WWE WrestleMania 40: 20 Things That Must Happen

Cody Rhodes finishes his story, WWE sets up The Rock's next blockbuster; more WrestleMania madness!

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Cody Rhodes
WWE

There's been a palpable sense of wonder and magic in the air during this sensational WrestleMania season.

The Rock's return added a sense of danger, Cody Rhodes has sustained as WWE's go to hero for the masses, Roman Reigns looks ready to relinquish his title(s), and that's just for starters. Linked Seth Rollins injury panic, CM Punk injury misery and Drew McIntyre heel turn goodness has all been box office too.

Sure, a few of the matches Triple H has on tap across two nights in Philly do smack of trying to squeeze as many workers in front of the pay window as possible, but there's enough meat on the bone for both cards to shine regardless. People are expecting big things from 'Mania XL though - it's extra large for a reason!

Last year, WWE arguably fumbled the ball for some. In hindsight, they didn't, but fans will be demanding certain results this time. The rest of 2024 could depend on it, but so could next year's 'Mania 41. That's something Trips will have one eye on.

Here's absolutely everything that simply must happen this weekend.

20. Sami Zayn Ends GUNTHER’s Run

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL GUNTHER Sami Zayn
WWE.com

How's this for a kick off?!

GUNTHER has been a record-breaking success story as Intercontinental Champ. The burly Austrian has deservedly etched his name into WWE history books, but now it's time for him to let someone else lug that secondary strap around. Who better for that spot than one Sami Zayn?

The beloved babyface shone as an unlikely member of The Bloodline, and he's worked cracking bouts at back-to-back WrestleManias; one against Johnny Knoxville, and one alongside Kevin Owens vs. The Usos. Now, Sami can grab IC gold and furnish that title's legacy with another memorable moment to sit alongside the likes of Steamboat vs. Savage in 1987, or GUNTHER's own heroics opposite Drew McIntyre and Sheamus.

Chad Gable was surely considered for this spot, but Sami feels worthy. He's exactly the kind of cherished baby fans would accept as a GUNTHER-conquerer. For some, this is defo preferable to the scrapped Brock Lesnar clash that ended before it got started on TV.


19. Santos Escobar Pins Rey Mysterio

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Rey Mysterio Dragon Lee Santos Escobar Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Being brutally honest, this is one of 'Mania weekend's weakest bouts. Santos Escobar vs. Rey Mysterio seemed likely one-one-one, but WWE shot that load on SmackDown during Rey Rey's return. So, they've drafted in Dragon Lee and Dominik Mysterio to pad things out and hope for the best on the undercard.

There's no point in denying it - this could be a bit of a struggle.

Creative can still point to progress if Escobar scores a pin over his old mentor and they manage to make both Lee look good and script more father vs. son stuff between Rey and Dom too. The most important thing is Santos coming out looking like a bigger star than he was going in though. If not, then why even book this in the first place?

Nobody in the match needs this win more than Legado del Fantasma's leader. Lose, and he'll be right back where he started before leaving the LWO. Triumph, and he might just become WWE's next main event player yet. Fingers crossed, eh?


18. Jade Cargill Scores A Debut Pin

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Jade Cargill Bianca Belair Naomi Dakota Kai Asuka Kairi Sane Damage CTRL
WWE.com

Putting Jade Cargill in a match this busy was a shrewd move from Papa H. He knows how special the ex-AEW star will be in the future, but there's no need to make Jade run before she can walk. Don't forget how raw she still was towards the end as an All Eliter; Cargill is ironing out kinks at the Performance Center for a reason.

She's a megastar in waiting mind.

It'd make perfect sense if Jade was handed the pin in this six-woman tag. Better yet, it really doesn't matter if she gets the three on Asuka, Kairi Sane or Dakota Kai. The most important thing is that she gets her hand raised for the babyface squad, and that Damage CTRL has a new headache to worry about other than Bayley or Bianca Belair.

Of course, the post-match stuff is where WWE would lay the groundwork for Jade's next bumper encounter. A match or two on the road with Asuka would be enough to help prep Cargill for that. Oh yes, "That Bitch" has come a long, long way since the old TBS Title days on Dynamite and Rampage.


17. There’s Tension With Bianca Belair

Bianca Belair Jade Cargill Naomi
WWE.com

Has anyone else kinda given up on lobbying for a Bianca Belair heel turn? It really looked like the writers fancied going down that path before, but then they got cold feet and Bianca has been stuck in a mini-rut ever since. Thank God for her hard work and talent, because some could've started sinking with this kind of indecision from those calling the shots.

The good news is that WWE has a natural showdown on ice. Bianca vs. Jade Cargill is one of those clashes made for the humble event poster. Aesthetically, it's mega-athlete vs. mega-athlete, and almost has a superhero vs. superhero vibe to it as well. That's something most fans can get firmly behind, so why not lay the foundations?

A bit of tension between both women during and after the six-woman tag would do the trick. Belair might be a tad p*ssed that the debuting Cargill stole the spotlight at 'Mania, and Naomi would be in the middle trying to play peacemaker.

Let's get this alpha female show on the road.


16. Judgment Day Drop The Tag Straps

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Ladder Match
WWE.com

It's time for this to happen.

Damian Priest's Money In The Bank future is questionable, but one thing's for sure: Judgment Day don't need the Undisputed Tag-Team straps any longer. WWE has options in this ladder brawl. The Miz and R-Truth would be a sympathetic legacy win, but Austin Theory and Grayson Waller are crying out for some focus to give them weekly direction.

Then, there's a fresh team like Tyler Bate and Pete Dunne. The New Catch Republic boys are already a better duo than Dunne (or erm...Butch) and Ridge Holland ever were, and it's surely inevitable that they'll enjoy a run with the belts someday. Will it come at 'Mania? Don't rule that out.

Personally, this writer would pick Theory and Waller to get the nod. They've worked diligently on scraps for a while now, and both deserve to make something of this union before an eventual split and possible Austin babyface attempt. Stick the straps on them!


15. Jey Uso Wins The Sibling Scuffle

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Jey Jimmy Uso
WWE.com

Regrettably, this family showdown has been squashed beneath other more important Bloodline matters like The Rock's return or Roman Reigns fending off Cody Rhodes a second time. WWE's tepid build towards Jimmy vs. Jey has exemplified just how old hat some of the stable's offshoot stories are now.

That sucks, but it's just the way it is.

The Usos are unlikely to top brotherly brilliance like Bret vs. Owen Hart from WrestleMania X, but they can do better than Matt vs. Jeff Hardy from 'Mania XXV. That was a letdown, so everyone watching will be hoping Jimmy and Jey don't suffer the same fate. Jey's fledgling permanent headline dreams hinge on this kind of bout.

Jimmy is more of a functional background player these days, meaning he'll be fine no matter how this one shakes out. Solo Sikoa getting involved and Jey grabbing a crowd-popping win on the undercard sounds like the best play from WWE here.


14. Rhea Ripley Proves She’s ‘The Man’

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Rhea Ripley Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Rhea Ripley has been Women's World Champion for a full year now, but memorable title defences on TV and PLE have been few and far between for 'Mami'. On the whole, she's been more of a non-wrestling character during Judgment Day's rise, but this is a big time collision with Becky Lynch for sure.

It's a big time collision Rhea must survive.

Look, Becky has a book to promote and is obviously one of the best female stars in company history. She probs has a few more title runs in her, but Lynch definitely doesn't need the title as much as Ripley these days. Giving Rhea a 'Mania win over someone who made history by headlining the card in 2019 could be massive for her.

In short, Ripley shouldn't be torn down and passed over just so WWE has the excuse to book another pyro-laden title change. She's the future of women's wrestling, not 'The Man'. Beating Becky would show off Triple H's faith in Rhea going forwards into the rest of 2024.


13. Drew McIntyre Costs Seth Rollins

drew mcintyre seth rollins raw
WWE.com

Night 1's truly tasty business is about to be examined, so strap yourselves in.

"Strap" is the operative word here too, because Seth Rollins' World Heavyweight Championship is a belt freshly turned heel Drew McIntyre has become obsessed with. That obsession is grounded in reality too. Drew won the WWE Title at 'Mania 36 in 2020, but the global pandemic robbed him of a title run in front of crowds.

WrestleMania 40 weekend is his chance to put that right, and the maniacal Scot should stop at nothing to get one over on his rival ahead of their clash on night 2. That's why McIntyre must rush out during the opening night's blockbuster tag scrap and blast Seth with his own belt for a laugh.

Rollins has Cody Rhodes' back and is warring with The Bloodline too, but his main quest line falls elsewhere. Matches vs. Drew and (eventually) CM Punk mean more to him, so it's vital WWE don't lose sight of what Seth is actually there to do in Philly.


12. The Rock Gets The Fall For His Team

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL The Rock Roman Reigns Bloodline Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The Rock's cutting remarks, violent behaviour and killer promos have been a breath of fresh air for WWE's product. Some are even proudly proclaiming that the 'Attitude Era' is back. Not quite, but Rocky's actions do stand out next to most company fare over the past few years. There's no denying that.

Initially, eyes would've rolled had Rock pinning either Cody Rhodes or Seth Rollins been pitched for this year's 'Mania. Here's the truth: Dwayne shouldn't beat Cody during the Bloodline vs. Babyface tag effort. No, he should crack Seth with a People's Elbow/Rock Bottom following Drew's interference instead.

Rhodes must be protected at all costs. That's crucial.

Rollins would have an out due to McIntyre's run-in anyway, and Rock getting the win for he and Roman could be useful later on once WWE pulls the trigger on that particular head-to-head. The Rock snagging the pin and ensuring 'Bloodline Rules' 24 hours later sounds logical.


11. Night 1 Ends With Bloody Babyfaces!

WWE Raw Cody Rhodes The Rock
WWE

Bloodline rules.

Rock cracking Cody wide open on Raw got a lot of people talking recently. It was quite the closing segment for WWE's flagship show, and proved that blood does still have a place on the product when used properly and sparingly. Ignore the latter word for now though, 'cause it'll be needed again come the final minutes of Saturday night.

Picture the scene: The Rock has pinned Seth Rollins, Drew McIntyre is grinning from ear-to-ear, Roman Reigns is content and the babyfaces have been devastated. Satisfied? Nah, The Bloodline wouldn't be close. Sensing opportunity, Rock, Reigns and maybe even McIntyre would bloody up the top heroes and send a message.

What a parting shot for WrestleMania 40's kick off night that'd be - Cody and Seth annihilated and swimming in a sea of their own claret as the show goes off the air and Michael Cole screams about vengeance 24 hours later. Blood, blood, gallons of the stuff.

This feud merits it.


10. A Grudge Match Kicks Off Night 2

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL LA Knight AJ Styles
WWE.com

What opens 'Mania 40's first night is up for debate, but there should be no squabble over the blowoff card. Philly would come unglued if LA Knight's catchy entrance track blasted out to get things started, and there'd be a big fight feel in the air as AJ Styles came out to go nose-to-nose with his hated rival.

That'd get things going the right way, and continue the same heated atmosphere as the bloody closing visual 24 hours before. Saying that, LA vs. AJ doesn't need the red stuff to make it worthwhile. It has to be more of a brawl than a straight up chain wrestling exhibition though.

These guys have been flying to Australia and invading one another's homes to fight, after all.

It'd be wise to put Knight vs. Styles on as early as possible and bring the thunder so night 2 matches night 1's intensity. Besides, AJ has shown he can open 'Mania well in the past. Dude squeezed a winner out of Shane McMahon, y'know.


9. LA Knight Beats AJ Styles

LA Knight
WWE.com

This weekend is huge for LA Knight.

Like Rhea Ripley over Becky Lynch, he inarguably needs the win more than his opponent AJ Styles. Despite getting into the shape of his life lately, AJ just doesn't have to win this match. In fact, it'd be for the best if he put Knight over and helped push LA up the ladder towards title belts yet again.

Stay tuned for more on this to come, but Knight is presumably going to be someone's foe in the US Title hunt soon-ish. If that's going to be the case over the summer, then he should beat Styles, grab a nearby microphone and say something simple like: 'It's time for LA Knight to hold some shiny gold. YEAH!'.

Philadelphia would "YEAH" along with the guy, and it'd become clear that WWE wasn't finished with his unexpected breakout babyface push quite yet. Don't worry about AJ. He'll be absolutely fine, and can bounce into another 'B' tier story soon enough.


8. Logan Paul Retains Via Miscommunication

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Kevin Owens Randy Orton Logan Paul
WWE.com

Yeah, yeah the build towards this Triple Threat has tanked harder than the prices on bottles of PRIME. Logan Paul remains an excellent addition to the roster and the right choice as United States Champion though, which is why he should clutch that gold for dear life and leave Philly with it on Sunday evening.

Some good ol' fashioned miscommunication can save his skin.

There hasn't actually been much of that between Kevin Owens and Randy Orton. They've been getting along great guns (that hasn't done much for the saggy build either), and even worked as tag-team partners on TV. 'Mania's pressure pot should bring everything to a head. Only one man can leave with the title, basically.

Maybe KO can screw over Randy after Orton lands an RKO on Paul, but then have his own pin attempt broken up. The fans would come up for Owens and Orton having a back and forth fist fight to make 2K24 owners proud, then LP can sneak his way to victory.


7. Final Testament Wreck The Pride

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Final Testament The Pride
WWE.com

Here's another of WrestleMania 40's least-impressive showings.

Perhaps that's unfair before everyone has a chance to work, but it's certainly lacklustre on paper. The Pride, comprised of leader Bobby Lashley and The Street Profits, awkwardly flipped from would-be heels to the faces of the piece, and The Final Testament (a vehicle for Karrion Kross) has yet to click into gear too.

Sunday could be Karrion's time to shine. Triple H has elected to cut to the chase and turn this into a "Philadelphia Street Fight", so expect weapons and carnage aplenty. That'll be especially interesting if the main event follows suit under "Bloodline Rules", but some chairs and tables here could whet everyone's appetites for more.

Testament should go over with a Kross pin on...well, literally anyone on the babyface side. It honestly doesn't matter if he pins Lashley, Montez Ford or Angelo Dawkins. The most important thing about this match is that it's an entertaining distraction and gets Karrion's faction moving the right way on TV.


6. Bayley Gets Revenge On IYO SKY

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL IYO SKY Bayley
WWE.com

IYO SKY is some worker between the ropes, but she's pretty limited as a character elsewhere. That wasn't as much of a problem when Bayley was there to do most of Damage CTRL's talking, but now IYO is the group's leader and more change is coming. 'Mania XL is Bayley's moment, not SKY's.

She had that by winning the Women's Title in the first place.

A strict one-on-one showdown between the woman who started CTRL and the woman who led a mutiny should rock. Bayley's exit from the faction, and her on/off friendship with former protege Dakota Kai, has been a hoot to witness on telly, but now it's time for reborn baby Bayley to seize the day and become SmackDown's top female star.

Her win will mean even more if Becky Lynch fails to get the job done against Rhea Ripley. In effect, Bayley would enjoy the biggest women's wrestling moment on the largest weekend of the year. She really, really deserves that. Go for it, WWE.


5. Drew McIntyre Wins The World Title

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Seth Rollins Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WWE announcing that Clash At The Castle II will come to Glasgow, Scotland this June ahead of 'Mania surely gives the game away on their plans. Home country hero Drew McIntyre strutting into The Hydro on PLE with the World Heavyweight Title is a lay up for Triple H, and the boss definitely knows it.

Seth Rollins, your reign is coming to an end. Thanks for holding that belt with distinction, sir.

It's unreal how things pan out when you stop to think about it. CM Punk was being lined up to supplant Rollins at 'Mania, but his injury forced a change of plans. Thankfully, Seth's injury didn't rule him out too, which means Drew can beat the champ without running some sort of bullsh*t "Interim Champ" nonsense (looking at you, AEW!).

In storyline, Drew has been reinvigorated as a heel. In reality, the Scot craves winning a World Title in front of actual fans. This title run would be special to him personally, and he must get to finally live it by hitting a Claymore Kick that puts Rollins down for good.


4. CM Punk's Involvement Is Minimal

CM Punk
WWE

Let's not forget that CM Punk will be around ringside on guest commentary for the World Title clash. WWE toyed with the idea of making him special guest referee for the match, but eventually decided against that. That's great, 'cause it means Punk's involvement in proceedings should be fairly minimal.

He is getting involved though, let's be frank about that straight away. There's no chance Punk camps out on comms and ends his night without incident. Maybe he'll be the one to cost Seth his gold, or perhaps Punk will eat a (gentle) bump from McIntyre to set something up between them for the summer once he's healthy post-surgery.

Options, options, options.

This writer would keep Punk out of it for as long as possible. He definitely doesn't need to be the deciding factor, and it's fair to say he has beef with both guys in the match anyway. One moment is all the trio needs to line up amazing bouts once Punk has healed up.


3. “Bloodline Rules” Is Wall-To-Wall Chaos

John Cena Steve Austin
WWE

You were likely wondering when these legends would show up.

WWE knew exactly what they were doing by showing off promo pics of Steve Austin and John Cena during that stunning bloodbath angle between The Rock and Cody Rhodes from Raw. Both guys were splashed all over some production trucks in the background, and that led some online to figure they'll show up in Philly.

A big, fat "Hell Yeah" to that. If Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes is going to be held under "Bloodline Rules" anyway, then that means The Rock, Jimmy Uso and Solo Sikoa will poke their noses in. Furious about their tyranny, cameo artists like Austin and Cena could march out to even the odds and send the fans loopy.

Carnage is essential in this kind of setting. Roman vs. Cody II is obviously a sequel too, so it needs to be different to the original. That was more of a straight up pro wrestling match. This should be a "sports entertainment" riot, one complete with 'Stone Cold' and 'Super Cena' influence.


2. Cody Rhodes Finishes His Story

WWE WrestleMania 40 XL Roman Reigns Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Getting déjà vu?

Last year, pretty much everybody and their dog thought Cody Rhodes would "finish his story" by winning the Undisputed WWE Universal Title(s) from Roman Reigns. It didn't happen, and some folks are still hot about it. 2024 feels different though - it feels like WWE has to give Cody his flowers in Philadelphia this time.

Reigns has been running low on steam as champ for a good while now. It's clear that creative has run out of ways to prolong his tenure as main man, and The Rock's arrival has only diluted his importance to the weekly cause further. Rhodes beating Roman and hoisting that gold above his head as the tears and confetti fall would be one of the best WrestleMania moments ever.

Cody has also shown he's sustainable as a babyface hero, which isn't always a given in the modern era. People haven't turned on him yet. They might when he's actually champ, but that's no reason to cancel his best career triumph.

WWE's 'American Nightmare' must live the 'American Dream'


1. The Rock & Roman Reigns Share A “Look”

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Roman would be crestfallen as he realised his ironclad grip on the top title(s) had loosened. The 'Tribal Chief' would be beside himself with grief, but then that'd turn to anger. At one point, seeing him temporarily snap and blame The Rock for everything would be fun. Think Bobby Heenan and Andre The Giant back at 'Mania VI, but sans slap.

Rocky wouldn't take kindly to being blamed. After all, he'd moved mountains to make "Bloodline Rules" a reality, and he'd even willingly acknowledged Reigns as his 'Chief' in front of the world. One bit of chewing out from Roman and a frosty glare between both men would be more than enough to tease fans with more come the following night's Raw.

WrestleMania 40 going off air with blood brothers at loggerheads and Cody celebrating his win would be class. Suddenly, WWE's top line mix would have a fresh feel on both Raw and SmackDown, and a blockbuster clash between Rock and Roman would be waiting in the pipeline for next year.

That's some multi-layered 'Mania worthy drama right there.

What else do you think must happen at WWE WrestleMania 40? For more wrestling, check out 10 Risks That Could’ve KILLED WWE Careers and WWE 2K24: 15 AEW CAWs You Must Download! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.