WWE Just Changed The Wrestling World Forever

Only smoke and mirrors, or a new paradigm shift...?

AEW The Elite
AEW

The paradigm has shifted again.

In an inconceivable development, Cody Rhodes, the leader of the revolution, has left AEW and is bound for the WWE establishment. It's a wild story, possibly the biggest since the very formation of All Elite Wrestling. Would the promotion even exist without him?

Tony Khan had surveyed the shifting landscape ahead of All In, which was Cody's brainchild; indeed, negotiations for an as-yet-unnamed wrestling league were so advanced that Tony Khan flew Chris Jericho into the event to facilitate his cameo appearance. All In didn't act as a pilot for AEW, though the proof of concept could not have hurt the talks with Warner.

The 2018 Kenny Omega Vs. Chris Jericho mega-match, itself driven by the new stratosphere of critical acclaim Omega entered alongside Kazuchika Okada a year prior, first sparked within Khan the realisation of his e-fed. But make no mistake: Cody's ambitious thinking, networking and sublime character work elevated the counter-culture into something that felt massive. He took an amusing after work f*ck-about, in Being The Elite, and catalysed a movement that felt too important not to monetise. He was, at the very least, indirectly responsible for the formation of AEW. It doesn't exist without Cody, Omega, or the Young Bucks - or any configuration of that group that isn't the whole. In an astonishing development, one of the original Executive Vice Presidents is longer All Elite.

What does the Cody news tell us?

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


Cody Rhodes
AEW

It tells us without doubt that AEW's selling point of creative expression isn't as important to this specific independent contractor as securing his future as a big money player.

It's not as if Khan wouldn't have offered him a significant sum of money; it just wasn't significant enough. Cody will doubtlessly enjoy certain perks in WWE - the Randy Orton schedule, the power to veto certain pitches - but his days of setting himself alight, emerging from a bespoke entrance tunnel, and yes, blading, are over. WWE will push him hard, and like Kevin Owens, they'll trust him to riff on their material, but he is walking back into WWE knowing that, in the end, he's another spoke on a wheel he is not in control of.

There's a hint, too, that AEW's very selling point - collaborative long-term storytelling - might actually end up benefitting WWE in the long-term. This is key.

The modern professional wrestler doesn't necessarily get into it for the money. They're fans. They don't bump for a living because they don't care about it. Many started training deep into WWE's monopoly, before the promotion warehoused any moderately gifted talent wearing trunks and kick pads as ring attire - which is to state that they entered pro wrestling for the love of it, first and foremost.

They're also artists, a mentality that created the paradigm shift of 2019 in the first instance. A generation of wrestlers, either worn down by or weary of WWE's heavily produced approach, depending on whether they'd actually stepped through the door, were suddenly enticed by an alternative that paid them significantly more money than the indies.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


Randy Orton The Fiend
WWE

AEW was a platform that allowed them to curate their legacy as artists without starving. The phrase "selling out" is rotten - the pro wrestler doesn't owe anything to the fan, particularly when so many of them will consider them worse than sh*t for plying their trade in a promotion with three different initials - but virtually every artist can't ignore the lure of long-term security forever.

The pro wrestler, in short, wants it all: the spotlight, the praise, the adulation, the money. What if they can get all of that - in that order - by carving their legacy in AEW and making the megastar money in WWE?

What if AEW in some indirect way functions as WWE developmental? What if Tony Khan's meticulous, patient star-making process ultimately benefits the opposition?

That might be an overblown way of looking at things, and AEW's track record of developing new stars is so strong that, ultimately, a handful of defections might not matter much at all - but the wrestling world is very different now than it was just last week.

Without being too blasé or cynical about things, if nothing changes in WWE for some time yet, any potential ex-AEW talents will get booked like total sh*t. The promotion is dire, and while that's a subjective opinion, it's one shared by a lot of wrestlers. They know that they run the risk of undermining their legacy in the scripted 50/50 sludge. Even Orton, a star who wins more often than not, a star that they've considered of top five importance for two full decades, is sometimes asked to set demon clowns on fire and sell fear of his doppelgänger.

But the wrestler also knows that they can always get their heat back.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Shawn Michaels
WWE

If anything, a legacy deepens over time, powered by nostalgia. Nobody really gives a sh*t that Shawn Michaels worked a Saudi show. He is still remembered as legendary, influential talent. As funny as his little ruffian head at Crown Jewel was, it's not the first thing one thinks of when recalling his run.

The next round of rights fees negotiations complicate the picture.

AEW stand a strong choice of procuring something approaching WWE money by the end of the year, but "WWE money" will take on an even more astronomical definition if that scenario plays out, and that doesn't even factor in an agreement with the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia than runs until 2028. The independent contractor might not be satisfied with 2022 WWE money in AEW, when 2023 WWE money will look even more appealing. WWE is in a strong position to offer an unprecedented retirement fund.

This all works out rather nicely for WWE, a promotion institutionally incapable of creating new stars. The promotion coasts along on its history. Now, potentially, WWE can coast along on AEW's.

This theoretical scenario also works out at AEW's expense.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Cody Rhodes Blood
AEW

The optics of Cody leaving what he himself named "Ellis Island" are a sobering reminder of what pro wrestling actually is. That line has taken on a sad note in retrospect. As a wrestling fan, you want to get worked, but you don't want to feel like a mark. More defections in the future threaten to undermine AEW's romantic status as the promotion that restored wrestling's soul, the destination for anybody who actually gives a sh*t. Of course, it's more important that the promotion is good, effective and rewarding, but the vibe of AEW is so crucial to its base.

It's not nothing without that, but it's something less.

In another thread in this fascinating spiderweb, Vince McMahon historically tends not to flatter main event acts that he recruited from the competition: Goldberg, Diamond Dallas Page, Sting...

He might be so petty that this fortuitous development blows up in his spiteful awld face, but that just adds to the intrigue - a level of intrigue that he is hopelessly incapable of orchestrating himself.

If the latest round of reports is to be believed, Cody and Tony Khan were simply too far apart on the valuation of his talent contract. Cody felt that he deserved the Chris Jericho, CM Punk and Bryan Danielson money. Khan disagreed.

How much was Cody truly worth?

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


cody aew
AEW

Cody was a needle-mover throughout his AEW tenure, certainly a focal point of the conversation, for better or worse, but the man was at his best elevating those he worked with. Everything Cody did felt big even if, at times, it was silly. Not since Mick Foley has a wrestler elevated his opponents so brilliantly. MJF was getting over regardless, but Cody introduced him to the wider audience. Darby Allin and Sammy Guevara evolved through the lens of Cody, who was so tremendous at working to his opponent's strengths that he all but convinced Khan to sign Eddie Kingston and Ricky Starks after five minutes of masterful TV work. During a pandemic.

Cody isn't just a star attraction, a fantastic and yet still underrated wrestler, a telegenic charmer who can act as bridge to new fans. He makes wrestling better. It might be impossible for him to make WWE better, but his exit might make AEW worse.

Who knows. Perhaps AEW might be better off without the worst of Cody's scatterbrained impulses; this is a man, after all, who planted the seed for a CM Punk match in his last promo, which was meant to build but didn't really build a match with Sammy Guevara (!), and has now left, meaning no match with CM Punk can take place (!).

It would be a very WWE thing to happen, were his valuation to fall below even Khan's after two months back in the WWE system, but Cody really is taking a part of AEW with him on the way out - a part of its old soul - and it's not so easily replaced, even if the work is done.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Cody Rhodes
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!