Why The WWE Network FAILED

Vince McMahon has sold the WWE Network to Peacock - but it didn't make fans feel like showing off.

WWE NETWORK
WWE

Even the most disillusioned hardcore fan - that description, you might have guessed, covers your writer - couldn't have pissed and moaned about the WWE Network.

From price point to content, it was wonderful. Yes, the search function was goosed for the longest time. Your writer once typed in ROCK AUSTIN with a view to just watching that seminal WrestleMania X-Seven clash, but the service yielded an NXT match between the ROCK star Shinsuke Nakamura and AUSTIN Aries.

But if anything, that was a funny quirk that brought into focus just how good we all had it. So you had to fast-forward for a few minutes just to watch one of the greatest wrestling matches ever for the lowest ever price for which it had been offered. So you couldn't easily skip around the best Four Horsemen moments. You could instead watch all of it: every piss-funny Ric Flair conniption fit, every measured Arn Anderson threat, every incandescent Tully Blanchard tirade.

For £9.99 a month. In addition to every new and historic WWE pay-per-view. In addition to the entirety of the Monday Night Wars. In addition to every historic WCW and ECW pay-per-view. For £9.99 a month, and it was cheaper for the yanks, you could relive the golden age of territory wrestling without WWE's revisionist lens clouding the story with masturbatory vaseline. For the budding historian and modern consumer alike, the WWE Network provided the ultimate fan experience.

But it failed. How?

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Elimination Chamber 2014
WWE

In reductive and broad dollars-and-cents analysis, the WWE Network failed to adequately replace the traditional pay-per-view model as a revenue stream. Physical media was dead as a market, but, as evidenced by several UFC and boxing mega-fights, and indeed All Elite Wrestling's not inconsiderable success, pay-per-view was not. WWE badly overestimated the potential pull of the new streaming platform and did not generate the amount of subscribers needed to make the venture (as) profitable. It was a failure, not a disaster. The exorbitant set-up costs were covered well enough, and in the rights fee era, there is no such thing as disaster, which is illustrated by every last episode of Monday Night RAW. But it did fail, and objective proof of that failure lies in the sale to NBC Peacock. WWE anticipated, in a January 2014 presentation, of generating between 2-3 million domestic subscribers. They never scraped the bottom of that projection globally.

The old DTC model negatively impacted the content. There was no longer an incentive for WWE to produce must-see matches on a monthly basis and write compelling stories around these attractions. That is a generous take - it suggests WWE is capable, just less willing - when in reality, WWE f*cked itself with both barrels by drawing out uninspired and often inexplicable programmes across the card.

Elimination Chamber 2014 wasn't some flashpoint moment - WWE was deep in the muck of the this-rivalry-must-continue era, as illustrated by the endless circles walked by Triple H, Randy Orton and John Cena in the monopolised 2000s - but virtually every major programme WWE presented followed the same deadening formula.

Only exacerbated.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


roman reigns brock lesnar
WWE.com

First match is built via contrived scripted segment on TV. First PPV match ends via f*ckery, if not tossed off on TV, thereby muddying journey with destination and ruining core dramatic principles of anticipation, peak and purpose. Second match ends via f*ckery. Third match is decisive. And the cycle begins anew.

WWE execs talked up this revolution of content and its direct, cheap, super-served delivery without ever addressing the content itself.

As the Network failed to ignite as expected, WWE tinkered with its programming to better suit the model. No, they didn't improve it, despite thousands upon thousands of fans, when they had the heart anyway, vocally guiding them towards it. In order to artificially inflate its success, the running length of pay-per-views was extended. 2018 represented the nadir of the experiment.

WrestleMania 34 ran for 5:03:35. That doesn't include the two hour Kickoff portion. The main card for Money In The Bank ran for 4:11:41, and that figure again does not include the Kickoff. The Money In The Bank PPV, a rare modern WWE success, is affectionately referred to as the fifth of the Big 4 traditional events, but it's still a B-level attraction. WWE demanded an outrageous amount of your time to "consume" it, and that verb took on a rather suboptimal connotation. WWE events felt like something to get through, almost as a requirement. The fan had become - or was asked to become - a completist.

If that reads as a subjective take, go back and watch virtually every main event from that era.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


AJ Styles Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

It didn't matter whether the match was anticipated before the night itself, nor how well the great workers involved struggled through a basic build. So many of them - enough for this trend to become definitive - were received or barely received with a damning and perhaps involuntary silence. Those fans were full.

They were fed these ridiculous literal super-servings because minutes-streamed became a metric with which to sell a failing model as something less than a failure to shareholders. This strategy aligned with assorted covert messaging - by "super-serving," they meant "Sure, the base isn't growing, but they're replica belt marks who'll watch anything" - but it didn't work. Network subscriptions continued to decline just as TV ratings continued to decline.

The importance of TV as a revenue stream here can't go unmentioned, incidentally; WWE constantly recycled or "gave away" big matches after or even ahead of Sundays. The upshot was that, beyond the returning part-time megastar of yore, little distinguished television and pay-per-view in terms of personnel and even match length. Those three hours of RAW sure as sh*t didn't fill themselves. Which begged the question: what was the incentive to pay even a bargain fee?

It's not as if the narrative events truly meant anything, either. The 50/50 booking, frivolous comedic stakes and the crippling notion that a rematch could just happen - nothing was do-or-die in WWE, from the match result to even a digital start-up project costing hundreds of millions of dollars - all mattered as much as they didn't.

All of this added up.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Kenny Omega WWE Story Time
WWE Network

WWE, to many fans who switched off in recent years - Triple H called him "Mark," but it was very much plural - had become as repetitive as it was drawn-out as it was, ultimately, meaningless. Long-term storytelling executed by over stars used to draw punters. Content, however, draws billions. A great deal of wrestling fans never could reconcile this warped manner by which the industry had evolved and failed upwards creatively. Just as well for WWE that they don't matter, at least in the medium-term. But analysts are scrambling to work out just what's in this for Peacock - some speculate that an outright purchase of WWE must be the end goal, with the Network an absorbed body blow en route to victory - because the fans at large weren't moved by this apparent billion-dollar property.

A bargain only feels like a bargain when discounted against something of premium quality. One can only exist alongside the other. By failing to preserve WrestleMania as a destination that once felt like it took forever to arrive, it became just another thumbnail. This was key; literally all of WWE's output bled into itself, and WrestleMania while pretty and everything was just as bloated and as inconsequential as everything else.

If the discounted streamed pay-per-views weren't enough to claw back the lapsed fans, the original content was inessential to even the hardcores. The fluff wasn't even irreverent enough to become beloved in cult circles. Story Time was pointlessly animated repurposed shoot interview fodder. Swerved, an attempt at a prank show, was a weird continuation of the idea that WWE is legitimate entertainment anybody might like. Legends' House placed several old-timey carnies with various issues into a house, and unsurprisingly, the expected joviality mutated into unsettling darkness. And did anybody ever give a sh*t about the lore of Corey Graves' tattoos?

Even the (well-produced) documentaries put together to further draw in the hardcore fan didn't really work.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Kevin Owens Vince McMahon No
WWE Network

They were only perversely interesting.

Kevin Owens asked Vince McMahon if he liked his WrestleMania 33 match. Vince shook his said "No," seething in silent fury. Ricochet insisted, between footage of his own decline, that he was still happy to be there. In Liv Morgan, barely and erratically used, there wasn't even a subject to cover. Dean Ambrose's Chronicle portrayed a man plagued by doubts over who he wanted to be, and becomes fascinating in retrospect, looking at his rebirth as Jon Moxley. The man is mulling over his decision to leave on a documentary covering his big comeback. WWE, in effect, recorded its own decline and sold it, inexplicably, as something to promote. For £9.99 a month!

This "original content" was meant to supplement and deepen our connection with WWE's stars. It just made you wonder why you bothered, in the end.

WWE exists now as a bloated and homogenised content factory coveted by streaming services under a ballooning WalMart-adjacent model in which volume trumps art. The vast library and the streaming framework were made for one another, as President & Chief Revenue Officer Nick Khan so astutely surmised.

The Network failed because the content did.

The End.

Except it doesn't work like that anymore. Increasingly, it's hard to figure out how it does at all.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!