4 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (5 Dec - Results & Review)

Cody Rhodes takes matters into his own hands; Gunther gets John Cena's last match.

Gunther WWE
WWE.com

Gunther is vowing to make John Cena tap out next weekend during the legend's final match at Saturday Night's Main Event. The 'Ring General' won WWE's 'Last Time Is Now' tournament to secure his spot opposite JC on 13 December in Washington, and he did it in typically excellent fashion. Few are better at working the 'push/pull' dynamic Gunther does during matches.

One minute, he's dominant and physically overwhelming foes. The next, the Austrian is backpedaling like he's slipping on ice as babyfaces start to fire back against his attacks like they're Hulk Hogan in his prime. It's a nice mix, and combining that with LA Knight's willingness to sell then "Hulk up" when it counted made for a hot main event on Friday night.

It'd be easy to call SmackDown a one match show, but that'd be unfair. A United States Title 'Open Challenge' bout was bags of fun too, and there's more where that came from thanks to upcoming challenges from Tommaso Ciampa and (eventually) Tama Tonga.

Sadly, things aren't going so well in the women's division or on the undercard elsewhere. Jade Cargill badly needs something better to do, Giulia is totally lost in the shuffle, the duo of B-FAB and Michin are boring everyone to tears, and the ongoing MFT vs. Wyatt Sicks battle is flagging.

Fans should expect plenty more episodes like this one throughout December, especially once the Cena retirement stuff is all said and done. Thankfully, at least the roster depth means you're guaranteed some cracking matches for your time.

Here's all the yay and nay from SmackDown.


Downs...

2. So This Feud Is Gonna Be A Chore

Solo Sikoa MFT Uncle Howdy The Wyatt Sicks
WWE.com

Anyone who reads this article regularly already knows that the dude writing it has a tough time getting onboard with The Wyatt Sicks. The fact they're a tribute act in memory of Bray is awesome, but that's where the praise stops. Personally, this fan didn't like Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis winning the tag titles, and he doesn't like the way The Sicks managed to swoop in and seize control in an otherwise hot SmackDown doubles division.

Solo Sikoa's MFT group have slightly more potential, but this feud between both sides is already sucking wind. MFTs want the tag belts, and they want revenge for The Sicks attacking them last week following the traditional Survivor Series elimination bout. Here, Erick Rowan and Talla Tonga going nose to nose was fun, but there isn’t much to look forward to from this rivalry overall.

Said it before, and it’s worth saying again: The quicker Sikoa’s crew take the straps from The Sicks, the better. Surely others are over Uncle Howdy and pals by this point? It's just the same thing over and over and over again with them, and that's unlikely to change heading into 2026. It's dull. Genuinely dull.

There are only so many staredown spots one group can work, and there are only so many poetic/cryptic promos one fanbase can listen to before something has to change. This isn't character development, and it says everything that The Wyatts could be about to hold MFTs back. Think about that for a second!

Please, please, please burn through this ASAP.


1. Wasn’t Feeling This Squash

Jade Cargill Alba Fyre
WWE.com

Jade Cargill ran straight through Alba Fyre in 90 seconds or so. That's it - that was the match.

Look, on the surface there's nothing especially wrong with a physical marvel like Jade mowing through challengers like she's paid for a bodycount. There really isn't, but how long does it go on for? This whole thing feels backwards, to be honest. Cargill should probably be past this sort of thing by now, and she should certainly be telling B-FAB and Michin to jog on.

That duo's skit with Jade backstage had already been done to death. Seriously, what did any of these women say that was different from last time? FAB is still acting like she'd intimidated by Cargill's mere presence, Michin is writing checks with her mouth she won't be able to cash inside the ring, and Jade is repeating the same 'step up and get stepped on' lines.

Chelsea Green was at ringside for the Cargill vs. Fyre match, but she got into it with Giulia and Kiana James. Yeah, the whole exercise felt fairly pointless. Jade gained nothing by squashing Alba, and Giulia has become that big an afterthought it’s now hard to care about anything she’s doing. How did we get here with SmackDown's women's division?!

Bianca Belair cannot return soon enough for Cargill. That's the sort of big time rival Jade badly needs right now, because she can't keep mixing it with the Women's United States group and some hangers on like B-FAB and Michin for much longer. Jade vs. Green has some value, but that's about it.


Ups...

4. Women’s Tag Division Heats Up

Nia Jax Lash Legend Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

On the plus side, the women's tag-team division is a bit more spirited and competitive. At least there are multiple teams vying to become champs across both Raw and SmackDown. On Friday's show, Alexa Bliss vs. Kairi Sane was a perfectly fine singles outing for both, and the involvement of Charlotte Flair and Asuka around ringside made sense given everything else that's been going on between these women.

No problems with any of this booking, basically.

Bliss scoring the win puts she and Charlotte in frame for a title rematch, but Lash legend and Nia Jax also annihilated everyone post-match to stand tall with the belts. This is all somehow more interesting without the forced WarGames stuff, which speaks volumes about the set up for Survivor Series. It must also be said that this fracas was the best use of everyone involved.

Sane is way better in a tag context with Asuka that she is as a singles star, but both she and Alexa have some chemistry. Kairi likely enjoyed working with somebody she's ever so slightly taller than too. That doesn't happen often! It meant WWE avoided an odd fighting from underneath story with the heel, which could've been awkward.

The women's WarGames match last weekend was a complete and utter waste of everybody's time, but it's lovely to see creative find something worth clinging on to coming out of that scenario. Now, a Triple Threat or Fatal-4-Way showdown (also involving Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez) wouldn't go amiss on TV soon.

That match could easily headline on Raw or SmackDown.


3. They Were Cooking Second Half

Ilja Dragunov Carmelo Hayes
WWE.com

Ilja Dragunov and Carmelo Hayes started off slow. Real slow. It was an interesting call to go with Ilja dominating the entire first half of the match. Some of his work was borderline methodical heel beatdown stuff, so that showed a different side to his game that'll come in handy should he turn heel in the future. As likeable as he is, you know that's coming with Dragunov someday.

Following that slower first half, things picked up a ton during the second act. Tommaso Ciampa ran in to attack Hayes and cost him the match, but Ilja didn’t see it until watching a replay on the tron afterwards. That’ll come up in the story soon, because the reigning United States Champ wasn't happy that the DIY man had effectively won him the bout.

This is a solid way to go with things too.

It's tasty to see WWE weave some storytelling into these ‘Open Challenges’. They'd be easy to phone in due to the nature of them. 'Ah, just stick Dragunov out there in an endless string of matches then we'll take the belt from him eventually'. That sort of thing. The fact Triple H isn't doing that is testament to how keen he is to make fans pay attention to the title and Ilja's slow burn push.

He's someone with potential to reach main event status if he stumbles on the right feud or storyline. Is Ciampa his ticket to the top? Nah, and neither is Tama Tonga (another challenger being lined up), but some story is better than no story. At least the writing team are trying with this bunch.


2. Fired Up Cody = Vast Improvement

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody Rhodes is at his best when he’s ticked off and out for vengeance/justice. Attacking Drew McIntyre in the Scot’s rental car, then demanding that GM Nick Aldis reinstate Drew so he can “stomp him out” worked a treat to kick off Friday's show. So, being fair, did McIntyre screaming “reinstate me” at Aldis post-attack. That’s what he’s wanted all along too, and he’s goaded a top babyface into doing the dirty work for him.

Let's be real about something: Drew can’t really afford another unsuccessful title shot, so WWE have to be careful here, but this was excellent stuff from both he and Rhodes. Cody’s promo set the bar for energy on the show too. He went full on old school NWA by melding wild eyed facial expressions with some serious rasp over the live mic.

It's clear to see that Rhodes loves when he gets the opportunity to cut this kind of promo. It's like he gets to be his father for a few minutes, and that's always welcome. WarGames was a speed bump in the rivalry between Cody and Drew. Sounds weird, but it was. Now it's history, they can get back to weekly business over the WWE Title.

All going well, Randy Orton will return and go rogue on Rhodes so McIntyre doesn't have to do another unnecessary clean J.O.B. There'd be few complaints about a Drew title run heading into WrestleMania 42 season, but that's unlikely to be Triple H's plan. Few will focus on that if a rogue Randy returns to try punt Cody's head off his shoulders and take the WWE Title himself.

McIntyre can then resume his feud with Jacob Fatu but moan about 'being screwed'.


1. A Final Every Bit As Good As Anticipated

Gunther LA Knight
WWE.com

The 'Last Time Is Now' tournament designed to find a foe for John Cena's final match at Saturday Night's Main Event on 13 December was a bit of a formality once Gunther was announced for the brackets. Pretty much everyone knew that the 'Ring General' would get that slot, but WWE did throw a curve ball into the works by eliminating Jey Uso on Monday's episode of Raw.

That meant it was one LA Knight who squared off with Gunther in the final.

SmackDown's blow off was a worthy finale for the John Cena tourney, as expected going in. Gunther was physically dominant during the early going, and Knight channelled his inner Sami Zayn to play the slightly outgunned underdog well. A one-two punch of LA hitting an Attitude Adjustment then Burning Hammer for a big near fall was awesome, and there was another fab close one when LA hit his BFT but Gunther got a foot on the bottom rope just in time.

What a tidy main event for this week’s SmackDown. Again, most got the feeling that Gunther was always winning this thing, but the final didn’t suffer because of that. Plus, the submission story they're telling going into Cena's last hurrah is juicy. Gunther won with a submission eerily similar to Cena’s STF, and the heel now says he wants to make Cena tap out so he can make a mockery of the legend's “Never Give Up” catchphrase.

That's a fine way to go with John's final bout as an active member of the WWE roster. Bring it on.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 15 Wrestlers That Got BANNED From WWE and 9 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2004!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.