Wrestling's 10 Greatest Kay-Baes

From AJ Lee to Stacy Keibler, when having a fake wrestling girlfriend makes you a winner...

AJ Lee
WWE.com

Fans were about to exhale a sigh of relief that the relationship between Ric Flair and Lacey Evans was merely one of mentor and student. Then WWE creative slapped us with references that Evans’ real-life pregnancy may result in a new Flair. We still don’t know how Lacey’s husband, who features prominently on the star’s Instagram, feels about it all…

Since the death of kayfabe, romantic storylines occupy a bizarre place in sports entertainment. We often see our favourite superstars more on social media than we do on weekly wrestling programming. On top of this the WWE Network has found a successful niche in wrestling documentaries. Though these peaks behind the curtain are curated by the company, and the editing decisions primarily concern themselves with protecting the company’s reputation and secrets, the talent are shown real and raw.

This poses challenges in telling romance stories through the lens of professional wrestling. Fans being invited into personal lives and relationships often muddies the characters we see on-screen. In real life, having a fake girlfriend makes you a bit of a loser. Yet, in the semi-reality of professional wrestling, a Kay-Bae comes with great advantages…

10. Vickie Guerrero

Edge and Vickie Guerrero
WWE.com

Vickie Guerrero, the real-life wife of the iconic Eddie, became increasingly involved with WWE after her husband’s death. In an inspired move, she was not cast as the eternal grieving widow, but rather as an authority heel. She excelled at being that potent combination of irritating and vindictive.

In 2007, Vickie capitalised on Teddy Long’s kayfabe heart attack to become the new General Manager of SmackDown. She showed her worth as an on-air love interest, making her faux-beau Edge the number one contender for the World Heavyweight Championship. ‘The Ultimate Opportunist’ used this, and several acts of favouritism, to win SmackDown’s main prize at Armageddon 2007. Edge gave Vickie an engagement ring, which only spurred on her desire to be useful. When the Championship was taken out of the situation, though, Edge’s admiration wavered. Vickie then fled WWE heartbroken.

She returned with her on-screen boyfriend Eric Escobar, who quickly revealed he too was using her. Undeterred, ‘The Cougar’ embarked on a new relationship with Dolph Ziggler. Although she awarded him the World Heavyweight Championship on SmackDown’s 600th episode, Ziggler lost it that same night. He was unable to manipulate and exploit her quite as well as the Machiavellian Edge.


9. Nidia

Jamie Noble and Nidia
WWE.com

Nidia Guenard, the first female winner of wrestling reality show Tough Enough, came into her own when she was paired with Jamie Noble. On screen the two were a trashy redneck couple, with Nidia putting her man’s interests before her own. Though she didn’t personally hold a title, she was instrumental to Noble’s Cruiserweight Championship success.

As well as proving a necessity to Noble’s victories, Nidia also played off him well, adding some comedy to the traditional chickens**t heel trope.

Following her meddling in another of Noble’s matches, however, Nidia was blinded by Tajiri’s Black Mist, a particularly venomous version akin to battery acid.

In the end, the despicable Noble even found a way to make a kayfabe-blind Nidia an instrument in his cheating ways. He used his TV girlfriend as an unwitting human shield and belittled any opponent who would accidentally strike her. Nidia eventually turned on Noble when she became wise to this tactic, however. The couple broke up, cumulating in a blindfolded match at No Way Out 2004; A bout in which Noble cheated his way to victory.


8. Daffney

David Flair Daffney
WWE.com

David Flair had the age-old struggle of anybody who follows a parent into a career. Accusations of nepotism and lack of originality flourish like rancid weeds. This situation is heightened in the case of second-generation wrestlers.

Early in David’s WCW career, his father awarded him the WCW United States Championship, which came along with a copycat makeover. David’s hair was dyed platinum blonde, he wore his own bedazzled robe to the ring, and he was (briefly) accompanied by Kay-Bae Torrie Wilson.

Quickly losing his title, Flair languished until he was paired with Daffney. His psychotic goth girlfriend was a mixture of DC’s Harley Quinn and Mallory Knox (Juliette Lewis) from the film Natural Born Killers. Though Daffney was a favourite amongst fans, and often a scene-stealer, she elevated Flair to be his own man, challenging him to descend into madness.

She led Flair and Crowbar to tag title gold but also became a solo titleholder herself winning the Cruiserweight Championship through convoluted circumstances. Aside from title success, the love triangle between Flair, Daffney, and his real-life girlfriend Stacy Keibler, kept Flair relevant away from his father’s ongoing feuds and storylines.


7. Stacy Keibler

Stacy Keibler 16
WWE

Stacy Keibler never truly troubled anybody in the Women’s Championship scene, but she was over with the predominantly male fanbase and was a great ambassador for WWE in the wider media. Stacy notably cut her teeth as a wrestling manager alongside her real-life boyfriend David Flair. She briefly helped him maintain a short-term relevance but soon dragged him into a risqué pregnancy angle that left him humiliated.

In WWE, Stacy again tried to mix business and pleasure when she brought her relationship with Andrew ‘Test’ Martin to the screen. She overhauled his image and dubbed his fans "Testicles".

When Test’s love turned (storyline) abusive, Scott Steiner saved her and the two began hinting at more than just a professional relationship. This gave audiences a reason to cheer for Steiner while he was on a tight WWE leash – losing his psychotic rambling charm. Stacy was questionably put on the line on several occasions, passing back and forth so much she might as well have had a 24/7 rule.

Things turned even grimmer when the two men decided to share her as a “sex slave”. As heels, Steiner and Test were easy to hate in this thankfully short-lived angle.


6. Molly Holly

Molly Holly Spike Dudley
WWE.com

Molly Holly is better remembered for her heel Women’s Champion runs, in which shorter, darker hair made her evil, and as Mighty Molly, The Hurricane’s super-sidekick. Yet, as the on-screen cousin of Crash and Hardcore Holly, she won not only fans' hearts, but also the runt of the Dudley clan.

In a surprisingly successful spin on the star-crossed lovers trope, Spike and Molly’s relationship blossomed amid a rivalry between his storyline brothers and her kayfabe cousins. The couple’s wholesome romance didn’t spread to those around them, who continued to brawl across family lines. As expected in any Dudley rivalry, tables were aplenty. In a memorable gesture of love and self-sacrifice, Spike lay across a table to stop his brothers smashing Molly through it.

Spike Dudley’s gimmick was as the perpetual underdog, short in stature and easily disregarded. While Molly didn’t lead Spike to championship victory, she made his plight sympathetic and gave him a rare victory over life.

Molly commented on the pairing:

“It was fun to have acting skits and the things that the fans could get involved with, get behind, root for. So my Disney romance with Spike Dudley was by far one of my favorite things in my time with the [WWE].”

5. Mandy Rose

Mandy Rose Otis
WWE

Otis and Mandy Rose’s relationship was played for odd couple laughs, with Otis trading his tag partner Tucker for a new flame to heighten his outrageous behaviour. The two started working opposite each other while there was talk of Mandy and Sonya Deville’s relationship taking a romantic turn. This made more storyline sense, however it was 50/50 whether we’d get real LGBTQI+ representation or softcore titillation.

With Mandy, Otis’ character development was vastly boosted. The relationship allowed him to show his lovable underdog side via his devotion, while also showcasing the gross-out comedy side of his gimmick, such as when the two hugged and Mandy’s dress was stained by Otis’ meat sweats.

Otis got a kiss and a ‘Mania moment at WrestleMania 36 – a satisfying payoff for the odd couple who navigated the betrayal and deceit of the locker room.

Many wrongly assumed Otis championed the storyline, though, as Mandy later revealed:

“Otis always was around in NXT and posting pics of me and talking about how much he liked me. In a cute way, not a creepy way. This continued on and I thought it would be great if this became a storyline, especially once Otis entered WrestleMania. I actually went to Vince McMahon myself and pitched the idea and he loved it.”

4. Trish Stratus

Christian Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Due to her abundance of high quality in-ring work, Trish Stratus’ skill as a manager are often overlooked. When she first entered WWE, she helped Test and Albert stand out. Even in the stacked Attitude Era, T&A were a constant presence on TV due to their association with the beautiful and devious Stratus.

The most memorable kayfabe romantic relationship of Stratus’ career is her time with the boss, however. Vince McMahon’s mistreatment of Stratus in the overtly abusive partnership helped send him to new heelish heights, even if it’s not exactly a time most would wish to revisit.

However, it is her short romance with Christian in which she was the most effective fake girlfriend. WWE tried using Stratus the previous year to elevate Jeff Hardy in his transition from tag team stardom to solo success. This was abruptly dropped due to Hardy’s release on April 22, 2003.

After a kayfabe relationship opposite Jericho, Stratus turned on Y2J at WrestleMania XX, aligning with Christian. The two kissing on the entrance stage gave him a solo ‘Mania moment and elevated him as a heel. Stratus by his side, and “problem Solver” Tyson Tomko”, exhibited Christian as a star.


3. Torrie Wilson

Torrie Wilson Tajiri
WWE.com

Torrie Wilson was a serious kayfabe dater. In WWE, her on-screen boyfriends included Billy Gunn, Carlito, and a partnership with real life fiancé Billy Kidman. Yet it was Tajiri who received the biggest boost from a sham-relationship with Torrie.

When Tajiri signed to WWE in 2001, he was best known for his strong kicks and his willingness to engage in the hardcore brutality of his previous stomping ground ECW. ‘The Japanese Buzzsaw’ had a short comedy alliance as the assistant to Commissioner William Regal, followed by a fun feud that ended too quickly.

Tajiri then entered the Light Heavyweight/Cruiserweight Championship picture that was muddied by The Invasion. His in-ring work was superb, but he needed an extra something – the universally loved all-American Torrie.

The relationship gave fans an added dimension to his character and it was unique to see a foreign face who (kayfabe) couldn’t speak English in a relationship with a top female babyface. The ending of the relationship also facilitated his later heel turn, when he imposed the chastity of his tradition onto Torrie, forcing her to dress as a geisha.


2. Chyna

Chyna Eddie Guerrero
WWE.com

Chyna is the often-overlooked component of the initial DX trio. Although, she embodied a classic enforcer role, a woman cast as such was a revolution. DX was key to Chyna’s development, but in leaving the group she continued her rise, until backstage politics grounded her.

One of Chyna’s career highlights was as Eddie Guerrero’s “Mamacita”. The kayfabe relationship allowed her to showcase a more traditionally feminine side. Guerrero greatly benefited, transitioning from his role in The Radicalz to solo success.

The two came together on the Raw following WrestleMania 2000, Chyna turned on her ally and former co-Intercontinental Champion Chris Jericho. She helped Guerrero become the new European Champion, his first title reign in WWE. The relationship also spawned the classic “Latino Heat” tagline to explain Guerrero’s charisma and magnetism. The pair were initially heels but underwent an organic babyface turn, becoming fan favourites.

Guerrero used Chyna’s success to cheat himself to the Intercontinental Championship. She forgave him and uneasily stood by as he retained the belt by any means necessary. However, she couldn’t make excuses when she caught him in the shower with two of Godfather’s hoes.


1. AJ Lee

Bryan Kissing Aj Lee
WWE

AJ Lee is wrestling’s greatest Kay-Bae. Her WWE gimmick seamlessly alternated between devoted girlfriend and crazy ex-girlfriend, often enough to keep the crowd entertained and on side. Of all the fake girlfriends listed, Lee used the role to get herself over just as much as her partner. Often, she completely seized the spotlight.

After briefly being romantically linked to Hornswoggle, AJ was booked in an on-screen relationship with Daniel Bryan. This inserted her into the World Heavyweight Championship picture at the top of the card. She was integral to Bryan’s run with the championship, even if her good luck kiss led to Bryan dropping the title in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII. The two’s love triangle alongside Lee’s real life husband CM Punk gave all three some good material to work with. Being left a slighted woman, AJ became Raw General Manager, a privilege which she leveraged to punish the men in her life.

AJ’s initial foray into the main roster no doubt increased her popularity and propelled her on her way to becoming a three-time Divas Champion.


In this post: 
AJ Lee
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.