WWE Survivor Series 2018: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

All over the place.

Ronda Rousey Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

As expected, NXT won the weekend yet again.

In fairness, Survivor Series certainly wasn't as bad as it could've been, especially given the late-day changes to the card, but it was a wildly mixed bag of dull, inspired fare, underwhelming traditional elimination matches and a couple of good-to-great bouts.

WWE's usual bizarre booking was in full effect as ever, along with some distinctly goofy shenanigans which occasionally ruined the fun, to say nothing of a crowd that alternated between comatose and obnoxious.

As for the show's treatment of its "brand supremacy" narrative, short of it having an unexpected, spectacular payoff in the coming weeks, it really feels like a most pointless burial of Smackdown for no good reason.

If the two biggest matches on the card delivered more often than not, though, the Match of the Night award was stolen out of left-field, and once again serves as a reminder that fans shouldn't sleep on what's happening over at 205...


8. The Bar Vs. AOP

WWE Survivor Series 2018 AOP Cesaro
WWE.com

Result: AOP drills Sheamus with a Suplex-Powerbomb combination for the win (9:00).

Rating: This match was so anodyne you'd be forgiven for forgetting it even happened, to be honest.

The most memorable thing was Enzo Amore being kicked out of the building, and it's just as well, because otherwise the crowd would've had absolutely nothing to react to here.

This had potential to be a fun car wreck but it was insanely boring, and having Drake Maverick p*ss himself in the final stretch only added to the feeling this was a hugely wasted opportunity.

Plus, even that inane spot didn't really work because we could obviously see Maverick fiddling with a tube in his pants.

Is it so much to ask that we have a PPV tag match that doesn't involve someone voiding their bladder? 4/10


7. Women's Survivor Series Match: Team Raw Vs. Team Smackdown

WWE Survivor Series 2018 Women S
WWE.com

Result: Nia Jax kills Asuka with a Samoan Drop (18:50) to give Team Raw the win.

Rating: The pacing for this thing was all over the place: it started out with a few quick eliminations - including, bizarrely, Team Smackdown captain Naomi - but dragged itself out to a painful length in the final stretch.

The Sonya/Bayley double countout was a deeply lame way to take them out of the match, but the only real story here is Nia's predictable steamroll over Asuka.

WWE's clearly trying to capitalise on her nuclear heat, which makes a certain amount of business sense, but she's clearly not ready to put on a compelling match against Ronda anytime soon.

This only compounds the fact that Asuka continues to be booked like a joke. Parts of the match were certainly decent, but it left a sour taste overall. 5/10


6. Men's Survivor Series Match: Team Raw Vs. Team Smackdown

WWE Survivor Series 2018 Men S
WWE.com

Result: Braun eliminates Shane McMahon with a Powerslam to give Team Raw the win (24:00).

Rating: This was a mess, basically. Drew eliminating Joe was great for Drew, but did it really need to come at the expense of burying Joe rather than, say, eliminating Jeff Hardy?

The Team Raw dissension was mildly amusing at first but quickly got irritating, especially as it ended up making Drew look like a bit of a goof, and had no payoff with Raw still winning. The Balor/Mysterio sequence was the easy highlight, especially as Mysterio ended up scoring the surprise elimination.

The final stretch was boring and uninspired, with Shane lasting to the end despite being far younger than his teammates.

The Miz forcing him back into the ring was hilarious, sure, but the ego-centric booking just makes Shane frustratingly unlikeable, especially following the Crown Jewel incident.

At least Shane took the L, but in terms of pacing, layout and booking, it was sloppy as hell, if moderately entertaining as a demolition derby. 5/10


5. Seth Rollins vs. Shinsuke Nakamura

WWE Survivor Series 2018 Nakamura Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Result: Rollins annihilates Nak with the Stomp to score the win (21:50).

Rating: On one hand this was far too long and agonisingly slow at times, but on the other it certainly had its moments and the final five-or-so minutes were really quite excellent.

It didn't help that the crowd was asleep, it felt like a kickout-fest at points, there were no real stakes and nothing really mattered.

Still, despite it hardly breaking Nakamura's streak of underwhelming PPV matches, the lack of Ambrose shenanigans and strong ending certainly elevated it into decent territory.

Both men are clearly capable of so much more, but the enthusiasm was lacking. 6/10


4. 10-On-10 Survivor Series Match: Team Raw Vs. Team Smackdown

WWE Survivor Series 2018 10v10
WWE.com

Result: The Usos put Scott Dawson away with the Superfly Superman Splash, giving Team Smackdown their solitary win (22:20).

Rating: This was a pretty standard Survivor Series match, but a lot of fun and something WWE seems almost embarrassed of these days.

There wasn't much breathing room for the 20 men in the early going with a lot of signature/finisher spam, but it was never less than moderately enjoyable, even in its ropier moments.

Roode and Gable made for a great team, there was a neat mix of styles and some surprisingly hard bumping for a kickoff match. Gable's top-rope German Suplex was incredible, of course, and the final Usos/Revival showdown got the crowd hugely invested.

It's a damn shame WWE took a steaming dump on the match by quickly claiming Smackdown's victory didn't count, though. Way to instantly fob off 20 of your roster members right there. 6/10


3. Brock Lesnar vs. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan Brock Lesnar Survivor Series
WWE

Result: Brock puts Bryan down with the F-5 (18:50).

Rating: How weird is it to see a heel-vs-heel main event, especially one featuring Daniel Bryan? This was a frustrating match in that the first half was a boring slog, but the final 10 minutes were absolutely terrific.

There was a ton of stalling in the early going before Brock pulled out his usual Suplex City shtick, with Daniel taking some utterly unnerving bumps.

This section of the match dragged on way too long, but things took a turn for the better after the ref spot, which was admittedly embarrassingly telegraphed.

It actually got competitive with Bryan wrestling smart, exploiting Brock's size against him and making the most of his own superior speed. There was genuine tension when Brock was caught in the Yes Lock, even if Brock's win was of course inevitable.

This was one of the weirdest main events in recent memory, if only because Bryan was booked like an underdog face despite being a heel, and the fact it capped Raw's 6-0 dominance over Smackdown (or 6-1, really).

The ending was a bit deflating but the back-half of the match saw both men putting in the work after a cynical and tedious opening half. Not a great main event, but it did what it needed to. 6/10


2. Charlotte Flair Vs. Ronda Rousey

Charlotte Ronda Rousey
WWE.com

Result: Charlotte attacks Ronda with a kendo stick, giving her the DQ win (14:40).

Rating: This was scrappy as hell from the opening bell and would've been a fitting way to close the show out.

Ronda always brings a unique roughness to her matches that makes them feel more gritty and authentic, and though not all wrestlers gel with this style, Charlotte did a great job keeping up and holding her own.

It loses a point for the mildly frustrating ending, but as far as DQ finishes go, this at least made something approaching character sense, and of course led to that ludicrously entertaining post-match beatdown.

Charlotte is an inherently unlikeable character so she doesn't really work as a face: turning her heel was a smart move and the ending protected both of them. 7/10


1. Cruiserweight Title: Buddy Murphy (c) Vs. Mustafa Ali

buddy murphy mustafa ali
WWE.com

Result: Murphy nails the Murphy’s Law to retain the strap (12:20).

Rating: In a sea of mediocrity, this terrific match arrived mid-show and provided some temporary relief.

Despite a disinterested, gassed crowd, Murphy and Ali fought hard to perk them up with incredible bumps and amazing selling. It's honestly incredible nobody suffered a neck or head injury here.

The Spanish Fly off the table finally seemed to wake the crowd, even getting them to chant "205!", and though the match ran a little shorter than it could have, it was a fierce sprint that didn't feel rushed.

Both men deserve joint MVP honours for the night, but please, get Buddy some new entrance music ASAP. 8/10

What did you think of this year's Survivor Series? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.