WWE WrestleMania 38: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
Unwanted title changes, false advertising, flat debuts and more WrestleMania nightmares!
Vince McMahon must bloody hate it when he gets WrestleMania wrong.
The WWE patriarch isn't keen on failure generally (who is?!), but 'Mania is still his pride and joy. It's an annual reminder that everything is rosy in the sports entertainment garden, and it's Vince's chance to shove words like "stupendous" to the forefront of advertising campaigns - how's a fella' supposed to resist that?
Seriously though, this is a big weekend for the company. Last year's cards welcomed fans back, so they were always going to get a pass, but WWE smashed it last time out. Both WrestleMania nights were, for the most part, a rip-roaring success creatively. There's no way McMahon wants 'Mania 38 to be a backwards step.
Apologies in advance to anyone who looks on the brighter side of life too. There's no room for such sickly positivity here. No, this is all about the worst that could happen between 2-3 April. Unwanted title changes, a bit of false advertising from WWE itself, debuts that fall flat and all the nightmare outcomes that'll keep fans awake in the wee hours.
What goes bump in the night? Maybe not Steve Austin...
10. Omos Is Next!
"Omos! You're next!".
Oh God, this is gonna happen isn't it? The rumour mill is teasing a comeback for one Bobby Lashley come 'Mania's opening night. That could happen, mainly because Bob is a freak of nature who may recover from his Elimination Chamber woes in time to score a berth on the biggest show(s) of the year.
Alternatively, WWE might fire out a call to Bill Goldberg and have him come in to tear a giant apart instead. No, Goldberg isn't under contract anymore, but that doesn't mean both parties couldn't reach a short-term agreement to dig creative out of a hole. Besides, they f*cking love a Billy big b*llocks comeback.
The sad truth is that even a huge Goldberg mark like this writer has zero desire to see him slay a promising newcomer like Omos. Similarly, he doesn't want to see Omos squash Bill either. So, in short, WWE shouldn't book the match.
9. Logan Paul Is No Bad Bunny
Last year, rapper Bad Bunny surprised everybody by delivering a silky smooth, professional performance when teaming with Damian Priest. Of course, Priest, The Miz and John Morrison all helped guide the musician through, but Bunny smashed his opportunity.
Over to you, Logan Paul.
The nightmare outcome for WWE here is that LP can't match what the rapping rabbit did in 2021. Miz will be expected to hold his hand during the tag vs. Rey and Dominik Mysterio (and WWE has already added a sub-plot in there surrounding Rey's mask), but Paul will still have to get in there and bump around too.
WWE likely want more than one match from Logan before he returns to his day job(s). If he sh*ts the bed on the grandest stage, then that won't happen. Celebs don't come cheap, so the E will be hoping that Paul is more Bad Bunny at 'Mania 37 than Tyson Fury vs. Braun Strowman at Crown Jewel 2019.
8. Charlotte Flair Taps Ronda Rousey
Ooooooh boy.
Can you imagine the uproar on Twitter if Charlotte Flair locks Ronda Rousey in the Figure Eight and taps her out come WrestleMania? It's not that WWE fans are fiercely protective of Rousey - it's that most believe Flair is over-protected when it comes to crunch title situations.
Realistically, Ronda has to win. The entire story between both women has revolved around Charlotte trying to evade (and latterly come up with a counter punch for) Rousey's feared arm bar submission. If the ex-MMA fighter doesn't pin Flair down and make her squeal like Stephanie McMahon at 'Mania 34, then this match will be considered a wasted chance to humble the 'Queen'.
Also, there are hardly any viable babyfaces waiting in the wings for Charlotte beyond 'Mania. Meanwhile, Rousey would have returning heels like Bayley to work with in the short-to-medium term. It'd suck if Flair left Dallas with the SmackDown Women's Title. If Ronda can't beat her, then who will?
7. Johnny Knoxville = IC Champ
Being honest, the once-proud Intercontinental belt is in the toilet anyway. WWE's crappy booking since Big E dropped it to Apollo Crews at last year's 'Mania has seen to that; follow up champs like Crews and Shinsuke Nakamura tanked, and now Ricochet is the latest to try and make something of IC.
Cue quite the insult?
What if Rico's reign was suddenly ended on the SmackDown before WrestleMania 38? Why? Well, WWE writers may reason that the flyer isn't getting on to either night's card anyway. So, basically, they'd stick the Intercontinental prize back on Sami Zayn and...have Zayn drop it to Johnny Knoxville 48 hours later.
This might sound controversial, but yours truly wouldn't have minded JK winning the IC Title from Sami had Ricochet not been involved. Stripping the title from him without giving Rico a proper chance sounds sucky though. Also, yeah, this writer has flip-flopped on Knoxville as champ several times.
Urgh, this belt's modern lineage is a nightmare.
6. Fans Reject Edge’s Heel Turn
If anyone can pull off this post-retirement heel run, it's Edge.
There are only two major worries hanging over it. One, the sympathetic comeback story Edge has worked since 2020 was so strong that his heel turn caught peeps cold. Two, AJ Styles is hardly an outright babyface himself these days. In fact, ol' AJ hasn't been a face for the longest time.
It's really hard not to root for Edge after everything he's been through. WWE might've done a better job of prepping Styles for this role than they have, because there's a decent chance he hears some boos in Texas next month. That's a bit of a sh*temare for the company - they want Edge to get those jeers instead.
Again though, it's all so sudden. Edge has gone from beloved returnee to dark, twisted and cold. Sure, he showed splashes of that during his run towards 'Mania 37 last year, but this feels different. WWE will be praying that fans in Dallas play ball here.
5. Both Nights Go Too Long
Caffeine warriors, assemble!
The whole point of spreading ‘Mania out over a full weekend was to stop those interminable Sunday night sessions. That's rather pointless if WWE just book back-to-back four-hour pay-per-views over the same weekend, but it wouldn't be out of character for the promotion to do just that.
Vinnie Mac is very much a believer in the "more is more" approach. WWE rarely show restraint or hold anything back, especially during WrestleMania season, and that could mean both Saturday and Sunday feel loooooooong. Plus, it's true that some matches don't really belong on cards this heavily-hyped.
Drew McIntyre vs. Happy Corbin and the Women's Tag-Team Title four-way could be considered prime examples. Both are TV bouts at best, and they'll gobble up extra time across the weekend. Hell, the entrances for that women's match alone could be longer than the bell-to-bell action itself.
4. Vince McMahon Replaces Austin Theory
The ears of casual/lapsed fans worldwide perked up when rumours began circulating that Vince McMahon would be wrestling Pat McAfee at 'Mania. Be honest though - most reading this who did get a little excited were picturing McMahon at the 1999 Royal Rumble. As always, reality bites.
It bites so damn hard.
76-year old Vince is still in cracking physical shape, but...he's 76 and has had his time on screen. It'd be an absolute shame if a young buck (steady) like Austin Theory was replaced on the biggest weekend of the year by his boss. Is it possible? You bet your a*s it is!
McMahon could announce on Raw that he plans to "lead by example" and show an out-of-his-depth Theory how it's done by putting McAfee in his place. Does that sound kinda fun on paper? Sure, but the reality would be sobering and it'd be rubbish if Austin missed out on his first big 'Mania moment.
3. Cody Rhodes’ Debut Falls Flat
Is the 'American Nightmare' about to live a WrestleMania nightmare?
Those "Cody! Cody! Cody!" chants on this past Monday's Raw must be music to WWE's ears. They've got to be careful mind; Seth Rollins is likely to be Cody's first opponent during this bold return spell, and he's hardly a pushover or someone creative will want to trash for the sake of anybody else.
This feels like a lose/lose situation for Rhodes. If he comes in and has a standard, competitive match vs. Seth, then he'll just look like everybody else on the roster and blend in far too quickly. That'd be true even if he wins. Then, there's the other scenario - what if Cody comes in and loses to Rollins?
A loss like that would kill his momentum immediately, and negate any big reaction for him 24 hours later on the typically boisterous post-WrestleMania Raw. Squashing Seth doesn't seem like something WWE would be up for, so there's a chance Rhodes' re-debut could fall flat.
2. WWE Flunk On “Winner Takes All”
Some fans believe that either Brock Lesnar or Roman Reigns winning both World Championships at 'Mania 38 will bring about the end of WWE's latest brand split. The "ironclad rosters" on both shows are useless anyway, 'cause wrestlers work where they want willy nilly and without much need for explanation.
WWE painted themselves into a corner by announcing a "Winner Takes All" stip for the battle too. That, to literally everyone, means that Lesnar is taking Roman's Universal Strap and keeping his, or Reigns is grabbing Brock's WWE Title and holding both major prizes.
Would anyone really be shocked if the E got cold feet here?
It's not impossible for the company to pretend that this was just 'Champ vs. Champ' (like Hulk Hogan vs. The Ultimate Warrior back at 'Mania VI) all along. They could also change the "Winner Takes All" thing right before next weekend's pay-per-view and keep both titles exactly where they are.
Would that blow? Absolutely.
1. Steve Austin’s Return Is Hype For Saudi Arabia
'Stone Cold' went from definitely/maybe having a match at WrestleMania 38 to appearing in a talk show skit opposite Kevin Owens. This isn't meant as a dig at KO, but he never felt like the right man for Steve Austin's return match. Who is? Who knows, but Owens was a curious choice.
Austin holds all the power here, and he'll be aware of that. WWE are clearly desperate to get a match or two out of him in 2022, and that means the legend can ask for whatever he likes. Y'know what crossed this writer's mind as a horror outcome? That 'Mania 38 and this 'KO Show' bit is mere hype for the next Saudi Arabian stadium show.
Sorry for that painful thought.
Many will say, 'No chance! Austin wouldn't do that!". Did anybody think Shawn Michaels would give in to the power of moolah and return for that car crash tag with Triple H vs. The Undertaker and Kane though? Nah, they didn't. Money talks.
What other WrestleMania 38 nightmares do you have? For more like this, check out 10 Scott Hall Moments Wrestling Fans Will Never Forget and WWE 2K22: 10 Things You NEED To Do First!