WWE The Horror Show At Extreme Rules: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
5. Eye For An Eye Match: Rey Mysterio Vs. Seth Rollins
Result: Rollins used the steel ring steps to "extract" Mysterio's eye (18:05).
Rating: Sadly WWE didn't fully commit to the silliness of this match and actually have a bad prop eye rolling around the ring, but the bulk of the match itself was still surprisingly fun.
Because we as fans knew so little about where the match was going, there was genuine suspense anytime the men ventured near sharp objects, and the pair clearly relished teasing viewers in that regard.
The key takeaway here is that, somehow, Rey scarcely seems to have slowed down since his heyday, and absolutely brought it with full force against Rollins.
The ending was underwhelming considering the hype, because let's face it, if there was any match that should've gotten totally silly and dumb, it was surely this one.
Rollins puking and Samoa Joe calmly saying "It's out" made the match worth watching alone, though. 6/10