WWE WrestleMania 32: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best

Shane McMahon gets his wings back.

chris jericho aj styles.jpg
WWE.com

WrestleMania is over for another year, and fan reception has been...mixed to say the least. It was a peculiar show more than anything, exemplifying either how stubborn or out-of-touch with fans the booking team appears to be.

Though there actually weren't many outright bad matches, a number of hyped-up fights didn't quite hit the markers they could have, and had to settle for being TV-quality bouts you wouldn't hope to see at the Granddaddy of Them All.

So, not a WrestleMania for the ages by any means, then, but most fans likely expected this, given the controversy surrounding Roman Reigns' current angle and the litany of roster injuries right now. Even so, it fell a little short of its promise, and feels strangely unimportant for something that's so huge in the industry.

12. The Rock Vs. Erick Rowan

the rock eric rowan.jpg
WWE.com

Result: The Rock nails Rowan with the Rock Bottom...and that's the entire match (0:06).

Rating: The match itself was totally inconsequential compared to everything around it: The Rock finally came out almost 4 hours into the show to announce the 101,763 attendance record, before the Wyatts interrupted.

The Rock of course had his wrestling gear on underneath his clothes and had the impromptu "match", after which the Wyatts attempted to attack him and he was saved by a returning John Cena.

An entertaining if overlong segment on the whole, but the match itself didn't even touch the sides, so it can't really score more than a default 1/10


11. The Usos Vs. The Dudley Boyz

Dudleyz Usos WrestleMania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Jimmy lands a super-kick to D-Von for the easy win (5:18)

Rating: Even for the standards of a pre-show match this was super low-effort, and it didn't help that we've been massively over-exposed to these two teams wrestling lately. Couldn't The Usos have fought someone else, or at least made this into a three or four-team match instead?

It's a glorified TV bout as expected: the crowd weren't really into it at all, and it ended suddenly without much fanfare. The most exciting moment came post-match when The Usos put the Dudleyz through a table each, but even that wasn't enough to get the crowd going much. 4/10


10. 10-Diva Tag: Team Total Divas Vs. Team B.A.D. & Blonde

divas wrestlemania.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Naomi tapped out to Brie's Yes Lock (11:25).

Rating: It's pretty baffling that this match ran longer than either of the other pre-show bouts, and was about as forgettable as you'd expect.

A few nice moments for sure (Natalya and Paige using the Hart Attack for one), and the crowd were white-hot for Brie, but otherwise it felt like a lot of the Divas didn't work well together, and so it just came off as kinda clumsy.

At least it was rightly relegated to the pre-show, though, and you probably won't even remember that the match happened in a few days. 4/10


9. 20-Man Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal

baron corbin wrestlemania.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Baron Corbin throws out Kane for the victory (9:41).

Rating: This was your garden variety Battle Royal and not a single thing more. While it was cool to see DDP show up and hilarious that Shaq made an appearance, it was really just going through the motions like everyone expected, all the more so because winning this match doesn't really mean anything.

At least they gave the victory to an on-the-rise talent who deserves it rather than The Big Show: it's a strong win for Corbin and will give him some bragging rights moving forward. Still, nothing to see here aside from the satisfying result. 5/10


8. U.S. Title: Kalisto (c) Vs. Ryback

ryback kalisto.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Kalisto nails the Salida del Sol for the win (8:58).

Rating: There weren't exactly many fans hyped for this match from the outset, and it aptly lived down to expectations. Kalisto and Ryback aren't at all well-matched here: they have zero chemistry and the fact that the arena was incredibly empty at this point only made it feel even less energetic and exciting.

From a TV perspective, the fact that a commercial break interrupted the match didn't much help (such is the nature of the pre-show), and made it even more difficult to care about what was going on. Everyone knew Kalisto would retain: it was the right call, but an utterly uninteresting title defense for the plucky champ. Not awful, just not good either. 5/10


7. 6-Man Tag: The New Day Vs. The League Of Nations

New Day League Of Nations WrestleMania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Sheamus destroys Xavier with the Brogue Kick for the win (10:03).

Rating: It goes without saying that this match will only be even remotely remembered because of what happened either side of it. Firstly, The New Day's entrance saw them emerge from a giant box of Booty-os while wearing Power Ranger gear, and after the match, The League of Nation were obliterated by Shawn Michaels, Stone Cold and Mick Foley. Rusev's brutal Stunner sell was a particular highlight.

As for the match itself? Glorified TV fare: nothing extraordinary or particularly interesting about it, and it was a strange booking choice to have The New Day lose considering how much momentum they have right now. 5/10


6. AJ Styles Vs. Chris Jericho

aj styles chris jericho.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Jericho pulled the referee in front of him to confuse Styles, then landed the Code Breaker for the win (17:10).

Rating: This one had the potential to be a classic but was actually pretty underwhelming overall, and really just OK. First and foremost, it was clear that it ran way too long at almost 20 minutes: the two had exhausted most of their best spots by half that time, and it just sort of clambered to a fairly dull heel finish.

It was interesting to see Styles lose his first Mania match, which on one hand was disappointing but at least less predictable than a decisive Styles win. Still, nothing hugely memorable here even if it was decent enough. 6/10


5. World Heavyweight Title: Triple H (c) Vs. Roman Reigns

Triple H Roman Reigns WrestleMania 32.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Reigns landed two Superman punches and a Spear to win the title (27:11).

Rating: Fan response going into the match was hugely divided, and that was no different at crunch time, in addition to the audience both at home and in person being massively exhausted by the ridiculous 50-minute overrun.

As such, the crowd were fairly muted for large portions of the match, making it feel like anything but a Mania main event, compounded by the huge pops for Trips' offense and frequent booing of Reigns. Roman's inevitable victory pretty much sucked the air out of the arena and resulted in one of the most underwhelming celebratory finales in recent Mania memory.

On the other hand, at least we got to see Stephanie get speared and another hilariously over-the-top cornball Triple H entrance. But as a main event, this one was a really mediocre affair, as most fans seemed to expect. 6/10


4. No Holds Barred Street Fight: Brock Lesnar Vs. Dean Ambrose

dean ambrose brock lesnar wrestlemania.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Brock nearly kills Ambrose with an F-5 onto a huge pile of chairs to get the pin (13:06).

Rating: Nothing hugely surprising here, but a fun brawl all the same. It pretty much hit all the beats you expected: Brock nailed a ton of suplexes, Ambrose attempted to mount a comeback and made himself look good in the process, but was ultimately destroyed by the Beast.

The most memorable moments include Ambrose trying to literally murder Brock with a chainsaw, Brock botching a suplex onto a pile of chairs and landing on them himself, and the appearance of the barbed wire baseball bat.

What held the match back from being anything more is that it lacked majorly brutal spots, such that Ambrose's defeat just kinda happened when he could've been beaten down much more severely for a few more minutes. If there was any match on the card that could've used some blood, this was it. 6/10


3. I.C. Title Ladder Match: Kevin Owens (c) Vs. Ziggler, Zayn, Ryder, Sin Cara, Stardust & Miz

zack ryder intercontinental.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Just as The Miz was about to grab the title, Zack Ryder came out of nowhere, threw him off and nabbed the strap (15:23).

Rating: This was a white-hot opener and an excellent match to get the crowd going after three sluggish pre-show bouts. Though it followed your typical lazy MITB booking formula, where the match focused on just two or three guys at a time while everyone else "recovered" on the floor, it was full of fun spots and everyone got at least one moment to shine.

Particular props to Sami Zayn for some wonderfully imaginative work with the ladder, and the crowd were rightly devastated when he came close to winning but was foiled by The Miz. Ryder winning was an unexpected and entertaining choice: the guy has been thoroughly mis-used for years and though he'll probably lose the title quickly, it's great that he got his WrestleMania moment. 7/10


2. Hell In A Cell: The Undertaker Vs. Shane McMahon

shane mcmahon the undertaker.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Taker drills Shane with a Tombstone for the win (30:05).

Rating: We all went in expecting this one to be a huge spot-fest with an early break out of the cell and a ton of run-ins, but it was actually a disappointingly ordinary HIAC match for the most part, if still terrifically entertaining to watch.

More than anything, Shane proved that he's still got the guts and athleticism to hang with the roster, memorably turning the Hell's Gate into a Sharpshooter and nailing an awesome Coast-to-Coast. Other fun spots include Shane and Taker going through the side of the cell, Taker dive-bombing into the announce table to break Shane's sleeper hold, and of course, Shane's death-defying dive from the top of the cell, which was surely this Mania's big money moment.

This is perhaps the first time where many fans were actively encouraged to root against Taker, as Shane taking over Raw would've hugely shaken up the product. Instead of all those rumours about Kurt Angle, Stone Cold or the Balor Club showing up to help Shane win, we got a shockingly down-the-line bout that insta-killed a potentially interesting storyline. 

Plus, considering that Shane returned to the WWE and pretty much disparaged the product, what does it say when he loses and has no opportunity to change things up? 7/10


1. Women's Title Triple Threat Match: Charlotte (c) Vs. Sasha Banks Vs. Becky Lynch

becky lynch sasha charlotte.jpg
WWE.com

Result: Charlotte locked the Figure 8 on Becky for the win (16:03).

Rating: Everyone knew this would be a killer match, and disappointing ending aside, it absolutely lived up to the hype. Technical exchanges between all three were sharp for the most part even if it was clear that Becky was basically the third wheel here, though she got her WrestleMania moment by taking out Ric Flair in revenge for his previous interference.

Charlotte also hit a super-slick moonsault that proved she's talented enough not to need lazy heel tactics, even if her victory was annoyingly still the result of her daddy holding Sasha's leg and preventing her from breaking up the Figure 8.

Some really strong work overall here, though having Charlotte win was massively underwhelming, and Ric constantly aiding her victory is so, so boring, especially in a WrestleMania match and one that's ushering in the new Women's Title. 7/10

What did you think of this year's WrestleMania? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.