Why Vince McMahon Has Lost Total Faith In Triple H

The future of WWE RAW and SmackDown isn't "now". It isn't in a year's time. It is in 2009.

revival american alpha
WWE.com

In 2015, it really did feel like the future was now.

In what is a grand irony, casting a glance towards the toxicity of the Wednesday Night Wars, everything AEW fans feel about that product in 2021, they felt for NXT in 2015. The NXT of that era wasn't just critically acclaimed, boasting electric in-ring action thrillingly removed, in the case of the Revival's phenomenal southern tag style update, from the passé and overbearing norm. The product didn't merely introduce new faces, in American Alpha and the Four Horsewomen. Nor did it rely entirely on the super-indie imports in a cynical quest for the inflated currency of critical acclaim. NXT was the feel-good alternative that rewarded investment. It felt like the long-overdue paradigm shift needed to superkick the cobwebs off the face of what became known, pejoratively, as the "main roster". The imposition of John Cena and Roman Reigns and the ridicule directed towards your support of Daniel Bryan felt like it was being dismantled before you.

The man wielding the sledgehammer, Triple H, was greeted by the same hardcore fan community that had once despised him as a saviour figure. This was it. Triple H was going to assume Vince McMahon's role as the boss, and he was going to do it in direct opposition to the mentality with which Vince had created such a void of despair. The contrast between NXT and WWE was so stark that it was as if Triple H was orchestrating this plan in secret.

Of course, NXT functioned to inform the main roster, and in a grim premonition of the events to come, the system immediately revealed itself to be dysfunctional.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Emma WWE NXT
WWE.com

The early call-ups failed dismally, floundering under Vince's impulses.

Emma was brought up not as the architect of the Women's Revolution but to do her funny dance because, pal, she just loves to have fun. Eva Marie was promoted literally years before she was ready because they didn't think a woman of her quality was in World Wrestling Entertainment to do something quite so pointless as wrestle. Mojo Rawley was Very Vince McMahon - a big, daft, energetic unit - and Carmella was Blonde. So too was Alexa Bliss. American Alpha did shockingly little, and that they still reigned as SmackDown Tag Team Champions for a brief while is indicative of how so little meant anything. The celebrations in Dallas were euphoric. It felt like you'd watched your own underdog sports team win the league. You will never remember the name of the city in which Chad Gable and Jason Jordan won main roster gold.

As the years dragged on, it all became so numbing. It was hard not to feel stupid for ever believing that Vince would embrace the vision. This defining trend mutated into developments even the most cynical of fans would not joke about as something that might happen in an even more laughably catastrophic timeline. Finn Bálor, the swagger-drenched sausage-!*$% of the walk WWE signed in 2014, entered the ring in 2017 with an almost eerie fake smile etched across his damned face. Chad Gable was repackaged as Shorty G, a diminutive fellow who decided to listen to his parents and own the name-calling, much like an eight-year old child might unsuccessfully attempt to do before getting the absolute sh*t kicked out of him regardless.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Bayley Sasha Banks
WWE

Bayley and Sasha Banks entered counselling, which was significantly less good than settling their differences with some gruesome stamps of the hand in the molten hate-fuelled heat of the best matches of the year.

In 2021, the extent to which the supposed future has not informed the present is really quite remarkable.

The paradigm has shifted into an even more damning direction. Where Vince once comically mishandled the carefully built or preserved talents bestowed upon him, he has now in effect no-sold the very existence of NXT and the Performance Center. NXT has essentially been retconned in main roster canon. It is an incredible development; between the ancient-feeling top of the card and the almost total lack of stylistic change, if a casual fan dropped out of WWE a decade ago, and for whatever reason dropped back in, they'd have no idea that the last several years happened because, through the prism of RAW and SmackDown, they ostensibly haven't. There are NXT "graduates" littered about who haven't yet been vanished, in Damian Priest and Matt Riddle - neither of whom, incidentally, remotely evolved in NXT - but beyond a higher proportion of women's wrestlers, the pre-NXT landscape remains virtually untouched.

By programming Bobby Lashley, Drew McIntyre and The Miz at the top of RAW, Vince McMahon appears to have favoured Ohio Valley Wrestling, Florida Championship Wrestling and Deep South Wrestling as the most effective developmental territories. Deep South Wrestling! This was a system so laughably incompetent that, tired of hearing reports that they simply pretended to book house shows, John Laurinaitis shuttered the whole thing down under cover of darkness in a late-night sting operation.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


WWE Elimination Chamber 2021 Kofi Kingston Sheamus Drew McIntyre Randy Orton AJ Styles Jeff Hardy
WWE.com

The players of the RAW main event scene all debuted on WWE television before NXT was a game show, much less the template of the company's future. Over on SmackDown, Roman Reigns, Edge and Daniel Bryan are key to the WrestleMania picture. None of these men came up in the NXT system. Edge debuted in 1992. The WWE Championship Elimination Chamber match featured nobody that had debuted in the prior five years, and featured just one man who (re)entered the main roster via NXT. If you don't think there's a systemic issue with how WWE functions, you are wilfully ignorant at this point.

Meanwhile, entire "classes" of NXT talent have vanished, very conspicuously, in parallel. Keith Lee, reportedly not deemed "ready" by Vince McMahon, is nowhere to be seen. Aleister Black is done. Andrade is done. All three of these men are former NXT Champions, and Vince McMahon won't even beat them on Main Event. Bianca Belair is set for a big match at WrestleMania 37, and not to diminish that - she's so good that she pierced the soulless WWE veneer to elicit real emotion around her Royal Rumble victory - there was hardly a wealth of alternative options. Braun Strowman is a rare in-house Performance Center success story, a description that ages badly by the week, and is bound for a feature role in the Raymond James Stadium. But he does not embody Triple H's vision for the future.

He isn't the sort of performer Triple H would shake hands with for cool points or would promote in the front row of an old world TakeOver show.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Bruce Prichard
WWE

The grand vision for NXT wasn't limited to a state-of-the-art training school; it was erected to build WWE's future from top-to-bottom across virtually every department.

In 2015, you'd have expected NXT creative wizard Ryan Ward to have "taken over," and while he is positioned as Vice President of Creative Writing, WWE in 2021 is the Vince McMahon and Bruce Prichard show once again. Hell, big John Laurinaitis, the man who allegedly explained to AJ Lee that it's a shame no man would want to have sex with her, is back in as talent relations liaison. The WWE of 2021 is eerily - damningly - similar to the WWE of the late 2000s. The very existence of NXT is almost completely superfluous to it. That is wild.

If you are Triple H, you have to be thinking: "The f*ck?"

You have to be. You have to be thinking that for whatever reason - Vince's specific tastes, the fear of embracing a different future he doesn't need to in a post-rights fee era, or those telling TV ratings on Wednesday nights - Vince no longer perceives him as his successor. He can't. The evidence is all there on the screen. The future isn't now, the past is, and it's such a solid and unremarkable past, too. This is the biggest indictment. It's not as if Vince has once again parachuted in the stars of the Attitude Era in order to blind out how drab everything is.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Property Of
WWE

He's into drab now, having no-sold almost entirely the super-indie boom Triple H reinvented his thought process in a bid to adapt.

The counterargument is that NXT is no longer a developmental programme and exists in itself as legitimate third brand. This explains why Vince McMahon's WWE is so oddly uninformed by it.

NXT is developmental. Virtually every talent debuts there. They aren't trusted to appear on RAW or SmackDown without first being "developed". This process is of course largely pointless, patronising, and a waste of time. What did Riddle really do for those two years in NXT, beyond gradually lose the hype of the all-important immediacy factor? But the point remains: if NXT was a legit third brand, a destination, 98% of WWE talent would not begin their journey in the Performance Center.

NXT is perceived as developmental internally, but increasingly, Vince McMahon appears unwilling to buy into the hype. He has reverted back to an old headspace, and this can only be interpreted as a total loss of faith in Triple H's vision.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!