8 Most Polarizing Wrestlers Working Today

One man's heel is another man's babyface.

Charlotte Flair
WWE

Before social media became the phenomenon it is today it was easy to tell which wrestler's were popular with the fans and which weren't. Crowds cheered the wrestlers they liked and booed the ones they didn't. Now, thanks to anyone with an internet connection being able to instantly broadcast their opinions to the world, the lines have become blurred.

If you follow wrestling on twitter it seems damn near every wrestler is simultaneously under/over-rated and the greatest/worst thing to ever happen to the business. Obviously a lot of these comments are hyperbole, but it doesn't change the fact that there are some wrestlers who elicit particularly polarizing reactions from the pro wrestling community.

To that end, we have chosen who we believe to be the eight most divisive wrestlers in the business today. As the title suggests only currently active wrestlers were eligible for the list, so no appearances from Hulk Hogan, HHH, HBK or any other wrestler whose name contains a capital 'H'.

If there's anyone you feel we missed please let us know in the comments below and, in the spirit of the article, feel free to tell us if this was the Greatest List Ever or Minus Five Stars.

8. Bray Wyatt

The Fiend
WWE

The line between genius and madness is a thin one. Such is the case for Bray Wyatt who, depending on who you ask, is either the most inventive mind the WWE has ever seen or a gimmicky goof who puts on terrible matches.

After unveiling the Firefly Fun House and the Fiend to near universal acclaim last year, segments of the wrestling community have begun to turn on the former Husky Harris. His disastrous match agains Seth Rollins at Hell in the Cell didn't help matters, and his nonsensical feud with the Miz and disappointing Universal Title reign had some wrestling fans declaring the character washed up less than a year after he debuted.

To counter these claims, one could (as is so often the case) point out that the above problems are indictments of WWE's booking team and not the man himself. When Wyatt has crafted his own material for the character, such as in the opening 8 Firefly Fun House vignettes and the Fun House match against John Cena, the results have received near unanimous approval.

Bray Wyatt is undoubtedly one of the most unique minds in the history of wrestling, but whether he's a Fiend or a Fool is a matter of personal opinion.


7. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega
NJPW

Kenny Omega - according to to the internet he's either a phenomenal talent who lives up to his Best Bout Machine nickname, or an over-rated try-too-hard who believes his own hype (and he can't book for toffee either).

Make no mistake, Kenny Omega is an extremely talented wrestler. His tag-team with Adam Page has provided the best in-ring action AEW has seen since it's inception, the Stadium Stampede was cinematic wrestling near-perfected and, of course, there's his generation-defining series with Kazuchika Okada to consider.

To counter this, Omega's detractors like to point out the man's tendency to go over the top and provide self-conciously 'epic' matches, his unsanctioned match against Jon Moxley being the perfect example. One of the most divisive bouts of last year, watching Omega and Moxley tear into each other was a genuinely gruelling experience to watch and not many people's idea of entertainment. It was deathmatch wrestling writ large, but for many the over the top violence didn't enhance the match but took away from it. A noble failure, but a failure none the less.

Add to that his rather prickly online reactions when people bring up the AEW women's division and you have one of the most fascinating characters in wrestling - a flawed prodigy whose weaknesses add to his legend as much as his strengths.


6. Brock Lesnar

Paul Heyman Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Of all the wrestlers on this list, Brock Lesnar is arguably the most frustrating.

When he's in the mood, Lesnar can put over a superstar like no-one else in the business. Look at what he did for Drew McIntyre. He didn't just do the job for him at Wrestlemania, he made McIntyre look like a million bucks in the run-up. Who can forget him instructing Drew to Claymore him on the entrance ramp at RAW and hold up the title to the approving roar of the crowd? Great, great business sense from Brock and the perfect example of how a bulletproof, established star should act when putting over younger talent.

Unfortunately, that's not always the Lesnar we get. Sometimes we get the arrogant mercenary who squashes his unlucky opponent back down the card. The paycheque warrior who destroys Ricochet in two minutes, who ends Kofi's title reign in nine seconds and who puts in next to no effort when beating Braun Strowman in successive matches, doing irreparable harm to the Monster among Men's reputation in the process.

Brock Lesnar: Great Worker or Selfish Mercenary? He's both, really, which is what makes him so polarizing.


5. Shayna Baszler

Vince McMahon XFL
WWE/XFL

Well we certainly didn't see this coming.

Coming off a stellar run in NXT and immediately launched into a program with the most over woman in the history of professional wrestling, Baszler looked set to be a cornerstone of the women's division for years to come. Instead, at the time of writing she's been off TV for two weeks with no sign of a return on the horizon.

Some use this as yet another example of WWE letting a world class talent go to waste. Others say it's as an example of how NXT is a very different beast to the main roster. Shayna went from producing white hot matches on the yellow brand to being greeted with near-apathy when she was called up. The crowd turned on her Survivor Series match with Bayley and Becky, her match with Kairi Sane on RAW was showered with chants of “Boring!” (Something that never happened between them in NXT), and the audience began leaving early during her showcase bout at Elimination Chamber.

It looks like Baszler will be staying out of the title picture in WWE, at least until the writers and Baszler herself figure out why she isn't catching fire on the main roster like she did at Full Sail University. Here's hoping they can find a solution as she's too great a talent to be sitting on the sidelines.


4. Marko Stunt

Marko Stunt
AEW

Can someone be too much of an underdog? Marko Stunt is wrestling's attempt to find an answer to this very question.

Standing at a legitimate 5 ft 2 in., Marko is invariably the smallest man in any match he's in. Those who decry him say that he has no business being in the ring as he makes everyone involved look ridiculous for fighting him. Unlike other similarly size-disadvantaged superstars such as Rey Mysterio, Marko has neither the superhuman level of athleticism or charisma necessary to offest the obvious disparity between him and his opponents.

His supporters, however, say that this is precisely the point. Marko Stunt isn't supposed to be a heavyweight contender, or someone who can stand toe toe with the company's best. Every match he's in involves him using his quickness and ring smarts to make a nuisance of himself, darting around his opponents to fluster and frustrate them while his Jurassic Express team-mates do the heavy lifting. When he's caught, he gets murdered. But until that point, he's living his dream of being a professional wrestler despite the criticism and negativity sent his way.

Whether that's uplifiting or self-indulgent is in the eye of the beholder.


3. Tessa Blanchard

Tessa Blanchard
ImpactWrestling.com

Oh boy. Tessa Blanchard - Professional wrestling pioneer, or yet another example of bad guys finishing first?

While Tessa becoming the Impact World Champion was a genuinely historic moment in professional wrestling , watching her win the title felt akin to watching Margaret Thatcher becoming Prime Minister - it's great to see women breaking new ground, but did it have to be this particular woman?

Shortly before her inauguration as champion, Blanchard tweeted "Hey women, try supporting one another. Cool things happen". This seemingly innocuous message unleashed a tidal wave of negativity on the soon-to-be champ's head. Accusations of bullying came flooding in from wrestlers like Chelsea Green and Priscilla Kelly, while the NWA's Allysin Kay alleged that Tessa "spat in a black woman's face and called her the N-word in Japan" (a claim later backed up by Puerto Rican wrestler La Rosa Negra). Blanchard's lack of contrition hasn't helped matters, with her stating “Not everyone is gonna like you. I’m going to build my own legacy based on my work ethic, not by trying to win some popularity contest.”

Regardless of how you feel about her, there's no doubt the allegations cast a pall over what should have been one of the most feel-good moments in wrestling history.


2. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy
AEW

The coolest man in wrestling or the death of the entire industry?

"Pockets", as Cassidy's number one nega-fan Jim Cornette calls him, is wrestling marmite. You either love his laid-back-to-the-point-of-being-comatose attitude, or you think it's a slap in the face to anyone who has ever taken wrestling seriously.

One thing that can't be denied is the man's talent. As he showed in his match against PAC at AEW Revolution, the man behind the sunglasses has some serious in-ring skills despite his carefree persona.

Nothing sums up his paradoxical nature better than his finishing move, the Mouse Trap. A complex looking cradle where Cassidy uses his arms and legs to pin his opponent's shoulders to the mat, it's arguably the most scientific finisher in wrestling today. It harkens back to the days of Bret Hart using his superior technical skills to pin larger opponents and represents wrestling in its purest form - a competition to see who can keep their opponent down for a three count.

To reiterate, the most technical finisher in wrestling today is used by a man whose trademark is gently superkicking his opponents in the shin. Orange Cassidy is a riddle wrapped in an enigma, and consequently one of the most fascinating characters in wrestling today.


1. Charlotte

Charlotte Flair
WWE

Ah, Charlotte. The hot-button issue of the moment. Depending on who you ask, Charlotte is either the best women's wrestler on the planet or the most over-exposed, over-pushed wrestler of the current era.

Charlotte's supporters, and Charlotte herself, point out that she's the hardest worker on the roster, at least in terms of the number of shows she's appeared on. Others point out that this is the problem - her recent overexposure has turned the fanbase against her, as people have gotten sick of WWE force feeding them Vitamin C three times a week (and we don't mean Orange Cassidy).

Some say that she's arguably the greatest female wrestler on the planet, with a lengthy list of great matches backing up the claim. Others say that she may be great between the ropes, but she's poison to her opponents. Look at Rhea Ripley - she was white hot until she lost to Charlotte, and is now in a much worse position than she was before the feud started (a feeling Sasha Banks and Asuka can sympathize with).

Regardless of how you feel about her, one thing is certain - she's not going anywhere.


WWE Quiz: How Much Do You Know About Charlotte Flair?

Charlotte Flair WrestleMania 34
WWE

1. Which Wrestler Did Charlotte Bring To School In First Grade For 'Show And Tell'?

Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.