Why Dave Meltzer Is RIGHT About Kenny Omega
Devil's sky in the detail.
In a recent statement that annoyed the same people such statements typically annoy, the Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer wrote the following on the F4W boards:
"Nobody in history has ever put more thought and more layers of storytelling in a match than Kenny Omega. It's ridiculous. That's why when you watch his matches over and over you see more each time. That's what makes him so great."
He was right.
Kenny Omega - and since the title will inflame certain people irrespective of the content, one might as well go all in - is almost too intelligent for the American television wrestling audience. That is a confrontational stance, but too many people insist that he has failed to transition to the new medium. In some ways, perhaps he has. A more accurate way of putting it might be that the medium itself needs to adjust to a performer of Omega's ambition.
Consider his match with Trent on the April 1, 2020 Dynamite. It didn't need to be anything other than a great opening match. With so much AEW talent locked down, it was promoted tacitly as just that; outside of the TNT Title tournament that was booked tremendously, under high-pressure circumstances, there was little scope nor time to tell a traditional TV story. This, as framed by the opening handshake, was a tale of two babyfaces, with no preexisting tension, working a competitive contest in the trenches because the context demanded it. There was nothing else to do but wrestle in front of their peers to determine who the best man was on the night.
But it also wasn't.
CONT'D...(1 of 6)
Trent, sensing an opportunity for something more than that - a win over one of AEW's biggest stars - targeted Omega's injured hand to alter what was a plain dynamic and mutate the tone of sportsmanship into something far nastier and more compelling.
This transgression opened up the narrative and justified the brutality of the final third, in which Omega and Trent, driven now by something else, spiked each other onto the apron and the floor with vicious suplex variations. Omega, surveying this new and theoretically constrictive environment - this was QT Marshall's tiny, barely-dressed wrestling school - looked at the pillar, saw an opportunity to do something cool, and smashed Trent into it with a powerbomb. This was a gruesome spot earned by the theme of vengeance developed in the match. Everything that might have felt excessive did not because of the level of detail Omega applied to his work. It was a situationally perfect match in the least ideal situation pro wrestling has ever found itself in.
Omega didn't just do a bittersweet, uncanny emulation of wrestling in lockdown; Omega did lockdown wrestling.
His iconic, controversial Lights Out war with Jon Moxley at Full Gear was another match loaded with detail. Omega's condescending dig at Moxley's pure wrestling ability - "What, are you gonna chain wrestle me Jon?" - was avenged, literally, with a steel chain wrapped around his teeth. In a match in which Omega "lowered" himself to Mox's artless level, Mox transcended his perception as a dumb, tough meathead in victory.
CONT'D...(2 of 6)
Virtually every weapon used was a visual extension of the story and character - Omega, the artist, built a torture device, Moxley crawled through broken glass to symbolise his perseverance - and the finish used symbolism to put over its gravity. With the ring canvas torn up, Omega, his wrestling heart still in Japan, attempted best friend Kota Ibushi's Phoenix splash. He failed. Much like the wooden boards, he was, poetically, exposed as the failed U.S. singles TV star. He had lost, and had to enter tag team competition in a bid to prove himself.
On the February 26, 2020 Dynamite, Omega defeated PAC in a phenomenal 30 minute Iron Man match. PAC had countered his One-Winged Angel at every turn (with a poison 'rana in just one electrifying moment). Omega had to draw on something else to secure the win. He did not use the Buckshot lariat nor anything else from the arsenal of his partner and fellow World Tag Team Champion Hangman Page. He used Ibushi's Kamigoye finish before finally executing his own.
The PAC bout contrasted with Hangman Page's performance in the seminal Revolution match against the Young Bucks - his own arsenal exhausted, he respected Omega's enough to hit the One-Winged Angel - to a level of pathos that was aching, were you informed enough to detect the story beat. Was Hangman Page the glory hog, exploding into the win after the hot tag? Or was he just desperate to prove himself Elite? In the same, incredible match, Omega showed the most fire he ever has in AEW when kicking out of the Golden Trigger at what was barely a one count. The Golden Trigger was his double team finish with Kota Ibushi.
Would Omega have shown the same fire, had one of the Bucks used the Dead Eye?
CONT'D...(3 of 6)
The real hero in this ongoing saga was very subtly revealed on February 29, months and months before it was made explicit in the narrative. The very best professional wrestlers master the space between moves to extract the most from the moves themselves. Omega does this too, but he also doubles the meaning of his moves. And if you did not detect the story beat, it did not matter.
It was, to those unfamiliar with the mythology of the Golden Lovers, a perfectly-timed moment of badass babyface fire. Omega's work is at once esoteric and primal. There are - yes - levels to this sh*t. Kenny Omega is a professional wrestler capable of placing subtext into his matches to deepen their narrative heft. We are so far removed from blading to get the marks onside in the carny days that it's not even funny.
The version of Kenny Omega that fans have wanted - the conquering singles Ace - manifested last night in an absolutely sublime top-to-bottom presentation. What a heel turn. What a magnificently cruel heel turn this was and is; Omega, with his deliberately, hilariously on-the-nose grandiose "I'm a big star" presentation has turned himself into a caricature to mock you. You wanted this version of Kenny Omega in AEW? You fools. He is going to make you resent the living sh*t out of that which you once loved. Drenched in detail, everything about this act - already - radiates mega-heel star power.
This analysis hasn't yet covered Omega's legendary run in New Japan Pro Wrestling.
CONT'D...(4 of 6)
His last match with the company, against Hiroshi Tanahashi at Wrestle Kingdom 13, was a stunning philosophical war that beautifully realised its meta premise.
Tanahashi was the storytelling purist, Omega the gratuitously dangerous fireworks factory, and Tana had to put over Omega's style to defeat him. In one amazing out of character moment, one that was so, so much better and earned and congruous than virtually any cool spot ever, Tana, the man repulsed by head drop excess, levelled Omega with a poison 'rana. It was heart-stopping.
Omega's best work in New Japan was with Kazuchika Okada. Their climactic encounter at Dominion 2018 remains by acclimation the greatest pro wrestling match ever. Not only did they work the greatest wrestling match ever, they registered it as they greatest match ever before it was done. After 50 minutes of scorching dark arts pacing - how that epic built after blowing everyone away in minute 20 remains the sort of genius no observer could ever accurately articulate - Okada and Omega, exhausted, spent a long, drawn-out sequence deliberately failing to execute what remained of their arsenals.
It was worked almost in slow motion, and yet it was more electrifying and heated than the most insane of short-form sprints, which, incidentally, Omega and Okada had somehow conspired to work for almost an hour.
CONT'D...(5 of 6)
It was the greatest performance ever because it was the greatest babyface performance ever. Omega and Okada entered the match as perfectly equal machines of stamina. Omega left as IWGP Heavyweight Champion because, as was so beautifully realised through nods to his former friends - the Styles Clash, that Phoenix Splash again - he showed the most heart.
Tanahashi and Okada are honourable mentions in the debate. Both are geniuses at building a match with exquisite detail to peak at the perfect crescendo. Minoru Suzuki and Tomohiro Ishii are just as great, if not more understated, with their mastery of the fighting spirit rhythms and the knowledge of when to use the last remaining fumes of piss and vinegar to explode into the comeback. The All Japan Four Pillars between them created an anthology of storytelling almost unparalleled in its rich scope.
Bret Hart was another genius; his greatest night, WrestleMania 13, was so subtly magnificent that every progressively nasty stomp and every extra snug submission application placed the trust in the audience to grasp the story. To get Austin over as the new top babyface, that story had to be shown. It was a personal decision for those fans to make - they had to make it themselves to forge the bond with Austin that they subsequently did - and a difficult one. Hart was the man they stuck with the WWF for. The story had to show itself, not tell, and Hart did so with a working majesty few have ever rivalled.
Omega has surpassed him, and indeed everybody else.