Why Vince McMahon Has Failed To Kill AEW
Rights fee versus wrong approach.
The narratives surrounding this Wednesday Night War change so often that every critic, commentator and viewer suffers more whiplash than they do in the face of a Fénix Vs. Nick Jackson sequence.
It was thought WWE pulled off a masterstroke in the build towards Survivor Series by successfully promoting NXT as not merely a third brand, but the dominant brand. The cool brand. The advertised invasion on the go-home show, oxymoron or no, succeeded: NXT defeated AEW Dynamite in the ratings war by promoting appearances from the talents of RAW and SmackDown.
Your writer, admittedly, was too quick to engrave the trophy by declaring WWE as the ultimate victor. This sentiment was echoed elsewhere in the wake of December 18's Dark Order furore. Meltzer referred to it as the "tipping point" in NXT's favour, and the general sense was that AEW Dynamite, if not failing, had become a normal, uneven wrestling TV show with highlights, lowlights, and an inescapable sense that it wasn't effectively promoting its star talent. WWE had successfully marginalised AEW as a niche portion of the weekly wrestling diet, for all of a fortnight.
Last week's news changed everything, in conjunction with AEW's vast improvement in 2020.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
AEW has proven itself capable of drawing and retaining the sought-after 18-49 demographic, and, per the Wrestling Observer, has vastly improved TNT's ratings on a comparative basis. Last year, TNT averaged ratings of 520,000 viewers on Wednesdays at 8 EST. Dynamite's success has seen an 82% ratings increase. This compelled TNT, after just months, to pay AEW a rights fee for Dynamite. This is a game-changer because it represents a far more significant victory than any weekly war, because the war isn't even of TNT's concern. AEW has drawn the demo, emerged as a key programming asset, and has been rewarded with the most significant deal since the closure of WCW. This was the case with the original deal, but if the asterisk of an advertisement split symbolised doubt, that doubt has now been eradicated.
As Dave Meltzer pointed out on Sunday's edition of Wrestling Observer Radio, AEW by virtue of signing this revised TNT deal became the second biggest wrestling promotion on the planet overnight; the deal alone is worth more than New Japan Pro Wrestling's collected revenue streams, and while Ring Of Honor is backed by a corporate monolith mightier than even WWE, the promotion is entirely dependent on Sinclair. It cannot survive on the revenue it generates, particularly now that so much money is being thrown around in a bid to compete.
WWE's goal was always to siphon viewers away from AEW by counter-programming Dynamite with its apparent analogue: NXT was meant to create an unbearable conflict in the minds of the viewer: which state-of-the-art, critically-acclaimed wrestling TV show to watch live, and which to DVR? Vince McMahon has failed in his mission of sabotage because, in effect, TNT has no-sold the very existence of NXT, because NXT has thus far only drawn around half of WWE's core 50+ base.
That's the why. But how?
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
To borrow an analogy from another pop cultural war of which viewers of NXT and Dynamite will be familiar, NXT is the Sega Mega Drive, and Dynamite is the SNES. NXT is Sonic The Hedgehog 2, a scintillating sprint powered by so-called "blast processing". It's a sensory overload of adrenaline and advanced visuals. AEW Dynamite is Super Mario World; it boasts the same exhilaration but a deeper sense of exploration, minutiae, charm and multiple secrets that reveal themselves on revisit. Both are exceptional games; one is programmed to immerse the player for longer.
Consider the two major programmes simmering across each show.
NXT is intense, and based on competition and proving oneself. That one dimension is exhilarating, but it's still only one dimension. Most every performer on the roster is an incredible athlete at their physical peak with something adjacent to a real name. Few of the characters are fun, there is little to separate them in age, style and motivation, and the manner in which they are programmed together is based on fairly routine physical interaction. Distractions, post-match beatdowns, retaliation, posed stand-offs, hat-theft: none of this A-B plotting is elevated by witty, improvised verbal spiels. The promos are stilted and driven by marketing word play.
Tommaso Ciampa Vs. Adam Cole is NXT's top long-term programme, and it's lukewarm. Ciampa never lost 'Goldie'. He wants Goldie back, and while the diversions have proven fairly organic and satisfying - Keith Lee's emergence as a player is welcome, and the Finn Bálor Vs. Johnny Gargano programme dovetailed eloquently enough - the thrust of the story itself hasn't been advanced. The plot is effectively what it was months ago. NXT isn't building this story, they are prolonging it, and it isn't hot as a result.
Meanwhile, over on Dynamite, MJF and Cody are at war.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
But this programme is unfolding amid an expanding shared universe, progressive stakes, and fire promos. QT Marshall has emerged as a sympathetic favourite; the Butcher and the Blade are an established midcard tag team; Diamond Dallas Page returned to avenge MJF's hilarious baiting; the debuting Wardlow is set to clash with Cody in a steel cage. The prospect of Cody humiliating himself to take 10 lashes of a whip is pure, unbearable drama. As a babyface, he'd rather be humiliated than proven a coward, but fans are genuinely split: they want the match, but not like this. It's expert, captivating episodic TV that is both unpredictable and consistent with the motivations of each character.
What's more likely to draw eyes: that angle, or the inevitable Cole Vs. Ciampa contract signing?
Now, some of this argument is shaped by personal inclination, but even a quick reading of the objective data yields the same conclusion. Consider which episodes of NXT have defeated AEW. On November 20, NXT defeated Dynamite under the promise of a siege attack from RAW and SmackDown, and that promise was immediately realised with Becky Lynch's opening promo. The events of Survivor Series, on which NXT defeated RAW and SmackDown, informed the ratings victory of November 27's post-PPV show.
The next week, with viewers now aware that there would be no further cross-pollination - for now - they chose to watch Dynamite on December 4.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
The last NXT success, at time of writing, came on December 18, which between its two, big Championship matches, two feud-settling midcard encounters, minimal promo segments and angle progression was essentially the televised TakeOver as advertised. With NXT once more in a state of storyline transition, Dynamite has dominated the ratings battle in 2020.
This pattern indicates that fans aren't much interested in NXT as an episodic television show in its own right. Fans aren't engaged in NXT storylines - only the intrigue of brand warfare and the echoes of those glorious Saturday nights. NXT's strict and risk-free formula has proven unsuccessful as a live, weekly concern. The strong emphasis on in-ring action clearly isn't enough. It was once such awesome tonic, in comparison to WWE's often nonsensical storyline developments, but what once was so refreshing for its simplicity now just feels basic and unadventurous. NXT's remit was once easy - WWE production values - bullsh*t + great wrestling - but now, it will prove far more difficult to appeal to an audience tiring of it.
None of this is to suggest that AEW Dynamite is set for 83 weeks of dominance, nor that it is a perfect show, but it's a very successful show that Vince McMahon has failed to kill. AEW draws the young crowd WWE cannot, because NXT doesn't do enough that the young crowd hasn't already seen in 20 years.
This is a very, very hasty take, so early in the company's life, but it's a promising sign that the successor to the COO cannot kill AEW, either.