, game-changing driver of growth.

The bad faith misconception is that AEW has somehow failed because it hasn't "brought back" Attitude Era fans. This is simply not true, nor was it ever a realistic goal - but attracting the scorned WWE fans of the mid-2010s, or at least enough of them to topple RAW and make the next round of rights fees negotiations very interesting, is not an implausible scenario.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Darby Allin Coffin
AEW (@AEW, Twitter)

Punk and Bryan will, at a minimum, pop a monster number on their first Dynamite appearances. This is guaranteed, and here's the interesting part: as reflected in the strong average numbers pulled since the return to Wednesdays, and an almost unanimous critical reception, AEW is killing it. Those additional, curious viewers are likely to stick with the product on recent form. Dynamite has ruled since resuming live touring.

AEW used to divide critical opinion, contrary to gotten-to claims that the wrestling media is in Tony Khan's pocket. AEW did tremendously well to excel during a pandemic era that somehow wasn't good if bittersweet. It was simply very, very good, mostly, but not unanimously so. It took forever to get Miro right, and most people hated it. FTR's Tag Team Title run while excellent chafed against the idea that AEW rotated its cast effectively. All Out 2020 invited a creeping criticism that things got too whacky in a Stadium Stampede dragon-chase by maxing out the appetite for stipulation matches.

Post-Revolution 2021, beyond a middling, phoned-in run on Fridays, AEW has been on fire. AEW has established an identity, after so much tiresome discourse about what it actually was; in 2021, it is simply the very good promotion that has mastered every awesome quality required from episodic wrestling TV to be awesome: excellent in-ring, quality unscripted promos, wild, electrifying angles. AEW is undeniable, to use its own copy. Surely, two major bridge figures will spike numbers to a level that will make Vince McMahon take a sh*t with his trousers on. CM Punk's return in particular is an enormous prospect. He's been gone seven years, during which time his iconoclastic legend has only deepened - particularly since WWE has declined so spectacularly that he is almost a soothsayer. The Backstage thing was daft, but nobody will give a f*ck about that or his UFC run when he cuts his first incendiary promo.

The question then extends to what Punk and Bryan can do to maintain viewership.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Vince McMahon
WWE

CM Punk can't play heel for at least year. He could, but Tony Khan would be pissing in the wind. Nobody is going to boo him. His body will be ready. He has avoided seven years of wear and tear, and is only 42. He's the average age of a WWE main roster headliner. And if he can't play to his strengths immediately, he'll have a hell of a time pitching ideas for heels to get heat on him, even if he wishes he were on the other side of the ring. He was phenomenal in his day, and if there's an argument to be made that others have ran with his style, it won't matter. He will exude a megastar aura in the context of AEW. And when he does turn, there's a certain anxious beer enthusiast he can finally work with to get the very best facet of his militant straight edge act over.

Bryan is different - he was presented at the upper midcard level in WWE just this year before a WrestleMania rewrite - but in the opinion of many, including your writer, he is the superior talent. He is one of the very best pro wrestlers to ever do it - a storytelling wizard so powerful that he can get anybody he works with massively over. He is a genius. He headlined WrestleMania this year. He is a get.

How big a get, if in fact AEW get him?

Time will tell, but a better product boasting Daniel Bryan, CM Punk, Kenny Omega, Jon Moxley, Chris Jericho, Sting, Darby Allin, Hangman Page, the Young Bucks, Britt Baker, MJF, and more versus a dog-sh*t product boasting Bobby Lashley, Randy Orton, Riddle, John Morrison, and Alexa Bliss?

The game is changing.

How can it not be?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!