12 Most Notorious Batman Urban Legends

Decoding the Dark Knight's biggest myths...

The Joker Makeup Test
Warner Bros.

Like Star Wars, Marvel and Disney in general, the Batman brand is one that tends to inspire its own world of over-enthusiastic fandom.

Though the comics aren't quite as big business as they once were (they still make millions), each film release comes with a hype machine so tangible you can almost taste it in the air, and as fans and media race to feed into that excitement, it's inevitable that some half-truths and untruths end up being peddled out as fact.

Even with the Internet apparently offering an infinite resource for fact-checking, emotional fandom has a habit of riding rough-shod over the truth and giving birth to some Urban Legends that run wild and end up gathering pace as more fans become intoxicated by their ideas.

Right now, we're staring down the barrel of one of the biggest periods for Batman in decades (thanks to the 80th anniversary of his creation), rumours on what could be happening have begun tumbling out of every crevice of the Internet. Whether they'll ever occupy the same sort of space as some of the biggest Batman urban legends of all time in years to come remains to be seen.

Most stunningly of all, of course, is the revelation that some urban legends are actually true...


12. There's A Batman Curse

Batman The Joker Jack Nicholson
Warner Bros.

Verdict: Questionable, but there's evidence.

According to accepted wisdom, there's a hellish Batman curse that has killed and almost killed numerous people over the years.

Back in the 60s, Burt Ward was almost killed on the first day of shooting Batman 1969 (mostly because his stunt-man looked nothing like him and wasn't used, ridiculously), but it wasn't until the Dark Knight trilogy that things started to tumble.

Stuntman Conway Wickliffe was killed in a stunt on The Dark Knight, Heath Ledger died tragically while filming The Imaginarium Of Doctor Parnassus, Morgan Freeman was almost killed in a car wreck in 2008 and Anne Hathaway's stunt double was almost killed after crashing into cameras during The Dark Knight Rises shoot.

And finally, the plane used in TDKR prologue to transport Dr. Pavel crashed in Botswana almost a year after the film was released killing the pilot and co-pilot.

The case of sadistic killer James Holmes murdering 12 people and injuring 50 at the opening night of The Dark Knight Rises in Aurora, Colorado is often cited as part of the "curse" but that comes down to an unhinged individual with a dangerous agenda. Unfortunately, thanks to these tragic coincidences, the mythology of the curse will appeal to certain commenters who will continue to perpetuate it.


11. Batman 1966's Set Was An Orgy (And Burt Ward Did Porn)

Camp Batman Adam West
Warner Bros.

Verdict: True-ish and Untrue

In 1991, former Boy Wonder Burt Ward released a "tell-all" expose of his time as Robin, which effectively painted a picture of the set as a constant orgy, fuelled by free-running sex (which Adam West couldn't complete sometimes) and debauchery.

One interview released at the time, selling the book to potential audiences includes a raft of lurid revelations, though all introduced with the caveat that it was the 60s and everyone was boinking everyone else, so it was fine:

"Well first of all, good question...people did know about. The people on the show. I mean when you come into the set at 7:30 in the morning and you come out of make-up and the first thing you know, the ladies start coming into our dressing rooms at 7:45. We're talking about wild times in the dressing rooms, on the set, between the shots, in the lunch wagon. When we got home at night after fourteen hours on the set, I think we redefined the meaning of the word pleasure pad. And then of course, doing the personal appearances on the weekend, that's where it really got wild. And I have to be honest with you, we became like sexual vampires."

It all sounds too weird to be true, which it partly was. Later - presumably after cashing his check from the book sales - Ward admitted that he was goaded by the publishers to make the book more interesting, and just made most of it up, including his vengeful claims of West's failure to perform sexually.

As a weird side-conspiracy, it was widely alleged (particularly before the age of IMDB) that Burt Ward did porn after struggling to find work post-Batman. He did no such thing (and married into a millionaire family, so it's not like he needed to). Perhaps the rumour came from this quote about his Batman audition?

"To be perfectly honest, I didn't even know what I was trying out for. The producers didn't tell me. I remember that I went in for my screen test and two guys pulled off my pants and pulled on these leotards. I was afraid I was auditioning for a porno flick."

10. Disney-Owned Critics Killed Batman v Superman (And Suicide Squad)

DC Rotten Tomatoes Splats
DC Comics

Verdict: Bullsh*t.

According to popular fanboy ire in the wake of the critical mauling of both Batman v Superman and Suicide Squad, Marvel-financed critics flooded the web - and specifically Rotten Tomatoes - with poor reviews in order to kill the hype around the movies, stopping them hitting the delicious $1bn box office take.

It's very much a case of raging against the dying of the light, as the idea that anyone could coordinate a pay-off on that scale - with a load of opinionated journalists who would love nothing more than a story as juicy as bribery and intrigue - is just ludicrous.

At least, that's what it says in this email I have from Marvel that I'm not allowed to admit they paid me, anyway.


9. There Was Supposed To Be A Dark Knight Tie-In Video Game

The Dark Knight Video Game
Pandemic Studios

Verdict: True

Before the Batman: Arkham games were released to massive critical acclaim, there was initially going to be a tie-in game for The Dark Knight that would have been released in June 2008. It wasn't widely publicised, and began to take on the label of being an urban legend when it didn't materialise.

It was particularly talked about in those terms because the only mention of it publicly came from Gary Oldman accidentally.

The truth is that the game did exist, but was killed by Star Wars: Battlefront developer Pandemic failing to hit their schedule. The release date was pushed back to December '08 to suit the blu-ray release, but still they failed to deliver and the game was cancelled, leaving behind a bill of $100m and a few whispering glimpses of what could have been...


8. Christian Bale Was Asked To Return For Batman v Superman

The Dark Knight Rises Batman Bruce Wayne Christian Bale
Warner Bros. Pictures

Verdict: Untrue.

Because everyone was so sad about the end of the Christopher Nolan Batman trilogy, fans took it upon themselves in the early days of Batman v Superman's production to fabricate some rumours around the series' links to the new chapter.

Nolan was linked to directing for a while by hopeful chancers, and there was a time when the Internet was awash with attempts to paint the stories together seamlessly. Even more excitingly for fans, it was said that Christian Bale was even approached to pull on his Bat-cowl again, proving the films were set in the same universe.

That ignores the fact that such claims are bullsh*t: Bale told Esquire that the rumours he was offered an eye-watering amount to return were as far off-base as him playing James Bond:

“No, I’ve never heard of that. Equally untrue about them coming to me for Batman, before Ben Affleck… I think it’s the right decision... People were talking about this obscene amount of money they were saying was thrown at me. No. I didn’t have a single conversation with anybody about ever playing the role again.”

7. Bob Kane Purposefully Diminished Bill Finger's Role In Creating Batman

Batman V Superman Bill Finger
DC/Warner Bros/Charlesbridge

Verdict: True

It sounds awful, particularly now that DC have started crediting Bill Finger as co-creator of Batman, but Bob Kane spent a lot of effort crushing the perception that Finger was as important to the character's creation as he was. He consciously and very publicly called out those claims as incorrect, threatening to sue those who published them.

Infamously, he sent a letter to fanzine BatMania's editor Biljo White stating in no uncertain terms that it was "All hogwash! I, Bob Kane, am the sole creator of "Batman." I created "Batman" in 1939 . . . and I signed the first strip.."

The long letter called such accusations "fraudulent and entirely untrue", mostly because the original Batman strip carried only Kane's name in the by-line (as if that was any concrete indication):

"The truth is that Bill Finger is taking credit for much more than he deserves... I created the title, masthead, the format and concept, as well as the Batman figure and costume. Robin, the boy wonder, was also my idea, . . . not Bill's.The only proof I need to back my statement is that if Bill co-authored and conceived the idea, either with me or before me, then he would most certainly have a by-line on the strip along with my name, the same as Siegel and Schuster had as creators of Superman."

It's all pretty cutting to read, and the intent to diminish influence - particularly in context of what happened later - is discomforting to say the least.

To give Kane his due, in his 1989 autobiography 'Batman and Me', he did eventually concede that Finger was "a contributing force" on the series, saying "I must admit that Bill never received the fame and recognition he deserved." He changed his tune massively, in other words.


6. Batman Was Almost Cancelled In The 1960s

Batman 1963
DC Comics

Verdict: Untrue (probably).

After flagging sales at the start of the 1960s, DC played with the idea of cancelling the character altogether, and that the character was teetering in 1963 before the introduction of the New Look by new editor Julius Schwartz revived it.

But consider the context: at the time, Batman was still all over DC's covers and was still featuring heavily in World's Finest. He was far from considered toxic and he remained the flagship even as he was supposedly circling the drain. The reality is that the New Look - which coincided with the 300th issue - was a marketing ploy, and so was the dire circumstances.

According to the excellent Silver Age Comics blog's take, Batman was still the 10th best-selling comic in 1962, out-selling JLA or Flash, or Green Lantern, and "20 other mags that DC was publishing at the time". That excellent run-down pours scorn on the idea of cancellation, instead looking at it as a necessary reshuffle, which is far more likely.

Interestingly, Gerard Jones's Men of Tomorrow (via OzAndEnds blog) claims that Bob Kane's 1947 contract stipulated that he'd retain all rights to the character if Batman was cancelled. Would DC really have handed over the rights in total and forever? Unlikely.

Artist Carmine Infantino claimed that one of the issues was that Bob Kane wasn't even doing the work, farming it out to ghosts, but Kane's letter to BatMania claimed that as utter BS - there he said he still did 90% of the Batman work. That much was untrue, but the cancellation probably wasn't.


5. Jai Courtney Took Drugs And Self-Abused For Suicide Squad

Suicide Squad Captain Boomerang Camera
Warner Bros.

Verdict: Apparently True.

The stories of what happened on the Suicide Squad set could probably make for a diverting expose movie in their own right. The studio allegedly waded in to edit their own film, strong-arming David Ayer into claiming it as his own in the process; Jared Leto ran wild over his co-stars, staying in character by sending disturbing gifts to everyone; and Ayer encouraged some weird methods for getting into character.

And by weird, he sent actors into the woods alone, made them read up on the psychology of murder and generally let them all throw restraint out of the window. Somewhat notoriously, he apparently also accepted some dangerous behaviour from Jai Courtney on his way to his best performance.

According to Yahoo, Courtney went the extra mile in a Skype call to Ayer by taking drugs and burning himself with a cigarette:

“That night I happened to eat some mushrooms… and I did self-inflict some burns."

And people say acting is easy!


4. The Delayed Explosion Scene In The Dark Knight Was Ad-Libbed

The Dark Knight Joker Button
Warner Bros.

Verdict: Untrue.

As a mark of Heath Ledger's genius performance as The Joker in The Dark Knight Rises, the story goes that he ad-libbed one of the film's most notorious scenes: when Mr J tries to blow up the hospital but is foiled by a faulty remote.

Rumour always had it that the malfunction was unintentional and Ledger styled it out so well that it made it into the final film. Which is a nice, romantic myth, but a made up one, unfortunately.

As revealed in the film's blu-ray special editions, the scene was shot as it was shown in the final cut and the delay was deliberate, in order to allow Ledger to be right next to the building when he tried to blow it up first. The scene was "endlessly rehearsed" according to the in-film Focus Point description, which specifies 12 different dry runs.

So it might have been ad-libbed in rehearsal, but what we see clearly isn't an in-the-moment improvisation.


3. Bill Murray Almost Played Batman

Bill Murray Batman
Warner Bros.

Verdict: True(ish).

As the Internet will tell you, Bill Murray was really close to being cast as Batman in Tim Burton's 1989 Batman, which would surely have changed everything about the dark movie.

The truth is a little more complex. It wasn't Burton who would have cast Murray at all, and the film he could have starred in was mostly unrecognisable from Burton's final film. Instead, Murray was targeted by Ivan Reitman who also wanted to cast Eddie Murphy as Robin and who was attached to Tom Mankiewicz's The Batman (written in 1983), which would have initially been released in 1985.

It went through at least nine separate rewrites and eventually Burton was hired after the success of Pee Wee's Big Adventure in 1985, at which point he rejected Tom Mankiewicz's script as too campy. So there was no way he entertained the Murray link either.


2. Trump's Inauguration Speech Stolen From Bane

Bane The Dark Knight Rises
Warner Bros.

Verdict: Fake News! (But not fully).

The Internet is to blame for a lot of things, and turning Donald Trump into a Nazi capable of James Bond villain schemes through half-truths and blatant lies is one of its worst crimes - particularly when the truth is bad enough indictment.

As well as claiming he stole a speech from Bee Movie (an insufferable meme now), it was also said that Trump stole Bane's speech from The Dark Knight Rises for his inauguration speech, and mainstream media sites regurgitated the claim.

Jezebel was the first to make the link:

Trump:

“But we are transferring power from Washington D.C. and giving it back to you… the people. For too long a small group in our nation’s capital has reaped the rewards of government while the people have born the cost.”

Bane:

“We take Gotham from the corrupt! The rich! The oppressors of generations who have kept you down with myths of opportunity, and we give it back to you… the people. Gotham is yours. None shall interfere.”

He didn't “directly lift” the speech, but as The Independent remarks Trump’s speech does “share... eerie sentiments” with Bane's rabble-rousing speech. They're both populist, they both seek to inspire a similar uprising, but whether he actually sat down and cribbed from The Dark Knight Rises remains a little doubtful.

At least let's hope so.


1. Playing The Joker Killed Heath Ledger

The Joker Makeup Test
Warner Bros.

Verdict: Untrue.

According to the narrative that swirled around Heath Ledger's death - particularly thanks to the revelation of his personal "Joker diary" - his experience shooting The Dark Knight caused him permanent mental trauma. He was left with insomnia after channelling his dark side too closely and required sleeping pils to help him get any sleep.

That was pointed out as the "reason" for his death, adding a mythology to his performance that arguably makes it even more astonishing.

But his sister says it's untrue, speaking to The Daily Telegraph as documentary I Am Heath Ledger was on the verge of premiering.

“I spoke to him the night before (he died) and we were laughing and joking... He was so proud of what he had done in Batman. And I know he had plans for another Batman. He loved working with Chris Nolan and Christian Bale and Gary Oldman. He just had the best time ever doing that film. When he came home at Christmas he couldn’t wait to tell us all about it and he was doing the voice and laughing, showing me all the rushes. We had a great time.”

She denies that he died because of the role, even as Jack Nicholson revealed that he allegedly "warned" Ledger about using Ambien after he almost drove off a cliff while using them himself.

What other urban legends belong on this list? Share your favourites below in the comments thread.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.