WWE Battleground 2016: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
What a pleasant surprise.
It's fair to say that expectations weren't massively high for this year's Battleground PPV: half the card looked uninspired and the fan consensus seemed to be that this was merely a filler stop-gap ahead of next month's SummerSlam.
That said, Battleground actually ended up being a relatively consistent and solid show, save for one undeniably terrible match. The rest ranged from acceptable TV-standard matches to a number of genuinely involving bouts, while the night's winner was genuinely one of the best displays the WWE has put on all year.
Sure, nothing of any real significance actually happened, cementing how arbitrary this show was, but it was a largely entertaining event on the whole and far better than most fans seemed to expect, so that's something.
Here is every WWE Battleground 2016 match ranked from worst to best...
9. I.C. Title: The Miz (c) Vs. Darren Young
Result: Young and Miz fight to what is apparently a double disqualification...for some reason (8:41).
Rating: Though it seemed possible that Darren Young's recent upswing might have an actual payoff, the fact that it would've resulted in Smackdown ending up with just one title made it pretty clear it wouldn't be happening.
Much like Becky vs. Natalya, this one suffered from having to come after Zayn vs. Owens, as it paled so heavily in comparison, such that the crowd resorted to "boring!" chants after a few minutes. Miz and Young tried to liven things up with a test of strength...which was a terrible idea.
The worst thing about this match, however, was the atrocious and confusing finish, and given that no result was ever actually announced, we're going with the real winner being the fan who shouted to Miz, "Straight to DVD, baby!".
3/10
8. U.S. Title: Rusev (c) Vs. Zack Ryder
Result: Ryder taps out to the Accolade (7:01).
Rating: Once you got over how distractingly awful Zack Ryder's attire was...this was pretty much exactly the match you'd expect, if at least a few minutes longer than the squash you might've anticipated.
Ryder got a few nice, high-impact spots in, but he was never going to win, and he pretty much just got fed to Rusev, though almost breaking out of the Accolade at least made him look strong (kinda), even if it's ultimately for naught as the WWE will never do much worthwhile with him.
Still, at least Ryder got some PPV time, which is both rare and very much welcome. That post-match Mojo Rawley debut fell incredibly flat, though.
5/10
7. Natalya Vs. Becky Lynch
Result: Becky taps out to the Sharpshooter (9:04).
Rating: Sadly this one was pretty much just filler and didn't do much of interest at all, even if it wasn't bad by any means, and definitely suffered from following the white-hot Zayn/Owens match. The crowd seemed totally bored by it and though Becky's leg selling was terrific, it just felt like a straight-up TV match with absolutely nothing to distinguish it.
Considering the popular belief that Natalya is nearing the end of her WWE run, this one did absolutely nothing good for Becky, and just solidifies how maltreated she's been by creative as of late.
Not outright bad by any means, just a bit dull.
5/10
6. The New Day Vs. The Wyatt Family
Result: Bray drills Xavier with the Sister Abigail (8:47).
Rating: This one started out pretty limp and struggled to find an exciting rhythm, but forcing two tag matches on the crowd in a row is always a risky prospect.
Still, it picked up soon enough with some impressive shows of strength from the Wyatts and exciting high-wire work from Xavier and Kofi, while Big E damn-near killed himself with his dive through the ropes.
Nothing in the ring was as entertaining, however, as Cole's "flotting a swy" commentary botch, which got most of the match's social media attention.
Still, the right team won, which is the most important thing, even if the match was pure TV fodder.
5/10
5. Pre-Show: The Usos Vs. Breezango
Result: Tyler Breeze rolls Jimmy into a small package for the pin (5:26).
Rating: It's fair to say that this was a quintessential pre-show match and few were particularly hyped for it. That said, it was a surprisingly lively and watchable bout, full of solid spots and frantic athleticism, and it didn't outstay its welcome by a single second either.
Considering the low expectations and general murky standard of pre-show bouts, this really wasn't bad at all and the crowd actually managed to get into it. And with all this, the right guys won too, especially given the huge heat The Usos have had lately.
6/10
4. Charlotte & Dana Brooke Vs. Sasha Banks & Bayley
Result: Charlotte taps out to Sasha's Bank Statement (7:25).
Rating: This was a strange choice to kick off the show, but it got things off to a strong start as Sasha Banks' partner did indeed turn out to be Bayley as so many hoped for. Sadly, though, JBL suggested that this didn't mean she had actually been called up to the main roster.
Sure, this was a hugely predictable match, but the crowd were hot for it throughout and Bayley and Sasha carried Charlotte and Dana to some of their best in-ring work in a while.
It seemed like an odd choice not to have Bayley win the match for her team (at least until it sunk in that she was remaining in NXT), but on the other hand Sasha beating Charlotte (and giving her the first PPV loss of her career) nicely sets up their inevitable SummerSlam match.
Not Sasha or Bayley's finest displays, and it probably could've gone a few minutes longer, but a solid opener all the same.
6/10
3. John Cena, Enzo & Cass Vs. The Club
Result: Cena destroys AJ with a top-rope Attitude Adjustment (14:30).
Rating: Enzo's pre-match promo ended up being the most entertaining component of this one, but the bout itself was a reliably solid affair as expected, even if having AJ ultimately eat the pin felt like a huge mistake, though it suitably sets up a Cena/AJ SummerSlam rematch.
This one didn't do anything spectacular but it also didn't get much wrong: it was the fun, fast-paced match it needed to be, and despite the end result everyone came out of it looking good, especially Enzo, which Vince and creative are hopefully taking big note of.
7/10
2. WWE Title: Dean Ambrose (c) Vs. Seth Rollins Vs. Roman Reigns
Result: Ambrose nails a sneaky Dirty Deeds on Reigns to retain the title (18:03).
Rating: This one took a little while to grow, but it was fun seeing the separate Raw and Smackdown locker rooms intently watching the match, and the McMahons thankfully didn't get involved in it despite being at ringside throughout.
Seeing Ambrose and Rollins briefly team up to dismantle Roman was undeniably satisfying to any Reigns haters, and played perfectly into the narrative that's been building since his suspension.
Considering that this one really could've gone in any direction, it was a relief that Ambrose wasn't just keeping the belt warm for Rollins, and Reigns got a fan-friendly punishment by eating the clean pin.
A thoroughly entertaining main event on the whole.
7/10
1. Sami Zayn Vs. Kevin Owens
Result: Zayn drills Owens with the Helluva Kick for the win (18:22).
Rating: Though it's understandable that some might start feeling fed up of this feud, it's hard to deny that Owens and Zayn have insane in-ring chemistry, and delivered another terrifically entertaining bout that easily stands among the year's best.
Though it looked like Zayn's nasty botch was going to torpedo the match, to his enormous credit he hung in there and didn't go for a fast finish. The injury only added a layer of psychology and emotion to the fight, and didn't stop him nailing a brutal apron brainbuster a few moments later.
Though this probably should be the decisive end to the feud, they sure as hell served up another corker. Nothing else on the show could touch this.
8/10
What did you think of this year's Battleground? What was your favourite match of the night? Shout it out in the comments!