WWE Crown Jewel 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Crown Jewel could be a vicious slap back to reality for WWE fans.

Triple H LA Knight
WWE

CAUTION! This piece was written on Halloween, so it's perhaps no coincidence it's crammed full of spooky horrors and nightmarish outcomes that'll leave you with half-chewed fingernails. Speaking of which, WWE's creative team must be gnawing their own nails ahead of Crown Jewel, because they've got some big decisions to make.

What if they make all the wrong ones?!

Oh, don't make that face. You know the drill by now, surely. The word "nightmares" in the title gives the game away. This article is obsessed with all the worst that could occur on WWE's next PLE. Saturday night's big show could be a pre-Survivor Series shocker!

Picture championship changes you definitely don't want to happen, writers slapping longstanding gimmicks right in the chops, more misery for top babyfaces, middle-finger sporting heels laughing at you and more. Those are the kinds of scares which could be waiting on WWE Network/Peacock this weekend.

There's virtually nothing positive within these pages. So, if you dare, take a walk through a WWE-themed house of horror and find out just how awful things could be come close of business on Saturday.

Have fun!

10. Nia Jax Becomes Women’s World Champ

Nia Jax middle finger
Instagram, @niajaxwwe

Good lord, what a terrifying thought.

The cat was out the bag a long time ago: Nia Jax is not a great worker, and is in fact rather dangerous during select moments in-ring. She is relatively fresh again having just returned though, and Rhea Ripley has a lot of other business going on with the Judgment Day. What if? what if?! Oh...oh no!

It'd be rotten if Triple H decided to put the Women's World Title on Nia and cast her as some dominant heel veteran who's returned to run roughshod over a division that was frankly better off without her. If that sounds harsh, then apologies, but the thought of Jax as champ is grim.

Rhea-listically, Ripley is the one who should hold onto that belt for as long as possible. Nobody else involved in this five-way has the star power she possesses. Unfortunately, WWE has made poor decisions before, and this would qualify as another one.


9. IYO SKY Loses Her Belt Too

IYO SKY
WWE

Might as well double up on that women's division misery.

IYO SKY appears to be viewed as little more than a transitional champion by creative. Fingers crossed that's way wide of the mark, because she has some seriously good matches, but long term? Yeah, long term it's difficult to see WWE sticking by the Damage CTRL member as Women's Champion.

Bianca Belair is a much bigger star and has the potential to blossom as a reborn heel who rubs her 'EST' stuff in everyone's faces. Higher-ups may figure that Bianca on top would be a good thing for SmackDown. It could even lead to another showdown vs. Charlotte Flair or WWE newbie Jade Cargill in time for 'Mania.

Something just feels off about SKY right now. She's probably cooked as a credible threat to the top prizes going forwards if she loses on Saturday, but she's had zero character development since winning gold. The writers may have eyes on a side-story that's been bubbling under the surface for a while instead.


8. And Bayley Is To Blame!

Damage CTRL Bayley IYO SKY Dakota Kai
WWE.com

Would anybody be proper shocked if Bayley finally turned on IYO and cost her the Women's Title at Crown Jewel? WWE is going to get to this Damage CTRL split eventually. It's a matter of time, folks. Trips could be thinking Bianca on top as champ as then a non-title rivalry between SKY and Bayley is his best bet.

Admittedly, this has been brewing for a good while, but...is it honestly necessary? It wouldn't even make sense if the announcers claimed Bayley was jealous of IYO. What does she have to be jealous of? Bayley has held multiple championships, and it isn't like SKY is exactly taunting her.

This plot point could be tricky.

There's a nagging thought at the back of this writer's head though. He can see Bayley vindictively costing IYO her belt, then trying to turn Dakota Kai against SKY as well before kicking both out of CTRL and warring with them. The problem? WWE needs good reason to do that.


7. WWE Misses A Big Layup

Rey Mysterio Logan Paul
WWE.com

An old WCW pay-per-view binging session led yours truly to an unmasked Rey Mysterio teaming with Billy Kidman to open up Halloween Havoc 2000 in a three-way tag match. It was genuinely so weird to see Rey running around with devil horns on in such an unimportant spot 23 years ago, and it was even stranger to realise he's the current WWE United States titleholder.

At least for now.

Logan Paul is surely winning that belt on Saturday and giving the midcard strap some crossover shine Mysterio (for all his brilliance) simply can't provide. Or, WWE could mess things up by booking Rey-Rey to win thanks to his LWO pals, thus leaving Paul without much to do heading into the latter part of the year.

Mysterio vs. Santos Escobar (that's incoming) for the US Title is nowhere near as interesting as Logan holding it would be. Like it or not, he commands attention from an audience bigger than WWE's, and that must guarantee his first title.

Anything else would be quite the clanger.


6. Jey Uso Accidentally Costs Cody Rhodes

Cody Rhodes is sad
WWE

Jey Uso was chatting about how much he'd like to win the Undisputed Tag Titles with Cody Rhodes again on Raw. That experiment is almost certainly over, but Uso and Rhodes can remain friends on TV heading through Survivor Series. They might be frosty friends if this does down mind.

Nobody needs to see Cody looking all sad and dejected again for a while. His loss to Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39 was a little too much for some fans, and they still haven't forgiven Triple H for refusing to upset The Bloodline narrative by having Roman take a loss.

Those people will be seething if Rhodes gets all teary-eyed again at Crown Jewel.

It's possible. Jey might well try to offset Judgment Day interference by interfering himself, but that'd end badly if Uso accidentally hampered Cody's chances and inadvertently handed the win to Money In The Bank holder Damian Priest.

Cue tension, and cue Rhodes having to forgive then forget if he can.


5. John Cena Obliterates Solo Sikoa

John Cena Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

A shudder went up one's spine when hearing John Cena masterfully manipulate fans into feeling sorry for him during a promo on SmackDown. 'Big Match John' pointed out he hadn't been winning too many matches on his own recently. This just in. He doesn't need to.

It'd be senseless if that was setup for Cena to beat Solo Sikoa.

Some older Cena marks might not like this (this guy is one of them, so he understands the difficulty), but here's the truth: John Cena never needs to win another one-on-one match in WWE again. He's had his time, and is only useful for helping fresher stars get over and reach the next level.

Solo is the concern at Crown Jewel, not John. There'd be absolutely no need to cut Sikoa down just so Saudi fans can see Cena hit an Attitude Adjustment then celebrate in front of them. Words cannot fully describe just how crucial this win could be for Solo's development and credibility.


4. Drew McIntyre Wins Gold Before Going Heel

Seth Rollins Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Note the wording there.

"Before" going heel. In other words, Drew McIntyre eventually turning full on heel is something you should get down to the bookies about. It's nailed on, and that seems to be true even if the big Scot neglects to put pen to paper on a WWE contract extension soon.

Putting the World Title on Drew mid-character arc would be too messy. Pro wrestling alignment changes are best kept as simple as possible. Plus, if McIntyre got the win on Saturday and held that belt aloft, what would he have to be mad about? It'd be like nothing ever happened between WrestleMania 36 and today.

No, no WWE cannot crown McIntyre champ before they know what's going on with his contract and before his on-screen presentation is more settled. Rollins' back injury story is still purring away, but he can soldier on for a while longer. If Drew is the guy to beat him later, fine. Just not at Crown Jewel pre-full on heel run.


3. Team Raw Vs. Team SmackDown Is Confirmed

Nick Aldis Adam Pearce
WWE

A quick glance at social media reveals some are for this and others against it. No prizes for guessing where this fella lands considering he's plopped it out onto a list about the worst that could happen on Crown Jewel. "Brand warfare" is an archaic concept, and frankly needs to beat it for good.

On the whole, fans don't really care about who has the superior show. Most watch both anyway, and it's hardly enticing to see Raw vs. SmackDown when there's nothing actually at stake other than bragging rights. Sadly, Nick Aldis turning up to become blue brand GM (as well as recent segments opposite Adam Pearce) suggest WWE disagrees.

Another face-to-face on Saturday could lead to more brand stuff, but hopefully not. Survivor Series would be strangled if it becomes another procession of meaningless 'Us vs. Them' fare that's hastily forgotten about as soon as clocks strike midnight post-PLE.

Sorry, WWE. Raw vs. SmackDown is old hat.


2. LA Knight Was Just Flavour Of The Month

LA Knight John Cena
WWE.com

Will LA Knight be a higher-profile Zack Ryder?

Don't rule it out, because the company has previous when it comes to dumping stars who catch fire with the audience. Obviously, creative has backed Knight well to this point, but it could all come crashing down after Crown Jewel. He'll likely fail to beat Roman Reigns. What's next after that?!

LA can become a sustainable headliner even in defeat, sure, but not if WWE loses interest in him. No-one should enjoy the idea of Knight being revealed as some creative team flavour of the month - the kind of flavour that's irresistible to begin with, but then gets boring as soon as you stumble upon another.

People have Knight in the convo to win January's Royal Rumble, so the fanbase believes in this dude. The layout of Saturday's match vs. Reigns, and the aftermath on TV, will reveal whether or not WWE's decision makers view him as a long-term concern.


1. Damian Priest Cashes In…On Roman Reigns!

Damian Priest WWE Money In The Bank
WWE.com

All signs are that Damian Priest will cash in his MITB briefcase on the World Heavyweight Championship and become Raw's top dog for a spell. He's even spoken of breaking Seth Rollins' heart, but something Rhea Ripley said recently on Raw got the wheels turning on something else.

That "something else" being Priest attempting a cash in on Roman Reigns and the Undisputed prize instead. Being totally honest, that'd be an automatic fail for the Judgment Day man. It'd obliterate his main event promise and make the briefcase gimmick look totally useless all at once.

Could it happen? Sure it could.

Keep an eye on the bout pitting Roman vs. LA Knight. If the latter takes Reigns to the limit and leaves him exhausted then victorious, then 'Mami' might trigger a MITB moment for one of her boys but end up furious when it flops.

What other nightmares can you see coming true at WWE Crown Jewel 2023? For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From IMPACT Wrestling Live and WWE 2K23: 15 TNA CAWs You Must Download!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.