WWE: 10 Things That Would Have Happened If Stone Cold Steve Austin Never Retired

Stone Cold Steve Austin OH HELL YEAH. Can you believe that it's been 10 years since Stone Cold Steve Austin has wrestled? At WrestleMania XIX (in 2003), The Rock pinned Austin in what would be Austin's last match. The next night on RAW, Eric Bischoff "fired" Austin, a necessary storyline to protect Austin from the ring. His body had finally waved the white flag, after years of struggling through his neck injury (sustained after a piledriver from Owen Hart at Summerslam '97) and multiple knee surgeries. Unlike Edge's retirement speech the night after WrestleMania 27 €“ also due to longstanding injuries - no one knew at the time that Austin's departure from the ring would also be permanent. But he was far from absent from WWE, and has served in many other capacities in the 10 years since. Shortly after his storyline firing, Linda McMahon re-hired Austin as Co-General Manager. He's been a guest referee, participated in beer-drinking contests, appeared on Piper's Pit, hosted Tough Enough, and destroyed the Anonymous Raw General Manager laptop with his 4-wheeler (you're welcome). Not to mention giving Stone Cold Stunners to half the roster and all of management. But what (WHAT?) if Austin had never retired? Without making the ridiculous assumption that he'd wrestle injury-free up to present day, let's operate under the assumption that he could wrestle at least a few more years without crippling himself. How would his career be different? How would WWE be different? And how would we, as fans, be different?

10. Goldberg/Lesnar Could Have Been Prevented

Goldberg

Let's talk about how bad the match was between Goldberg and Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XX. At a show commemorating 20 years of The Showcase of the Immortals, held in the historic Madison Square Garden, this mid-card match had no business existing. On paper, a clash between these two psychotic heavyweights made sense, but in reality, neither man was equipped to take the lead on it. The low effort put in by both men, coupled with their imminent departures from the company, resulted in a match made memorable for how awful it was. Steve Austin was right in the thick of it, as the GM who played a large role in the feud leading up to the event. Not only did Austin play puppetmaster in bringing these two together, but he was also designated the special guest referee for their showdown at WrestleMania XX. Austin's presence was a blessing throughout, as his brash personality and expertise on the microphone compensated for Lesnar and Goldberg's shortcomings. But once the bell rang at the famed MSG, not even Stone Cold could rescue the sinking ship that was this match. The fans in attendance chanted "You sold out" and "Boring", even prompting a middle finger from Goldberg. But perhaps more telling was the "Austin" chant that also rang out for the special guest referee, who delivered a Stunner to both guys and had his own beer bash thereafter: when all else failed, they relied on Steve Austin to revive the crowd. If he'd been cleared to compete, Austin would have been a much better opponent for either Goldberg or Lesnar, and his winning would have been a more satisfying send-off to the guy who was abandoning WWE. Steve had the ring experience to guide a "blunt object" through a match that could tell a compelling story, with some well-executed spots throughout, and a hell of a lot more personality. He was already heavily invested in the storyline as the General Manager, and possessed the tenacity to stand up to either one when he announced his departure. If he hadn't retired, Austin could have turned this into a huge adrenaline rush for the crowd, instead of a fecal stain on the record of this milestone event.

9. Guerrero and Benoit May Not Have Had A Chance

benoit guerrero The saying goes that when Vince closes a door, he opens a window. Well, maybe the saying doesn't go exactly like that, but it stands to reason that in pro wrestling, there's not enough room for everyone. No matter how talented a guy is, no matter how much the fans love him, that guy is at the mercy of Vince McMahon's whims. Vince is going to feature the guy(s) who he deems the most lucrative, at the expense of wrestlers who may never get the chance to prove their star power. And who has been one of the most lucrative stars in the history of WWE? Steve Austin. When Vince himself inducted Austin into WWE's Hall of Fame in 2009, he called Steve "The greatest WWE superstar of all time", while he was likely doing a mental calculation of all the money Austin has made for him. Let's make the educated assumption that Austin would have played a main event role in the year(s) following his comeback in 2003. We need only look at John Cena's alarmingly quick return from his triceps injury to see how Vince pulls out his reliable artillery at the slightest sign of sagging ratings. WrestleMania XIX had the lowest Pay-Per-View buy rate of the modern era. But McMahon had little choice but to start featuring the younger, smaller, hungrier talent €“ a big risk that paid off. From a fan's emotional standpoint, the main events at WrestleMania XX were very successful. Kurt Angle, Triple H, and Shawn Michaels could all be considered big names with drawing power (though none at the level of Steve Austin). But who were the two men who stood tallest at the end of that night, holding the most coveted titles? Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit. It was a sweet moment for fans, who respected Benoit and Guerrero for their passion and dedication in the ring. It was clearly a sweet moment for Benoit and Guerrero, who spent years together plying their craft all over the world. They were close friends sharing a moment of great glory and acknowledgement. We'll never know if that moment would have happened, if Steve Austin had been able to compete that night. The chain of events for the prior year could have been completely different: he wouldn't have been made RAW GM, and he would have had influence on Stone Cold's direction in the ring. Would Vince have taken a chance on Benoit and Guerrero, if he had Steve Austin to feature in the main event?

8. The Rock's Departure Would Have Been Very Different

dwayne the rock johnson Whether he knew it or not (and I suspect he did) when his shoulders were pinned for the 1-2-3 at WrestleMania XIX, Steve Austin was able to savour a pretty dramatic send-off. He had his last match in front of over 50,000 people, against one of his most legendary opponents, and the match was skillful and entertaining. The Rock's departure, shortly thereafter, was not tied to Austin's, as Dwayne Johnson was headed for the greener pastures of Hollywood. But he cannot cite that WrestleMania match as his last (of that era), and Austin was no longer on hand to give him the legendary send-off that he likely desired. No, The Rock faced a wrestler making his WWE debut: Goldberg. From a business standpoint, what better way to promote Goldberg as an unstoppable force, than to have him beat the guy who effectively retired Steve Austin? And it has been customary for WWE to bid adieu to talent with their shoulders down on the mat. It would have been a much more dramatic exit, and much more fitting closure, to have The Rock and Steve Austin clash a few more times to finish their feud. Both men had been working part-time and/or returning from hiatuses before they met at 'Mania, and so that story was only compelling by virtue of their shared history. Even though The Rock won that match, he still had other jobs to fulfill before taking his leave, and I'm guessing he would have loved to work with Austin. His farewell performance €“ flailing around in the ring at Backlash after being clobbered by Goldberg €“ felt like an afterthought, and not a turning point.

7. We Could Have Had More Austin/Angle

KurtAngle For all his personal obstacles outside the ring, Kurt Angle has been a highly-regarded wrestler (both amateur and pro) for over 17 years. No one can dispute Angle's talent, his work ethic, and his seemingly ageless abilities. It gives him a lot of credibility when you hear him talk about wrestling, and he credits Steve Austin as the reason he got into the business. After his Olympic gold medal, Angle was offered a WWF contract, but turned it down because he wasn't sold on the "entertainment" side of the company. Fast forward one year, and he turns the channel to see Stone Cold Steve Austin tearing up the ring and the microphone. He is hooked, and credits Austin with changing his mind about pro wrestling. Not only did Austin change Kurt's mind, but he also became one of Kurt's all-time greatest opponents. The two men created many epic moments together, always with Austin calling the shots (which made sense according to wrestling convention, but also developed Angle's trust and respect for him). Their matches throughout 2001 can be considered timeless classics, not only making Angle a huge star but also elevating the game of every other wrestler who got in the ring with them, such as Chris Jericho and Triple H. So can you imagine what 2003 would have looked like, if Angle and Austin had been able to write another chapter in their careers together? After WrestleMania XIX, Kurt Angle was out with a hamstring and neck injury, but came back to feud against Brock Lesnar, Eddie Guerrero, and Shawn Michaels over the next couple of years. No small feats, and all memorable indeed. His injuries plagued him throughout, leading him to wrestle on a part-time basis until asking to be released from his contract in 2006. Who better to work with Angle's strengths and weaknesses in the ring than Austin, who also suffered from a nagging neck injury? Both men refused to perform unless they were at the top of their games, and would have pulled together a match that showcased two great minds and endless heart.

6. Austin May Not Have Been The Draw He Is Today

We've heard the stories of famous artists and writers whose work did not sell until after they died. Well, Austin's work sold, and there's no doubt he would have continued to be a draw if he hadn't retired in 2003. But if he had kept on wrestling, relatively injury-free as per our assumptions, for how much longer would his drawing power last? It most certainly could not have kept up at its current trajectory, even factoring in the nostalgia that accompanies today's current part-timers like The Undertaker. The Stone Cold fever hit fast and hard, he's said as much himself in interviews. Perhaps his injuries forced a more poetic end to his wrestling €“ burning out in a flash, rather than slowly sputtering out. And at least he quit while he was ahead, still able to play a role on the programs without becoming physically handicapped due to overambition. He never wanted to wrestle if he couldn't give 100%, and if he hadn't retired, we would have possibly gotten a less-than-100% Stone Cold. When he "left" as he did, that made him an even hotter commodity. Each appearance was special, especially the fewer and farther between they came. If the fans were asked for vote for a guest referee, Steve Austin always won the election. If WWE needed to add cachet to a struggling event, they called up Stone Cold and start chilling the Steveweisers. He was always, ALWAYS good for a rabid reaction €“ and because he retired at the right time, he never failed to deliver when he had to get physical. Steve never dropped a beer, never botched a Stunner, and never failed to come back with the appropriate catchphrase or quick-witted reply. Not only did he continue to play a large role in WWE storylines after he retired, but his more permanent departure from the company €“ while punctuated with movie roles €“ could never be considered a full retirement. He's appeared at 6 of the 10 WrestleManias since then, not to mention countless TV and Pay-Per-View programs that no doubt received a boost in ratings when Stone Cold was on the marquee. His perceived value is much greater because he left at the top of his game, when we all still wanted him, and would pay big bucks for the chance to see him. He is forever ingrained in the consciousness of wrestling fans €“ every time you hear "What?" it is a prayer to Stone Cold.

5. Stone Cold Merchandise Would Not Be As Valuable

steve-austin

When he was an active wrestler, a large proportion of merchandise sales could be attributed to Stone Cold Steve Austin. The king of the catchphrase and the master of badassery, Austin was the most quotable, marketable commodity since Hulk Hogan €“ with the added bonus that Austin existed in an even more brand-conscious era. People were 3:16-ing everything in sight because Stone Cold said so. Shirts, hats, bumper stickers and teddy bears... the beauty of Steve Austin's marketability was this: he was much more than a one-trick pony. He didn't have just one quote; he didn't string all his quotes together when he'd run out of ideas. He was a naturally charismatic guy who was given free reign on the microphone, while Vince reaped the rewards. They didn't just have "Austin 3:16" shirts. They had shirts that said "F*CK FEAR" and shirts that said, "HELL YEAH" and shirts that said "Whoop-Ass". And whatever they were selling, people bought with abandon. Stone Cold was forever cool, and remained as such because he was a rare treat. He was an emblem of the treasured Attitude Era that so many fans reminisce about with longing. He didn't become a tragic story of the has-been who should have hung up his boots; he lived a cleaner life post-WWE than during, and became a reliable, continued source of income because he was no longer wrestling every day of the year. If he hadn't retired, the Stone Cold mystique would likely have faded in terms of merchandise.

4. Austin Wouldn't Have Been Forced Into Other Pursuits

Steve's been able to maintain a Superstar-At-Large style relationship with WWE, coming in for the occasional gig that keeps him alive in the hearts of the fans (and in the pocketbook of Vince McMahon). Steve Austin could do nothing else for the rest of his life but hunt and fish, then go drink beer on Raw twice a year. He'd be all set. But that's clearly not Steve's style, and if he hadn't been forced to retire, he wouldn't have found the myriad projects that have kept him busy and us entertained. Since leaving the ring, Austin has nabbed a dozen movie roles, most of which have required him to stay in tip-top condition. One could say that retiring from wrestling has gotten him into the best shape of his life: he's not living on the road, he's at peace, and he's motivated to make the right choices in order to thrive. Next year, Steve Austin will be 50 years old. He's on twitter (@SteveAustinBSR €“ that stands for Broken Skull Ranch, son) with over 2 million followers and one heckuva natural banter with them. His recently-launched Steve Austin Show is a brilliant podcast featuring interviews with the greatest minds in wrestling, his fave musicians, and his own best foil €“ himself. All that, plus he reinvigorated what could have been a painful concept with WWE's Tough Enough in 2011, and is going into his third season as the host of Redneck Island. This redneck was one angry rattlesnake, but has grown into a more well-rounded individual (with likely a much longer life expectancy) €“ two things that more positively embody the traits of today's WWE Superstars. Steve Austin may no longer wrestle, but his retirement made him into more of an entertainer.

3. He Would Have Evolved Into The PG Era

steve austin beer At least, he would have had to. He and The Rock represented the first and last vestiges of The Attitude Era, and their eventual departures coincided with the dawning of a new era. The PG era wasn't sumbitch-friendly, nor did it encourage middle finger salutes. What would have happened if Stone Cold was told to tone it down, or change his act to suit the shareholders? Well, he's conducted himself somewhat accordingly during his special appearances, otherwise he wouldn't be invited back on such a regular basis (see: Ric Flair). So it's not as if Steve Austin isn't capable of adapting. We've seen what happens when a wrestler fails to evolve, such as The Rock fumbling and eyebrow-raising his way through parts of his big comeback in 2012. People still love The Rock, but he wasn't winning any new fans, just nostalgic pops. (Please note that Dwayne Johnson, in my opinion, has been a whiz at personal PR and career development, but here I refer to The Rock character). So my jury is out in terms of Steve Austin thriving in the PG Era. Could he survive it? Well yes, especially in the beginning when there was no Senate Campaign or Wellness Policy to consider. He could tone it down and still thrill the crowd. It may have been interesting for us to see how he'd innovate and agitate with a few new rules in place. His legendary feud with Vince (which many feel has been imitated by The Authority and Daniel Bryan) could have morphed into something even more creative. But then again, I am a huge fan of McMahon's feud with HBK €“ I wouldn't trade their No-Holds-Barred Match at WrestleMania 22 for all the beer in Texas. So if Austin hadn't retired, would I have been denied the delights of that match?

2. John Cena May Not Have Become The Face of The WWE So Soon

john cena One year after Austin's retirement, John Cena won the opening match at WrestleMania XX. He defeated The Big Show for The United States title, and kicked off the event by rapping about S.T.D's. Quite a WrestleMania debut! And a gesture on the part of Vince McMahon that spoke volumes: he was taking a chance on the white-boy rapper. One year later, Steve Austin was at WrestleMania 21: locked into his bionic knee braces, he stormed out to a deafening reception as a guest on Piper's Pit. Once again, Stone Cold was called in to keep a segment afloat, as Roddy careened around the ring and threatened to capsize the entire operation. Meanwhile, John Cena beat JBL for his first WWE title. This was a huge turning point for the company: Cena wore the flagship belt, and then he was drafted to the flagship show €“ Raw. It wasn't long before John Cena was heavily promoted as the face of the company, and the future of WWE. His character flourished as the sharp-tongued rapper, but evolved into the much more palatable god-and-country-loving super-Cena who currently holds the record for Make-a-Wish grants. Cena was young, muscular, and willing to work tirelessly and with any storyline thrown his way. Would there have been a position open for John Cena, white-boy rapper, if Steve Austin was still in the picture? Would Cena have languished in the mid card for a few years longer, or kept the rapper image past its shelf life? These two men could have had some brutal knock-down, drag-out battles on the mat and on the microphone, if Austin hadn't retired. Or maybe Cena wouldn't have even had the chance.

1. He Would Have Wrestled CM Punk

Cm Punk Best As The Miz would say, "Really?" This point is stretching our operating assumption quite far €“ that is, Austin wrestling more than a few years without a debilitating injury. While CM Punk really hit the WWE scene five years after Austin's retirement, I'd say that Punk wasn't ripe for a feud with Austin for a few more years thereafter. That puts us into "coming out of retirement" territory, the subject of which has been broached with Austin, especially when both he and Punk have made comments in the media about a match together. What a tease! And yet... would we want to see it? As someone who idolized Ricky Steamboat, I felt a very bittersweet sensation upon seeing him re-surface as a senior at WrestleMania 25 against Chris Jericho. Relatively speaking, he still had it €“ which was much more than we could say for Snuka and Piper in the same match. Austin wouldn't come back unless he could hold his own, Steamboat-style, but with each day that passes, that possibility dwindles further. I'm not sure that I'd even want to see him operating Steamboat style. Stay gold, Stone Cold, stay gold. The Steve Austin mystique lives on. If he had never retired, we wouldn't pounce on comeback rumors with such crazed anticipation. Would he have wrestled CM Punk? In a perfect world, OH HELL YEAH. But I hope we will need to be okay with a retired Steve Austin, because it's much more fun to wonder what would have happened.

Contributor
Contributor

Follow me @kickyhick :) I hold a degree in English Rhetoric & Professional Writing from the University of Waterloo in Canada. I've done technical writing, executive presentations, and recruiting materials for BlackBerry, and I write for non-profit organizations. My favourite project so far has been combining my passion for writing with being a die-hard wrestling fan. It's a pleasure to write here for WhatCulture, and also for TJRwrestling.com.