10 WWE Fates Worse Than Death
Some WWE stars probably wished the company had just killed their characters off instead.
WWE has an erm...rich history of killing characters off onscreen randomly. They're not the only company to do that, of course (Lucha Underground once went wild with it), but high profile examples include Torrie Wilson's dad Al snuffing it because he can't keep up with a new bride in the bedroom, Paul Bearer getting drowned/suffocated in cement, and even Vince McMahon's limousine blowing up.
In typical wrestling fashion, some of those names actually returned to TV afterwards like nothing had happened. There are rarely any concrete (sorry, Paul!) rules when it comes to penning this stuff. Creative just make it up as they go along. That'd explain some of the outright insanity analysed in these pages. You'd swear that some of the wrestlers involved would probs rather have been written out with a kayfabe passing.
At least that'd spare some blushes.
Not everything is a writing team's mess though. Some "fates worse than death" came due to production mishaps that proved to be agonising for the guy afflicted. Another (g) string of incidents happened because one salty worker disliked some of his peers or was asked to dish out smelly punishments to those acting up behind the scenes.
These are totally different from onscreen deaths detailed before. Nobody was killed off, and they all lived to fight another day in some form or fashion. That is, of course, once they'd stopped gagging, vomiting, come out of hospital or quit hunting down members of the creative team for a quiet word.
Onscreen mercy killings might've been preferable to any of this, to be honest!
10. Taking A Rock Bottom On Dog Poop
"The British Bulldog's gonna win, whether he wants to or not!". That iconic line uttered by a happy kid before attending SummerSlam 1992 at the old Wembley Stadium in London, England could be adapted for this entry: 'The British Bulldog's gonna get slammed on some mushed up brownies, whether he wants to or not!'. Wait, what? Brownies?! Oh yes, that wasn't actually dog poo on the 11 October 1999 episode of Raw.
People didn't know that at the time though, so everyone tuning into the show believed The Rock had hit his Rock Bottom finisher and poor Davey Boy Smith had ended up covered in poop. The Brit would've been thankful that these were just excess cakes from catering made to look like a pile of brown smelly stuff, but it still wasn't a banner night for him personally.
A mild entry for this list to kick off with, shall we say, but still a mortifying experience nobody would want to live out. Imagine going into your workplace, saying good morning, then immediately being scooped up and sent tumbling into a handy platter of dog crap. Why was it even there to begin with? Is there anybody in the HR department you can talk to? Who's going to get these stains out of this brand new, out of the packet M&S shirt?!
This was certainly an inauspicious way for Bulldog to kick off his latest stint in the then-WWF, put it that way. He was a shadow of his former self, and anyone watching could see that, but now here he was being Rock Bottomed right onto some jobby. YES! It feels great to get that decidedly-Scottish word into an article.
Most wrestlers do a job, but Smith got a jobby.
9. Watching Your Pet Spider Get Squashed
What was the deal with Erick Rowan's pet (and possibly robotic) spider back in 2020? That pre-pandemic storyline was squashed (literally) before he could even really get going with it, but that's likely because the whole thing was stupid to begin with. WWE set up a mystery angle for the ex-Wyatt Family man without having any clue how it'd shake out.
This was typical latter-day Vince McMahon nonsense. The old boss might well have said, 'Ah, we'll figure it out pal!' when asked what the end goal for Erick's 'carry this around in a cage' gimmick was. 'Figure it out' translated to, 'Stop asking questions I don't have the answer to - I know this is silly, but I want to do it anyway because I'm running out of ideas for Raw'.
Rowan eventually clued everybody in that he was carting around a big robot-looking arachnid on the 2 March episode of Raw. Exactly a week later, Drew McIntyre grabbed the cage and squished the spider inside it on the 9 March edition. So, the real suffering here came for poor Erick. That spider was his only friend in the whole world, and some big angry Scotsman had just mauled it for no good reason.
What a jobby. Right, enough of that. Verging on, "JBL Is Poopy" or "Fudge, Baloney, Mustard" territory here.
Rowan's love affair with little (little?!) spidey was crushed in the blink of an eye. He had to be heartbroken. Not as heartbroken as he'd be when the heartless gits at WWE released him due to budget cuts the next month.
8. Getting Covered In Dog Food
3 of the 4 men pictured above went on to create "cinema" as part of The Bloodline story, but they were in bargain bin B-movie territory on the 31 January 2020 episode of SmackDown. WWE was still in the iron grip of Vince McMahon's worst era of booking. Genuinely. 2019-2020 gave anything from 1995 a run for its money. Yes, even 'King' Mabel.
Speaking of royalty, 'King' Corbin had to get his comeuppance after feuding with 'Big Dog' Roman. The company went literal with this by having Baron and his pals mock a mascot made to look like the eh...big dog from Reigns entrances. Things peaked (or dipped, which would be more fitting for this article) in late-January when Corbin lost a match to Roman and thus had to be covered in pints and pints of dog chow.
Corbin has since revealed that the food smelled awful. It was so foul, in fact, that the smell almost made him vomit chunks live on air. As Baron tried to maintain his composure and keep his lunch down, Reigns and The Usos celebrated and acted like they were the most hilarious bros on campus. Not quite Bloodline greatness, eh?
This would actually be a tipping point for Roman. He said enough was enough and marched off to map out his 'Tribal Chief' rebrand for the summer. Well, he did that after taking time out due to COVID concerns, but the point stands. The smell of that dog meat probs wasn't out of Corbin's clothes by the time Reigns returned to action with a bang at SummerSlam.
'Sad' Corbin right enough.
7. Getting A Literal Farting Gimmick
Every wrestler under contract prays to the good lord above that WWE higher-ups have something amazing in mind for them. For example, imagine how over the moon Ted DiBiase must've been when Vince McMahon laid out the once in a lifetime 'Million Dollar Man' character to him. Or, picture how chuffed Becky Lynch had to be when ideas for 'The Man' started to properly take shape in 2019.
Poor Natalya had an altogether different experience to those workers.
She was inflicted with one of McMahon’s worst ideas in February 2012. The boss (or some other creative team member) called the veteran over and said they had something new in mind for her. She’d fart all over the place in backstage promos and skits (careful!) as other workers looked disgusted or embarrassed for her. Boy that'd put some butts in (toilet) seats!
Viewers had second hand embarrassment for Nattie, and no wonder. This was rotten, so to speak. She might’ve preferred if had WWE said they planned to kill her off on-screen for good. Living this one down was going to take some doing. Somehow, Natalya has managed to shake off the stink of this gimmick and power forward, but who knows why anyone thought this was a grand idea?
Everyone from Beth Phoenix to Teddy Long held their noses whenever Nattie was around. The Great Khali didn't seem to mind though. He worked a romance with Natalya that also went nowhere. Do the writing staff just pick these things out of a hat and roll with whatever? That's what it smacks of.
'The Flatulence Of Execution' was some gimmick.
6. Accidentally Eating Your Own Chihuahua
There was kayfabe death involved in this. Lil' Pepper the doggo was murdered and turned into a "delicious" meal by the Big Boss Man, all so he could build towards a pay-per-view match with Al Snow. In fairness, Al should've smelled a rat early. His arch nemesis wanted to patch things up by inviting him to a rundown hotel room for a slap up feast out of the blue?
Stupid babyfaces are stupid. Come on, Al. Wake up, buddy! This made the deranged hero look like an absolute goof, and not in a lovably endearing way. No, Snow just looked so thick for trusting Boss Man and turning up at the hotel like this was the most normal thing in the world. If a corrupt corrections officer with a rich history of extreme violence fired out Facebook invites for this party, would you go?
Please don't say yes.
Al ran off as fast as his legs could carry him, and he was shown tucking into Boss Man's culinary genius on the 2 September 1999 episode of SmackDown. Then, once he'd finished stuffing his merry face, Al found out that he'd just enjoyed Pepper. Outrageous. He wanted a hole to appear in that hotel room floor (there might've been one judging by the state of the place) so he could sink into it.
This led to the infamous ‘Kennel From Hell’ match at Unforgiven that's best-known for mutts around ringside humping one another and defecating all over the place. Maybe they were staging a dirty protest in honour of Al Snow's heart after it kicked in that he'd just munched his own pet with a smile.
5. Potentially Getting Infected By Pig Crap
It's important to point out that this wasn't a punishment for the 'Curtain Call' incident at Madison Square Garden. People sometimes get their timings messed up when claiming it is; the 'Curtain Call' took place on 19 May 1996, but In Your House 5 took place before that on 17 December 1995. So, in other words, the WWF didn't view this as a means to punish Triple H for his part in that send off for Razor Ramon and Diesel with Shawn Michaels.
This was just a way to exploit his sneering upper class character by bringing it down a peg or 2. Hunter might've needed a peg for his nose on the night. He'd also surely have needed to see a doctor for some shots, because Mr. Helmsley flirted with disaster in mid-December '95. This wasn't quite the innocent comedy match it was presented as.
At IYH 5, Triple H worked an 'Arkansas Hog Pen Match' with Henry Godwinn. At one stage during the bout, Trips suffered a huge gash on his back, and he was visibly bleeding from it by the time he rolled around in pig s*** for a 'ha ha' spot later on. That was risky, and it could’ve had severe consequences for him had docs not been on hand to clean him up.
Let's be real: Rubbing actual pig poop into an open wound is not a champion idea. Hunter could've infected that wound rather easily. He's pretty lucky nothing bad came of this and he was able to get straight back to work on the road. The only explanation for this is that Trips didn't know he was wounded.
Surely he wouldn't have kept rolling around in crap if he did.
4. Kissing Someone’s BBQ Feet
Michael Cole's 2010-2011 heel turn ranged from passable to downright terrible. The worst of it came when he was ridiculing Jerry Lawler's recently-deceased mother or ruining matches by trolling as one of the most obnoxious bad guy announcers ever. There's some difference between a heel colour commentator and a heel play-by-play guy - play-by-play runs the show, so they talk too much to be constantly aggressive and dismissive of babyfaces.
WWE let Cole run amok with it though. He stunk out the ring opposite Lawler in a match that was far too long at WrestleMania XXVII, then they had a 'Country Whipping' tag bout also involving Jim Ross and Jack Swagger at Extreme Rules 2011. The following month, Michael then worked a 'Kiss My Foot' match with Jerry that again hogged far too much TV time in the build up to the pay-per-view.
Mercifully, it was a short, 3-minute affair on the night, but it'd live with Cole longer than that. He lost, then had BBQ sauce poured in his mouth by a vengeful JR before suckling on Lawler's toes. That had to be utterly disgusting. Jerry's feet would've been horrible enough to kiss without the added barbecue sauce shenanigans. That cold sauce mixed with cheesy tootsies? No thanks.
Credit to Cole for giving it his all, but this wasn't what people wanted to see on WWE PPV. They'd had more than enough of this commentary team rivalry, and most were screaming for Michael to return to his largely inoffensive, mild-mannered play-by-play guise. That'd happen eventually, at least.
Just go towards the white light, Mike. It'll all be over soon!
3. Taking Rikishi’s Stinkiest Stinkface
This is foul.
Workers suffering it couldn't head towards the white light, because it'd been shaded brown by Rikishi's giant butt being shoved right in their faces. His 'Stinkface' has become one of the most simultaneously cherished and disgusting spots in wrestling lore for a reason. Back then, it was over like rover as one of the big man's go to spots during matches.
Here's where things get awful. Rikishi has admitted that he had different sets of gear he’d wear depending on who he was working with. If he liked you, then he’d wear the clean thong/tights. If he didn’t, then you’d get stuff that had been sitting in his bag unwashed for weeks/months. In an even more repulsive move, Kish would also reportedly go for a huge dump before matches if he hated you, and wouldn’t clean his butt properly.
That’s just flat out gross. Here’s hoping it isn’t true and he/others were just at the windup when talking about it. Honestly, it's frankly unacceptable to think that somebody was allowed to rub their un-wiped anus on somebody else's face as thousands of happy wrestling fans cheered in unison and millions more laughed back home. That'd be a bad day for anybody, backstage annoyance or not.
It isn't crystal clear exactly who suffered the consequences of rubbing folks behind the curtain the wrong way, and Rikishi delivered a whole host of 'Stinkfaces' throughout his peak run. Hell, the move was so popular that this writer had a poster of him giving Val Venis one on his bedroom wall.
No, yours truly isn't proud of admitting that!
2. Getting Intimate…With Your Own Family!
At times, it was almost like the WWF wanted Mark Henry to call quits on his jump from Olympic weightlifting to pro wrestling. He'd started off as a babyface Olympian in 1996 and joined the Nation Of Domination in 1998, but nothing seemed to be getting him over. Then, somebody came up with the bright idea of outing Mark as a sex addict who needed "Sex Therapy" sessions on Raw in 1999.
During those skits, Henry revealed that he’d been addicted to sex since childhood and had even had relations with his own sister. Just stop talking, mate. Of course, this created the cult-classic ’Sexual Chocolate’ gimmick and led to his onscreen romance with pensioner Mae Young, but man...Mark must've thought someone backstage wanted him gone if this was all they had in mind for him.
The WWF booked actual incest on their programming, or at least hinted at it happening with one of their superstars. What's more, Henry said that he wasn't really ashamed of it. He'd have sex with anybody close to him. Hell, he wanted to get it on with the therapist too. This was peak 'Attitude Era' raunch, but it backed Mark into a corner as a ridiculously-perverted character who'd stop at nothing to get his rocks off.
In hindsight, he'd have been forgiven for saying: 'Just throw me into the abyss on TV and call it a day, guys'.
Becoming the first WWF/WWE star to officially brag about having sex with a member of his own family was sure something. It wasn't reality, clearly, but Henry waxed lyrical about all of the hijinks he'd get up to as a kid. Eek! That's dangerous territory for sure, and not the sort of thing anybody expects to see when they tune into a wrestling program.
1. Being Cooked Alive Mid-Match
There was hell to pay for an unfortunate member of WWE's production team at Elimination Chamber 2010. Someone let some pyro off too early (or it was set up wrongly) and ended up scorching The Undertaker. His trench coat caught ablaze, so he had to ditch it during his entrance and storm to the ring in a bad mood. 'Taker was also in a lot of pain for the rest of the night.
His flesh was literally cooking as officials around ringside doused him in water and he stormed uncomfortably around his Chamber pod. That had to be torture for ‘The Deadman’, and an interesting experience for fans on that side of the ring. They'd have surely heard some choice words coming out of the legend's mouth as he tried to get his head back in the game and fend off the weird mix of physical pain and mental embarrassment.
Undertaker's entrance was always a key part of his act, so it wouldn't have sat well with him that it was cut off by reckless production/pyro.
This would definitely have to rank as one of the most bizarre WWE injuries ever. The staffer responsible must've been fearing for their life throughout the entire match, because 'Taker was furious. Accidents happen, but someone had to be held accountable for nearly burning one of the biggest stars in the biz to a crisp live on pay-per-view.
The mere thought of Undertaker's arms, chest, back and shoulders cooking away as he writhed around the pod is excruciating. He got lucky. The staff member culpable for that early button press/setting pyro up in the wrong spot? Not so much.
What other WWE fates were worse than death? For more wrestling, check out 15 Times WCW Was Better Than Literally EVERYTHING and 10 Worst WWE Moments Of 2002!