WWE Tough Enough Winners: Where Are They Now?

They didn't make it in the big time, but these former reality TV stars are doing just fine in 2015.

If you've visited WWE's YouTube channel recently you will have no doubt seen the plethora of minute-long, fan submitted videos on there. With WWE Tough Enough returning in late June, wannabe WWE superstars from across the globe are applying for the competition in the hopes of making it to the big time. Even though WWE pitch the show as a chance to live out your dream and become a future sports entertainment star, the odds of that happening, should you win the competition, are surprisingly slim. You are more likely to become a name in the business if you don't win the competition, something that Ryback, The Miz and even The Boogeyman can attest to. No former Tough Enough winner has main evented WrestleMania (but The Miz has, unfortunately). A couple have went on to have good careers in the business but they haven't developed into headline talent. Some people have it in them and some don't, that's just the way it is. But what happened to those former Tough Enough winners, the likes of Linda Miles and Matt Cappotelli, who were promised the world but ended up leaving the company after troubled and/or unspectacular runs there? Some of their post-wrestling vocations may surprise you.

8. Daniel Puder

Daniel Puder became a hero of sorts (in certain circles) when he almost made Kurt Angle tap out in an unplanned, spur-of-the-moment shoot fight. Angle had easily beat Chris Nawrocki (and broke one of his ribs in the process) on the November 4th 2004 Smackdown and challenged any of the other contestants to step up. Up stepped Puder, who had previously trained in MMA. Puder caught Angle off-guard with a very painful kimura lock. Realising what was happening backstage Jerry Brisco instructed referee Jimmy Korderas via his earpiece to count Puder's shoulders to the mat and end the contest. Angle was furious and had some very stern words for the rookie afterwards. Puder won the 'Million Dollar Tough Enough', beating co-finalist The Miz (whom he also narrowly defeated in an amateur boxing match at Armageddon 2004). Puder was not well-liked by the Smackdown locker room after the Angle incident and he didn't endear himself with his cocky attitude, either. Puder's most notable WWE appearance was in the 2005 Royal Rumble, where he was brutally chopped by Hardcore Holly, Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit before being eliminated (Holly hated Puder after he had told his friends that he had beaten Holly for real on house shows). After that, he was sent to OVW to learn how to work but the WWE decided to release him in September as a cost-cutting move. What has Puder been up to since? He had some shoot fights, worked briefly for Ring of Honor (2007/08) and gave a lot of interviews where he talked smack about Kurt Angle. Now retired from MMA, he works for My Life Power, an organisation which mentors children and teenagers who have been the victims of bullying. He plans to wrestle again in 2015. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFzaT1Y-0l8

7. Matt Cappotelli

Poor Matt Cappotelli. The co-winner of Tough Enough III did not have a storybook career in WWE, due to injuries and frequent bouts of illness. First Matt broke his fibula in a tag match in early 2005, then he suffered a couple of serious concussions. It was while being tested for concussion, however, that WWE doctors discovered that he had a malignant brain tumour. He lived with the tumour for a year before getting surgery to remove it. It took thirty radiation treatments and a long recovery process to rid him of it. All of this after guest trainer Bob Holly controversially roughed him up on worldwide television. Matt did eventually work a programme with Holly in 2004, before his health woes began, but it remains a sore subject among fans who felt that Holly went a little too far with the newbie. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yW6_0H44aQw Cappotelli's WWE contract expired in January 2009. It was not renewed. Since then, Cappotelli has been working in Ohio Valley Wrestling, becoming a trainer in their beginners programme. More recently, however, the deeply-religious 35-year-old has been working as a motivational speaker and manages a couple of gyms. He's doing very well for himself.

6. Jackie Gayda

Jackie Gayda may not have been the most talented person to try out for Tough Enough season two, but her decision to 'gut it out' and continue to train when she suffered a serious knee injury convinced WWE officials that she had what it took to be a WWE diva. Those same officials were probably asking themselves 'what they hell were we thinking?' after Gayda's horrible performance in the infamous tag match in which she teamed with Christopher Nowinski to take on Trish Stratus & Bradshaw on the July 8th 2002 Raw. Jackie botched several moves and generally looked like she had no idea what she was doing (which, to be fair to her, she didn't since she hadn't received the proper/enough training to be in a match like that). She bounced back with her role as Miss Jackie, valet to the effeminate Rico, after a long stint in OVW. Life imitated art when Jackie and Rico's, erm, partner Charlie Haas fell in love. They married in June 2005 but WWE fired them both after just returning from their honeymoon. Since then, Jackie has done some modelling work, had a brief run in TNA, gave birth to four kids (two girls and two boys), opened a nutrition/fitness store with her husband and done the rounds on the convention circuit.

5. Linda Miles

Oh Linda Miles... Miles was co-winner of Tough Enough season two and it's not easy to see why WWE signed her up. She was big, athletic and appeared to be a natural in the ring. Miles debuted on WWE TV as Shaniqua, the dominatrix manager of new tag team the Basham Brothers. Later in the year, she began dominating the rest of Smackdown's divas and brutally beating them down. Miles took a month off in late 2003 after suffering a Clothesline From Hell from Bradshaw, returning with surgically-enhanced breasts (which she claimed had been 'swollen' by Bradshaw's lariat, in a ludicrous angle). It was around this time that Miles was getting a really bad reputation backstage for her prima donna behaviour. How did WWE punish her? By regularly booking her to take a Rikishi stinkface on house shows, of course! This was basically Miles' role for her last few months in the company. Her last appearance was at the 2004 No Way Out PPV. She was released in late 2004 after no-showing several OVW training sessions and house shows. What has the imposing Shaniqua been up to since? First she tried to get a job as a sportscaster and then became a substitute teacher in Cincinnati. It was reported in the Wrestling Observer in March 2014 that Miles was seen on TV at a Division 1 women's college basketball game. Miles had previously tried out for the WNBA but didn't make the cut. She now referees women's basketball games, as shown in the picture below.

4. Andy Leavine

Big Andy has to go down as one of the biggest WWE disappointments in recent memory. Leavine actually signed a developmental contract with WWE in 2010, but was released from it in January 2011 in order to try out and participate in Tough Enough. Leavine was miraculously announced the winner of the competition, despite being one of the back markers early on. Pretty much nobody had Andy pegged as the eventual winner but, sure enough, he defied the odds and won. Leavine was given a Vince McMahon slap and a Stone Cold Stunner on the June 6th 2011 Raw as a welcoming gift to the company. Backstage officials were reportedly furious that Andy didn't sell the two moves for long enough. It didn't really matter, anyway, since he was going back to train in FCW regardless. While training, he failed a Wellness Policy test and was suspended for thirty days. Leavine was released in April 2012, having never wrestled a match for the company. So what's he been doing in the last three years and where is he now? Leavine continued to wrestle, devoting most of his time to the World Wrestling Council in Puerto Rico. Some recent YouTube videos he posted showed him lifting some seriously heavy weight and he looks to be in great shape. Is a WWE return on the cards? Probably not.

3. Nidia

WWE stumbled upon something with Nidia. She wasn't the best wrestler in the world, far from it, but she undoubtedly had a lot of charisma and a certain presence to her. Nidia was the female winner of the first season of Tough Enough, setting the precedent for all those that would come after her. After the requisite spell in OVW, Nidia was given a role on WWE TV as Jamie Nobel's trailer trash girlfriend. Their act was a riot and Nidia looked comfortable in the ring and in backstage skits and promos. She engaged in a memorable feud with Torrie Wilson in 2003, which led to the two divas, Noble and Billy Gunn having a foursome on an episode of Smackdown. Nidia was given another memorable storyline later that year when she was 'blinded' by Tajiri's black mist attack. This led to a feud between Nidia and her exploitative boyfriend, which culminated in a dreadful blindfold match at No Way Out 2004. She was drafted to the Raw brand a couple of months later but didn't do a whole lot before being released on November 3rd during a talent purge. She briefly flirted with the indies, had a kid and dated X-Pac before deciding to pursue a culinary career and is now a full-time chef in her hometown of Houston, Texas. Nidia hasn't severed all her ties with the business, as the picture below from October 2014, showing her with former WWE star Shelton Benjamin, demonstrates.

2. Maven

As far as first winners go, you couldn't pick one better than Maven Huffman. Charismatic, athletic and a quick learner, Maven had a lot of the attributes that make a WWE superstar. Maven was thrown in at the deep end, feuding with The Undertaker, who he famously eliminated from the 2002 Royal Rumble. Maven floundered in the mid-card for the next couple of years before he began feuding with members of Evolution in late 2004. This feud included a Raw main event match against Triple H, which succeeded in making Maven look like a future star. It was frequently rumoured that Maven would be joining the stable but it never happened. Instead, Maven formed an entertaining tag team with fitness guru Simon Dean. When Dean was transferred to Smackdown in spring 2005, WWE saw no use for Maven and released him. Following his release, he worked for some indie promotions, including the TNA-affiliated UWF and also appeared on season six of VH1's The Surreal Life in 2005. He retired from wrestling in 2007. A tumultuous few years followed. Maven had developed a bad drug habit which landed him in trouble with the law in 2012 when he was found 'doctor shopping' (going from doctor to doctor in order to get refills). He subsequently entered WWE-sponsored rehab and managed to clean himself up. Today, Huffman is reconnecting with fans on social media and regularly posts on Twitter and Instagram. He provides commentary and does interviews for Extreme Cage Fighting as well as recently working as a bouncer in New York. You can find him at: https://instagram.com/mavenhuffman/ (he still looks exactly the same and is in really good shape).

1. John Morrison

Of all the Tough Enough winners, none had more potential than John Morrison. He actually failed in his Tough Enough II audition, after Kevin Dunn made it clear that he didn't like him at all, but made it through to Tough Enough III, which he won along with Matt Cappotelli. Following the expected OVW stay, Morrison debuted on the March 1st 2004 Raw as Johnny Blaze. The next week, he was renamed Johnny Spade. Three weeks after that, he was given the moniker Johnny Nitro. Considering the frequent name changes, it was clear that WWE had no idea what to do with him and sent him back to OVW. While in OVW he formed a very entertaining tag team with Joey Mercury. They had a decent run on Smackdown but Nitro was clearly meant to be a singles star. Unfortunately, his and girlfriend Melina's backstage attitudes ensured that it didn't happen, at least for a while. Nitro was rechristened John Morrison and had a very good run in WWE as a mid-to-upper-midcard talent before opting to leave the company in November 2011. The Shaman of Sexy has been busy since leaving McMahonland, working in film and television and wrestling regularly on the independent circuit. Under his newest name, Johnny Mundo, Morrison is one of the stars of the El Rey Network's groundbreaking series Lucha Underground

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...