WWE Greatest Royal Rumble: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
Friday Night Raw.
WWE's hugely-hyped Greatest Royal Rumble has come and gone, yet despite the surprising quality of the card on paper, the PPV largely ended up feeling like an especially mediocre house show.
Because WWE doesn't like doing much of consequence away from U.S. soil, little memorable happened in any of the show's ten matches, resulting in a painfully bloated five-hour broadcast that once again proves WWE doesn't know the meaning of the word restraint.
Was it all bad? Certainly not. While there weren't any great matches, there were a few rock solid bouts, and the titular Rumble itself at least delivered on the barmy spectacle everyone was hoping for.
As for the rest of the card? It was a dispiriting mix of aggressive mediocrity and occasional awfulness. Either way, this show clearly wasn't so much about doing anything interesting in the ring, but just netting a colossal payday for the company. If its commercial success is any indication, expect more of these bland Network specials in the near-future...
10. WWE Universal Title - Steel Cage Match: Brock Lesnar (C) Vs. Roman Reigns
Result: Roman spears Brock through the side of the cage, and because Brock's back hit the floor first...he retained? (9:15)
Rating: This was a dull title match made so much worse by its utterly atrocious ending. The bulk of the bout was nothing more than signature and finisher spam, and the finish was a total balls-up because Roman's feet so clearly hit the floor first.
Cue the commentators embarrassingly scrambling (in vain) to explain it away, all while the production kept replaying angles that only make it clearer that Roman was the real winner.
Whether you're a Roman fan or not, he clearly won the match. If WWE wanted to give Brock another win without making Roman look weak, they should've had him attempt to spear Roman, Roman dodge and Brock simply fly through the cage on his own. Simple. Instead we got this contrived crap that can't be easily explained away.
Honestly one of the worst finishes to a "major" world title match in years. 3/10
9. WWE United States Title: Jeff Hardy (C) Vs. Jinder Mahal
Result: Hardy slays Mahal with the Swanton Bomb to retail the title (6:10).
Rating: This is one of those "well, it could've been worse" matches, namely because Jinder didn't recapture the strap as many expected, and it was over before it could even remotely outstay its welcome.
Performance-wise, though, the two men just didn't gel well together at all - have they ever? - and the match is only likely to be remembered for Jinder's meme-worthy Whisper in the Wind botch.
It was a match that happened with zero significance in any way, and nobody cared. 4/10
8. WWE Raw Tag Titles: The Bar Vs. Bray Wyatt & Matt Hardy
Result: Hardy and Wyatt drill Sheamus with a tandem Twist of Fate to capture the titles (8:50).
Rating: While the result itself was pretty satisfying, the rest of the match? Not so much. Nobody was doing anything remotely interesting here, wrestling a house show-calibre tag match you probably started to forget before the match even came to a close.
The most disappointing thing here was the utterly flat finish, in part because the tandem Twist of Fate is so goofy looking with Bray just standing there, and the crowd clearly didn't care at all about the pair capturing the straps.
This title change probably should've been saved for a State-side show, really. 4/10
7. WWE Smackdown Tag Titles: The Bludgeon Brothers (C) Vs. The Usos
Result: The Blugeon Brothers land a Killer Bomb on Jimmy to retain the straps (5:05).
Rating: The champs are being booked pretty smart right now, with their matches running tight and intense, though this one at least felt a little more competitive than the WrestleMania match.
It was efficient, for sure, though the wrestling itself was utterly uninspired, and it basically settled for being a blandly watchable tag title bout and nothing more.
The result was fine, but following two prior dud matches, it's safe to say everyone was getting pretty fed up by this point. 5/10
6. Triple H Vs. John Cena
Result: Cena nails Trips with the Attitude Adjustment for the win (15:45).
Rating: While on paper it made a lot of sense to kick the show off with a nostalgia-fest battle between two undisputed legends, this was a disappointingly sluggish, dull match that pretty much made it clear the roster would be phoning it in for the rest of the night.
There was an agreeably old-school feel to the match, but it ultimately didn't build or translate into anything truly interesting. There clearly wasn't much desire for this to be anything more than an ultra-broad signature-spam match to kick the show off with some marquee talents. 5/10
5. Casket Match: The Undertaker Vs. Rusev
Result: 'Taker places both Rusev and Aiden English in the casket for the win (9:40).
Rating: Given 'Taker's long-standing mobility issues and WWE's bizarre treatment of Rusev, it would've surprised nobody if this was a hard-and-fast burial, so it was a pleasant surprise to see Rusev actually land a decent amount of offence against the Deadman.
'Taker played his crowd-pleasing greatest hits for the most part and the match was worked to his strengths, but Rusev came out of it looking pretty decent, especially following John Cena's WrestleMania squash.
The real talking point here, though, was the cringe-worthy Tombstone to Aiden English, which seemed to result in English legit landing on his head. Post-match reports state he's fine, thankfully.
The match was more competitive than expected if still fundamentally a "soft burial", as the saying goes. 5/10
4. WWE Intercontinental Title - Ladder Match: Seth Rollins (C) Vs. Finn Bálor, Samoa Joe & The Miz
Result: Rollins makes a daredevil leap onto the ladder and quickly snatches the title before Balor has time to react (14:33).
Rating: This could and should have been much better, but given its placement in the card, it felt positively miraculous following three shoulder-shrug matches in a row.
While the four men were clearly playing things safe, they at least delivered a solidly entertaining - if unremarkable - ladder match, with plenty of brutal spots and a clear sense of desperation to grab the strap.
The ending was half-neat and half-dumb, because while it was an extremely resourceful move on Rollins' part, Bálor looked like a bit of a goof just standing there gormlessly while Rollins did him over.
This had every opportunity to steal the show, but instead it settled for being a good, fun match. 6/10
3. WWE Title: AJ Styles (C) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Result: The match ends in a double countout.
Rating: This was a touch better than their WrestleMania match for the most part, though it's compromised severely by that ultra-cheap finish. If this match had to keep AJ and Nak in a holding pattern until the Backlash blow-off match, why even bother having it at all?
That said, the bulk of the match was pretty entertaining, if still miles away from what the pair should be capable of. They also missed a trick by not having AJ wear a cup to the fight this time when Nak attempted the low blow, but perhaps they're saving that spot for Backlash.
If WWE had the courage to commit to an actual ending that wasn't so cynical and patronising, this could've been the easy Match of the Night. Instead it's decent yet fundamentally flawed. 6/10
2. 50-Man Greatest Royal Rumble
Result: Braun Strowman wins after eliminating Big Cass (1:17:20).
Rating: The Royal Rumble is kinda like pizza: even when it's not that good it's still somewhat enjoyable. What this match lacked in memorable spots - aside from that hysterical Titus O'Neil botch, of course - it compensated with a great mix of competitors and two records being broken (Daniel Bryan lasting 76 minutes and Braun eliminating 13 entrants).
The highlights included Elias' surprisingly strong showing (even eliminating Kurt Angle), Bryan going the distance and Strowman's satisfying victory, even if the match ultimately felt quite cobbled together and under-booked in terms of crowd-pleasing moments.
It remains to be seen whether this will become an annual fixture or not, but if it was a one-off, it was certainly enjoyable enough. 6/10
1. WWE Cruiserweight Title: Cedric Alexander (C) Vs. Kalisto
Result: Alexander counters the Salida del Sol to kill Kalisto with the Lumbar Check and retain the title (10:15).
Rating: The crowd was disappointingly dead for this one, though that didn't prevent the two from putting on by far the best match of the night.
The pacing was fantastically breakneck from start to finish, with both men working hard throughout and clearly relishing the opportunity to - gasp - wrestle a PPV match outside of the pre-show.
It honestly could've gone a little longer, but it was a highly entertaining cruiser sprint all the same, with a smart finish to boot. 7/10
-
What did you think of Greatest Royal Rumble? Shout it out in the comments!