10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2005
WWE said goodbye to cherished in-ring greats and any remaining creative good taste in 2005.
Behold 2005, otherwise known as the year Dominik Mysterio's legend was born.
At SummerSlam, Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero worked a ridiculous 'Custody Of Dominik' ladder match. People scoffed at the time, and it was retrospectively bashed, but Dom Dom's rise to fame in modern times has softened views on this chaotic storyline. Thus, it has no place here amongst the worst '05 had to offer. It's nowhere near as crummy as some of the other stuff Vince McMahon slapped his own personal seal of approval on that year.
It's incredible to think that WWE went PG a mere 3 years after this in 2008. Why? Well, they were still peddling many of the 'shock TV' tropes first harnessed during the lucrative 'Attitude Era'. Unfortunately for McMahon and pals, his company was doing so in the face of diminishing returns. WWE was still big business in 2005, but they were also stumbling around in the dark creatively and frantically trying to create new stars.
John Cena, Batista and others offered hope on that front, but some of the other acts thrust in front of cameras proved ill-advised to say the least. Muhammad Hassan made headlines for all the wrong reasons, other racist gimmicks torched good taste on the undercard, and WWE awkwardly pushed lines like "bestiality sex" onto episodes of SmackDown.
Ye olde "new and improved" chestnut was wheeled into view for a tag-team that was anything but, the Royal Rumble finish proved to be a disaster, and pro wrestling lost one of its favourite sons towards the end of the year.
Here's 2005's worst laid bare.
10. Big Show Goes Sumo
The subheading for this entry was almost, 'Big Show's Supershow Butt', but cooler heads prevailed.
Seriously though, was there any call for a 'Sumo Match' pitting Show against Akebono at WrestleMania 21? Vince McMahon routinely enjoyed pushing pageantry and "attractions" over practically everything else, but surely even he knew that this would be a car crash once it got underway. That might be why the whole exercise lasted just a few short minutes before wrapping up with a Akebono win.
It probs took Show longer to get his mawashi on backstage than the match itself lasted. Visually, it was hardly a treat for anyone tuning in - they were greeted with the not-so-pleasing sight of Paul Wight's big pasty behind thrust right in front of the cameras. The fact this bout was sandwiched in between Shawn Michaels vs. Kurt Angle and John Cena vs. JBL is fascinating in hindsight; it was understandable to buffer between those matches, maybe, but something better than the sumo guff was needed.
The unwanted sideshow proved to be an insult to anybody who'd put down their hard earned pay-per-view dollars. Obviously, a lot of other things on the 'Mania 21 card more than made up for this slap in the face, but Show vs. Akebono just shouldn't have been on there. WWE fans didn't give a toss about the latter, and Show doing his best Rikishi-meets-Yokozuna-meets-John Tenta impression was frankly awkward to watch.
3 years later, WWE got it right by putting Big Show in there with boxer Floyd Mayweather. That boxer vs. wrestler showdown was a vast improvement over 2005's effort. What a colossal waste of time, especially on the biggest show (ahem) of the entire year.
9. Non-Wrestlers Stink The Place Out
In fairness, even Eric Bischoff has giggled at his match vs. Teddy Long at Survivor Series 2005. The former WCW head honcho likely knew that giving he and 'Tag-Team' Teddy precious minutes on one of the biggest pay-per-views of the year was a mistake, but he did his best to make the match as pain free as possible. That was mission impossible.
Look, nobody watching the show went in expecting an in-ring miracle. This was never going to be Ric Flair vs. Ricky Steamboat, but it was so, so bad. Yes, even from a non wrestler vs. non wrestler perspective. This was like Gerald Brisco vs. Pat Patterson from King Of The Ring 2000 without the comedic touch, which isn't meant as a compliment. Five minutes felt like five years.
Long mocked Bischoff's martial arts background, Bisch choked Ted with his belt, then The Boogeyman (of all people) showed face to help SmackDown's GM take home the victory. Oh, and forgotten face Palmer Cannon was at ringside representing Teddy too. Thankfully, he didn't bring his duff "Juniors Division" along for the ride with him.
It's legit shocking that this went on second from last on one of the traditional 'Big 4' PPVs. The match was a travesty. It was always going to be one, as Eric has pointed out via his '83 Weeks' podcast. He didn't have somebody like Steve Austin out there to slap him around, and that meant there was zero actual wrestling ability whatsoever involved. No, Boogeyman doesn't count. He ate some worms and facilitated the finish. That was it.
Horrible.
8. Cena & Batista Botch The Rumble Finish
January's Royal Rumble finish set the tone for the worst 2005 had in store.
John Cena and Batista bungled the 30-man bout's ending so badly that an irate Vince McMahon marched out to put things right. Unfortunately for the then boss, he bashed his knees on the steel support holding up the ring and ended up tearing both of his quads. That meant a shattered McMahon had to camp out on the canvas and bark instructions to everybody whilst looking up.
He had to be mortified by that. Vince has never been one to publicly sell weakness of any sort, but he literally couldn't stand up. He might as well have had spaghetti for legs instead of muscle, bone and skin. He was done in, and it was his own clumsiness that had caused the problem. Oops. That must've been really embarrassing for someone like McMahon.
WWE restarted the match and Batista won the thing as planned, but not before Vince needed a trip to the hospital. Both Cena and 'The Animal' likely believed they were in for quite the talking to at Raw the next night. Somehow, they'd managed to tumble over the top rope and hit the floor as exactly the same time - it was akin to Bret Hart and Lex Luger in 1994.
No-one really knew how to rectify things, but legless McMahon stumbled in to put things back on course. WWE's kingpin probably hated everything about this scenario, but it was at least entertaining to fans around ringside and to those watching at home. What a messy conclusion to the first tentpole pay-per-view of '05 though.
7. ‘The New & Improved’ LOD
"New and improved flavour". That's the food industry's version of pro wrestling's fascination with "new". Generally, unless you're Daniel Bryan, sticking the word "new" in front of anything means it sucks or at least feels less than promoters want it to. Think The New Rockers, The New Blackjacks, The New Generation etc. Granted, the 'New Gen' led to some brilliant stuff, but it still fits here.
Then, there was 'The New Legion Of Doom' in 2005.
It's just as well WWE didn't officially call Animal's new union with Heidenreich that. They did say it on commentary, and it was a "new" version of the famous team, but Hei-den-heidenreich replacing Hawk was flimsy. He and Animal formed their new duo in July, but then Heidenreich received his LOD spikes on the 18 August 2005 SmackDown and the entire fanbase groaned collectively.
Anybody with half a brain could've predicted that this would flop hard. Heidenreich wasn't even as good a Road Warrior as Droz had been years beforehand. The big muscle man couldn't work a lick no matter how hard he tried, but WWE seemed determined to make something of his abolished top line run by making him part of this "new and improved" LOD 2K25.
Fans did not latch on or particularly enjoy the fresh coat of white paint WWE gave LOD's spiky look. After holding the tag titles for a few months, Heidenreich was released by bosses and that was very much that. Animal moved on to a singles run you might not even remember, and LOD 2K25 became nothing but a fleeting memory itself.
Good riddance.
6. McMahon Rips JR’s Colon Surgery
Iconic announcer Jim Ross hasn't had his health troubles to seek over the years, but he's always maintained dignity and passionately discussed how much support from wrestling fans means to him. That's been true whether he's been battling Bell's Palsy, fighting skin cancer or dealing with colon cancer. People have been gracious and loving towards JR.
Then, there was Vince McMahon on the 24 October 2005 episode of Raw.
Ross was recuperating at home following colon surgery when he got word that Vince had a special treat in store for him on that evening's flagship. This turned out to be a dumb comedy segment that showed McMahon in scrubs ("Dr. Heiney" was present) as he pulled various things out of Jim's butt. One of those items just so happened to be JR's own head. Get it?
Watching from bed and in a lot of pain, JR didn't find any of this funny. Meanwhile, as he told in one of his autobiographies, the beloved commentator had to sit and suffer through Vince claiming that he was only being jocular and looking on the bright side of life. Apparently, McMahon thought that publicly humiliating one of his employees and using airtime on his biggest weekly show was the place to do that.
This was serious business. Jim could've died of cancer, and his surgery could've gone wrong. It didn't, thank God, but his boss didn't give a thought to any of that. No, he thought it best to kick someone when they were already down, and poke fun at their misfortune live on Monday Night Raw.
As you erm...do.
5. Tim White Tries To Commit Suicide
Imagine firing up WWE's official website, social media streams or YouTube channel today and being met with segments called "Lunchtime Suicide". That's what happened to many fans when they hopped onto WWE.com in 2006. Admittedly, those are just out of reach for an article dedicated to everything wrong with 2005, but not to worry - the promotion pushed the idea of suicidal thoughts that year too.
At Armageddon '05, Josh Mathews visited former WWE referee Tim White at his 'Friendly Tap' bar. There, he found a depressed Tim behind the counter serving customers. When asked, White admitted he was struggling with depression since getting injured back at Judgment Day 2002 during a Hell In A Cell bout between Triple H and Chris Jericho. He'd also attempted (and failed) to return in 2004, but had to call it quits due to injuries.
This was melancholy enough without what happened next. Almost without warning, White grabbed a shotgun and threatened to end his life on pay-per-view. The cameras went dark, and the insinuation was that Tim had killed himself during the show. WWE went straight to a Cruiserweight Title match between Juventud Guerrera and Kid Kash.
The whole sorry scene was dreadful at the time and it's dreadful now. The fact that someone/anyone thought promoting suicide on pay-per-view was perfectly acceptable is bad enough, but Mathews even delivered several lame jokes that attempted to make Tim White getting depressed and killing himself comedic.
Never mind rubbish excuses like, 'This was a different time'. People were shocked by this back in 2005. Pretty much anyone you spoke to agreed that it was in poor taste.
4. Chavo Guerrero Becomes Kerwin White
Chavo Guerrero once pitched dressing up as a member of racist, white supremacist group the Ku Klux Klan whilst moonlighting as offshoot gimmick Kerwin White in 2005. He told Chris Van Vliet in 2020 that Vince McMahon loved the idea, but WWE ultimately decided against pushing that onto television. This was obviously for the best, but the Kerwin character was shocking as it was.
Chavo debuted under the guise on the 10 September 2005 episode of Sunday Night Heat. Vignettes had aired signalling his arrival before that, and all of them had leaned on race-baiting and the idea that white supremacy was a gentle way of life (?!). Yeah, how they got away with this at all is anyone's guess, but it actually made it to screens for a few months and might not have ended so suddenly had Chavo's uncle Eddie not sadly passed away later in the year.
WWE abolished the racist gimmick following Eddie Guerrero’s death. They had to. There was no defending the Kerwin White persona anyway, but it made even less sense to have a member of the Guerrero family continue pushing such a controversial alter ego on camera in lieu of mourning 'Latino Heat' or paying respects to his life and career.
Urgh, what a disgusting situation all round.
Chavo would've surely regretted going even further with his "White Is Right" claims on Raw and Heat years later. Lord only knows what he and McMahon would've dreamt up longer term had they continued unfiltered. Simply put, Kerwin White is one of the worst things wrestling has ever done, let alone one of the worst from 2005.
3. The Sheer Shock Of “Bestiality Sex”
Kurt Angle has been viewed as somebody who can do it all since bursting onto the scene in 1999 and earning his stripes with one of the greatest rookie years ever. By 2000, the WWF/WWE knew they could task Angle with serious grappling, soap opera style stories and even laugh out loud comedy skits at will. He'd deliver to the best of his ability, and it usually worked.
A 2005 feud opposite Booker T didn't. The pair predictably meshed well between the ropes, but their storyline was shockingly bad. At one point, Kurt went after Booker's wife Sharmell by kidnapping her and saying he wanted to have "bestiality sex" with her. This is something Angle looked back on with an embarrassed glance now. Vince McMahon came up with that line (don't pretend to be shocked), but Kurt likely could've spoken up and vetoed it.
He didn't.
Later, Angle claimed in promos that Sharmell had fondled him behind Book's back. The plot was unnecessary when considering that Booker and Kurt were top workers who could have great matches in their sleep. They didn't need any of this kidnapping business, and they 100% didn't need any chat about bestiality.
It's a pity that this was one of Angle's last major feuds in WWE before leaving for TNA the following year. That jump proved to be successful from an in-ring perspective, but the stench of his rivalry with Booker and Sharmell sullied memories of his core run with the market leader pre-exit.
Never, ever use the words "bestiality sex" in a promo again. Pretty please?
2. WWE Airs Muhammad Hassan’s Attack
UPN pointed the finger of blame squarely at WWE for this incident, but the company would be forgiven for asking some questions themselves. After all, their SmackDown show had already been taped days earlier and shipped off to the station for airing on 7 July. Bruce Prichard later claimed that nothing could be done to edit the footage back then due to technological limitations, but surely someone should've screened the episode and realised: 'Yeah, we can't air this right now'.
A terror attack in London, England took place on 7 July. Later that same day, UPN showed the latest SmackDown, and it included a controversial (to say the least) segment involving Muhammad Hassan and The Undertaker. During it, Hassan led a group of hooded men in a violent attack on 'Taker, then they carried his unconscious body out in ceremonial fashion.
It was in poor taste and was definitely edgy to begin with, but the real-life misery people were going through made things even worse. This was a PR disaster, both for WWE and UPN, and the TV network weren't happy about it. They felt like they'd been hung out to dry by the promotion. In reality, nobody had any way of predicting what'd happen in the real world.
The timing was atrocious. To people worldwide, it looked like WWE were glorifying what had just happened in London and were not-so-subtly trying to turn that fear into a wrestling storyline. It was difficult to look at Hassan's brutal ambush of Undertaker any other way, to be honest.
It wasn't long until the Muhammad Hassan character was pulled from shows.
1. Wrestling Loses Eddie Guerrero
WWE staff, wrestlers, management and fans were ill-prepared for 13 November 2005. That day, the industry lost one of its most talented sons. Eddie Guerrero died in his hotel room. His nephew Chavo was the one who found him, but medics couldn't save Eddie's life. He was only 38 years old, and he seemed to have years of top tier matches ahead of him.
Worse, Guerrero was also a young father and husband. He should've been able to enjoy more time with his family, but his life was cruelly snuffed out during his prime years. Word quickly spread about Eddie's death, but nobody could really fathom it. After all, he'd literally just appeared in a match vs. Mr. Kennedy on the 11 November edition of SmackDown (taped on 8 November), and nothing seemed to be amiss.
WWE held a touching tribute episode to Guerrero’s memory. It was heartbreaking to witness. Various wrestlers broke down when talking about their fallen friend, then video packages in memory of 'Latino Heat' had tears flowing all over again. It was one of the saddest times in history to be a pro wrestling fan.
People still feel a pang of grief when they think about where they were when they heard that Eddie had passed away.
Thankfully, Guerrero had ascended to main event status and enjoyed a WWE Title reign the year prior. That was no substitute for lost life, of course, but his fans remain grateful that Eddie experienced such a career high. 2005 will forever be remembered as the year one of the greats left us.
What other moments from WWE's 2005 should go here? For more wrestling, check out 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2003 and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2004!