WWE SummerSlam 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
Sweaty, sleepless nights incoming if you care about MITB or WWE's future!
Abandon hope all ye with positive spin who enter here.
This is not the place for chirpy optimism about WWE's next PLE. No, the clue's very-much in the name - these entries are the damned souls of company creative, and they make no attempt to be upbeat. So, just be forewarned, because this is about everything that could turn SummerSlam 2023 into a nightmare of epic proportions.
Turns you'd never see coming ('cause they wouldn't make any sense), title switches for the sake of it, matches bombing spectacularly in front of a massive live crowd, WWE trolling everybody with a fake finish and more. That's all here, and so is the complete annihilation of a longstanding gimmick.
If that's not enough torment, then consider the featured image. Many fans anticipate some mega returns at SummerSlam, but they might regret tripping over one another to see what Triple H, Vince McMahon and the writers have in store. Ready for another round of supernatural heartbreak? No? Tough!
Here's all the absolute worst things that could happen in Detroit on Saturday night. None of them are impossible, but all of them would really suck.
10. Ludwig Kaiser Turns On GUNTHER
Remember when GUNTHER was slapping Ludwig Kaiser around and taking his own frustrations out on a fellow Imperium member? Or, how about when both leader and foot soldier left poor Giovanni Vinci high and dry? All of that was washed away when GUNTHER offered a handshake to Kaiser on Raw.
Or, was it? Someone in creative might think it's a cracking idea to have Ludwig be the one who costs GUNTHER his Intercontinental Title at SummerSlam. Vinci would be involved too, but Kaiser would be the ringleader, and the man leading this mutiny against he who previously chopped his chest raw.
This would suck for multiple reasons, not least because GUNTHER is a stone's throw away from beating Honky Tonk Man's longstanding IC Title record. It'd also be crap due to Imperium's standing on the roster, and the fact that WWE has only just scratched the surface on what they're capable of.
Please don't book this.
9. Someone Lame Wins The Battle Royal
The only names confirmed for the "SummerSlam Battle Royal" thus far are LA Knight, Sheamus, Chad Gable, Otis, Shinsuke Nakamura and Tommaso Ciampa. That reads like a who's who of guys that don't really have much else going on heading into the biggest pay-per-view of the summer months.
Surely Knight is a shoe-in to win the thing?
If he doesn't, then this will be the latest example of WWE overlooking the organically-over star for no real reason. It'd be hellish if LA was doomed to become this generation's version of Zack Ryder. You know the deal there: Ryder was over in spite of company plans, so they squashed his momentum at every turn.
Honestly, if this Battle Royal turns out to be a naff excuse to have Omos return (or somebody like that) then dominate and win the thing....forget it. LA's inclusion feels shaky enough as things stand, so the least WWE can do is give him a PLE win.
8. High-Flyers Fail To Gel
On paper, Logan Paul vs. Ricochet is a match made in heaven. Both lads can shift, and they'll be motivated to put on a show come Detroit. Plus, Rico doesn't get many opportunities like this, and he'll know some casual eyes will be watching Paul's every move. So, basically, it's a chance for Ricochet to soar in front of a new audience.
One niggling thing keeps rattling around the back of this writer's brain though. Rico and Logan have bumped bodies in a memorable Royal Rumble bump, and worked another top moment at Money In The Bank, but they haven't actually worked a full match together yet at full pelt.
Maybe they won't have any chemistry to speak of.
That's always a worry with any combo of wrestlers, sure, but Rico might be hoping for a Will Ospreay match against someone who still isn't all that experienced. It'd be a nightmare if Paul got lost out there and the full match was spotty in the wrong way.
7. Ronda Rousey Wins On The Way Out
It remains to be seen whether this will be Ronda Rousey's last match in WWE or not. Some say it'll be a wrap on her latest run, whereas others believe the ex-UFC fighter is just done with pro wrestling full stop. Then, there are those who think she'll beat Shayna Baszler before putting her over in a rematch later.
What a waste that'd be - Ronda doesn't need to be picking up any wins at SummerSlam. She has nothing to prove after years of being booked strongly. Meanwhile, her real-life pal Shayna has been made to look like an afterthought time and time again by creative. That must change on Saturday night.
Rousey winning then celebrating in front of fans she doesn't actually care for in the first place sounds...terrible. Let's definitely not go down the forced babyface route for either of these women, WWE. That'd be a mistake, especially for someone as polarising as Ronda.
Baszler needs this one more.
6. Brock Lesnar Wins The Series
SummerSlam is a crucial event for Cody Rhodes, and maybe even more than some critics out there realise. He lost at WrestleMania, but has managed to maintain a significant babyface connection to the core audience despite that hiccup. Now, his feud with Brock Lesnar comes to a head this weekend.
Few will believe Cody can "finish the story" long-term if he can't conclusively put this series of matches with Brock to bed and move forwards with momentum. Rhodes is good enough to lose (as 'Mania proved), but patience with WWE's handling of him will run out if the writers aren't careful.
Cody losing 2-1 to Brock, then moping around the place before promising to bounce back stronger would be a quasi-repeat of something that's already happened with another opponent this year. That doesn't sound very fun, and it'd be a challenge to get people up for more Rhody Codes storytelling if he can't back up bold words yet again.
Careful, lads.
5. IYO SKY’s MITB Flop
Quick pop quiz question! Who's the reigning WWE Women's Champion? It's Asuka, of course, but there are some in company creative meetings who'd likely hesitate before answering. They've pushed the champ so far into the background before SummerSlam that she might as well be a floating title in match graphics.
Then, there's IYO SKY. She's caught between Bayley's ongoing side issue with a revamped Shotzi and trying to muscle in on an already-busy title scene between Asuka, Charlotte Flair and Bianca Belair. Wouldn't it be awful if she was booked to cash in her Money In The Bank briefcase at SummerSlam and lose?
Y'know, just 'cause WWE couldn't be arsed to show some restraint.
They don't normally keep that case on women for this long, so the writers might be getting itchy trigger fingers. It'd be rubbish, but they'd blast away one creative headache by having Bayley accidentally cost IYO her cash-in moment, or something similar.
4. Charlotte Flair Wins More Gold
Oh dear.
Look, some reading this writer's work are gonna start thinking he has it in for Charlotte Flair. That's simply not true, but he does despise when WWE lazily uses her as some escape route panic button and pretends it's what the entire audience at large demanded when they really, really didn't.
Flair can hold a belt at some point in the future again, obviously, but now isn't the time. It'll feel like Groundhog Day if she's on top of the SmackDown scene booting arses and acting like nobody's on her level. That's old hat, and it'd only suffocate the division on Friday nights all over again.
Don't bet against it happening though. WWE blatantly doesn't fancy Asuka as champ, and they might want to develop Bianca Belair's possible heel turn further before sticking gold back on her too. So, Charlotte would be the lazy creative team member's default poison of choice.
Yes, again.
3. WWE Tries A “Dusty Finish”
Ladies and gents, your 'Tribal Chief' is...shocked and stunned.
Roman Reigns' Undisputed Title is up for grabs on Saturday, but so is his right to lead The Bloodline and order family members around like some big cheese. WWE is hoping that Jey Uso's pinfall win over Roman in a tag match at Money In The Bank convinces fans he can do it a second time in quick succession.
What if he does, but it's that old "Dusty Finish" chestnut and tricks Detroit into thinking they just witnessed the end of Roman? A Solo Sikoa turn, or something like that, could give Paul Heyman cause to argue immediately after that Reigns wasn't beaten fairly.
Cue Adam Pearce to "regrettably announce" that the match had to be restarted. Then, BOOM! Roman gets the win and all is right with the world. Except it isn't, and several members of the Michigan community have to be talked down from starting a riot in Ford Field.
2. Damian Priest Also Loses MITB
As if you didn't experience enough MITB-related agony in the IYO SKY entry, eh? Apologies in advance for this, but the nightmare fuel on tap in this entry is Judgment Day bruiser Damian Priest also shedding his briefcase. Yes, a real two-for-one dumpster fire for those who cherish the longstanding gimmick.
WWE has already teased Priest cashing in during one of Finn Bálor's matches with Seth Rollins. They might try that again at SummerSlam, but go through with turning the bout into a Triple Threat. Then, in a particularly foul moment, Damian's ladder match win in the UK would prove to be a pointless waste of everyone's time.
Oh great.
What if he cashes in, Finn is horrified, both stablemates end up bickering, Rollins seizes the advantage and puts Bálor away a second time? Then, the Judgment Day in-fighting can commence all over again and someone can emerge to try and get everybody back on the same page.
You're not ready for this!
1. Bray Wyatt = New Judgment Day Leader
Admittedly, Bray Wyatt's WWE career is right back up in the air following his disappearance from screens earlier this year right before WrestleMania. Nobody really knows what's going on apart from him and a select few behind the scenes, but he'll surely pop back up on TV at some point.
Judgment Day's new leader, anyone?
Stranger things have happened, but this would be a bad thing for the rest of the faction. Still, Triple H, Vince McMahon or another creative team member may argue that Wyatt bringing Finn Bálor, Damian Priest, Rhea Ripley and Dominik Mysterio under his spell would be interesting.
Fair enough, but it'd also take JD into supernatural nonsense (something WWE finds unavoidable with Wyatt) and rip away all of the hard work they've been doing since 2022 in an instant. Bray leading the charge might look cool on posters, but it'd be a nightmare in execution.
Which other nightmares could come true at WWE SummerSlam 2023?! For more like this, check out 10 Things We Learned From American Nightmare: Becoming Cody Rhodes and WWE SummerSlam 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen!