WWE Extreme Rules 2022: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

How could Triple H ruin Extreme Rules and Bray Wyatt's WWE Return? Here's how.

WWE Extreme Rules 2022 Austin Theory Bray Wyatt
WWE

Extreme Rules is the first 'B' pay-per-view of the Triple H era.

'The Game' assumed control from Vince McMahon right in time for bumper stadium events like SummerSlam and the UK special Clash At The Castle. Both played before big crowds and bagged a lot of natural attention from an audience intrigued by what WWE under Hunter Hearst Helmsley might look like.

This weekend's show doesn't have that honeymoon-style buff. No, it's a secondary show, and that's evidenced by the fact that top man Roman Reigns isn't even on the card. Christ, the dual WWE/Universal Champion probably won't even be in Philadelphia full stop - he might be doing media for an upcoming scrap with Logan Paul in Saudi Arabia instead.

Is this the nightmare fans should be concerned about though? Hmm, not really, but...unwanted MITB cash-ins and a wasted re-debut certainly would be. Bray Wyatt is the talk of the town right now due to WWE's 'White Rabbit' business, and Trips may reason that Extreme Rules needs something newsworthy to make it feel less like background noise to Crown Jewel.

"Let Him In" could become 'Stress Fans Out'.

10. WWE Repeats A SummerSlam Mistake

WWE SummerSlam 2022 Liv Morgan Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

At SummerSlam, WWE torched Liv Morgan's sympathy vote by booking a half-baked finish that saw the MITB winner tap out as the ref counted Ronda Rousey's shoulders to the mat. Morgan won, but she really, really didn't deserve to. It was a baffling decision when Liv needed a proper show of faith from creative.

What if they do it again?!

The company has booked themselves into a corner with this feud pre-Extreme Rules. Ronda is a reborn heel who could believably smash most on the roster into tiny bits, but Liv desperately needs some credibility again. In the end, WWE's writers may panic and reach for the 'sketchy finish' button again.

This would be a disaster for two reasons. Firstly, Liv's dire SmackDown Women's Title reign would continue. Second, there's just no way a boisterous Philly crowd would accept WWE running back one of SummerSlam's worst moments approx two months on.

Brace yourselves for boos if they even dare.


9. Charlotte Flair Returns…As A Babyface

Charlotte Flair Cruella
WWE.com

Then, start palming your foreheads.

Charlotte Flair is rumoured to be Bianca Belair's rival heading into WrestleMania 39 season. That's what industry critics and Twitter claims, at least. There's also a chance that Charlotte will return on Saturday night and reignite her heated feud with Ronda Rousey.

Imagine Ronda started kicking the sh*te out of referees and agents post-loss to Liv Morgan. Then, suddenly, Flair's music would hit and she's appear on-stage with a broad smile on her face. Immediately, those who recall the last face experiment would get acid reflux, because Ric Flair's lass is not a likeable goodie.

In fact, Charlotte is downright horrible in the baby role. Being fair, that's something she's admitted herself over the years; Flair much prefers playing heel, so it'd be awful if Triple H decided to try her on as a face and restart her issues with Rousey heading into Crown Jewel/Survivor Series.


8. Sheamus Gets A “Soft” Win

Sheamus WWE
WWE.com

This piece is being erm...pieced together before Sheamus wrestles Gunther on the season premiere edition of SmackDown. There, the Clash At The Castle show-stealers will hack lumps off one another yet again for the revitalised Intercontinental Title, and it's logical to assume that Gunther will retain.

Typical WWE booking would then give Sheamus a "soft" victory over the Austrian to make up for that, but they shouldn't do it. Extreme Rules' bold "Good Old Fashioned Donnybrook" brawl should either give Butch and Ridge Holland a leg-up in importance, or do the same for Giovanni Vinci and Ludwig Kaiser.

Putting Sheamus over the champ 24 hours after losing a hot title match on TV would be a goodwill gesture to the Irishman and nothing more. Nobody wants to see him Brogue Kick the reigning champion then pose over Gunther's body just for the hell of it.

That'd feel back-to-front with the title bout on Friday night.


7. Braun Strowman Squashes More Tag-Teams

Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Some things are certain under Triple H's watchful eye: Raw is a much easier show to watch (although Monday was a slight wobble), he's not quite finished with the post-Vince McMahon wrestler comebacks and Braun Strowman will mow down many in the tag-team division for unknown reasons.

Please don't let that continue at Extreme Rules.

The card is six matches strong, and every single one of them has merit. Shoving some handicap effort on the undercard doesn't exactly fit the "Extreme" description, and it'd just generally be rubbish to see burly Braun blaze through Alpha Academy, Los Lotharios or any other poor duo on the books.

Trips is a traditionalist, so it's somewhat surprising that he's having Strowman treat the tag ranks like a hunting ground anyway. Why is this even happening? It's not like Braun is going to win either set of tag belts on his own. Oh...oh God. They wouldn't, would they?!


6. Raw Did Telegraph The Ladder Match

Bayley Dakota Kai IYO SKY Damage CTRL
WWE.com

Speaking of traditions.

It's WWE booking 101 to make planned pay-per-view losers look strong before the big night. So, for example, Bianca Belair would logically retain her Raw Women's Title against Bayley because the heel and her Damage CTRL crew shone on the 'go home' episode beforehand.

Obviously, the promotion enjoys subverting those expectations occasionally by going the opposite route. That's exactly what they must do on Saturday night, because it's time for Bayley to take charge of the women's scene on Raw and for CTRL to become the belt collectors around these parts.

Dakota Kai and IYO SKY have the Women's Tag straps, and there's a pleasing symmetry to Bayley hoisting the Raw singles belt high above her head as the centrepiece. Think of it like this: Bayley's shocking SummerSlam return and union with Kai/SKY will lose some serious impact long-term if she's just jobbed out to Bianca at the first hurdle.

Belair can survive a loss. Bayley, arguably, cannot.


5. Karrion Kross Gets Flattened

Karrion Kross Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

For another example of how telegraph booking works, one need only glance over at SmackDown to see how Karrion Kross vs. Drew McIntyre has been handled. Pre-'Strap Match', WWE has carefully presented Drew as someone unstoppable when he's met head on. Attack him from behind and you have a chance though.

Kross won't be able to ambush at Extreme Rules. No, he'll be literally strapped to McIntyre, and that normally means the babyface is about to rain a beating down on the heel. The problem? Karrion needs to continue looking strong, 'cause this is probs his only chance to turn into a full-time member of the main event pack.

Like Bayley, his value would be slaughtered with a loss.

Drew is a top babyface, and top faces know how to take an 'L' properly. WWE should trust him to elevate Kross decisively, or they shouldn't have bothered booking this gimmick bout in the first place.


4. That “I Quit” Match Sags For The Live Crowd

Judgment Day Damian Priest Finn Balor Rhea Ripley Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Anyone who watched it remains haunted by Roddy Piper yelling, "WHADDYA SAY!?" into a microphone at WrestleMania XI. Back in 1995, the 'Hot Scot' accidentally turned a submission showpiece between Bret Hart and Bob Backlund into a nightmarish comedy that's still funny/tragic all these years on.

Yeah, "I Quit" matches are a tough sell.

Edge and Finn Bàlor could find that out on Saturday if they don't go the standard tap out route instead. Having the ref brandish a mic, and thus forcing everybody to shuffle awkwardly in their seats as workers grunt and sell over the PA, wouldn't be ideal - pro wrestling never really learns though.

Crowd noise will be at minimum levels as everyone pauses to listen and find out what's being said. That doesn't sound very exciting, and it could turn this fiery grudge match between ex-Judgment Day leader and current captain into Hart vs. Backlund for a new generation.


3. Daniel Cormier Steals Attention

Daniel Cormier WWE
WWE

The 'Fight Pit' brawl between Matt Riddle and Seth Rollins didn't need a special guest referee. Rumours of Ken Shamrock's return were tasty for the old-schoolers out there who still put him on a pedestal for Bret Hart vs. Steve Austin at 'Mania 13, but...even Kenny boy wouldn't have been necessary.

Daniel Cormier definitely feels superfluous.

It's gonna be tough for a UFC Hall Of Famer like Dan to stand in the background and just let Riddle/Rollins get on with it. WWE didn't book Cormier to play the same role as Charles Robinson, put it that way. He'll get involved somehow, and might even spark Seth out with a Tyson-esque punch.

Therein lies the problem with drafting him in: Rollins and Riddle had enough going on themselves without the addition of an MMA legend who's only there so this show has some sort of celeb special guest. Hopefully, Daniel is a big fan of WWE's usual refs and wants to mimic their work.


2. WWE Wastes Bray Wyatt's Return

Bray Wyatt WWE Goodbye
WWE

Ooft! Now isn't this a depressing thought?

Most figure that WWE's ongoing 'White Rabbit' angle is a clever way to reintroduce Bray Wyatt to the masses eventually. If so, then cool, but Triple H better have something mega in mind for the one-time 'Fiend'. "Mega" doesn't mean having him stick his nose in Seth Rollins' business again.

If that sounds terribly random, then just cast a glance towards some comments Seth made to WWE's media partners BT Sport. Rollins called Bray's alter ego character "difficult" to work with, but did say that he'd be willing to give things another shot if Wyatt returned to the company.

Immediately, this fan started sweating that Hunter will have Bray interrupt the 'Fight Pit' main event by costing Seth the win. That'd suck for Riddle too, because it's vital that he stamps his mark on the 'Pit' and turns it into his own personal match type.

Also, Rollins vs. Wyatt sucked last time. This reprise would be a poor way to book Bray's comeback.


1. Austin Theory Cashes In…

Austin Theory Corey Graves
WWE.com

...without Roman Reigns there.

It's becoming more and more obvious by the week that Triple H doesn't see Austin Theory the same way Vinnie Mac did. Unless he's playing the long game, then the new creative chief might decide to have Theory cash his Money In The Bank chips in for something other than WWE's Undisputed top prize.

Yep, that means Theory would cash in MITB for either the United States or Intercontinental Titles. This nightmare seems so silly, but it's one yours truly hasn't been able to shake ever since finding out that Reigns won't be in Philly. WWE could view this as an easy way to get people talking post-Extreme Rules.

Austin willingly trading his contract for one of the secondary straps would make him look idiotic, but it'd also either send him right back to square one (by beating Bobby Lashley) or ruin Gunther's own momentum on the IC side.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE Extreme Rules 2022? For more like this, check out 10 Most Ridiculous Things Wrestling Expected You To Believe and WWE Extreme Rules 2022: 10 Things That Must Happen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.