WWE 2K23: 15 TNA CAWs You Must Download

Get ready to fly...through IMPACT history in WWE 2K23 with these phenomenal TNA CAWS!

WWE 2K23 AJ Styles TNA
2K Games

Kenny Loggins was wrong.

You're not about to enter the 'Danger Zone', you're about to re-enter the 'Impact Zone' due to recent revelations that IMPACT Wrestling will soon return to the TNA name. Yes, yes that Loggins reference was a seriously dated one, but it's rather fitting giving the retro vibes of this Total Nonstop Action reprise.

Your console's storage space might already be bursting at the seams with countless CAWS from old-school WWF, WCW and WWE's latest to AEW, New Japan and others. Room for more? If so, then feast your eyes on some of these wonderful TNA/IMPACT beauties ripped straight from the ever-handy Community Creations tabs in WWE 2K23.

The aim here is to fill up more save slots with a mix of TNA favourites old and new. Ever wondered what it'd be like to see 2005-2009 era AJ Styles light up Raw, SmackDown or WrestleMania? You're covered. Fancy signing IMPACT sensation Josh Alexander out from underneath the nose of Scott D'Amore? Do it - this is your game.

All 15 of these TNA CAWs are must-haves. Less time browsing the tabs, more time playing!

15. Alex Shelley

WWE 2K23 Alex Shelley
2K Games

Creator: PacCreates

Downloads: 5,539

There's no better place to start than with reigning IMPACT World Champion and ex-tag star Alex Shelley. This Motor City Machine Gun has been wonderfully-recreated in WWE 2K23 thanks to PacCreates. Attention to detail is the name of the game here, which is why Alex kicks off the list.

He's a preview of the high quality to come.

Of course, you can always nab a copy of Chris Sabin whilst you're at it. Not only is he the current X Division Champ, but he's also perfect for teaming with Shelley and reliving those classic TNA memories. 'Best Of 5' with Beer Money, anyone?


14. Josh Alexander

WWE 2K23 Josh Alexander
2K Games

Creator: CasperCaws

Downloads: 26,844

An awful lot of people are excited to see what Josh Alexander will accomplish in 2024. Will he move on from TNA to pastures new and maybe (just maybe) try his luck in WWE via NXT? Or, does a spot on the AEW roster sound more likely for the talented technician?

Either way, fans win.

The same can be said for this CAW, should you choose to download it. CasperCaws has included two different attires to muck around with too, which is always lovely. So, if you're into your amateur stylings and want to match Josh up vs. Chad Gable, then have at it.


13. Eric Young

WWE 2K23 Eric Young
2K Games

Creator: IconicCaws

Downloads: 7,978

Some of the best CAWs on the market manage to bridge that gap between old and new. Case in point: THIS Eric Young. It has a splash of SAnitY to it, but the model is also faithful to the look EY has used since returning to IMPACT post-WWE stint.

If you're feeling funky, then you can always dip into the character edit screens, give Young some hair to make him look...well, younger, then recapture his glory days of yesteryear when the guy was a fun-loving babyface. Or a TNA version of Daniel Bryan's rise to the top.

Just saying - there were parralells with the booking!


12. Moose

WWE 2K23 Moose
2K Games

Creator: IconicCaws

Downloads: 4,026

It's kinda apropos that Moose is included here, because he brought back the old TNA Championship before company management made the change back from IMPACT to those three letters. There are certainly worse ways to spend your time than by recreating that in WWE 2K23's Universe Mode.

Make it happen, people.

The detail on Moose's ink work is especially pleasing with this CAW. Sadly, it doesn't come with a backup attire, but gamers can always have fun coming up with their own designs if the red trunks get boring. An all-round solid package from top to bottom. MOOSE!


11. Joe Hendry

WWE 2K23 Joe Hendry
2K Games

Creator: marmas

Downloads: 920

Less than 1,000 people have downloaded this Joe Hendry CAW, and that just won't do. Is it facially spot on? Nah, not really, but that shouldn't matter too much during matches at a distance. Besides, there's a lot to like about this download elsewhere.

Check the alt attires. First, you've got Joe's current look on TNA programming. Then, you can dive back into his independent wrestling past to become a "Local/Global Hero" (whichever one suits you) from the ICW/Defiant days.

More Hendry creations should pop up on the community hub as he gains traction in the promotion. The dude's unbelievably entertaining, let's be honest.


10. Magnus/Nick Aldis

WWE 2K23 Nick Aldis
2K Games

Creator: MisterFiendX

Downloads: 6,426

Now isn't this interesting?

Nick Aldis was recently installed as the new SmackDown GM, so it's timely. Also, more importantly for placement on this list, Aldis (as Magnus) is a former TNA World Champ. Sure, you could bung him in a suit and leave it at that. Or, you could play out Nick's matches in the NWA and IMPACT on WWE's stage.

A rematch vs. Cody Rhodes is practically begging to happen. Triple H might not make that a reality on WWE TV/PLE, so why not get it done in WWE 2K23? Oh, and download an NWA Title to stick around his waist. It just looks right.


9. Mickie James

WWE 2K23 Mickie James
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 24,147

Grab some "Hardcore Country" whilst you're downloading Aldis.

He and Mickie James are hitched in real life, so it's a cool idea to tag-team the pair in WWE 2K23. Let's face it, there's every chance Mickie makes a few more cameo appearances for the E at some point anyway. For now, she's back on IMPACT, and should play a neat role in the TNA return early next year.

WhatsTheStatus typically went to town on every little detail. That's a hallmark of their CAW work, to be honest, and it's appreciated. Honestly, this James creation looks like it was crafted by 2K artists themselves, which is a huge compliment.


8. James Storm

WWE 2K23 James Storm
2K Games

Creator: SteveWiseblood

Downloads: 4,891

What was that about Beer Money vs. Motor City Machine Guns in 2023/2024?! OK, so one Bobby Roode isn't on this list, but TNA versions of him do exist via Community Creations if that's your thing. If not, then just download James Storm solo and go 'Cowboy' on everyone in sight.

Time to put that all-too-brief NXT run right second time around, y'know? Storm should've got a fairer crack of the whip in WWE circles, but one of the best things about these video games is you can find out what might've happened if James had stuck around.

Top, top CAW.


7. Abyss

WWE 2K23 Abyss
2K Games

Creator: DapperArtistIT

Downloads: 22,677

This is another cracker.

Almost 23,000 gamers agree, and the downloads will only continue to rack up for DapperArtistIT if they keep pumping out CAWs of this standard. Here's a question: Who doesn't want to play as old TNA wrecking ball Abyss, and make dream matches vs. The Undertaker and Kane a reality for the WWE producer?

Bonus points for that shock white attire and the craftsmanship on the mask. That'd bring tears to a glass eye. Now, download some retro Mick Foley models and create the best hardcore tag-team pro wrestling never had. Paul Heyman would've loved that idea back during the original ECW days.


6. Trinity

WWE 2K23 Trinity Naomi
2K Games

Creator: illitegaming

Downloads: 3,183

OK, so this CAW is actually tagged under Naomi rather than Trinity, but it still counts. The current Knockouts World Champion doesn't wear her latest ring gear in this download, but it remains a winner nonetheless and is a real must-have to anyone who wants to play as her.

There are some alternatives if you'd rather have have something bang up to date. A quick search reveals them, but Trinity's face isn't quite as good as it is here in those packages. If that's important to you, then grab illitegaming's work instead.

They just crept up over the 3,000 mark for downloads. Let's keep that number growing!


5. Sting

WWE 2K23 Joker Sting TNA
2K Games

Creator: drake

Downloads: 13

It's 'Joker' Sting!

He's been a 'Surfer', a 'Crow' and an 'Icon', but the Heath Ledger homage remains one of Sting's most curious chapters. It happened exclusively in TNA too, and that's rather special. Countless variations of the Stinger litter download pages (from retro NWA/WCW to AEW, WWE etc), but this is a one-off.

One drake literally just uploaded 'Joker' Sting a few days ago, and it seems to be a bit of a hidden secret amongst WWE 2K23 players. 13 downloads is the real joke here. This kind of unique CAW work, one focused on a very specific era, is essential.


4. Bully Ray

WWE 2K23 Bully Ray
2K Games

Creator: RHassell94078

Downloads: 4,279

It's really fun to get both Dudley Boyz and play the hits in 2K23, but something else tasty is waiting if you're that way inclined. Basically, you should ignore the phone number style of RHassell94078's username, hop on their creation page and download this version of Bully Ray.

Aces & Eights goodness awaits you.

Ray had one hell of a singles run in TNA a decade or so ago, but it rarely gets the love or respect it should. Is that because Bully was never a credible singles wrestler in WWE? Maybe. Is that totally unfair? Absolutely. Good thing you've got stellar CAWs like this to make things right in-game.


3. Jeff Jarrett

WWE 2K23 Jeff Jarrett
2K Games

Creator: DreCAWS

Downloads: 6,249

The man who started it all, folks.

TNA wouldn't exist without the influence of Jeff Jarrett. He might be riding high as a surprisingly-good addition to the AEW ranks today, but ol' J-E-Double-F laid foundations for what IMPACT became. No TNA reprise would be possible without his hard graft and entrepreneurial spirit.

One of the nifty things about DreCAWs handiwork is that it covers multiple eras of Jarrett. The alternative attire is straight up AEW circa 2023, but the first one could encapsulate WWF, WCW, TNA and the independents. In fairness, that might be because Jeff never seems to age.

Cherish him in digital form.


2. Gail Kim

WWE 2K23 Gail Kim
2K Games

Creator: wcruz

Downloads: 4,250

Gail Kim was a true trailblazer of her time. She refused to put up with utter nonsense attitudes towards women's wrestling in WWE during the "Diva"-obsessed days, and carved out a legacy for herself on the TNA side. Those bruising battles vs. Awesome Kong defo stand the test of time.

wcruz nailed it, although it would've been lovely to see a second set of ring gear for our Gail.

That's a small gripe, because the quality of character model is second to none. This is the best version of Kim on Community Creations, and even beats out some really great efforts that aim to honour both failed WWE stints.


1. AJ Styles

WWE 2K23 AJ Styles TNA
2K Games

Creator: WhatsTheStatus

Downloads: 32,939

Good lord, WhatsTheStatus - does this person ever take a break?!

No wonder almost 33,000 players decided to hit the download button and grab this retro-tastic CAW of AJ Styles. Much like the man's body of work (and his nickname), it really is phenomenal. What's more, there are two separate versions of the character available, which takes the attire count up to four if you need that in your life.

Word of warning: Don't panic when you download then dip into the edit screens to take a look close up. This download is automatically set as an alt attire for the base AJ model already on-disc, so you won't find TNA's Styles rattling around as a separate choice on the wrestler select menus.

Keep that in mind, but have fun.

Which other TNA CAWs have you found on Community Creations? For more like this, check out WWE 2K23: 18 Best Legends CAWs You Must Download and WWE 2K23: 13 Best Female CAWs You Must Download!


In this post: 
TNA WWE 2K23
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.