WWE Royal Rumble 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
Royal Rumble could be the night WWE changes EVERYTHING going into WrestleMania.
You know the drill with this sort of thing by now.
Positivity takes a temporary back seat, and it watches in horror as negative WWE thoughts take the wheel whilst driving haphazardly right off the side of the gigantic WrestleMania stage. That's precisely what the upcoming Royal Rumble could do - it could ruin everyone's night(s) come 'Mania. Eek!
OK, so not every nightmare pondered here can happen simultaneously. That's fine though, because this is all fantasy. It's horror-soaked, 'THIS IS THE WORST THAT COULD OCCUR' fantasy, but fantasy nonetheless. It's the kind of stuff that'd make Triple H and his merry band of superstars wake up in a cold sweat on Friday night before Saturday's supershow.
Put succinctly, what if WWE changes everything? To explain, what if the World Title scene is about to turn upside down before April's huge weekender, and what if someone makes an unwanted comeback to try and play the tough guy like he always does?! Perish the thought!
Actually, no. Don't perish the thought. Let it sneak up on you like some bad guy in a movie. Have erm...fun!
10. Sami Zayn Screws Over KO For No Reason
What a way to start.
You've got to feel just a wee bit sorry for Sami Zayn. He's gone from WrestleMania 39 headliner to possibly sitting outside with his nose pressed up against the window come this year's weekender. Unless, of course, Triple H is about to open the door for Sami by having him turn on Kevin Owens without any warning whatsoever.
Will this happen? Nah, probably not, but it could and that's the magic at play here. At first, it'd look like Zayn was rushing out to save his old tag-team partner from a two-on-one kicking at the hands of Logan and Jake Paul. Then, completely out of nowhere, he'd blast KO with a Helluva Kick/Blue Thunder Bomb and let LP retain his United States Title.
"Why, Sami? Why?!" phrasing would hog social media afterwards, then fans would have to wait until Monday's Raw for Sami's explanation. His justification? An f'n match at 'Mania with his on/off best friend, that's what.
9. WWE Gives Away #1 & #30!
This is always a worry, and it's become something WWE enjoys doing when they really, really shouldn't. Part of the thrill involved with watching any Rumble match is wondering who might be lucky enough to bag the #30 spot. Will it be Jade Cargill in this year's women's match? How about Steve Austin on the men's side?
Antici....pation is important, basically.
WWE could spoil all of that merriment by announcing who's #1 and #30 in both Rumbles ahead of time. Absolutely screw that, man. Nobody watching needs to hear Michael Cole say: 'Well, we already know that Nia Jax is #30". That ruins the whole moment, and the element of surprise shouldn't be overlooked.
No pre-show matches to determine who's out first and last either. That's a concept which should've died a quick death following 1996's battle between Triple H and Duke Droese. The fact the WWF thought selling Duke as #30 in the Rumble at all was a good idea should've earned someone a cuff across the ear.
Sorry, got sidetracked down memory lane.
8. Triple H Ignores Jade Cargill
Let's be honest here: The 2024 Royal Rumble is the ideal place to pull the trigger on Jade Cargill's in-ring WWE run. She'll have been with the company approx three months by the time Saturday rolls around, which means Jade has been training relentlessly at the PC for around 90 long days.
Triple H should let her loose and see what happens.
Or, maybe 'The Game' will decide that debuting Cargill on the post-WrestleMania TVs is the best course of action. That doesn't sound nearly as fun as hearing fans count down from 10, then witnessing Jade's very first full entrance on one of WWE's most iconic PLEs.
This is the kind of thing Cargill was built for. She's a megastar in the making, and deserves to be presented as someone big time straight away. So, Papa H, stick her in the women's Rumble and watch people pay attention. Ignoring her would be a sin.
7. All Of The Legends Cameos Stink
When he comes crashing down, and it hurts inside. That'd be the scene if Hulk Hogan stumbled his way down the aisle for a cameo appearance on Saturday night and tried to dish out some of his signature offensive moves. A leg drop is out of the question after so many surgeries, but the old finger point and punches wouldn't be.
It's important to note something at this point. The dude writing this sees value in 'Real American' blasting over the speakers and Hulk wandering out for a short stint in the men's Rumble. He does, but he also realises that it could be a complete and utter disaster for remaining Hulkamaniacs worldwide.
Actually, what if all of the legendary cameos in both matches suck? How horrible would that be?! Seeing AJ Lee struggle with ring rust or Ken Shamrock fall over after a few suplexes would be crap. It wouldn't be nearly as rotten as this next entry, to be fair.
Brace!
6. Shane McMahon MUST Punch
Cast your minds back to the 2022 Rumble and Shane McMahon's, 'No I'm really hard, honest!' performance. The way he self-booked himself to look competitive with Brock Lesnar was laughable; so much so that even Vince decided to turf his boy out of the company for a spell afterwards.
The 'Boy Wonder' may return this weekend for more Shane-O shenanigans.
You better hope he doesn't, because they'd be insufferable after so much time away. McMahon didn't even get his licks in at 'Mania 39 either (injury robbed him of that), so he'd be all revved up to rabbit punch the heck out of everyone in sight. It'd be a quite miserable viewing experience to see sweaty Shane do his thing.
Put it this way, if it's a choice between Shane McMahon or Hulk Hogan in this year's Rumble, then someone look out this guy's red and yellow bandana. To some wrestling fans, even skipping an entry in the match and having no-one bounce through the curtain would be preferable.
5. Seth Rollins Vacates & Misses WrestleMania
Argh! This would be hellish.
It'd also be heartbreaking, because 'Mania XL wouldn't be the first April supershow Seth Rollins has been forced to miss. Don't forget he also had to sit on the sidelines back in 2016 as well, and he described how difficult that was for him mentally in WWE documentaries back then. This, arguably, would be even harder to swallow.
At time of writing, Rollins says he's good to do something in Philly, but things could change. WWE will need to be real careful with his injuries, or they'll lose that much-anticipated bout with CM Punk in a heartbeat. What if docs change their minds and Seth has to announce he's vacating the World Title at the Rumble though?!
Admit it, a lump just formed in throats everywhere. Nobody likes the thought of a hard worker missing out on 'Mania paydays, but the match with Punk is a tasty one on top of that. Sadly, this could actually happen. Sorry to be such a bummer, but that's kinda the gig here!
4. That Men’s Rumble Is For The World Title
WWE business would need to move on without Seth, so they'd presumably announce that the upcoming men's Rumble that night was now for the vacant World Heavyweight Championship. Admittedly, some traditionalists out there would get a kick out of this and start reminiscing about 1992 (or maybe even 2016 depending on your age), but yeah - it'd be a bummer due to Rollins.
Attention would turn to exactly who supplants Seth as the new World Champ on soon-to-be Netflix Mondays. CM Punk? Cody Rhodes? Akira Tozawa? Right, enough laughing at the back. Akira's one hell of a worker between the ropes, y'know. Besides, "anyone can win the Royal Rumble".
Ahem.
In all seriousness, the mood would be low if Rollins announced he was vacating and was missing 'Mania. Fans in Florida would still be hyped when a new champ was crowned, but there'd be a slightly sour taste in everyone's mouths once they started thinking about Seth again.
3. Cody Rhodes “Finishes The (Wrong) Story”
Last year, Cody Rhodes came up short against Roman Reigns at 'Mania and people were p*ssed. Folks weren't mad enough to riot, but there was a lot of tut-tutting about Triple H electing not to "finish the story". Remarkably, partly owing to Cody's popularity, there's still time to put things right in 2024.
Yeah, about that.
Rhodes has to be considered one of the frontrunners to win this year's Rumble, but if it's for the vacant World Title then...wouldn't be he finishing the wrong story by winning it? After all, it's the WWE Championship that Cody craves, not this new-fangled World Title created exclusively for Raw.
WWE could pretend all they wanted, but fans wouldn't be buying this as closure for Cody's tear-jerking tale about Dusty. If anything, it'd be just another gut punch during back-to-back WrestleMania seasons, which may well be too much for some to take.
Please don't do anything like this, guys.
2. Roman Reigns Briefly Loses Gold
Onto one of those nightmares that couldn't really happen in conjunction with another.
Well actually, a quick point to ponder first. Roman Reigns has been Undisputed Champ (thus holding the WWE and Universal straps) for an age now. Some folks still see merit in him as champion, whereas others would like the company to move things along and book a title change.
Careful what you wish for. Nick Aldis has stacked the deck against Roman in this four-way encounter on Saturday, and WWE has specifically noted that Reigns doesn't need to be involved in the finish to lose his gold. So, in other words, Randy Orton could pin LA Knight or AJ Styles to become Undisputed Champ.
Watch this space on that, because it could be the out Triple H needs to protect Roman. Then, oh boy. Let's just say a lot of you reading this are not going to like what's about to be proposed next. Remember when the intro said everything could change in one fell swoop?
1. Then Becomes World Champ!
Say Seth vacates, WWE makes the men's Rumble for the World Title, and Jimmy Uso is part of the 30-man field. Would there be anything stopping Paul Heyman from pulling some strings and having Jimmy step aside so his 'Tribal Chief' can enter the match? This is pro wrestling - loopholes come with the territory.
This'd be totally in character for Roman too. He'd happily palm off his cousin's own dreams to replace Uso in the Rumble. Then, what if Reigns actually wins the whole thing and ends the evening as World Heavyweight Champ? Theoretically, depending on what happens at Elimination Chamber, he could end up challenging for every World Title come WrestleMania.
Gee, that'll placate those who want something new.
Roman has been awesome as The Bloodline's overlord, but taking the Undisputed Title(s) from him and then sticking the hastily-vacated World belt on him in the same night? Nah, that'd be too much for some folks out there to take.
What other WWE nightmares could come true at Royal Rumble 2024? For more like this, check out WWE Royal Rumble 2024: 10 Surprise Entrants We Could See and WWE 2K24: EVERY Major Change 2K Just Announced!