WWE Survivor Series 2019: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
A (mostly) solid show.
Despite following the lead of another exemplary NXT show, this year's Survivor Series event proved to be impressively consistent for the most part, bar a couple of undercooked efforts.
It's probably no coincidence that the event as a whole felt like a bizarre showcase for NXT itself, with the night's strongest showings coming from Rhea Ripley, Keith Lee, and Adam Cole. Go figure.
But most of the marquee matches delivered - with only one extremely disappointing exception - while the show pacing was great, the crowd was (mostly) hot, and we actually got a great honest-to-God classic Survivor Series elimination match out of it.
Some questionable creative decisions definitely undermined a few of the satisfying results - especially in the case of the main event - but for the most part the show delivered on its promises, and wasn't thoroughly embarrassed by NXT's own offering the night before.
But as ever, it's probably smart to keep your expectations low for the follow-through...
10. Tag Team Battle Royal
Result: Robert Roode throws Montez Ford over the top rope for the win (8:20).
Rating: At least this offered something a little different from the usual generic kickoff show Battle Royal, even if it was still ultimately completely forgettable.
Roode and Ziggler winning was pretty odd considering the number of actual, long-tenured tag teams in the match, but Ziggler's desperation spots were at least one of the match's few highlights.
Still, a Street Profits win would've been far more satisfying, especially given their amusing showing here.
It got in and got out quickly, but while it was always going to be a whole lotta nothing, it at least could've given an up-and-coming team the rub. 4/10
9. Bayley Vs. Shayna Baszler Vs. Becky Lynch
Result: Bayley taps to Shayna's Kirifuda Clutch to win the night for NXT (18:10).
Rating: This was incredibly flat and disappointing, and though it seemed like a worthy main event on paper, the three ultimately lacked the expected chemistry.
This just didn't have a big fight feel, oddly, and it's tough to say that the three even seemed to be putting much effort in to actually make it happen. The generic triple threat formula, with one of the three regularly taking a nap, didn't help at all.
The ending was also predictable and anti-climactic, with Becky being taken out of the frame with a limp table bump while Bayley once again ate the L.
It was a pleasant surprise to have NXT come out on top at the end of the night, even if Becky of course had to have the last laugh. 5/10
8. Women's Survivor Series Match: Team Raw Vs. Team SmackDown Vs. Team NXT
Result: Rhea Ripley destroys Sasha Banks with the Riptide to win the match for Team NXT (28:00).
Rating: There were some great individual spots in this match, but overall it just felt a bit sloppy and thrown together.
The booking was straight-up nonsensical at times, having wrestlers needlessly break falls - or not break them when they really needed the help - and Asuka then randomly leaving the match despite never being eliminated.
The injured Io Shirai and Candice LeRae spot, meanwhile, was pure generic Survivor Series throwback nonsense and felt like a desperate attempt to inject some drama into the match.
Rhea Ripley was the easy MVP and continued to boost her brand, even if she didn't make much of an effort to sell the effects of WarGames, and the interference at the end was totally unnecessary.
Still, it was neat to see NXT scoop such a decisive win, though given the ridiculous amount of talent standing on the apron, this was overall just OK.
Above all else, it's a reminder of just how much thought needs to go into laying these epic matches out. 6/10
7. WWE Title - No Holds Barred: Brock Lesnar (C) Vs. Rey Mysterio
Result: Brock murders Rey with an F-5 to retain the title (7:00).
Rating: This was pretty much what everyone expected: a filler near-squash match for Brock, with some silly Dominick shenanigans thrown in for good measure.
But to be fair, the Dominick interference was fun - especially the dual 619 - even if Brock's win was never not happening, and it should've taken a little more to keep Rey down for the count.
It was over fast and inoffensive, if ultimately relatively pointless, and they could've done a lot more with the No Holds Barred stipulation. For a formulaic Brock title match, though, it was fine enough. 6/10
6. WWE Universal Title: "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt (C) Vs. Daniel Bryan
Result: The Fiend incapacitates Bryan with the Mandible Claw to score the pin and retain the title (10:10).
Rating: Yes, they're really committed to that red lighting, and yes, it's still terrible.
The crowd was totally dead for the first half of the match, and things only really picked up when they stopped trying to have anything close to an actual wrestling match.
It was fun seeing Bryan go absolute ham on Wyatt later on, and he did a great job getting the crowd behind him while still selling The Fiend's power and intimidation factor.
The ending was always a foregone conclusion, but this was mostly booked right, bar the tedious opening. It was certainly a stronger showing for The Fiend than in his Rollins matches, even if nobody would call it a classically good title bout. 6/10
5. NXT Cruiserweight Title: Lio Rush (C) Vs. Kalisto Vs. Akira Tozawa
Result: Rush kills Kalisto with the Final Hour to retain the strap (8:20).
Rating: This was a fun cruiser sprint with all three men getting their solid licks in before Rush predictably retained.
It moved fast and the crowd were into it - as much as they could be with such an early slot, anyway - and all three men treated it like they actually cared.
Given that there was a very real future where Rush was buried after voicing his displeasure with how he was used last year, it's refreshing to see creative not go the vindictive route.
With more time to go this could've been really good, and hopefully we'll get to see them go at it again on a stage like this, but with a longer ring time. 7/10
4. The New Day Vs. The Undisputed Era Vs. The Viking Raiders
Result: The Viking Raiders score the win after Ivar drills Kyle O'Reilly onto Bobby Fish with The Viking Experience (14:35).
Rating: Predictably, the third and final kickoff show match evened the scores at the doors before the event proper started.
But given that the Raiders stole the show here, it was tough to argue with their eventual, well-deserved win.
All three teams certainly got plenty to do - Kofi's top-rope Stomp was incredible, and The Undisputed Era being slightly off their game also played nicely off their WarGames match the night before.
The trio sustained the surprisingly lengthy ring time well, even with a fairly lethargic crowd. This was shockingly good for a kickoff match, basically. 7/10
3. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. Roderick Strong Vs. AJ Styles
Result: Roderick Strong steals the pin for NXT after AJ blasts Nak with a Phenomenal Forearm (16:45).
Rating: If you could deal with the obnoxious crowd and Jerry Lawler's insufferable commentary, these guys put on a ludicrously entertaining show.
Even Nakamura did enough to almost make you forget about the general mediocrity of his WWE run so far, and given the sure temptation to overbook the match into oblivion, it was refreshing not to see any interference shenanigans.
Giving Strong the sneaky win was surprising and well-earned, and if we're lucky, we might one day get to see these guys square off again. 7/10
2. Men's Survivor Series Match: Team Raw Vs. Team SmackDown Vs. Team NXT
Result: Roman kills Lee with a Spear to give Team SmackDown the win (29:25).
Rating: There were some really great pairings here: it was especially fun to see Walter sparring with Braun Strowman and Drew McIntyre at the start, even if Walter's early elimination was intensely disappointing.
Orton and Ciampa also had a nice little run, and Orton being taken out by Matt Riddle was a fantastic crowd-pleasing moment.
And just when it seemed like Ricochet was a lock for the match MVP, Keith Lee came along and stole the show in the final stretch, getting a huge pop for taking out Rollins and very nearly going the distance against Roman.
This certainly suffered a bit from excess elimination spam, but slowed down nicely for the final showdown between Rollins, Reigns, Ciampa, and Lee.
Overall it was a fun, crowd-pleasing car crash elimination match, while not nearly as clumsy or overbooked as the women's equivalent. 8/10
1. NXT Title: Adam Cole (C) Vs. Pete Dunne
Result: Cole destroys Dunne with The Last Shot to retain the title (14:10).
Rating: Trust an NXT Title match to steal the show on a marquee WWE PPV, the night after both men were put through hell at WarGames no less.
This was everything an NXT main event match should be, with both men giving everything they have, even if Cole winning after being half-murdered the night before required some slight suspension of disbelief.
The match was booked quite brilliantly to sell that neither man was anywhere close to 100%, though, and that psychology really enhanced the visceral quality of the fight.
This was incredibly intense and didn't feel remotely watered down for the mainline WWE brand: especially fantastic were the horrific-looking Panama Sunrise on the apron and that climactic Bitter End counter. The night truly was a win for NXT in every possible way. 8/10