WWE SummerSlam 2014: 5 Winners And 5 Losers

Forget the match results. Here's the real winners and losers from WWE's big summer event.

The 2014 edition of WWE€™s annual SummerSlam is in the books, and the consensus is that the show delivered in a big way. This now makes two consecutive years where SummerSlam has been one of the best card on the calendar, living up to the lofty billing as one of the promotion€™s marquee events. We saw the crowning of a new WWE World Heavyweight Champion in dominant fashion, as Brock Lesnar german suplexed the hustle, loyalty and respect right out of John Cena€™s body before leaving him lying in a lifeless heap to end the show. Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins took their red hot rivalry to the next level with an outstanding match that, despite the bemoaned lumberjack stipulation, hit it out of the park with the execution. They brawled all over the arena, treating the lumberjacks like the jobbers they are in the process, and ended with a result that will no doubt see the continuation of one the most well-booked feuds in years. Stephanie McMahon vs. Brie Bella was better than it had any right to be, Bray Wyatt and Chris Jericho made up for that utter lack of chemistry and bland match at Battleground, Roman Reigns got a clean win over Randy Orton is his ascension to the throne, Paige regained the Divas title from AJ Lee, Rusev defeated Jack Swagger and raised the Russian flag in the arena and the Miz and his moneymaker lost the intercontinental championship to Dolph Ziggler. All this coupled with an enthusiastic Staples Center crowd made for one of the better shows the company has produced in recent times. But as we all know, wins and losses aren€™t the only thing that matters in the world of professional wrestling, where the quality of a worker€™s performance is what truly determines their place in the WWE pecking order. We€™re going to delve into the talents who used the high profile stage at SummerSlam to make the most out of their opportunity, as well as those men and women who ended the night in a less desirable position than when it began. Strap in and let€™s look at who the real winners and losers were. Let€™s begin with the winners. Honorable Mention:Dolph Ziggler It would be much easier to view this as a win if A) the Intercontinental championship hadn€™t been devalued to that point that it€™s virtually worthless, and B) Ziggler has been the recipient of so many start-and-stop pushes that it€™s impossible to get excited about anything he does, because we€™ve been conditioned to believe he€™ll be jobbing to less-talented guys again in no time. Nevertheless, it was surprising to see him go over Miz here, considering the former champ is currently doing the best character work of his career and drawing pretty good heel heat. We€™ll have to wait and see how this one plays out. Honorable Mention: Triple H Purely for the way he sold for Brie Bella. That was best for business.

The Winners

5. Stephanie McMahon

No one expected this match to be anywhere near as entertaining as it was, and a large portion of that credit needs to go to Stephanie. She€™s been on fire for the last 6 months, serving as arguably one of the two most effective heels in the entire business (the other being Paul Heyman). Now granted, when you two best villains aren€™t even wrestlers that€™s a problem that needs to be remedied, but it€™s hard not to enjoy her character in all its megalomaniacal, power-mad glory. This was the third highest billed match on the card, and WWE promoted it as such, ending consecutive Raws with angles revolving around the feud. There was much trepidation on the part of the audience due to the fact that, despite improving greatly over the course of the last year or so, Brie Bella isn€™t a very good worker to begin with and Stephanie hasn€™t had an actual match in over a decade. But the two ladies went out and did their best to entertain the crowd, and for the most part they absolutely did. There€™s just something about those McMahons. Performing is in their genes, because despite having very little formal training, anytime Steph, Vince and especially Shane have stepped in the ring it€™s usually a wildly entertaining affair. The decision to turn Nikki heel on her sister is one that was heavily rumored and telegraphed, but there wasn€™t anywhere else left to go with them so it was a nice change. Stephanie used her considerable size and strength advantage to toss Brie around like a rag doll and looked far better in the ring than most of the active Divas. Give her credit: She knows her role and plays it to perfection, and last night was no exception. But the most impressive thing was the actual quality of the match, keeping people engaged and not the usual bathroom break stigma that most Divas matches are plagued with.

4. John Cena

Last night John Cena martyred himself for the WWE universe. Most fans who boo the 15-time champion aren€™t doing so out of an actual dislike of Cena the man, or even Cena the performer. What they€™re actually voicing their displeasure over is the booking of John as the superman who can overcome all obstacles, standing tall atop the wrestling world for over a decade now. It€™s tiresome and the fans, at least the vocal subset that boo him out of arenas and drown out the kids and females during his matches and promos, want something new and fresh. And John Cena knows this. He calls attention to it in promos, dismissing it with his usual €œCheer me or boo me, I love the WWE universe and how vocal and passionate you are€ diatribe, but as far as the actual booking goes, it€™s ignored for the most part. But not this time. Cena walked into the ring and was basically the victim of a main event squash match. The stress on his back, shoulders and neck from those 16 brutal german suplexes was intense, and yet he did it for the fans. For all the flack he gets, some of it deservedly so and some wholly unjustified, you would have never seen Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin or The Rock booked to lose like that during their primes. It€™s a credit to the man and how secure he is with his spot and his legacy that he agreed to be decimated in such a convincing manner. And he did it for you.

3. Bray Wyatt

Ever since about midway through his program with John Cena, Bray Wyatt has felt like he€™s been spinning his wheels, with the company unsure what to do with him. He€™s an incredible promo, one of the most compelling speakers in wrestling, and his ring work has improved by quantum leaps since his days as Husky Harris. It€™s not his fault that his booking has been somewhat directionless, but it€™s hindered him nonetheless. He isn€™t your typical wrestler in that his motivation for being there can€™t always be explained as someone who is in pursuit of championships and glory. He€™s a unique character who is been driven by goals outside of the realm of wrestling matches. And that€™s led to him hitting a wall of sorts. Enter Chris Jericho. For the past several years Y2J has popped in and out of WWE to work brief programs and elevate the talents he€™s positioned with. He did with Punk, he tried it with Fandango, and now he€™s in the process of doing it with Wyatt. Their first encounter at Battleground was a huge disappointment and we all hoped it would be an anomaly, as both men have proven to be capable of so much more. The SummerSlam rematch was a definite step up, although still not the classic we had hoped for, and it was a big help in reestablishing the eater of worlds as a credible threat. Now if WWE can just find a way to stave off the audience support and keep him a heel. Or, as this author has advocated for a while now, give us the eventual Wyatt family vs. The Authority storyline that seems to be such a natural character progression. But for now, Wyatt fans should be very happy with what we saw.

2. Brock Lesnar

If you were to pour back through the professional wrestling history books, you€™d be hard pressed to find another performer who had a more impressive back-to-back match span than Brock Lesnar has this year. The Beast Incarnate did the unthinkable and defeated The Undertaker to break the streak at WrestleMania XXX and then returned to do the unthinkable yet again and made John Cena his b*tch at SummerSlam. Despite the fact that booking him to lose in his first match after The Undertaker would have been a waste of the streak, fans still sat with baited breath half expecting to Cena to RISE ABOVE STREAK-BREAKING UFC FIGHTERS and retain the championship. But WWE, and especially Cena did the right thing in making Brock look like the monster he is. Lesnar has been brilliant at crafting his matches, giving us something different in each one. For all the credit he gets for being a bloodthirsty feaster of human flesh who wears a skull necklace and kicks babies for fun, he€™s not touted nearly enough for being a talented ring technician. His first match with Cena at Extreme Rules 2012 was practically and MMA fight with the kind of brutality WWE is shy about giving us, the Punk encounter at last year€™s SummerSlam was a classic big man vs. little man affair and this year€™s Cena bout was a textbook lesson in punishment. If WWE can keep him strong before felling him at the ends of their own conqueror, be it Roman Reigns or possibly a returning Daniel Bryan, this has the potential to be one of the most exciting reigns of terror in a very long time. Also that Undertaker sit-up/troll job was pretty much the greatest thing in the history of all things.

1. Dean Ambrose & Seth Rollins

The true winners of SummerSlam 2014 are undoubtedly former Shield brothers Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose. Since the dissolution of The Shield the night after Extreme Rules, these two have engaged in the most well-booked, intense rivalry since Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels in 2008. When the lumberjack stipulation was announced, a large segment of the fanbase groaned, hoping for something a little more exciting, despite Ambrose€™s excellent justification for why he chose that particular match type. But these two workers took the constraints of a typical lumberjack bout and shattered the norm, putting on a hell of an affair that was easily the best match of the night. Rather than serve as detractors from the quality of the match, Rollins and Ambrose used the wrestlers surrounding the ring as literal props to enhance what we were witnessing. And despite the entire point of lumberjacks being that the two competitors stay confined to the ring, the former partners did whatever they wanted and battled all throughout the crowd anyway. It was a thing of beauty, and the best case scenario for how it could have played out. But the real story is how well both men performed and the investment of the crowd in what they were doing. We all know Roman Reigns is the hand-picked heir apparent to John Cena, but at SummerSlam his two ex-Shieldmates showed the world that they will not allow themselves to be lost in the shuffle. It was awesome (clap clap clap clap clap).

The Losers...

5. Brie Bella

It€™s crazy to think that two workers in the same match could have so firmly landed on opposing lists, but that€™s what happened. Let€™s face it: Brie Bella seems like a really nice lady, tries hard at her craft and has obviously been working to improve over the course of the last year or two. But she still has a long way to go, and when paired with a natural performer like Stephanie her deficiencies become even more glaring. Brie was clearly being carried here, with McMahon doing the heavy lifting, and her timing was really off in spots, including being unable to land her kicks at the right tempo for the audience to do the €œYes!€ chants along with them. The differences in their abilities, with Stephanie being so amazing at her role, actually caused a subtle shift in support during the match, with a segment of the crowd getting behind The Authority€™s queen bee. From a kayfabe standpoint, Daniel Bryan€™s wife lost the match to her hated rival and was betrayed by her sister all at the same time. That€™s a bad day at the office. It€™ll be interesting to see where the feud goes from here, with the logical continuation being the shift from Stephanie to Nikki, but that€™s a losing situation for Brie, who needs a more talented worker to help her along, and for the fans who will probably crap all over when THE BELLA POWERS EXPLODE.

4. Jack Swagger

The Jack Swagger/Zeb Colter face turn has been fun and given American fans a cathartic release when we chant €œUSA! USA!€ at the dastardly foreign menaces. But here€™s the problem. There€™s absolutely nowhere for the duo to go from here. I don€™t think anyone expected Swagger to get the better of this program. It was just a placeholder to help build heat for Rusev. But now that they€™ve turned The Real Americans face, despite Swagger being a far more natural heel, there€™s a very real fear that they€™ll soon be directionless. The former University of Oklahoma All-American is hoss in the ring, like a charisma-less blend of Kurt Angle and Steve €œDr. Death€ Williams, and despite a few runs near the top of the card, he€™s just never felt like someone who was destined for much more than what he€™s already achieved. We€™ll probably get one more match between the two, leading to a definite victory for Rusev before he€™s cycled onto something bigger, but unfortunately the smart money is that Jack will be stuck doing nothing much of anything after that.

3. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho is one of the greatest professional wrestlers who€™s ever laced up the boots. He€™s a complete performer, as talented on the mic as he is in the ring and has shown a propensity for having good to great matches with a variety of workers. As highly as most fans think of him, he€™s probably still underrated and underappreciated. That being said, this most recent run has not been good. At all. For one thing, Jericho€™s persona is infinitely better as a hell. As an in-ring worker, he€™s got great babyface fire, but his character is far more suited to playing the bad guy. This is probably part of the reason the chemistry with Bray Wyatt has been nonexistent. Take for example the segment from the Raw before SummerSlam with the sit-down confrontation between the two. The levity of Bray€™s words were almost ruined by the silliness of Jericho€™s scrunched up angry face. As excited as we all were about the prospect of these two feuding, it just hasn€™t clicked. In addition to that, his work in the squared circle has just felt a bit€off. In both of his matches with Wyatt, he just hasn€™t seemed like the Y2J we all know and love. It could be that Father Time is finally catching up to him, or maybe he and Bray just don€™t mesh well together. Whatever the case, as the veteran of the two he carries the most responsibility. At this stage of his career, fans are becoming conditioned to know that Jericho is coming back to work with an up and coming talent and put them over, helping to get them to the next level. And he should be commended for that, the ability to put his ego in check and help out the business by ensuring its future. What happens after he leaves is out of his hands (see Fandango). Hopefully WWE realizes that and makes sure Wyatt means even more after this, especially because this program hasn€™t done Chris Jericho any favors.

2. Cesaro

How the mighty have fallen. Cesaro went from being a hot property, propelled by organic fan support into a higher profile with a big win at WrestleMania XXX and an association as a Paul Heyman guy. But somewhere along the way someone decided that wasn€™t the plan, crowd responses and talent be damned. Whatever the reason, he€™s fallen far than any other superstar since the WWE€™s biggest event. This is a guy who went from getting some of the loudest reactions on the card, vanquishing his former partner in short order, winning a prestigious battle royal at Mania and then being paired with Paul Heyman. This all felt like the natural progression was a break away from Heyman and a big star-making match vs. Brock Lesnar. Instead he€™s now losing to Heath Slater. At SummerSlam he was demoted to the pre-show, losing to Rob Van Dam of all people, a part-timer who the company has shown no interest in pushing due to his lack of long term commitment. The optimists among us would like to believe that WWE has big plans for The Swiss Superman, biding their time until they need to push him strongly again. But the overwhelming majority of fans who could generously be called pessimists fully suspect that he€™s floundering because the creative department has no idea what to do with him. And that€™s a shame because he€™s one of the most talented workers on the entire roster.

1. Roman Reigns

Perhaps the one thing WWE has done nearly perfectly over the course of the last year or so is their handling of the booking of The Shield. When they were together they were booked as strongly as any unit since the nWo, and now that they€™ve been split all three men have been positioned excellently, involved in top storylines and matches. They€™ve made no secret they view Roman Reigns as the next to be €œThe Guy€, but if SummerSlam showed us anything, it€™s that he may not be quite ready for the spot they€™re grooming him for. Reigns has the look; his Dothraki warlord appearance definitely gives him the physical traits of someone who would just as soon kick your *ss as speak to you. He also has a unique charisma that makes you feel as if you€™re watching a special performer. And most importantly, he has the full and total support of WWE management. But what he doesn€™t have, and shouldn€™t be expected to this early in his young career are the in-ring skills to sustain him at a main event level, and last night drew a bullseye around that fact. It doesn€™t help that the conspiracy theorists among us could make a case that Orton was sandbagging him a bit, purposely slowing the match down with this patented chinlocks. The main deficiency in his work is his lack of transitional moves. A wrestler doesn€™t have to have the repertoire of Dean Malenko to put together an effective match. Just look at The Rock. He had a handful of spots that he relied on, but everything he did in the ring was very smooth and fluid, and even the most basic of moves were executed efficiently. Now watch a Roman Reigns singles match and count the punches. In between the headbutts, clotheslines and Samoan drops and preceding the superman punch and spear, it€™s practically all he does. He throws a hell of a working punch, or if you ask Miz a shoot punch, but his reliance on it is hindering his progression. Reigns has a tremendous future and he will be a huge star for them for years to come. But the best thing for him would be to pair him up for an extended house show run with a great worker who can give him the on-the-job training that will really help him grow. One thing's for sure: he isn€™t going to get any better trapped in Randy Orton€™s chinlock.

Contributor
Contributor

Brad Hamilton is a writer, musician and marketer/social media manager from Atlanta, Georgia. He's an undefeated freestyle rap battle champion, spends too little time being productive and defines himself as the literary version of Brock Lesnar.