Why Daniel Bryan Winning Royal Rumble 2018 Would Be WWE's Biggest Ever Pop
Yep.
Rumours persist that Daniel Bryan’s medical status is not definitively clear. According to the man himself, every last doctor, of some repute, has declared Bryan fit to wrestle following the experimental hyperbaric oxygen treatment he has undergone in an attempt to repair his damaged brain tissue.
It’s the experimental nature of the treatment, the long-term ramifications of which aren’t yet known, that has precluded WWE Medical Director Dr. Joseph Maroon from giving Bryan the all-clear. Consequently, Bryan is marooned in a General Managerial role the likes of which, as his flippant no-f*cks disposition suggests, offers him no creative gratification whatsoever. He wants to wrestle.
This great unknown is a far greater threat to WWE than any boring Batista Vs. Randy Orton main event, which, realistically, would not have altered the landscape in any meaningful way. If the worst were to happen - if WWE cleared Bryan, and he died in the middle of the ring - this would be catastrophic. Perhaps even more so than the Chris Benoit double murder-suicide. WWE in 2007 were forced to alter their entire business ethos under accusation of indirect responsibility. Direct legal responsibility, especially in this age of increased concussion awareness, smears the blood all over WWE’s hands - and repels virtually any corporate sponsor of any repute. WWE’s stance might not be popular. It might not be, and gauging by its past likely isn’t, altruistic. But it is entirely understandable. The cause-and-effect is both disastrous and precipitous.
That said: as long as Bryan inspires hope, we will feel it. That is the foundation on which his WWE career was built - and the foundation of what would perhaps be the greatest, loudest reaction ever in the rowdy history of the company.
Competition is fierce. CONT'D...
The arrival of Steve Austin, as Mankind battled The Rock for the WWF Title on the January 4, 1999 RAW was as loud as it was impressive; those fans, having endured hours of marathon taped action, roared their heads off. The pitch was almost brown note-low. It was primal. The fatigue-induced delay that really brings it into focus, even after the umpteenth re-watch; the fans were too tired to register it, for a nanosecond, before the sheer love for the man stirred them from their slumber. Parents don’t even spark into life that quickly at the sound of their crying babies.
CM Punk’s entrance at Money In The Bank 2011 saw a convergence of life-affirming change and pure, intense regionalism magnified into a deafening din. Seth Rollins’ WrestleMania 31 Money In The Bank cash-in sparked a relief-driven cacophony. Triple H’s early 2002 return from a quad injury capped off a sentiment expertly massaged through sympathy-generating vignettes. Even a comparatively lesser star like Dolph Ziggler commanded a megastar reaction when he cashed in his Money In The Bank briefcase on the post-WrestleMania 29 RAW.
The Great Montreal Fake-out Of 2006 is the closest spiritual antecedent, in that Hart’s home crowd were promised by Shawn Michaels in a superb heel performance a hugely improbable and emotional return. When it didn’t happen, the cackling Michaels somehow failed to incite a riot. Mercifully, that era and that mentality had long since faded.
Bryan’s pop might even dwarf those volcanic reactions. The emotional drivers are both plural and incredibly potent; such a pop would conflate the aforementioned emotions and converge them into something unprecedented.
After the now-customary Big 4 PPV marathon, the Philadelphia fans will be fatigued, come the main event. Historical precedent suggests that genuine star power is immune to it. CM Punk was the hero of Chicago in 2011; Bryan reached the pinnacle of his popularity because he was so thoroughly relatable to the 99%. The relief factor, too, is immeasurable, especially since the Rumble match itself has, in recent years, symbolised both a regression to the past and an almost antagonistic vision of the future. The goodwill afforded to Triple H, forged through respect, turned him face. In the case of Bryan, it would turn him from hero to myth.
Since the Attitude Era, in which the heat sustained itself throughout almost every show, reactions are significantly more polarised in the more polarising modern era. This explains why, within the pockets of silence, comparatively smaller moments, like Dolph Ziggler claiming a glorified midcard title, are received with such noise. With the metric skewed through so much ambivalence elsewhere, a moment genuinely legendary in itself would positively drown out a pop driven by a game of catch-up. CONT'D...
Moreover, the site of the pop itself - the Royal Rumble - is synonymous with WWE’s mishandling of Daniel Bryan. It is the last level in a game as difficult - and unfair - as Battletoads. The sheer incredulity of it all, the sheer relief, would feel like victory for Bryan and the fans alike - a true win evoking the inimitable rush of your sports team battling against the steepest odds.
There is also the Final Boss to consider: Roman Reigns. Whether in defiance of the man himself, or what he symbolises, the overwhelming majority of fans don’t want the Big Dog to point at the WrestleMania sign. He has essentially pointed to it since April 2, 2017 - if not far longer. Anybody but Roman, is the mentality. Amplify that sentiment, with the pipe dream pick, and the reaction becomes amplified to an unprecedented extent.
Philadelphia, too, is a traditional WWE stronghold. Their fans are often very loud, and fully attuned to this anti-Reigns sentiment: they rained down the jeers three years ago. Virtually nothing - and that’s the problem - has changed. That toxic reaction would amplified through the familiarity-breeds-yet-more-contempt principle. Subverting it in this fashion is the very formula of euphoria.
Certain bookmakers slashed the odds on a Bryan win recently, but they’re an opportunistic and unscrupulous bunch; some of them are still offering long odds on Kenny Omega, despite his recently re-signing with New Japan Pro Wrestling. Their word is far, far from gospel.
Daniel Bryan securing victory in the 2018 Royal Rumble would not represent the realisation of an improbable dream, but the impossible dream. Whether it should remain impossible is a story for another day.
It’s probably not going to happen - but, if it were to happen, Vince McMahon would have to remove his metaphorical earplugs in place of the real deal.