"The Showstopper", "Mr. Wrestlemania", "The Heartbreak Kid", or maybe you know him as one of the greatest of all time. Whatever you call him, Shawn Michaels wowed audiences worldwide with his wrestling skills, natural ability on the mic and general showmanship for over 25 years until he retired back in 2010. With hindsight, it's easy to see just how much he has contributed to the wrestling industry, not only through the many wonderful matches and moments but also through the way he has trained other names during his original retirement, including Daniel Bryan, Paul London and Brian Kendrick. For all the great matches though, there were many where Shawn was forced to work with those who he either didn't match up well with or simply didn't have the talent to pull off something spectacular. Whilst HBK had plenty of matches that were "just there" as a result, when he was off his game there could be even worse outcomes. Not only that, but there were moments where Shawn's ego (nearly as legendary as his wrestling abilities) visibly got in the way of what was going on in the ring. It's fair that whilst we recognise all those incredible matches he put on, it's only fair to remember some of the stinkers as well. For now though, let's pick up on the best bits...
5 Awesome Matches...
5. Shawn Michaels vs. Shelton Benjamin - RAW, 2nd May 2005
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L-FBBolZN-w "This is gonna be awesome" was how Jim Ross introduced this match - and boy, was he right. The first ever meeting between Michaels and Benjamin, there was very little that needed to be set up in order to sell this match. Two incredible athletes, one a living legend and the other a sure-fire future star (at that moment, anyway); Shelton was still riding a wave of support and momentum as Intercontinental Champion following the initial Draft Lottery in 2004, whilst Shawn had just teamed with Hulk Hogan at Backlash. In terms of potential matches, this was the WWE throwing it all on the line for free on RAW. The two men went back and forth in the early goings, with neither really looking likely to pick up the victory as the crowd settled in for what would obviously be a lengthy match. Shawn's athleticism seemed a match for Shelton early on, but Benjamin would turn the match around following a top-rope counter to a backdrop. The back-and-forth action would continue though and the fans in the arena were soon eating out of the two wrestler's hands, after HBK performed his trademark kip-up, only for Shelton to pull off an even more impressive one. Shelton again took control, but now seemed to be edging closer and closer to the victory with every move. He twice countered the Sweet Chin Music, once with the Dragon Whip and the second with a high kick to the side of Shawn's head. Whilst Shawn had played the plucky face coming from behind many times in his career, for once it seemed that Shelton was playing that role even better. Seemingly out of desperation, Shawn was able to send Shelton over the top rope before falling back to his knees. Benjamin, clutching on to the ropes, poised himself before springboarding off the ropes...and landing right in to Sweet Chin Music. One of the most devastating, jaw-dropping (let alone shattering) deliveries of the move got the three and HBK picked up the win; in many ways, that one moment has outlived the incredible standard of this match. What should have been a star-making performance for Shelton was left to slide, but this proved that Shawn still had plenty left in the tank and he could go as well as he ever could.
4. Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - Wrestlemania XIX, March 30th 2003
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WMPAqnflAU There have been many incredible matches between Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho, but it was their incredible clash at Wrestlemania 19 that really set their on-off rivalries rolling. After returning to the WWE in 2002, Michaels' first feud outside of his hunt for the World Heavyweight Title would be with Jericho, who said that whilst he has wanted to be the "next Shawn Michaels", he had instead decided to be even better as the "first Chris Jericho". After the two traded blows for several months, including causing each other's eliminations at the Royal Rumble, they ultimately agreed on a Wrestlemania match, HBK's first since 1998. Whilst Shawn was casually cocky as ever to begin with, Jericho would dominate the match from the start, blocking many of Shawn's trademark moves; the tide particularly turning after Jericho countered a Figure Four Leglock. Many of Shawn's initial matches after his return saw his opponent's focus on his back, and this was no different, with Jericho obviously keeping in mind the Walls of Jericho as an obvious match-ender. It took nearly ten solid minutes of Jericho offense before he finally made an error, kipping up and posing with his back turned to Michaels. To the fans delight, Shawn sprung up behind Jericho and started to fight back - right up until a roll-up sequence saw Jericho lock in the Walls, the submission finisher that should have sealed the match. Showing why he was "Mr. Wrestlemania", HBK was able to get to the ropes, but Jericho remained in control yet again. A second Walls of Jericho again saw Michaels somehow escape, leading to Jericho getting frustrated. HBK was able to slide out of a backdrop, catch Jericho with a rollup from behind and steal the threecount. Throughout his career, HBK was able to "get lucky" several times, but this was perhaps one of the best examples and where it worked best. It did no harm to Jericho, who came out of the match looking strong - particularly when he low-blowed HBK after teasing respect with a hug after the match. Shawn, meanwhile, was able to prove he could wrestle a no-frills match and last in the ring with an "unknown" opponent, far from the matches he had been having with Triple H earlier in his return. Whilst some of their later matches would be much more brutal - their epic ladder match in 2008, for example - this was a great example of two technical greats putting on a stunning show.
3. Shawn Michaels vs. Mankind - In Your House: Mind Games, September 22nd 1996
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PG-l6Wxo6As A match that Mick Foley would, for a very long time, consider to be the best he ever wrestled, also happens to be one of the best matches that Shawn Michaels has ever put on. It's also fair to say that it was something of an unexpected result: the two men's styles were hardly complimentary, but like the matches preceding this, it allowed Shawn to play the "face in peril" whilst also showing that he could go at it a lot rougher than people may have expected. With his WWF Title on the line, Michaels got off to a bad start as Mankind immediately began slugging it out with the Heartbreak Kid, sending Shawn to the outside and using the ringside environment to his advantage, very much "his" territory. That plan backfired though when Michaels crushed Mankind under the floor matting, before going high-risk with a crossbody to the outside. The commentary team noted the aggressive side of Michaels, who kept pressure on Mankind - who then retreated for a "pep talk" from the dastardly Paul Bearer on the outside again. If there was one other impressive sidenote to the match, it's that Foley's character work was impeccable, staying in the deranged state perfectly throughout. Shawn would soon give up control of the match though as Mankind overpowered him, even resorting to tactics such as biting Michaels as he writhed on the mat. The pace of the match drastically slowed down at this point, raising the drama stakes as he did so; Mankind's power came across as he was able to boot Shawn over the top rope easily. Still using what they could without being disqualified, arguably one of the highlights of the match saw Shawn wrap Mankind's head in between the top and second ropes, choking him out - as Mankind replied in kind by shoving his hand down HBK's throat for the mandible claw. The crowd went wild, but it wouldn't be until the weapons came in to play that the match really got in to full gear. With chairs in the ring and the referee distracted, Mankind looked set to fly from the top rope with a chair - only for Michaels to land a Van Daminator-style Sweet Chin Music. It should have ended the match, but the contest was brought to an abrupt close when Vader interfered. Whilst there was no clean result that the match perhaps really deserved, it was without a doubt an incredible contest that proved a lot about Shawn Michaels. His performance in the match and his ability to adapt to a much more aggressive style would obviously suit him well and proved that, whilst he was smaller than many of the previous WWF Champions at the time, he still had the ability to take out a much bigger man and beat him at his own game. A rare classic that anyone should watch to see a great performance from two legends of the sport.
2. Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon - Ladder Match, Wrestlemania X, March 20th 1994
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5RM33CphV8I Perhaps the match that made Michaels the Wrestlemania Icon he would be known as for the rest of his career, the "first ever" (actually second) ladder match in the WWF's history saw Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon face off, in an effort to determine who the real Intercontinental Champion was. Ramon had taken the belt in a tournament following Michaels' suspension in late 1993; upon returning, Michaels brought Diesel along with him and set about crowning himself the true undisputed champion. What made this match so exciting was how innovative it was - and how it still holds up in a time when ladder matches, TLC, Money in the Bank etc. are much more commonplace. While spots like Michaels springing off the ladder for a splash may seem tame compared to some seen in the modern era, it still is an incredible physical feat. This was HBK arguably at his very best athletically, whilst Razor's popularity was probably at its peak. The crowd reactions to both throughout the match are electric and deservedly so. The match tells a good story; Diesel is thrown out early on, but Michaels seems to maintain the advantage at most points. They utilise the environment well, brawling all over the ringside area, but it's only when the ladder is really introduced that they seem to really start taking it up a notch. The mentality to the match shows; Ramon knows that Michaels is unlikely to stay down after he is launched in to the ladder and out of the ring, so he goes outside to punish him more. It's only when Shawn gets too cocky and after too many flashy moves that, when he starts to climb the ladder, he ultimately seals his fate. Ramon shoves him off the top and in a now all too familiar spot, Michaels lands crotch first on the top rope. It's when he falls off and traps his leg that Razor is finally able to take advantage and win the match - an ingenious way of making both men look good, with Michaels only being beaten by "chance" and the fact that Diesel was removed early on in the match. If you've never seen this match, then you owe it to yourself to watch it in its entirety, as it's truly an incredible showing by both men and really has set the standard for any other "speciality" match to live up to.
1. Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker - Wrestlemania XXV, April 5th 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n75tyZCTL4g Not only is this possibly the greatest match that Shawn Michaels ever wrestled, it's also possibly the best Wrestlemania match ever. With neither man having ever met at the "grandest stage of them all" before, despite the fact they had both made the PPV their own, the match didn't even really need any more building on than that. Instead, we got something much greater; Michaels consistently using his own faith as a way to make this a match of "heaven vs. hell"; it was the first time time that HBK had really played a heel since his feud with Hulk Hogan in 2005, meaning that there was an added breath of fresh air about his character. Perhaps oddly, there was no real referencing the fact that it was the Undertaker who initially ended the career of Michaels in 1998, but in reality the feud probably did not need it. Come the PPV, the match went on shortly after the midway point of the event; in typically overdone Michaels fashion, he entered bathed in a white light, like some kind of evangelical preacher. Claiming not to be afraid of Undertaker, Shawn struggled slightly early on in the match, but quickly began to outmanoeuvre the Undertaker, going after the legs and even locking in a Figure Four leglock, harking back to his "retiring" of Ric Flair the year before. Perhaps more controversially, Michaels would lock in the Crossface, again calling back to a previous Wrestlemania match he had been involved in. Back and forth the action went, both men clearly giving it their all. The live crowd - and no doubt those at home too - were left in shock as each near fall went by. At several points, it genuinely seemed that Michaels might finally be the one to break the Streak; unlike their foll0w-up match the next year, the result of this match really did seem completely up for grabs. If anyone could beat Undertaker, surely it would be HBK. Perhaps one of the all time classic moments saw Shawn attempt to skin the cat back in to the ring, only for Undertaker to grab him mid-motion, drag him from the ropes and plant Michaels with the Tombstone. It seemed the perfect ending to the match; Michaels' showboating leading to his demise. So when he kicked out of the pin, the crowd went wild and the camera zoomed in on an exasperated Undertaker, clearly shocked that he had not picked up the win. Somehow, Shawn fought back, landing the Sweet Chin Music only for Undertaker to then kick out. Yet again, the crowd were left on their feet. By throwing everything at each other and visibly giving it their all in the ring, the two veterans - who many had deemed to be "past it" by this point - completely stole the show. By the time the finish came, with Michaels being caught again for the Tombstone (this time from a moonsault), there was no doubt left on anyone's mind that this should clearly have been the main event, in a rare case of the WWE perhaps showing a lack of forethought when it came to the big show. Nevertheless, it was a match that any wrestling fan should have been proud to watch and be a part of. Shawn Michaels was indeed the Showstopper; but he just couldn't stop the Streak.
And 5 Matches That Sucked...
5. Shawn Michaels vs. Batista - RAW, October 13th 2008
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BiwNtQmIWI Proof that whilst Shawn Michaels can usually pull off a good match with ease, sometimes things just don't go his way. Whilst there had never been a standout Michaels vs. Batista match, they were usually at least entertaining affairs - the two men had put on a relatively strong performance at Extreme Rules earlier in the year (albeit with a poor ending that left Batista looking like a chump). Not only that, but Shawn was in the middle of a great streak of performances with Chris Jericho, which was the basis of this Lumberjack Match, so for this match to be so underwhelming said something. From the getout, the fact that the ring was surrounded by a feast of (mostly) midcard heels indicated that this would probably end up being a fairly obvious story in terms of the lumberjacks, but the actual match itself before any shenanigans was just...boring. Shawn seemed to be phoning it in for the most part and Batista was not able to carry the match by himself. The crowd, who had been hot early on in the match, seemed to be caring less and less as it went on. Shawn hit the spots that he had to, but it was clear that there was no real desire there. The end came when Batista and Michaels ultimately were ganged up on by the lumberjacks, right until the point that they somehow managed to turn it around and start to fight back. A "superhuman" effort that really just made everyone else look far too weak. A thankfully short affair, what could have been a much better match just ended up being a dud.
4. Shawn Michaels vs. Mr. Perfect - Summerslam, August 30th 1993
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uVLB4KYq6aQ Perhaps a hallmark of what could have gone wrong in the Michaels vs. Benjamin match, here was a match that again, on paper, sounded like it would be a wonderful contest. Instead, we were given a sloppy match between two wrestlers who were clearly not on top of their game. This was the beginning of Shawn's descent in to a number of drug and attitude problems, whilst Mr. Perfect was struggling with his own back injury. The tone for the match was perhaps set with the opening back-and-forth exchange resulting in both men seemingly colliding in the middle of the ring, though it was clear that this was perhaps not the intended outcome, as the commentary team quickly tried to cover up the error. A sloppy, plodding affair followed as the two men traded a few big moves before returning to a series of rest holds. The limitations to the match were obvious; Shawn's cocky heel stick was still obviously much better suited to Perfect, who was forced to play a questionable face role. A backbreaker in to a back hold submission perhaps exemplified the problems with the match - neither Michaels nor Perfect seemed to be making it look like there was any real pressure applied for a submission that lasted nearly half a minute. The end thankfully came when Michaels rolled in to the ring, seemingly tripping referee Earl Hebner up and knocking him to the floor. Diesel shoved Perfect in to the turnbuckle, whilst Hebner counted Perfect out with his back turned to the situation. An abrupt and dull end left the entire match feeling flat, arguably a fitting result for a "must-see" match gone awry.
3. Shawn Michaels vs. Hulk Hogan - Summerslam, August 21st 2005
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_viLz2JAZ0 At his worst, Shawn Michaels could prove to be petulant, unwilling to put talent over and often treating things as if he was the only one who was important. There are several matches that could have proven this point (his match with Vader in 1996, for example) but perhaps the worst example of this was when he went up against someone just as good as backstage politics - Hulk Hogan. Whilst the idea of Michaels vs. Hogan facing off properly in a "Legend vs. Icon" was understandably a fan's dream, the way that the match turned out was more of a nightmare. Shawn had done everything he could to carry the feud in the weeks prior to Summerslam, so perhaps it's better to remember his work in that - his epic promo in Montreal, including the ultimate tease of Bret Hart's "return" - than the actual match. From the get go, Shawn oversold pretty much everything that Hogan could throw at him, making the entire match seem like a mockery. Shawn's backwards flip out of the ring from a shoulder block was more reminiscent to The Rock's brilliant selling of the Stunner, a legitimate finisher, than a basic wrestling move. It would only get worse, with Hogan looking progressively less impressed as the shameful display continued. For Shawn, this was all about making his own point: he was unhappy having to job to Hogan when he believed that he should be the one being put over, particularly given that he was going to have to do the majority of the work in the match one way or another. Whilst the aftermath of the match, with the two men shaking hands, was a glossy finish to the encounter, in many ways Shawn had allowed his personal feelings to get in the way of fans enjoying a match that should have been as iconic as the two men participating in it.
2. Shawn Michaels & God vs. The McMahons - Backlash, April 30th 2006
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JvNKavKoK1s Yes, Shawn Michaels was guilty of putting his own agenda first in matches, but even some of his selfish behaviour can't hold a candle to that of Vince McMahon. Fans had been "treated" to a feud between Michaels and McMahon since the start of the year, with such highlights as HBK and Shane McMahon being forced to join the reformed "Kiss My Ass" club; in truth, when Michaels and McMahon met at Wrestlemania, they pulled off a mightily impressive hardcore match, where Michaels soared off a huge ladder, driving an elbow through a trash can and putting Vince through a table in the process. That spot and the victory for Shawn should have been the end of the feud, but clearly Vince had other plans. Instead, we were then treated to Vince claiming that Shawn had only won because he had "God" on his side - and therefore created a tag match for Backlash, where he and Shane would face off against Michaels and God. The match was clearly just a desperate attempt at grabbing headlines and for McMahon to be able say that he had "beaten God". The crowd were dead as the match opened with McMahon demanding that God (portrayed by a spotlight) be checked for illegal weapons by the referee. Shawn did his best to pull a reasonable enough match out of the scenario, but it really was for naught - the concept alone was enough to make this match suck horribly. To make things worse, the McMahons would pick up the win after the Spirit Squad interfered, highlighting the fact that this feud was still nowhere near over. It was just another treat for the fans in what was arguably one of the WWE's worst years.
1. D-Generation X vs. The Spirit Squad - Saturday Night's Main Event, July 15th 2006
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBaDJ0JsqNQ A fine example of all the problems that the WWE can have with building new talent, encapsulated in one horror-show of a match. Riding on a wave of ill-placed nostalgia, Shawn Michaels and Triple H had reformed D-Generation X to combat the McMahons and their lackeys, the Spirit Squad. Here were five massively talented young stars, who were making the best out of what should have been a dead-end gimmick...running in to the glass ceiling incarnate. 5-on-2 odds should never have been as one-sided in favour of the "2", but that clearly was not the case when the two were part of the Kliq. The two sides had actually met at Vengeance earlier in the month in a straight-up handicap match, with no elimination rules; in that contest, the Spirit Squad were actually dominating for considerable periods, as one would have expected them to. Clearly, the same rules did not apply when it came to this encounter. With ease, D-X picked off the Spirit Squad one-by-one and ultimately were victorious in a straight up whitewash, embarrassing the five youngsters. This was just one of several times that D-X would humiliate the Squad this over the course of the next few months, but this is perhaps the most egregious example of it given the rules of the match. It might not have been the in-ring action that sucked in this match, but the sentiment and the bad taste it leaves in the mouth does. This was all about Shawn Michaels and Triple H stealing the spotlight and having their own fun at the genuine expense of others; it's telling that the only member of the Spirit Squad who would go on to have a lasting career with the WWE was Nicky - who shrugged off his association with the Squad thanks to a little gimmick change to become Dolph Ziggler. Whereas it's easy to find great Shawn Michaels matches - and believe me, there are lots of them that didn't make this list (several of his matches with John Cena, the first Hell in a Cell, the Iron Man classic with Bret Hart at Wrestlemania) - it is harder to find bad ones. But it's telling that whilst fans don't remember many poor matches, it's the poor sportsmanship and sour moments that sometimes spoil the memories we have of the "Showstopper". Whilst he in an in-ring icon who deserves the plaudits and recognition he has received time and time again, one would hope that those breaking in to the business try and avoid emulating some of Shawn's backstage behaviour.
22 year old Journalist/Producer, with far too much to do and spends far too little of his time actually doing any of it. You can find me on Twitter (@KatsJonouchi) or on my YouTube (katsinthebox)