WWE Hell In A Cell 2021: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

A solid night of wrestling with some lousy finishes.

WWE Hell In A Cell Bobby Lashley Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

As a somewhat appropriate end to the "pandemic era" of WWE PPV events, this year's Hell in a Cell was a textbook holding pattern show, delivering little of true significance whatsoever.

No titles changed hands, two anticipated matches ended in ridiculous rollups - one of them being the main event, even - and there just wasn't much here fans are likely to remember for long.

Though there was thankfully only one stinker of a match to suffer through - and it's exactly the one everyone expected it to be - the strong in-ring performances were so often pitted against questionable booking decisions.

If WWE can't seem to put even basic effort into the storytelling, then why should fans care?

Thankfully the in-ring work still prevailed enough to make Hell in a Cell an entertaining - if frustrating - show.

However, it did seem to illustrate that the titular gimmick has basically lost its "specialness" at this point, and sadly just feels like another match.

It might be time to retire this themed PPV, at least for a few years, and try to give the match type its exciting edge back...

7. Shayna Baszler Vs. Alexa Bliss

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Alexa Bliss Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Result: Alexa puts Shayna away with a Twisted Bliss for the win (7:00).

Rating: Alexa and Shayna tried their hardest to make this work, but it was a whole lot of nothing, and having Shayna eat such an unconvincing loss was a major mistake.

Supernatural shenanigans can be a lot of fun as WWE has proven in the past, but audiences have to invest in the character and what they're doing in the ring, neither of which were true in this case.

No amount of possession hooey could contrive a convincing Alexa victory over Shayna here, who just continues to be booked horribly despite her exceptional in-ring skills. At least it was fairly short, but it could've been even shorter.

It wasn't quite a total dud because there was at least an attempt to craft an actual wrestling match for some time, but the exterior silliness was mostly a bust. 4/10


6. Natalya Vs. Mandy Rose

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Natalya Mandy Rose
WWE.com

Result: Natalya scores the win after locking Mandy in the Sharpshooter (9:45).

Rating: Few were particularly looking forward to this but it was a solid enough kickoff show match, yet having Mandy lose was definitely the wrong call considering that she's clearly been putting in the work to improve.

Natalya didn't need the victory in the slightest and so all it did was keep Mandy down, which is especially odd given how the build was booked to make Mandy look unworthy of her spot.

A Mandy win would've made more sense story-wise and actually made the match at least somewhat memorable, but it was still a decent-ish bout that gave the women enough time to breathe. 5/10


5. WWE Raw Women's Title: Rhea Ripley (c) Vs. Charlotte Flair

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Charlotte Flair Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Result: Charlotte wins via DQ after Rhea hits her with part of the announce table (14:10).

Rating: This is a textbook example of a very good match hampered by a truly terrible finish. Nothing like making your star champ look like a geek on the PPV stage, right?

This has to be one of the softest, most nonsensical DQ calls in recent years, and while you can arguably about it being technically correct, it was just a most transparent way to set up a rematch without having either wrestler concede a pinfall loss. Lazy doesn't even cover it.

This was very solid right up until the end, but it's impossible to ignore how braindead that finish was. Just let Charlotte lose clean and have Rhea, the champion, be on equal footing with her. 6/10


4. Kevin Owens Vs. Sami Zayn

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Result: Sami puts Owens down with the Helluva Kick for the win (12:40).

Rating: There was never any possibility of this being less than a very good match, and despite its fair brevity, that's exactly what it was.

These two just went for each other from the jump, delivering a thoroughly entertaining, totally brutal smash-mouth fight, that also ended with the right man winning.

Given Owens' condition going into the match, a Sami loss would've been insanely stupid and yet, that's exactly the sort of thing WWE would do.

This was predictably strong work, building and building to a satisfying finish that made total sense story-wise.

Not quite the best they're capable of, possibly because Owens may have received a legit arm or shoulder injury during the match, but very good overall. 7/10


3. Cesaro Vs. Seth Rollins

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Cesaro Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Result: Rollins rolls up Cesaro to score the win (16:15).

Rating: Apart from the painfully unimaginative rollup finish, this was an incredibly solid match and hopefully far from the last we see of these two working together.

It's a shame to see Cesaro lose though, especially in such a limp way, just when he looked to be building momentum, even if the preceding content of the match was still so much fun.

The match had great ring psychology with both men trying to neutralise each other's conflicting strategies - Rollins the crafty, scrappy heel, Cesaro the indefatigable pillar of strength - and it was neat to see them given so long out there too.

With a stronger ending this would've been truly terrific. 7/10


2. WWE Title - Hell In A Cell: Bobby Lashley (c) Vs. Drew McIntyre

WWE Hell In A Cell 2021 Drew McIntyre Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

Result: Lashley beats Drew with a rollup - with some help from MVP - to retain the strap (25:45).

Rating: Another strong match with an atrocious ending, sadly. Though a rollup can be a smart and surprising way to end a match, nobody wants to see that in a world title main event, especially not one inside the Hell in a Cell.

It did nothing to elevate Lashley and just made Drew look like a fool. Otherwise this was an entertainingly hard-fought bout if hardly a HIAC match many are likely to remember for long.

When WWE books such lousy endings as this, you have to wonder if it's worth giving the gimmick a break for a little while.

The result was certainly the right one, but not how it was achieved. When you're presumably wrapping up a feud, a decisive ending is almost always the right call. 7/10


1. WWE SmackDown Women's Title - Hell In A Cell: Bianca Belair (c) Vs. Bayley

Bianca Belair Bayley
WWE.com

Result: Bianca retains the title by putting Bayley away with the Kiss of Death on a ladder (19:45).

Rating: This was a great opener to the main show, and while hardly the most creative or necessary Hell in a Cell match, it saw both women battering the absolute hell out of each other.

There were times where it admittedly felt a tad overbooked - Bianca's hair should be used more sparingly - but Bayley played the heel role to perfection, putting up a mighty fight even in defeat while Bianca continues to be shot all the way to the moon.

You could feel the competitive physicality throughout, and the finish was absolutely killer. The outcome was never really in doubt, but they both did their level-best to convince us otherwise. 8/10


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.