10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2005
WWE missed a blockbuster feud during one of SmackDown's most controversial years ever.
Batista was a made man by the time he ruled the blue brand landscape from mid-2005 onwards. He'd beaten Triple H in a feisty main event at WrestleMania 21 to become the new World Heavyweight Champion, and now he was moonlighting as The Rock from 2000 by turning SmackDown into "his show".
Life was good. Death, as always, was sad.
2005 was a year overshadowed by the passing of a true great. Eddie Guerrero left us in November, but 'Latino Heat' still managed to leave gifts wrestling fans would cherish forever beforehand. One of his finest hours is examined here, but there's also the rather spooky experience of reliving the legend's final match ever. It came against someone who was blowing up as a future headliner himself (or so everyone thought).
SmackDown switched from Thursday nights to Fridays in '05 too, and that wasn't strictly Vince McMahon's choice. UPN and WWE were on shaky ground a few times throughout the year, mainly due to one of the most controversial characters and one off angles the promotion would ever produce. Everyone involved surely regrets that now. Entire documentaries have been made about it!
McMahon knew he had some world class stars he could rely on (Kurt Angle, The Undertaker, Booker T, Chris Benoit etc), but he was also desperate to push some fresh faces who'd hopefully be every bit as successful as the likes of Batista and Randy Orton. Success varied, which is being kind to some aborted WWE projects they'd give up on by the time calendars turned.
Revisiting such a controversial year for SmackDown was packed with ups and downs. Here's everything learned.
10. 2005’s Draft Was Fairer To SmackDown
If you were looking for just three words to describe 2004's Draft, they'd be: 'SmackDown', 'got' and 'screwed'. The 'other show' was initially handed Triple H, but then Hunter decided he didn't want to work Thursdays and fancied sticking around on Raw. So, one of the bigger picks in the entire Draft was a total waste. Great.
2005 was way better for both brands.
John Cena jumped to Raw to become the poster boy, and SmackDown received the likes of Batista, Chris Benoit, Randy Orton and others in return. There was better balance to the roster separation on this occasion, which definitely hadn't been the case the prior year. Back then, it was blatantly obvious that SmackDown was the 'B' show next to Raw's 'A' tier status.
Admittedly, team blue did spend a few weeks in no man's land - Cena leapt to Raw on 6 June, and Batista didn't sign on with Teddy Long's show until 30 June. Being fair, WWE managed to mask that by asking who'd be joining the roster eventually, and by drip-feeding other picks like Benoit.
When binging, it was nice to see the show getting more love and being treated less like a secondary concern. SmackDown didn't get shafted like it did in '04, and the onus was now firmly on guys like Batista and Orton to fly the flag as bonafide stars on the level of others like The Undertaker or Kurt Angle. They'd relish that challenge for the rest of the year.
WWE can't say this often, but the 2004 Draft was a success.
9. Heidenreich was Heiden-HORRIBLE!
It's understandable why a body guy like Vince McMahon would look at Jon Heidenreich and smell money, but wrestling needs more than just bulging biceps. It always has. Some crudely palm off the 1980s boom as one obsessed with lumbering muscle heads who couldn't wrestle, but that's unfair. Hulk Hogan and cohorts had more to offer than workout tips.
Heidenreich never grasped the basics, and he was a regular nuisance throughout the year when binging. His feud with The Undertaker trickled into 2005 and proved unsatisfying, Jon's rivalry with Booker T sucked wind, his poetry-reading babyface turn was painful, his brief issues with Orlando Jordan achieved nothing, then he joined LOD even though literally no-one in the audience wanted to see that happen.
The revamped Doom squad's tag title run was the pits, and some of the matches were only passable due to MNM's involvement. Heidenreich was gone by January ’06, which speaks volumes about how successful he was as a McMahon pet project. It was a thoroughly painful experience to sit through his moments and matches.
Why? Well, Heidenreich was one of those forced pushes akin to Vladimir Kozlov. Fans, industry critics and everyone in between can see that there isn't much there, but WWE keeps pushing them regardless in the hope that something will click. It rarely does, and it was never going to for Michael Cole's least favourite wrestler.
Almost everything Heidenreich did was dampened by the fact that he was the one doing it, and that's a problem. If every match, promo and storyline you're working would be better if you weren't there, then you know you've got no chance.
8. WWE Blew Hot & Cold On Orlando Jordan
Meanwhile, Orlando Jordan had a wee bit more about him than Heidenreich. A wee bit.
Someone in the office must've agreed, because they booked Orlando to beat John Cena and become United States Champ on the 3 March SmackDown. He'd successfully defend the belt against Heidenreich (not a candidate for one of WWE's greatest matches ever, let's be honest) at Judgment Day and Chris Benoit at the Great American Bash. Then, something changed, and it was clear to see when reliving SmackDown in 2005.
Between the Bash and SummerSlam, WWE's opinion on OJ shifted. Benoit battered him in a mere 25 seconds at the latter pay-per-view, and that was that. He even left a cushy position in JBL's Cabinet (which was effectively a main event stable from minute one) behind to strike out on his own. That solo trip didn't end in fist-pumping delight for Orlando.
He went nowhere fast before being released in 2006.
There were a few periods throughout '05 when SmackDown’s midcard often didn’t have a lot going on, so it’s puzzling that WWE soured on Jordan so suddenly. He was rough around the edges and sorely needed some personality, sure, but he was way better than the likes of Jon Heidenreich and deserved a little more time in the oven to develop.
Maybe instincts behind the curtain were spot on. Maybe McMahon and his team figured that Orlando would never develop the charisma necessary to proceed beyond US Title level, and so they decided to cut their losses. Still, his drop off was severe.
7. You Need To See This Marty Jannetty Match
Iconic wrestling machine Kurt Angle was working his final full year as an active member of the full-time WWE roster in 2005, but nobody knew that at the time. They were far too busy getting pumped for Kurt's dazzling WrestleMania 21 showdown with fellow standout Shawn Michaels to worry about whether or not the Olympian was struggling behind the scenes.
Speaking of which, enter Marty Jannetty. The perennial pain in the neck for management popped back up as part of a mini-Rockers reunion in early-2005. After working a tag-team bout with HBK over on Raw, Marty brought his skills to SmackDown for the ultimate test: A lengthy singles showing against one of the best wrestlers in the industry on the 17 March episode.
It was fabulous, and you really need to see it.
Angle beat Jannetty in a wonderful match that reignited WWE's interest in using Marty. Sadly, some old persistent problems and his behaviour away from the ring would end that interest fairly swiftly, but he honestly looked to be on top of his game vs. Kurt, and their match comes across as a real clash of generations.
It worked a treat within the context of Angle's feud with Shawn heading into 'Mania, and it's well worth seeking out if you’ve forgotten about it or just fancy seeing how good Jannetty could be even this late into his career. At his best, and when motivated, Marty looked every bit like somebody who should be working near the tippy top of WWE cards.
He didn't get the renaissance he was looking for, but at least Jannetty could look back on this beauty of a match.
6. The First Friday Show Was A Banger
UPN moved SmackDown to Friday's starting with the 9 September episode. A benefit concert held in aid of victims who'd suffered the wrath of Hurricane Katrina meant that the first hour was going to air exclusively on WWE.com. Then, UPN would air the second hour; WWE's hands were tied there, but they must've been a bit miffed considering the jump from Thursdays to Fridays was the network's call in the first place.
The timing wasn't great, although the benefit bid for those affected was obviously important.
Soldiering on, Vince and troops put on the best card they could think of anyway. Yes, Chris Benoit beat Orlando Jordan in a few seconds (again!), and the team of Heidenreich and Animal retaining their tag belts against MNM was only as good as match involving big Jon was going to be, but at least those weaker points happened early or were short.
The real lures for fans tuning in came in the form of a steel cage grudge match between old friends turned enemies Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero, as well as a 'Bullrope Match' for the World Heavyweight Title between reigning champ Batista and perennial SmackDown linchpin JBL.
Those were some tasty matches SmackDown could brag about for this first foray onto Friday nights. You can’t really argue with 2 PLE quality scraps on a 2-hour show. WWE tried their best to offset the annoying .com thing and give fans something worth going out of their way to see.
Guerrero vs. Rey would go down in history as Eddie's final big gimmick bout too.
5. The Mixed Emotions Of Eddie Guerrero’s Last Match
Tussling with Rey inside the steel cage was Eddie's last gimmick match, but obviously not his last match full stop. That'd come on the 11 November '05 SmackDown vs. Mr. Kennedy. They taped that bout on 8 November, then Guerrero was tragically found dead by his nephew Chavo on 13 November. What a depressing series of events.
On one hand, you’ll smile when watching Eddie do his ‘lie, cheat and steal’ thing vs. Kennedy. On the other, it’s painful knowing he’d be gone mere days later. Watching his final match feels surreal, if anything. There was a smile on Guerrero's face as he pulled the wool over Kennedy and referee Charles Robinson's eyes - the fans were in on it, and they grinned along with him.
This was Eddie at his cheeky, creative best. He'd been a heel opposite Mysterio, but now here he was lapping up the adulation from those who adored his roguish ways. There's something quite poignant about the fact that 'Latino Heat' got to go out with this kind of performance. He wasn't booed, he wasn't some character villain trying to wreck someone's family.
No, he was a devilish pro wrestler who used his brain power to outgun a newer star.
Guerrero was robbed of life and gone far too soon. Inside the ring, he clearly had so much more to give and was about to embark on yet another magical babyface sprint heading into 2006. It wasn't to be. Sadly, rather than furnishing the biz with more of this wink and nod chaos, Eddie passed away.
4. The Palmer Cannon Experiment Was Weird
Psst! Remember this guy?
WWE brought in a journeyman pro called Brian Mailhot (as opposed to Brian Hotmail, who would've been a wrestling postman during the mid-90s for sure) to play the role of Palmer Cannon. Those initials were not accidental; PC, get it? He was ostensibly a retread of Cyrus (AEW's Don Callis) from the old ECW days.
In other words, he was there from UPN to monitor what GM Teddy Long was putting on SmackDown in the wake of the Muhammad Hassan controversy. It was a jab at the network for criticising what Vince McMahon wanted to put on his programming. On-air, Cannon was responsible for such thrill rides as The Boogeyman, the ill-fated “Juniors Division” and a tag-team literally called The Dicks.
Looking back, it's weird to watch WWE willingly throw crap on-screen and blame it on a kayfabe character. They’d pretty much do the same with ‘Constable’ Baron Corbin in 2019, then the McMahon family absolved themselves of any sins. Fans didn't buy it then, and they didn't buy it in 2005 when ol' Palmer was grinning from ear to ear at the prospect of ruining Long's day yet again.
Only Boogeyman stuck around as a lasting concern from the PC experiment. The quasi-authority figure was sort of similar to the old Right To Censor group in presentation, but had this unlikeable 'dorky dad who thinks he's hip' swagger about him on top of that. Come to think of it, why didn't they just amalgamate multiple Steven Richards gimmicks by calling Cannon 'Big Stevie Cool'?!
A missed opportunity that would've raked in millions. Millions!
3. Jumping To SmackDown Ended Muhammad Hassan
Muhammad Hassan will forever be known as one of the most controversial gimmicks in wrestling history. VICE even produced an entire 'Dark Side Of The Ring' documentary on the character, and it's worth seeing just to hear from the guy behind the guise. Marc Copani's wrestling career would never be the same again.
WWE upped the amount of controversy surrounding his persona almost immediately after he moved to SmackDown in the 2005 Draft. Hassan beat Big Show in his first match, then launched into a feud with The Undertaker. That led to an infamous angle on the 7 July episode which frankly changed everything. UPN were not happy with WWE after negative feedback amidst terror attack panic in London, England poured in.
Bruce Prichard has claimed that technological limitations meant nobody could edit the tapes in time for the US audience, but the angle was removed from select broadcasts elsewhere, including in the UK. On the US side, they did at least run a crawler warning fans about the content, but it was too late. Damage had been done.
Now, it's easy to see now that moving to SmackDown in June was effectively the end of the Hassan gimmick. He was written out at the Great American Bash pay-per-view on 24 July, but wouldn't have even been feuding with 'Taker had he not moved from Raw the previous month.
UPN made it clear that they didn't want to see Muhammad on screen again, or else. WWE had to comply, and Copani was the unfortunate collateral here. Management didn't even really bother trying to repackage Marc into something else before releasing him.
2. Kurt Angle’s Final Feud Is Regrettable
Final feud as a full time in-ring WWE talent on SmackDown, that is.
In 2005, Kurt Angle was part of a brutally bad storyline with Booker T and Sharmell that saw Kurt claim Sharmell was coming onto him and that he wanted to have “bestiality sex” with her. Yeah. Oh yeah, then he kidnapped her and generally acted like a total creep in between having solid wrestling matches with Book.
Angle was moved to Raw in the Draft that June. He'd return to SmackDown again by January 2006, then got bumped to the ECW brand before finally leaving the company to try and sort out a personal life that was spiralling completely out of control. Thankfully, he'd manage to get a grip on things in the end and is living a happier, healthier lifestyle today.
It’s just a pity that this “bestiality” business would become known as Angle’s last major story on SmackDown before he was drafted. The Olympian had been a staple on the brand since the first roster split in 2002 - he'd been part of the famous 'SmackDown Six' group (alongside Chris Benoit, Eddie and Chavo Guerrero, Edge and Rey Mysterio), had worked World Title feuds better than almost anyone, and now here he was involved in some undignified soap opera crud that spilled over into offensive territory.
That's coming from the horse's mouth. Kurt looks back on this story saga with regret. No wonder. He didn't mind going above and beyond to entertain, and willingly made a fool of himself, but the whole tale with Booker and Sharmell was simply too much.
1. An Evolution Spinoff Feud Was Right There!
How did they miss this?!
Both Batista and Randy Orton jumped to SmackDown in the Draft, but WWE elected not to book them as rivals. At least not rivals who'd have a protracted series of matches on pay-per-view. Instead, Batista warred with JBL then moved into a tag run with Rey Mysterio. Meanwhile, Orton feuded with The Undertaker.
That was great, but it’s baffling that they moved both guys without running Batista vs. Randy for the World Title on a major show. It seemed like a certainty. The pair did collide on countless house shows during the second half of 2005, and they were punched in to work opposite one another on the 25 November episode of SmackDown over in Sheffield, England.
Their match went to a no contest quickly when various Raw wrestlers ran in to brawl and hype what was coming at Survivor Series that weekend. Fair enough, because they had to plug the PPV, but surely WWE would come back to Randy and big Dave later once the dust had settled? Apparently not.
Batista vs. Orton was literally one of the biggest rivalries the company could've gone with on SmackDown, but they had other plans. This sticks out as a real missed opportunity throughout December particularly, because the cancelled November match seemed to be a teaser for more to come.
What else did you learn from watching every episode of WWE SmackDown from 2005? For more wrestling, check out 12 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2003 and 9 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE SmackDown From 2004!