Why WWE WrestleMania 38 Reeks Of Desperation
Company is relying on smoke and mirrors to hide institutional shortcomings.
From the outset, let’s establish the obvious: WrestleMania has always been a spectacle. WWE’s biggest show of the year has long been an extravaganza that has combined wrestling, pop culture, celebrity, showmanship and glitz since its inception way back in 1985.
The inaugural event featured Cyndi Lauper managing, Mr. T wrestling, and celebrities such as Liberace, Billy Martin and Muhammad Ali involved in the main event. Through the years, wrestlers have made stunning returns to action, sports figures have crossed over, and celebrities have stepped inside the ring to tangle with WWF/E superstars. To list all the truly special moments would fill this entire intro.
But that also is a list that spans 37 WrestleManias. We literally are talking about decades of involvement, whether it’s Alice Cooper at WM 3, Lawrence Taylor at WM 11, The Rock at WMs 28 and 29, or Ronda Rousey at WM 34.
But WrestleMania 38 is something truly special. WWE is pulling out all the stops to build this year’s event as “The most stupendous two-night WrestleMania in history…” which is comical considering this is only the third two-night Mania ever, and the first was the empty-arena edition at the Performance Center. But we digress.
The buildup is for one simple reason: to sell tickets. A company that brags about filling the same stadium with 101,000 screaming fans six years ago surely wants to boast about having 200,000 attendees over two nights, right?
But ticket sales are lagging (despite various deals), and WWE is notoriously bad at writing compelling television, forcing them to employ a series of desperate tactics to artificially inflate the event. Individually, they wouldn’t seem egregious. But crammed together in the same year?
CONT’D (1 of 7)
Celebrities are rooted in the very DNA of WrestleMania. Mr. T competed in the very first Mania main event. Lawrence Taylor beat Bam Bam Bigelow at WM 11. Floyd Mayweather battled Big Show at WM 24. And Bad Bunny dazzled at last year’s event.
So it’s not unusual to have Hollywood and music figures take part in the festivities and even mix it up in the ring. But having two celebrity-involved matches at the same Mania? That’s pretty damn unusual, if not unprecedented.
First up, Johnny Knoxville has been a thorn in the side of Sami Zayn for several weeks, and now he’s back to get in the new Intercontinental Champion’s face. This time, however, it’s not a short confrontation at the Royal Rumble, but a Mania match between the two. The question is whether the IC title will be part of this story or not.
And now, the Miz has recruited social media star Logan Paul to team with him to face Rey & Dominik Mysterio. Never mind that Paul threatened to beat up Miz the last time he was in WWE, the celebrities are teaming up to take on the luchadores in the name of reality TV!
How much of a crossover audience will Knoxville and Paul bring? Probably not much, but it might generate a quick headline or boost some social media metrics.
CONT’D (2 of 7)
Bringing back Ronda Rousey was never a bad idea. The former UFC champion took to sports entertainment like few could have ever imagined, surpassing even the most optimistic person’s expectations.
By the time she left WWE after WrestleMania 35, Rousey had truly elevated women’s wrestling and raised the bar for the competition. Three years later and things have almost completely fallen apart due to injuries, releases and motherhood.
Still, Rousey was barely on the radar when a buzz quickly stirred up in the days before the Royal Rumble and she was suddenly heavily rumored to be a surprise entrant. Sure enough, there she was, tearing through everyone and punching her ticket to WrestleMania, one of the biggest crossover, mainstream stars WWE has had in the past several years.
Naturally, they put her up against the woman whom they feel is their biggest star: Charlotte Flair. Flair has name value in wrestling circles, while Rousey still is a household name for sports combat fans. Never mind Sasha Banks, she can compete for the women’s tag titles. And Asuka can continue to sit on the sidelines with no storylines from creative. Rhea Ripley can continue to tread water. Lita can get a payday in Saudi Arabia. And Alexa Bliss’ revenge can wait.
Rowdy Ronda is back! And that’ll move the needle. But just in case it doesn’t…
CONT’D (3 of 7)
A returning superstar who has been out of the company for a long time can really shock the system and jolt the fanbase. Those who remember the superstar from yesteryear will be psyched to see them, looking back through rose-colored glasses.
These coups are fewer and farther between ever since WCW disappeared and any potential holdovers either debuted or retired. The Hardys’ surprise return at WrestleMania 33 might have been the last such instance. But WWE has a potential ace up its sleeve if the stars align.
Cody Rhodes’ departure from AEW last month has opened the door to a potential return to the company he left five-plus years ago. The speculation has been rampant since the announcement more than two weeks ago, though recent developments have cast some doubt.
Still, if this happens, WWE undoubtedly will hype it to the hilt, trying to capture any fan – including AEW diehards – who will be curious what Cody has to say, and what he’ll do. This one is far from confirmed, and really, you can’t blame WWE for having this dropped in their lap. But we still have to note it here.
CONT’D (4 of 7)
Dusting off a long-retired wrestler and convincing them to have one more match on the biggest stage of them all is far from unprecedented. The Rock headlined WrestleManias 28 and 29 after being mostly out of the game since WM 20. Ricky Steamboat returned to the ring at WM 25. Batista showed up for one last match at WM 35.
But luring “Stone Cold” Steve Austin out of a 19-year retirement that has persisted despite the wishes of millions of fans and wrestlers up and down the card has to top the list. Austin last competed at WM 19, though he’s dished out plenty of Stunners in a WWE ring in the years since.
Despite his various appearances, whether as Raw sheriff, guest referee or whatever role they’ve carved out for him, Austin has resisted entreaties to actually wrestle again.
Now, however, it looks like WWE has indeed broken the glass, signalling an emergency, as they’re seemingly enlisting a Texas native to help sell a Mania taking place in Texas by competing against a guy in Kevin Owens who has been trashing Texas at every turn recently.
If pulling Austin out of a nearly two-decade retirement to wrestle in his home state isn’t a sign of desperation to move the needle, then surely the next item is…
CONT’D (5 of 7)
WWE likes to operate in this strange universe where its ruling family are the biggest stars in the company. Pay no attention to the superstars who compete week in and week out, it’s the millionaires who run the show who deserve all the adulation and hype.
And while historically there has been no bigger villain and evil boss than Vince McMahon, it’s not the Attitude Era anymore, and Vince is no longer a virile, strapping man who can stand toe-to-toe with any opponent.
But if the rumors are to be believed, McMahon could be stepping into the role his son and erstwhile WWE employee Shane McMahon played the past several WrestleManias: Vince could be competing (or at the very least involved in a match) at the big show.
We’ve seen Vince mentoring Austin Theory recently on Raw, and the pairing has produced some memorable moments… though not necessarily for the reasons WWE would like. And now McMahon has done a podcast interview with Pat McAfee that could be used in storylines going forward.
Even if this doesn’t pan out for the 76-year-old boss, the fact that the rumor has gotten so much steam speaks to the desperation to try to move a few more tickets.
CONT’D (6 of 7)
The main event of WrestleMania 38 on Sunday night has always been a big match. Brock Lesnar versus Roman Reigns is a titanic clash – even if we’ve seen it several times in the past few years.
But WWE has gone out of their way to blow this one up to artificially epic proportions. First, Roman cost Brock the WWE Championship at Royal Rumble, so Lesnar went out and won the Rumble later that night. Then he chose Reigns’ WWE Universal Championship. Fine so far, right?
However, Brock then regained the WWE Championship at Elimination Chamber, making this a “champion versus champion” match. And this is where WWE’s hype machine went into overdrive.
The match quickly became “title for title, winner take all,” which is the same thing that happened at WrestleMania 35 with the two women’s titles – they remained two separate titles. The billing then shifted to “championship unification match,” implying that only one world title would emerge from Mania.
And finally, they’re now calling this “the Biggest WrestleMania Match of All-Time,” which is a bit of a reach. So, we’ve progressed from a Crown Jewel rematch to a title unification match that is supposed to be the biggest in 38 WrestleManias. Why don’t they just promise a live human sacrifice or a free concubine with your Mania ticket?
There’s hype, and then there’s “bad car salesman” hype.
CONT’D (7 of 7)
For years, people have criticized WWE for relying on part-timers at WrestleMania, observing that there would come a day when Undertaker, John Cena, Triple H and even Shane McMahon wouldn’t be able to perform, and what would the company do then to fill out a Mania card? Book Dolph Ziggler in a prominent feud?
The solution, for this year it seems, is to lean on Brock Lesnar again, throw money at Ronda Rousey, book a couple of celebrities, try to entice Steve Austin out of retirement, toss Vince McMahon into a feud at 76, and combine your two biggest titles in the company on six weeks’ notice.
WrestleMania is WWE’s biggest show of the year, and it’s an ambitious effort to try to sell out the Dallas Cowboys’ stadium. So yes, they should be pulling out all the stops.
One or a two of those gimmicks would suffice for a Mania, but all of them? Do you know what else they have in common? Aside from Roman (and to an extent Rousey), none are WWE roster m ainstays or current champions. Sami Zayn, Miz, even Kevin Owens aren’t the selling points of these matches.
That gets to the bigger issue here: WWE is relying on smoke and mirrors to make Mania seem like a dream event and that the company is bigger and better than ever. And while they could pull all of this off and deliver a “stupendous” two-night WrestleMania, it doesn’t take into account that the shortcomings that force this desperation aren’t being addressed the other 363 days of the year.