WWE: 15 Wrestlers Who Should Have Been Top Guys

Even when they're clearly talented, not every wrestler fulfills their potential. And honestly, that's a damn shame.

"Be not afraid of greatness," the Bard tells us. "Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon 'em." It's a maxim as true in professional wrestling as it was on Shakespeare's stage. Not everyone gets to be the main attraction, though.

Sung or unsung, the wrestlers on this list had just as much charisma and in-ring ability as their more well-known counterparts, and often put many main eventers to shame. Some were held back by the tastes of fans and promoters. Others caved to their own excesses. All played a critical role in making wrestling the modern spectacle it is today.

15. Marty Jannetty

As the Midnight Rockers, Marty Jannetty and Shawn Michaels were a two-man wrestling machine. By the time they hit the WWF in 1988, the team, their name now shortened to the Rockers, were touted by commentator Gorilla Monsoon as "tag team specialists." Quick tags, double-teaming, and a high-energy style would become their trademark, and their rock star looks gave them tremendous youth appeal. (Only heavy metal fans noticed, but Jannetty was a dead ringer for Iron Maiden's Dave Murray.) In the performing arts, real life can sometimes get in the way. Such was the case with the Rockers. Like a great rock band broken up before its time, they were simply too good to last. Tempers were so heated at one point that the pair got into a legitimate fistfight. If not for Randy Savage telling the police that it was all part of a storyline, Jannetty may have gone to jail. Backstage politics and real-life animosity ruined a good thing, and the WWF soon realized that Michaels and Jannetty couldn't co-exist. You know the rest. Michaels put Jannetty through the Barber Shop window. Then he started dressing like a Hallmark card and became a huge star. Jannetty faded from the limelight soon after. He made the occasional return, but he would never make the same splash as his ex-partner. Michaels has always been quick to point out how much he learned from Jannetty. If there's any justice in the WWE Universe, we'll see Jannetty in the Hall of Fame soon.

14. Brian Pillman

If there's one thing wrestling fans and detractors can agree on, it's that wrestling is a work. A fan will tell you, "Of course. That's the point." A non-fan will say, "I don't want to watch fake stuff. Put on American Idol." That's why the infamous Brian Pillman/Steve Austin "gun angle" was so disturbing. It was an eye-roller, to be sure, a desperate attempt to get some attention away from then-ratings champ WCW. It was only unprecedented in the sense that it hadn't happened in wrestling. Bad guys have been brandishing firearms onscreen since "The Great Train Robbery." It was only a matter of time before a gun became a storytelling device on a wrestling show. Even so, the USA Network was livid after the incident, and it undoubtedly affected Pillman's career afterward. Austin went on to unprecedented heights of popularity. Pillman wound up wearing a dress. It was a sign that the writers had run out of things to do with the "Loose Cannon" character. He died of heart disease in 1997, an unfortunate loss of a great talent.

13. Booker T

booker-t Booker T was one of the few wrestlers who could work a crowd as a babyface or a heel. As part of Harlem Heat with his brother Stevie Ray, Booker T immediately cut an impressive figure, taking on main eventers from the outset of his career. He later became the most decorated wrestler in WCW's history, and was WWE's King of the Ring and World Heavyweight Champion. He's a WWE Hall of Famer now, but for a while there, it looked like things weren't going so well. He was one of several names in the Signature Pharmacy affair, in which several wrestlers were linked to the use of anabolic steroids. WWE's Orwellian-named "wellness policy" reared its ugly head, and Booker T soon left for TNA. Booker T has since patched up his relationship with WWE, but his tenure as champion was far too short for a man of his ability.

12. Rob Van Dam

"You deserve no credit for tonight's success. The office might be blind to it, but these people are gonna let you know," Rob Van Dam said at 2005's ECW One Night Stand. Work, shoot, or something in between, his speech to the hardcore faithful was a breath of fresh air, as well as a prototype for CM Punk's "promo heard round the world." A year later, again at One Night Stand, RVD won the WWE title from John Cena. RVD, who had stuck with the original ECW until its demise, had turned the brand back around. For a brief, shining moment, all was well. Then Van Dam got busted with weed and Vicodin. That it happened so late in his career was all the more tragic. RVD would never get another chance to be a top guy in WWE. Fans will debate about whether the fault lay in RVD or in WWE's wellness policy, but the fact remains that, in the end, RVD got suspended, and the ECW fans got Bobby Lashley.

11. Rick Rude

First, there was the whole reworking of "The Stripper." The silly mustache helped, as well. Best of all, though, was the in-ring promo before the match. Who knew you could refer to anyone as a "Pennsylvania p*ss ant," let alone on television, let alone in Pennsylvania? "Ravishing" Rick Rude was a perfect example of what the WWF could do with an already-established wrestler. Gimmicks come and go, and sometimes they feel forced (see: Bastion Booger). Yet every once in a while, a wrestler will turn a gimmick into an essential part of his character. It's one of the things the WWF did best in the eighties: turning established wrestlers into icons. Now recognized by WWE for having the greatest physique in the history of professional wrestling, Rude was better known for his promos. If you were a tad pudgy or had overactive sweat glands, you were guaranteed to be offended. And even if you weren't, there was that creepy hip-grinding thing. Rude's unique ring work and innate sense of timing set him apart from most of his contemporaries. He was a genius at selling moves, and his Rude Awakening finisher was the most painful-looking neck-breaker in the business. He was briefly in the WWF's main event picture, finalizing a feud with champion the Ultimate Warrior in 1990, but it was a short-lived stint. When he retired from regular ring work in 1997, his generation's "methodical pace" was phased out in favor of a faster in-ring style, more Michael Bay than Alfred Hitchcock. He is now perhaps most famous for appearing on both the taped WWF Raw and the live WCW Nitro on the same night, as well as appearing on ECW's Hardcore TV later that week. Even in retirement, "Ravishing" Rick Rude, one of the best villains of the eighties, was breaking new ground. Had he not died of heart failure in 1999, he undoubtedly would have continued to innovate.

10. Tito Santana

They get you every time with those retro discs. You pop in an old Wrestlemania or Summerslam. You hear the unmistakable Latin rhythm of Tito Santana's music. You know you're about to get a great match. Then Jesse Ventura ruins it with one word: Chico. Wrestling has always been a weird mirror of society. The problem is it is often a mirror into the past, at least in terms of race relations. Whether commentators were writing their own burrito jokes or Vince McMahon was privately feeding them lines while publicly pooh-poohing their actions, it doesn't really matter. It was indefensible, then or now. Santana was an amazing technical wrestler with an uncanny ability to work a crowd. He could work a fast-paced match, but was best at building suspense. He appeared in the first nine WrestleManias, and was a solid utility player during his time in the WWF. He was Intercontinental Champion and a World Tag Team Champion, but never quite made it to the top. More enlightened attitudes may have helped sway his career in another direction. Instead, WWF turned him into "El Matador," and gave him a bullfighting gimmick years after fans knew him as the high-flying dude with long hair and a white T-shirt. His matches are fantastic. Watch as many as you can. Just prepare to roll your eyes at the commentary.

9. Ron Simmons

No matter where he worked, Ron Simmons had more strength, ability, and charisma than most of his better-pushed contemporaries. During his five months as WCW Champion (the first African-American World Heavyweight Wrestling Champion in history), he was new, innovative, a champion youths of any color could look up to. It was disappointing to see Simmons him turn heel shortly afterward. Simmons's WWF gimmicks ranged from strange (that weird, blue gladiator-looking costume) to controversial (the original Nation of Domination), to iconic (the Acolytes/APA). He was always a mid-card guy in the WWF, but he was still fun to watch. He also had a single-word signature catch phrase years before Daniel Bryan's. He still shows up now and then, and every time the crowd goes insane. He's a Hall of Famer now, and deservedly so. Still, he could have been champion at least one more time. Damn.

8. Kerry Von Erich

It's hard for people who weren't living in Texas back then to understand just how important World Class Championship Wrestling was, not just to wrestling, but to the culture at large. At the center of this was the feud between the Von Erichs and the Freebirds. ZZ Top's "La Grange" would hit, and the screams would practically crack your television set. Before the Rockers, before John Cena, the Von Erichs were a huge hit with wrestling's fledgling youth market. Considering how not only wrestling, but every facet of popular media is now youth-driven, the Von Erichs were certainly innovators in this regard. In classic WWF fashion, Kerry was nicknamed the "Texas Tornado" when he joined the Federation in 1990. He was quickly thrust into the Intercontinental Championship scene. Holding the IC title was an honor in itself, as always, but at the time it was becoming a bridge to attaining the WWF title. Sadly, this didn't happen for Kerry Von Erich. Like many wrestlers, he became addicted to painkillers. After two drug arrests and the threat of jail time hanging over his head, he shot himself in the heart in 1993. It was a shock to fans, but to the Von Erich family, Kerry was only the latest tragedy; they had already lost three of the legendary brothers. It's impossible to say whether a main event push would have sent Kerry Von Erich's life in a different direction. Taking the later deaths of Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit, both top guys, into account, it's not likely. The champion of a major wrestling promotion has all eyes on him at all times. It's a high-pressure gig, and the last thing Kerry Von Erich needed was more pressure.

7. Bruiser Brody

Brawlers are a dime a dozen these days, but Bruiser Brody was the original. Even Mick Foley, the hardcore legend himself, says that his Cactus Jack character was a ripoff of Brody's in-ring style and demeanor.

Brody was immensely popular with fans, but wasn't the best locker room politician. He was famously uncooperative with wrestlers he didn't like. Brody once stopped working in the middle of a cage match with Lex Luger, just before Luger was to leave NWA Florida for Crockett Promotions. The reasons are unclear, but one thing is for sure: guys in a real fight don't just stand around, which is exactly what Brody did, making Luger look like a chump in the process. Brody is still talked about by old school wrestling fans to this day. His terrifying presence, solid promo work, and feuds with Kamala and Abdullah the Butcher are highlights of a career that ended far too soon. He was stabbed to death by another wrestler, Jose Huertas Gonzalez, in 1988.

6. Curt Hennig

Curt Hennig, a second-generation wrestler and all-around gifted athlete, had already made a name for himself as the AWA Champion by the time he reached the WWF in the late eighties. Under his new moniker Mr. Perfect, Hennig held a winning streak for nearly two years, a gimmick borrowed by Kurt Angle a few years later. He was a two-time Intercontinental Champion, and the first to make that title synonymous with technical wrestling. While Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels went on to become WWF Champions after their respective IC reigns, Hennig remained a mid-card guy. He could out-talk and out-wrestle anyone on any roster, but a series of injuries left him unable to perform regularly. He had a memorable run in WCW as member of the Four Horsemen, the NWO and, best of all, the West Texas Rednecks. He had a brief return to WWE in 2002, but was mainly there to put over other guys, and was released after a legitimate fight with Brock Lesnar. He died of a cocaine overdose in 2003.

5. Jake Roberts

Jake "The Snake" Roberts cut the best promos in the history of wrestling. Words seemed to pour out of Roberts, and not the made-up, Ultimate Warrior kind. Roberts had the ability to hype a match like no other, and did it in a far more intelligent manner than the usual blathering, yelling style that wrestling fans had become accustomed to. Although he didn't have the most traditional body type, Roberts's in-ring work was second to none. Since he didn't have the bodybuilder physique of the Rock N' Wrestling era, he had to work extra hard to make his matches realistic. His slew of dirty tricks, including his patented DDT finishing maneuver, convinced fans that, face or heel, he was the most dangerous man in wrestling. These qualities alone should have guaranteed Jake Roberts a top spot, but it wasn't in the cards. He left the WWF in 1992, played a heel in WCW for a while, then returned to the WWF in 1996 with a born-again Christian gimmick, inadvertently playing a vital role in Steve Austin's rise to the top of the company. He was hoping to get a writing gig with the WWF, but it didn't pan out and he left again. His appearance in 1999's Beyond the Mat cemented his legacy in the eyes of many fans. The documentary was a high-profile release, and depicted Jake as a crack-smoking womanizer with an estranged daughter. He made sporadic wrestling appearances afterwards, and even released his own documentary with WWE, but the damage was done. The most recent news about Jake Roberts is that he's recovering with the help of his friend, Diamond Dallas Page. If yoga can get Roberts back into wrestling shape, we may see his best work yet.

4. Owen Hart

Owen Hart was, arguably, a better performer, both in the ring and on the mike, than his more famous brother Bret. From his high-flying abilities to his solid ground game, he was the prodigal son of Stu Hart's famous "dungeon." He wasn't afraid to make himself look like a dork, either. If you can make the audience laugh, you're halfway there, and Owen had that ability in spades. Had it not been for his 24 meter fall from the rafters in 1998, Owen Hart would most assuredly have become a WWE Champion. His legacy as a performer speaks for itself. His presence is sorely missed.

3. Davey Boy Smith

"British Bulldog" Davey Boy Smith was the total package long before Lex Luger took that nickname for himself. He was the genuine article, a guy who could make you believe, night after night. Smith first made a name for himself along with the great Dynamite Kid, as part of the legendary British Bulldogs tag team. Later, in singles competition, he and Bret Hart had the greatest Intercontinental Championship match of all time at Wembley Stadium, the first time the WWF had made the IC Title the main event of the evening. After that, he was in an out of the WWF, his first release due to the revelation that he and the Ultimate Warrior were using human growth hormone. This was around the time of Vince McMahon's steroid trial, so it's arguable that the company was making an example of anyone caught using. He hopped back and forth between WCW and the WWF over the years, went through a divorce, and entered rehab for painkillers, but never quite attained the popularity he had a few years before. He died in 2002.

2. Ted DiBiase

"Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase was, hands down, the Rock n' Wrestling era's best villain. Infamous for his trickery, as well as his harsh treatment of his bodyguard Virgil, DiBiase was equally celebrated as the WWF's most gifted technical wrestler. He was a staple player during the eighties and nineties. If you turned on a WWF program, you were guaranteed to hear his maniacal laugh and "Million Dollar Rap" theme song, which he performed himself. You were also guaranteed an outstanding match. DiBiase could elevate a Saturday morning squash match to high art, all while being persistently booed. He obviously enjoyed playing the bad guy, but his moves were smoother-looking than most babyfaces'. DiBiase was briefly in the main event picture during the late eighties, but it didn't last nearly long enough. He tried to buy the WWF title, which led to a title tournament at the over-long WrestleMania IV. He wrestled three times that night, eventually losing to Randy Savage. He later appeared with his own iconic Million Dollar Championship, and became a Tag Team Champion along with Irwin R. Schyster in the legendary Money, Inc. A neck injury took him out of action, and he became a commentator and manager.

1. Scott Hall

Two words: "Hey, yo." If you hadn't known Big Scott Hall from his AWA days, or even his early WCW run as the Diamond Studd, then you were probably convinced he really was Razor Ramon, the Cuban-American from Miami, Florida. You may have even believed that if something happened to that gold, something was going to happen to the poor guy holding it at ringside. Scott Hall invented the character as an attempt to branch out from what he'd been doing, and was so successful that WCW eventually called him back, where he made wrestling history. As the first member of the NWO to be seen by wrestling fans, his very presence convinced everyone that the WWF was invading and taking over WCW. To this day, Hall's charisma sets him apart from the pack. He was frequently involved in the main event scene, but never quite stayed in the spotlight. Although a four-time Intercontinental Champion, he never won the WWF Championship, a belt he would have been greatly suited to wear. He got the NWO ball rolling, but once Nash and Hogan revealed themselves, he seemed more like a sideman, a "medium-sized mang" after all. Not that any of that matters. Hall's fans knew he was more gifted than just about anyone he wrestled. His personal troubles are well-documented, but like Jake Roberts, Scott Hall appears to be headed for a recovery thanks to his friend Diamond Dallas Page. His son Cody is wrestling now, and the kid looks poised for greatness. Perhaps we'll get another father-son tag team out of the deal.

Contributor
Contributor

Check out "The Champ" by my alter ego, Greg Forrest, in Heater #12, at http://fictionmagazines.com. I used to do a mean Glenn Danzig impression. Now I just hang around and co-host The Workprint podcast at http://southboundcinema.com/.