10 Most Polarizing Wrestlers Working Today

To yeet, or not to yeet? That is the question.

By Iain Taylor /

With the latest WWE Royal Rumble officially in the books, it's safe to say that this year's winners were a tad more contentious than 2024's popular winning duo of Bayley and Cody Rhodes.

Advertisement

Online reaction to Jey Uso and Charlotte Flair's Royal Rumble wins was mixed, to say the least, as wrestling fans vented their spleens over the untossed duo. Both Jey and Charlotte have their share of detractors and supporters, which naturally led to the thought: which other active wrestlers manage to elicit both fervent adoration and unbridled scorn from the modern wrestling fan?

Wrestlers splitting fan opinion is hardly a new phenomenon (hell, this writer wrote an article on the subject four years ago). The 2010s were dominated by the dueling chants of "Let's Go Cena/Cena Sucks!", and Shawn Michaels was both loved and loathed throughout the nineties as his incredible ability and boyish good looks were offset by his obnoxious attitude both on and off-screen.

So, without further ado, let's look at the first entrant on this particular list. And if you clicked on the above link, you may notice we're starting things off with a familiar face...

10. Charlotte Flair

The last time this writer discussed divisive wrestlers, Charlotte took the no.1 spot. Back in 2020, Charlotte had legions of fans who adored for her sensational wrestling ability, as she stuffed her resume with mat classics against the the Asuka, Sasha Banks and Rhea Ripley. However, there were an equal number of detractors who pointed out that the majority of Charlotte's opponents were worse off after feuding with her, and that they were sick of WWE placing all its eggs in a Flair-shaped basket.

Advertisement

Flash forward to the present day and, while Charlotte deservedly retains a huge number of fans for her unquestionable wrestling skill, her detractors have only become louder and greater in number.

Despite missing over a year of her career due to injury, Charlotte's return to regular TV saw her roundly booed by a RAW audience who were clearly less than enamored with her Rumble win the night before. You can understand their frustration - people were getting sick of Charlotte being pushed to the moon five years ago, and WWE have clearly learned nothing during Flair's prolonged hiatus.

Charlotte will always have fans due to her unparalleled work-rate, but it's telling that her 13-month absence did not engender feelings of fondness from many of the WWE faithful.

9. Kazuchika Okada

When all is said and done, Kazuchika Okada will go down as one of the greatest to ever step foot in the ring.

Advertisement

Chosen as the standard bearer for NJPW after Hiroshi Tanahashi dragged the company out of the doldrums in the early 2010s, Okada proved more than capable of filling his illustrious predecessor's boots. After decisively defeating Tanahashi at Wrestle Kingdom 10, Okada went on an absolute tear, producing more 5-star classics in his 2 1/2 year reign than most wrestlers manage over their entire careers. This is the Okada his fans rhapsodize about to this day - an imperious, unmissable talent whose presence made NJPW the hottest promotion on the planet.

Sadly, that's not the same Kazuchika Okada who turned up in AEW.

Since jumping ship to Tony Kahn's company, it's felt like Okada left a considerable portion of his talent back in his old promotion. AEW fans have only been shown glimpses of the former NJPW champion's potential, as his ring work has failed to come close to the Olympian heights of his matches in Japan. Heck, even his clash against fellow GOAT contender Bryan Danielson was a mild disappointment, like being given a fancy shaving kit for Christmas.

For NJPW fans, Okada will always be remembered as one of the greats. For AEW fans, he's simply another good worker in a company full of them.

8. Liv Morgan

Watching a WWE livestream is always interesting whenever Liv Morgan makes an appearance. She always generates huge traffic in the comments section, split into two distinct reactions: "Oh good, it's Liv!" and "Oh God, it's Liv!"

Advertisement

People in the latter camp tend to focus on how much air-time Liv gets compared to her peers in the locker room. In this, they have a point - Liv's feud with Rhea Ripley last year took far too long to resolve, and essentially relegated the rest of the RAW's extraordinarily talented Women's Division into the background.

Liv's fans, however, can rightly point out that the Morgan is doing more than enought to justify her push. She's clearly connecting with the crowd, as seen by her incredible merch sales, and her once average in-ring work has come on leaps and bounds over the past year. Hell, she just helped put on arguably the best women's tag match since the division rebooted in 2019!

Liv Morgan may have been hogging the spotlight over the past year, but only the curmudgeonliest curmudgeon could deny that she's been flourishing under it.

7. DIY

Well, that Royal Rumble match between DIY and Motor City Machine Guns sure was something, wasn't it? It's been a while since this writer has seen such an objectively good match play out to such deafening silence. While slightly uncomfortable to watch, the match did help to illustrate the problem with DIY - namely, the ever-widening gap between how they're perceived by WWE Creative and WWE fans.

Advertisement

WWE head honcho Triple H clearly loves DIY, and he has plenty of justification for doing so. Back in the good old days of NXT, Johnny Gargano and Tomasso Ciampa carried the black and gold brand on their shoulders, first with dazzling tag team displays and then with their brutal, incredible rivalry. Backed by great matches and stellar storytelling, it's small wonder HHH and the fans were united in their love for the dazzling duo.

Unfortunately, times have changed. While DIY's prominent screen time shows that Triple H's love for the pair remains undimmed, the fans' ardor has cooled significantly. When 65,000 people sit on their hands during a title match at one of the biggest events of the year, it's safe to say something has gone awry.

Here's hoping WWE can work their magic on the beleaguered duo, so the fans may once again join in the love affair between HHH and DIY to create a happy, supportive throuple. 

6. Mercedes Moné

When the former Sasha Banks arrived in AEW to thunderous acclaim, it looked like she was set to become one of the promotion's biggest heroes. Fast forward a year later, and Moné is a midcard champion firmly entrenched in the dark side of the force.

Advertisement

It's not hard to see how Mercedes has found herself in her current position. AEW didn't do her any favours by almost immediately booking Moné against the wildly popular Willow Nightingale, and Mercedes herself didn't help when she pulled a Saraya and started acting like AEW fans should be grateful she deigned to grace them with her presence.

To be clear, Mercedes is a world class talent. As Sasha Banks in WWE, she put on a litany of classic matches against some of the biggest names in the business, from her revolutionary match against Bayley in NXT to her historic WrestleMania main event against Bianca Belair. If Mercedes has an ego, it's one that's well earned.

Unfortunately, many fans have found Moné's attitude to be abrasive and off-putting, resulting in her being booed so relentlessly that perennial heel Britt Baker became the de facto face in their rivalry (a rivalry that gave Moné's haters further ammunition when the subsequent match stank out the joint).

Mercedes will go down as a revolutionary talent when all is said and done, but, like most revolutionaries, she's picked up a fair few detractors along her journey.

5. Trick Williams

For some, Trick Williams is everything a champion should be. With his action-hero good looks and overwhelming charisma, Trick is simply the coolest man in any building he walks into.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, for certain types of wrestling fan, the former NXT champion is a walking case of "...and then the bell rang".

When discussing Trick Williams, the wrestler who keeps popping into this writer's head is the late Sid Vicious, a.k.a. Sycho Sid. Like Sid, Trick has the "it" factor that simply can't be taught. But whereas Sid's charisma came from sheer physical presence and intensity, Trick's is from being inescapably cool. Take the scene in NXT last year, when he worldessly seduced an antagonistic Lash Legend into kissing him through sheer animal magnetism. It could have been utterly cringe-inducing, but the undeniable electricity emanating from the couple had the entire arena buzzing.

Unfortunately, cool factor alone does not a wrestler make and, again like Sid, it's in the ring where Trick's weaknesses become apparent. All too often you can see Trick's opponents covering for him, such as in the the conclusion of a bout against Ethan Page where Trick's adversary had to trip over his own feet to cover up the fact Williams was out of position for the finish.

Trick Williams is agonizingly close to being a genuine world-beater (or "Master and Ruler of the World", as Sid used to say). But until he improves in the ring, he's always going to have contend with the naysayers.

4. Logan Paul

Logan Paul's appearance on this list has nothing to do with talent, as Logan has proven himself to be a wrestling prodigy who can more than hold his own against the biggest names in WWE. He's also a genuine heat magnet, with crowds guaranteed to go nuclear whenever he appears.

Advertisement

Logan is an unquestionably great professional wrestler. It's who he is outside the ring that's the problem.

To put it diplomatically, Logan Paul has shown himself to be a complicated individual. To put it plainly, much of the heat he generates in the WWE is for his genuinely harmful real life actions.

Logan hardly helped his reputation with CryptoZoo, a scam sold as a game that forced him into making a public apology (an apology so heartfelt he subsequently sued the journalist who exposed his grift, like a Scooby Doo villain putting the blame on those meddling kids).

And during the Olympics, Logan Paul tweeted that Imane Khelif being allowed to compete was "The purest form of evil", assuming she was a transgender man. She wasn't, and Logan's attempt at an apology simply read, ""OOPSIES, I might be guilty of spreading misinformation along with the entirety of this app." - an apology almost Hogan-esque in its lack of remorse or actual acknowledgement of guilt.

As a celebrity wrestler, Logan Paul is peerless. As a person...

3. MJF

And now, a look at someone whose villainy is confined to the wrestling ring.

Advertisement

MJF's return to his bad old ways was initially a cause of celebration for the AEW faithful. After playing an "AEW rah-rah!" babyface (an archetype AEW fans were already sick of), Maxwell Jacob Friedman reverting to his villainous self was a much needed reboot of his character. After all, AEW's best years were greatly enhanced by Friedman's diabolically evil scumbag of a heel. Surely a return to those salad days would be welcomed by all?

Given that MJF is in this article, you can probably guess the result.

MJF's recent feud with Jeff Jarrett hasn't exactly been the stellar return to form fans were hoping for. Of particular offense was the January 15th episode of AEW Dynamite, which saw the pair engage in a fifteen minute promo war that saw MJF bring up Kurt Angle's balls and inadvertently imply that AEW was on its last legs. The promo, and it's excruciating length, was less-than-unanimously praised by wrestling fans, and showed that MJF's once unsassailable grip on the wrestling fandom was weakening.

MJF will always be remembered as one of the best bad guys of his generation, but - much like with AEW in general - the critics are already lapping up the blood in the water.

2. CM Punk

In Brain Azarello's Joker graphic novel, there's a scene where one of the clown prince of crime's henchman explains that his boss' mood is like the weather - a sunny, upbeat Joker cheers everbody up, while a downcast clown means everyone is about to have a terrible day.

Advertisement

It's a feeling you can imagine CM Punk's peers can identify with.

CM Punk is very much a man of two halves. On the one hand, there's Punk the super-worker - the man who elevates his peers (just look at what he did with Drew McIntyre), puts on wrestling clinics and goes out of his way to encourage and advise upcoming superstars. Then, there's the thin-skinned, wildly unprofessional prima donna who publicly eviscerates his colleagues, punches out his co-workers and constantly stands on the knife-edge between passion and pugilism.

Whether you love or loathe Punk very much depends on which half of his personality you choose to focus on. But one thing's for sure - when all is said and done, C.M. Punk will go down as one of the most unmissable acts of this or any other generation.

1. Jey Uso

Jey Uso is a phenomenon. An anomaly. A phenomaly.

Advertisement

Apologies for the gross abuse of the English language. But it's hard to find the words to describe a man who has his Royal Rumble win castigated on YouTube, yet is showered with such love and affection by live fans that he breaks down on camera.

How to explain such a disparity? To start, it's easy to see where Jey Uso's fans are coming from. His "Yeet!" catchphrase is insanely catchy and popular, and WWE have marketed it perfectly. Even more importantly, however, is that Jey Uso is a genuinely excellent promo. When Jey places his heart on his sleeve, fans can't help but respond to it and create a genuine emotional connection with him - hence Jey being literally moved to tears by their support during his Royal Rumble celebration.

However, he is not the complete package. Hardcore fans - i.e., those most likely to frequent the internet and leave negative YouTube feedback - tend to point out that his in-ring record as a singles star is spotty, to say the least. He put on one of the worst WrestleMania matches of all time last year, and his previous bout against Gunther did absolutely nothing to make fans salivate over the prospect over their upcoming rematch.

Whichever side of UsoMania you fall one, though, there's one thing we can all agree on - everybody will be yeeting their opinions over Jey Uso for a long time to come.

Advertisement