3 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (29 December - Results & Review)
Punk, Breakker do the hard sell for next week, Usos overcome themselves, Dupri outshines Theory.
Just in case anyone was tempted to write/utter/think that nothing of consequence happens on WWE programming during the holidays, Raw closed out 2025 with a title change that sent fans home happy. But Raw this week faced the dual challenge of overcoming the holiday doldrums and the reality that next week’s loaded Netflix one-year anniversary show is effectively the season premiere. That left Raw flat at times and somewhat inconsequential, despite the title switch.
WWE continues to insist that Austin Theory is more than “a guy,” and the evidence just isn’t there. Meanwhile, Maxxine Dupri showed more charisma in one promo than Theory has in three years.
CM Punk and Bron Breakker delivered a solid go-home promo for their World Heavyweight Championship match next week, despite both men already having put in the work in previous efforts. The women’s tag title match, however, had a basic, boilerplate promotion segment that did little to enhance that rivalry.
And then there was the title change, with the Usos becoming nine-time Tag Team Champions in a match that was “meh” for the first two-thirds and heated up in the closing act. Evaluating the title switch itself is a bit more difficult: they needed to win to advance the redemption (and eventual falling out) angle, but what does it say about AJ Styles and Dragon Lee that they lost to wrestlers who have been scuffling and doubting themselves for months? The jury is still out on this one.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
4. An Empty Go-Home Segment
The Women’s Tag Team Championship match on next week’s Raw has a floor of “very good,” with a ceiling of “show-stealer.” However, the drama between Rhea Ripley and Iyo Sky and the Kabuki Warriors has been less than enthralling the entire rivalry. WWE has been laying it on thick when it comes to the relationship between “Rhiyo,” and Monday was no different.
The Kabuki Warriors cut a rare in-ring promo that only excelled when Asuka started yelling in Japanese. Her “Kairi!” routine didn’t quite have the same effect in the arena as it does in the backstage segments. Rhea and Iyo then charged the ring for a brawl that saw Ripley facing a two-on-one assault before Sky recovered and they dispatched the Warriors.
This wasn’t a bad segment, but it was just empty calories. Nothing new was said, and there was no escalation of the rivalry. It simply existed to remind you that the four of them are wrestling next week in a high-profile match. A 90-second video package could have done a better job of hyping the match.
3. A Perplexing End To Vaquer’s 2025
For much of 2025, Stephanie Vaquer seemed to be on the constant ascent. She captured accolades and titles while wowing WWE fans with her in-ring action, en route to a surprising Women’s World Championship victory this autumn. However, her close to the year has been less than stellar.
Vaquer has been mired in an ongoing feud with Nikki Bella and Raquel Rodriguez, and while there have been some good moments, there has been a noticeable drop-off in in-ring quality and a bit of a loss of her luster.
Monday’s triple threat between the women had some good moments – Bella locking in an STF and drawing a “Thank You, Cena” chant that she rebuffed with “No, thank me!” was fantastic – but several of the spots were incredibly contrived, including Nikki having to wait an eternity to charge Vaquer on the floor so Rodriguez could get into position. The Tower of Doom spot – which always looks contrived anyway – looked terrible here, with Stephanie basically climbing right into a superplex and launching herself off the top rope.
The match, though, was overly long and had a bizarre ending, with Raquel dropping Bella with a Tejana Bomb and Vaquer – the babyface champion – tossing heel Rodriguez out of the ring and pinning heel Nikki, or in WWE parlance, when a heel does it, “stealing the pin.”
If the goal was to put sympathy on Rodriguez, there were other ways to do that without making La Primera look like every WWE sneaky heel.
2. Middling Action Precedes A Hot Finish
Ah, the WWE 2025 main event formula: a 15-20-minute match that is three-quarters filler and one-quarter killer.
The Usos versus Dragon Lee and AJ Styles might get some rave reviews for its closing moments, which objectively contained some heart-pounding action, but that hot finish was preceded by a mostly dismissible, sometimes clumsy first 15 minutes that just filled space and time. They could have hacked 8-10 minutes off the match and had a really fun, energetic sprint that would have captured fans’ attention throughout.
Instead, the crowd was quiet for good sections of the first 12-15 minutes before things really picked up. Credit has to go to the now-former Tag Team Champs, who controlled the pace and gave the Usos their first “good” match since re-forming as a tag team.
It’s the same issue across a great deal of today’s wrestling: a belief that main events or even just “epic” matches need to be a certain length. This and the opening match could have lost seven minutes each, and they could have thrown a fifth match out there with entrances using that time.
1. Theory Just Ain’t It
At least Austin Theory ditched the Shield-adjacent combat pants with the unfortunate coloring.
CM Punk deserves an up for interrupting Theory during the opening segment on Raw, because Austin was in the middle of another bland, cue card-reading promo when “Cult of Personality” hit. One would think that spending months off television would have afforded Austin the opportunity to work on emoting and delivering his lines with conviction, but apparently not.
In the ring against Rey Mysterio later, Theory was his usual competent self, and that’s not a knock against him, but nothing he does is memorable. Quick, name something he did in that match other than his rolling dropkick attempt. It was just a basic match that ended in a DQ when Logan Paul interfered. Penta returning to make the save was the only true positive.
Austin Theory is the most “factory settings” guy on the roster. He’d be right at home in that mid-2000s group of Johnny Ace-endorsed, flavorless warm bodies.
It’s not that Theory is bad, but Paul Heyman lumping him in as a future WrestleMania main-eventer just screams the same mistake Vince McMahon made in pushing him a few years ago, and the only thing that’s really changed is his haircut.
To paraphrase Mean Girls, “Stop trying to make Theory happen.”
UPS…
3. Gunther Vanquishes Cena’s Biggest Fan
In a parallel universe, R-Truth never returned to being a clown after his mini-feud with John Cena this summer and remained a semi-serious midcarder who was overjoyed to see his “childhood hero” return to his babyface ways before retiring.
Regardless, Truth absolutely was the right person for Gunther to maul on Monday night. With Raw effectively in a bit of limbo during the holidays before ramping back up with the Netflix one-year anniversary next week, this was a perfect opportunity to sacrifice Truth to the Ring General while trying to defend Cena’s honor. Goof or not, Truth is a beloved character to many WWE fans, and they were going to rain down boos on Gunther for demolishing him.
In a great touch, Gunther mocked Cena’s “You can’t see me” taunt, only for Truth to launch into Cena’s patented shoulder tackles… and then immediately get his head kicked off and powerbombed. Gunther even picked Truth up at two and then elbowed him down before tapping him out with the sleeper.
Good stuff here, but WWE should not try to replicate this with someone like Akira Tozawa. At this point, WWE might want to consider having legends un-retire, just so Gunther can immediately send them back out to pasture.
Either way, a good, economical use of time here, and credit to WWE for not having Gunther sell much before squashing Truth.
2. Maxxine Has Confidence On The Mic
In contrast to Austin Theory’s bland line-reading promo earlier on Raw, observe Maxxine Dupri, who sounded natural and confident as she talked to the fans Monday night and then went toe-to-toe with Becky Lynch.
The Man confronted Dupri and verbally sparred with the audience (“The only thing I tapped out to was living in Orlando!” “Don’t boo because I left. Cheer because you had me!” “Let me be an inspiration to you – if you become rich and famous, you can move out of here one day too.”)
Maxxine wasn’t impressed by Becky’s shtick and warned her to choose her next moves carefully, threatening to break her ankle. When Lynch said Dupri stole the Women’s Intercontinental Championship from her, Maxxine wasted no time in pointing out that the only thing she stole was the spotlight… and then she appropriated Becky’s affection for referencing Sports Illustrated.
Becky got some verbal licks in before the segment ended, but Dupri was solid here, sparring with Lynch, interrupting her, and feeling comfortable on the mic. It really would be so much better if she suddenly started absorbing in-ring talent through osmosis from The Man, but she deserves credit for Monday’s performance.
1. Punk, Breakker Do The Hard Sell
By all accounts, CM Punk and Bron Breakker had already put in the hard work and talked people in the door for their World Heavyweight Championship match next week before Monday’s Raw began. Anything additional this week would just be gravy.
Opening Raw with an in-ring promo, Breakker started out a little wobbly talking about his Vision stablemates before dialing in and venting his frustration at people saying he’s “the future” and will one day figure things out; Bron viewed himself as “the now.” He challenged Punk to find anyone in the back who could do what he could with less experience and who was more committed than he was.
While some viewed his family lineage as an advantage, Breakker observed that his familial ties put him under the microscope more than anyone else. He closed by noting that both of them were willing to die for the world title – and Bron was willing to let Punk do just that.
Punk didn’t have to say as much to rattle the younger Breakker, simply noting that he wasn’t ready to let the World Title go or stop being a champion for the sold-out arenas they visit. He dared Bron to try picking up the title, but it’s heavier than it looks. Someday, someone will beat Punk for the title, but it wouldn’t be Breakker.
Their individual efforts leading up to this face-to-face were stronger, but both men delivered well enough here to make their World Heavyweight Championship match feel like a can’t-miss affair. Breakker is best when he has a chip on his shoulder and is more economical with his words; this could have done without his rundown of his Vision compadres. Overall, though, Bron did well when venting about being “the now” and threatening violence next week.
Punk, as the old gunslinger, didn’t need to match that intensity; he needed to cast doubt in Breakker’s mind. Simply telling Bron that he wasn’t ready to let go of the title while simultaneously warning the challenger of the burdens that come with being champion was enough to make him think twice. Punk wasn’t going to out-rage Bron, but he could nullify that aggression with just a hint of doubt. Mission accomplished.