What is the criteria for whether someone "deserves" a spot at WrestleMania? Is it his tenure with the company? His merchandise sales? Perhaps his work ethic? If you guessed option 4, that it's based on the whims of Vince McMahon, you'd be correct! And so while we cannot define "deserving", because the notion is so subjective, we have to lay down our own whimsical guidelines for this list. I scrutinized the cards of every WrestleMania, all of which I have seen many times ("with pride"). If a name jumped out at me and I found myself thinking either, "Who?" or "Why?" or "Horrible!" then I stopped for further analysis. What could have been the possible reasons for this person being at The Showcase of the Immortals? Are they valid reasons? Could a more deserving person have been in this spot? I tried not to let personal bias get too much in the way, but you can be the judge of that. This is a tricky one to call! Let's see if you agree with this list this first installment covers WrestleManias 21-29.
10. WrestleMania 21 - JBL (vs. John Cena)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOuGlGFTSfM I know, this was probably all based on JBL being a great heel. He brought out the edgy aggression in John Cena upon which Cena's original persona was based. They were great foils on the microphone, both alpha males from different worlds. Different philosophies, different generations. But that doesn't change the fact that this was a boring match for which it didn't seem like a championship could have been at stake. The match was just a whole lot of clobbering, because simply put, that's JBL's style. He was never an exciting wrestler, unless you enjoy a slugfest - but even that gets tiresome, and doesn't seem worthy of the secondary main event at 'Mania. John Cena shines when he's in the ring with an inventive wrestler, not to mention this is Cena 9 years ago, when he was even less experienced. Tazz and Michael Cole do their best to play up the story between these two men, and enhance every move in the ring. After beating up Cena for a long time, we are treated to a sleeper hold (and this after the long-winded Sumo Match, for which I'm giving Big Show a "deserving", because "DIAPER".). Then I realize that it's all a ploy to make Cena look super-human in his comeback, a short-lived Hogan-style exercise in suspended disbelief. And all of a sudden, Cena wins. A totally empty victory after an uninspired match.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3J131j4bDk This may be a controversial pick, given the loyal legions of Bret Hart fans (myself included). But in this fan's opinion, his no holds barred match against Vince was the runner-up for worst match on that WrestleMania card (following close behind the 10-Diva Tag match). Vince's past appearances at WrestleMania have usually been enhanced by engrossing drama and/or hard-core hijinks, but it all fell flat this time (possibly due to his being more elderly). Bret Hart's past appearances at Mania have often ranked as match of the year, some of the greatest matches of his (and his opponents') careers! His reputation is near-immaculate: all the more reason that he shouldn't have been here in a wrestling capacity. The aged/injured state of both men was even more exaggerated by the "added bonus" of the Hart family. Aside from the Hart Dynasty and Natalya (most of whom have failed to inspire much excitement in the ring, in their primes), the Hart family is a weather-beaten crew of bitter folk. Seeing them hobble and sneer their way down the long ramp of the stadium, their legacy just didn't hold up under the glittering lights. While respect should be paid to the Harts for their contributions to pro wrestling, their appearances here (even Bret's), seemed ill-placed. The spotlight became unflattering. The match itself was so plodding and uncomfortable, a tarnishing mark on a once-great grappler's career. Bret deserved a comeback. He deserved closure. But this was too much, for all of us.
8. WrestleMania 28 Most Of Teams Teddy & Johnny
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OjUiAxXNGc This was the equivalent of a Battle Royal, in that it crammed a lot of people into one match, thereby affording them all a WrestleMania moment (and accompanying pay bonus). But the painful, boring storyline leading up to this match was indicative of how awful a "payoff" it would be at the big event. Between the flag bearers (er, "flag buriers", according to Brie Bella's introduction), guest announcers, and valets, you almost don't notice the bevy of barely-talented dudes in the ring. Poor Zack Ryder has even gotten himself a custom-made RyderMania jacket, I suppose all the better to commemorate this "achievement". Aside from his joke-worthy travel mug, David Otunga never clicked as a wrestler, and looks as shoe-horned into this situation as The Great Khali. Factor in the equally yawn-worthy Miz and Drew McIntyre, and the painfully-cheesy Santino, and you have a bloated mess. They've thrown in Booker T as well, who knows all too well about lame WrestleMania gigs! R-Truth, Kofi, Mark Henry and Swagger are all there too, probably happy enough to at least be at Mania, but still working below their potential. The greatest tragedy is that Dolph Ziggler was sucked into this, when he could have been stealing the show elsewhere. This match was worthy of a Smackdown main event at best.
7. WrestleMania 27 The Miz (vs. John Cena)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O20Po-_kyuk To someone's credit, they did a fantastic job of the video package leading up to The Miz's entrance at WrestleMania. It told the story of how he'd always dreamed of being a WWE Superstar, and how the odds were always against him as he clambered through the ranks of the roster. For a few minutes, I felt something for The Miz, and that was a lot more than I'd ever felt for him before or since. And then he came out, clambering again, but this time through a set of giant, inflated letters that spelled "AWESOME". Oh right, it's The Miz. And I'm a selective John Cena fan he can be great on the mic, but he can often be so robotic; he can be a dynamo in the ring, with the right opponent, but The Miz wasn't that. And this was the main event at WrestleMania, so I am most unforgiving. The Miz did NOT deserve to be there, even though he was ultimately a placeholder for The Rock. Someone else could have given Cena a good match, and more intrigue for the fans. Even worse, The Miz has referred to his main-eventing WrestleMania ever since then, as an indicator of his awesome status and reason to be back in the spotlight. It has had the reverse effect, reminding us all of the backstage ineptitude that led to The Miz bursting out from between those huge inflatable letters. It just makes The Miz look even more pathetic, because he never belonged in the main event to begin with.
6. WrestleMania 29 Fandango (vs. Chris Jericho)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YRO3lvxIuLk If you'll recall, Fandango actually had his debut match at WrestleMania. Until that point, he'd dodged his bookings by refusing to wrestle unless they could pronounce his name properly. So unless you'd seen Johnny Curtis's work on NXT, this was everyone's first look at Fandango's wrestling skills. They should not have been showcased here. When you have this much of a build, you'd better deliver, and Fandango did not dazzle in the least. The match was completely unremarkable, and that was only because Chris Jericho and JBL worked so hard to elevate it from complete garbage. It's not that Fandango is a terrible wrestler; it's that his level of expertise was wildly misplaced here. When you're trying to tell the story of an impressive debut, as JBL was doing his darndest to do on commentary, you need the fans to believe that you can challenge your opponent. Luckily, Chris Jericho is known for helping new talent, and he led Fandango through a serviceable match. Unfortunately for the fans, serviceable is really not enough when your expectations are so high at WrestleMania. They did the best they could with what they had, and it DID spark a Fandango-ing revolution for a moment. We'll always have the music.
5. WrestleMania 23 - The New Breed (vs. The ECW Originals)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dZXoMWG-iE I can understand the sentiments behind this choice: the company wanted to lend a higher profile to its fairly new C-list program, ECW. Cobbled together from the dregs of Paul Heyman's ECW and the development outfit known as OVW, the roster would only have been familiar to die-hard fans. For the majority of WrestleMania viewers, most if not all of these guys would have left them scratching their heads, something you do not want people doing at your biggest show of the year. I will concede that The ECW Originals were deserving of a WrestleMania moment, such were their contributions to sports entertainment in general, even if not WWE specifically. Especially given that this crew (Tommy Dreamer, Rob Van Dam, Sandman, and Sabu) were in the twilight of their careers, and probably wouldn't garner another chance to shine on the big stage. But The New Breed - positioned as upstarts who dared to challenge the veterans - consisted of, well, upstarts, who inspired no confidence or excitement whatsoever. Kevin Thorn had a short-lived stint as a vampire known for openly tonguing his valet; Elijah Burke had a more respectable run on several programs, and did not tongue anyone; Matt Striker may be the most recognizable name today, but more for being a commentator, and often for being dislikeable; Marcus Cor Von had a terrible name, and a career that could be equated to the sound of someone passing gas. Their wrestling didn't hold up either, especially in this stadium setting. While they positioned it as a palate cleanser between marquee matches, it failed to refresh. If they wanted to showcase ECW, I would have recommended a 1-on-1 match between their best talents.
4. WrestleMania 21 - Christy Hemme (vs. Trish Stratus)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Pw9k8Sh3VY This is a case of the Playboy model vs. the wrestler (a 6-time champion at that point, to overstate the differential between women at a time when many on the roster could really wrestle). Christy was gorgeous, and so it was understandable that a company would want to use her from a marketing perspective. Past companies who employed Christy: a burlesque troupe, Hawaiian Tropic sun tan lotion, Bench Warmer trading cards, the "Juggy Dance Squad", Hooters, and the Lingerie Football League. That's not to say that her prior work makes her undeserving, but it certainly makes her undeserving of a match against Trish Stratus at WrestleMania. They told the story that Christy was "trained" to "wrestle" by Trish's arch-enemy, the injured Lita. As we see in the clip, Lita was only able to teach her one move of doom, the Twist of Fate, and the rest was in god's hands - or in this case, Trish Stratus. As Christy enters the arena, Lita distances herself from her protege, a skipping, hair-flipping spectacle. Jerry Lawler makes quips about loving Christy's spunk. She may be spunky, but she can't take a bump, let alone get up thereafter. Trish can barely beat her up convincingly, and does her best to lead Christy through this match. Agonizingly awkward, with Trish setting up every move and overselling the offense like a clown. Why couldn't Melina or Victoria have wrestled Trish instead? Oh right, Playboy. After several 2 counts that look like they should have been 3, we are all relieved of this pain when Trish gets the pin (for which she doesn't even bother holding on for the entire 3 count).
3. WrestleMania 22 - The Boogeyman (vs. Booker T and Sharmell)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtN1lKpsnu4 It was suggested that Mark Henry challenging the Undertaker's streak at this Mania is a candidate for undeserving, but I'm going to give Mark a pass, based on his fake retirement speech last year. That swerve was worth a lifetime of forgiveness. However, there is another match on that card which deserves such "undeserving" recognition. From the Bottomless Pit, the Boogeyman! Though undefeated coming into WrestleMania, the Boogeyman was a comedy/carnival act who never really got over in terms of desired reaction. Forced into a farcical fit of overacting, Booker T and Sharmell were terrified of the Boogeyman. Their handicap match versus the worm-spewing freak is thankfully short, supposed comic relief meant to amuse, but failing to do so. Sharmell runs screaming after a worm-infused kiss, and the 5x champion is pinned after a cursory choke slam. Tell me Booker T couldn't have been better used (I'd say, "not at all" might have been better than this embarrassment). Gross in every way.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3phYYHKU8E Now I understand the need for comedy bits and naughty bits as a means of giving the audience a break between high intensity matches, but some of these "palate cleansers" are still undeserving of a spot on the WrestleMania card. For example, the Playboy Bunnymania Lumberjill match. Made "prestigious" and "hip" by the presence of Snoop Dogg (who advises on these special guests?), it was an embarrassing outing for all involved. The other Divas on the roster trail behind Snoop's pimped-out golf cart, gyrating with varying degrees of enthusiasm. It's a throwback to the Godfather and his Hos, many years past its expiry date (and somehow more depressing because those Hos are the likes of Mickie James and Victoria). While Beth and Melina could have put on a respectable match between the two of them, instead we have two Playmates inserted for the sake of "drama". At best, the Bunnies should have joined the other lumberjills at ringside, and witnessed a proper pro wrestling match. At one point, the stadium lights go out a merciful glitch that casts Maria's efforts into the shadows. Alas, the lights come back on in time for us all to see her grind and make out hungrily with Snoop. Cheque, please!
1. WrestleMania 27 Michael Cole (vs. Jerry Lawler)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9NghgpC0_o One might argue that Michael Cole is a bit of a cheat here, as he is not a real wrestler, and I've steered clear of "celebrity guests" who could usually be deemed undeserving. But Cole was such a blinding stain on the WrestleMania record books that his presence could not be ignored. True, part of my vitriol stems from the build to this match, characterizing Michael Cole as a despicable bully. The story was so infantile and annoying that every painful minute wasted on it seemed like an eternity. How agonizing, then, that it was deemed worthy of a WrestleMania moment. Sure, we all laughed and winced to see Cole come out in his creepy collegiate wrestling gear. And yes, they tried to resurrect the situation by adding Steve Austin as the special guest referee. But when a comedy singlet and Stone Cold can't do the trick, you've got one heck of a deficit on your hands. Meanwhile, perfectly able wrestlers are sitting in the back, shaking their heads at it all. Michael Cole didn't raise our ire because he was such a terrific heel. We hated him because we didn't want to see him on our screens! Putting him in the ring against a far-past-his-prime Jerry Lawler handicapped Cole further. Lawler wasn't in Mania shape either, but I won't begrudge him his solitary match on the grandest stage. Michael Cole should have never left the announce table, and his being able to claim a WrestleMania victory sullies the notion of being WrestleMania-worthy.
Follow me @kickyhick :) I hold a degree in English Rhetoric & Professional Writing from the University of Waterloo in Canada. I've done technical writing, executive presentations, and recruiting materials for BlackBerry, and I write for non-profit organizations. My favourite project so far has been combining my passion for writing with being a die-hard wrestling fan. It's a pleasure to write here for WhatCulture, and also for TJRwrestling.com.