Captain Marvel: 10 Biggest Changes From The Comics

The MCU continues to be very loose with its adaptations, and it keeps working.

Captain Marvel Skrulls
Marvel Studios

Marvel Studios' take on Captain Marvel has remained true to the formula that the MCU has established. Like Civil War, Ragnarok, Age Of Ultron and every other major storyline they've adatped, it is no more than a very loose adaptation of the source material that leads to audiences.

And when the reactions are as good as they've been almost universally across the board for the MCU so far, why would they mess with that formula?

With that in mind, us expecting to see a pure adaptation of any Captain Marvel comic was probably foolish from the very start. And now the film is out, there are some seriously significant changes made to the comics ranging from the small details like changing Chewie's name to Goose right up to major character and story changes...

10. Star Force

Captain Marvel Star Force
Marvel

While the Star Force of the comics and the one in the movie acted in pretty much the same capacity – that being an elite group of Kree warriors, there are a few notable differences between the two versions.

For a start, the group lacks the presence of any version of Captain Marvel or Yon-Rogg, making them a far more minor team in the comics.

The presentation of the roster is also far more fitting with its medium, due to how the characters on the roster sport unique, colourful costumes instead of the uniformed attire of the movie, with Dr. Minerva wearing an outfit similar to Danvers’ original Ms. Marvel costume and Atlas wearing the exact same costume that Mar-Vell wore in his MU debut.

Keeping with this far wackier theme, the group were also depicted as out and out villains, instead of the morally ambiguous soldiers of the MCU. For example, their main appearance as a team saw them battle the Avengers as Earth’s mightiest heroes attempt to broker peace between the Shi’ar and Kree, and following this Dr. Minerva has been a recurring antagonist of the Captain.


9. Carol's Relationship With Nick Fury

Captain Marvel Fury
Marvel

In the comics, Carol Danvers and Nick Fury haven’t really interacted all that much, something that the movie really changed.

Though, one of the times that did see them quite have a fair amount of shared panel time was in Marvel’s Ultimate universe – a relaunched version of the mainline Earth-616 continuity – which saw many of the publisher’s characters reimagined.

This timeline gave us the incarnation of Nick Fury that appears in the MCU, with the casting of the character as Samuel L. Jackson actually stemming from the depiction of the spy in the Ultimate universe. Carol however received a kind of downgrade being transformed from a superhero to someone acting in similar capacity to Fury – even being director of S.H.I.E.L.D for some time.

Her being in such a position led to the two going to war with one another in the Civil War-esque conflict Avengers Vs. New Ultimates – a rather large departure from the buddy cop dynamic of the movie.


8. The Origin Of Carol's Costume

Captain Marvel Suit
Marvel

In the comics, Carol's costume was clearly designed simply to evoke the same design principles of Mar-Vell's suit, with a the colour palette being a slightly brighter version of the original and the same Hala star logo featuring on the chests of both outfits.

Now, this may seem like a rather miniscule change, but its implications are quite the opposite. You see, in the books the choice of colour really is inconsequential, though, in the movie, it signifies a major turning point for Carol.

Choosing the same colours as that of the United States air force shirt that Monica was wearing signifies how Danvers' has finally accepted who she is and that Yon-Rogg and the rest of Star Force aren't the best of people, with the keeping of her Kree uniform also symbolising that she is a citizen of two worlds even with the deceit she received from her supposed allies on Hala.


7. How Fury Lost His Eye

Captain Marvel Fury Eye
Marvel

While the moment that saw Goose/Chewie scratch Fury's eye to such a degree that it was irreparable was undoubtedly humorous, it wasn't quite as dramatic as how it happened in the comics.

For the original Nick Fury (who is basically the same character you know from the MCU, but Caucasian), his eye was lost thanks to a piece of shrapnel gained during the second world war.

And more recently, for his son, Nick Fury Jr. (a character created to resemble the Samuel L. Jackson incarnation) had his eye cut out by assassins attempting to get some of the Infinity Formula flowing through his veins, the formula being the one that had given his father such a long life.

Finally, for the Ultimate version of the character (the one based off of Jackson that led to the actor being cast in the MCU) he lost his eye in an as a result of an attack on the convoy transporting Wolverine that he was a part of.

Maybe if we get a fourth comic book Nick Fury he'll have better luck keeping both his eyes intact.


6. The Reason For Carol's Amnesia

Captain Marvel Amnesia
Marvel

Over her long tenure on Marvel's roster of characters, Carol Danvers has lost her memory quite a few times.

Originally this was because her Ms. Marvel persona functioned like a split personality, with Carol having no recollection of her heroic actions, but the most notable instance of the hero losing her memories was during Danvers' early days as the Captain.

In the Kelly Sue DeConnick written series, the first solo-outing of this incarnation of the character, a Kree structure in Carol's brain caused the hero to have a brain haemorrhage (with every time she used her powers prior to this bringing her closer to it), leading to the Captain losing years of memories, a tale slightly different to the version depicted in the movie.


5. Why Carol Is In Space

Captain Marvel Space
Marvel

Unlike her Kree kidnapping and indoctrination on-screen, Danvers' reasoning for being in space in the comics is entirely voluntary.

Also unlike the film, the Captain hadn't really left our solar system for an extended period of time, with her only really venturing into the stars to face a cosmic threat alongside the Avengers or X-Men, but that all changed in, you guessed, Kelly Sue DeConnick's run.

Following Jonathan Hickman's brilliantly written Infinity event (a book which Avengers: Infinity War drew a lot of inspiration from), Iron Man expressed to Carol how the Avengers needed a presence in space (as you can see in the image above) and wanting to go higher, further, faster and do more Danvers obviously leapt at the chance, spending many an issue off-planet.

During this time the character joined forces with the Guardians of the Galaxy on a number of occasions, something which seemed to enjoy vastly more than the waging of war seen in the film.


4. The Kree-Skrull War

Captain Marvel Kree-Skrull War
Marvel

In Captain Marvel, the Kree-Skrull war was depicted as more of a slaughter of the latter species, with the supposedly 'noble-warrior-hero' people seeking to eradicate them from the galaxy - despite how, at least for the faction of Skrulls we met, they just wanted to find a new home, and escape the devastation of the conflict.

This is somewhat different to the version seen in the comics, with both sides being a lot more evenly matched than the on-screen incarnation.

Another massive alteration to this particular set of battles was how much it involved Earth, with the Avengers, Fantastic Four and Inhumans ending up being tied up in the event - due to how Ronan The Accuser wanted to scorch the planet in order to use it as a base of operations against the Skrulls, something that the heroes inevitably stopped.

Meaning that, in essence, the Kree-Skrull war in the movie is really its own story, with the Carol Danvers, Mar-Vell, Nick Fury, the Supreme Intelligence and Ronan really being the only characters that were featured in both incarnations - though in completely different ways to that of the comic - but it worked, so it would be unfair to complain.


3. Monica Rambeau

Captain Marvel Monica Rambeau
Marvel

In Marvel Comics, there have been several characters to take up the mantle of Captain Marvel, though it may surprise those of you who don’t read the comics to hear that the first woman to do so was Monica Rambeau.

You see, in the books, Rambeau is a hero on a similar level to Carol Danvers herself with Monica being the Captain all the way back when Danvers was still using the Ms. Marvel moniker – making her arguably a much larger part of the House of Ideas’ history than the now world famous, Brie Larson portrayed hero.

In comparison, Monica’s on-screen depiction is rather lacklustre, with the character filling the role of the comics’ Kit – that being a young girl who’s very close to Carol due to their mothers being friends and the one that Danvers nicknames Lt. Trouble.


2. The Origin Of Carol's Powers

Captain Marvel Origin
Marvel

As we saw in the film, Carol received her powers when she was exposed to the Tesseract-powered FTL core, an origin far less convoluted than the one seen in the comics.

Originally, Danvers gained her abilities during her time with Mar-Vell: being caught in an explosion of a Kree device known as a psyche magnetron which merged Carol’s DNA with that of her alien boyfriend – giving her similar powers to him.

Then, in the recent Life Of Captain Marvel series by Margaret Stohl and Carlos Pacheco (spoilers, by the way), it’s confirmed that Carol’s mother was actually Kree the entire time and that the psyche magnetron only activated her powers, instead of giving them to her.

So, I think it’s safe to say that we’re all thankful that this element was changed.


1. Mar-Vell

Captain Marvel Mar-Vell
Marvel

While the version of Mar-Vell that appeared in the movie may have fit the arc set out for Carol, the character is vastly different to the one we see in the comics.

As the name suggests, Mar-Vell was the original Marvel Comics incarnation of the Captain, starting a life on Earth after being abandoned there by fellow Kree Yon-Rogg (played by Jude Law on-screen).

During his time spent on our planet, the character assumed the name Lawson (similar to the film), struck up a relationship with Carol Danvers and acted as superhero until his surprisingly emotional demise at the hands of cancer in 1982. Oh, and if you hadn’t realised already, Mar-Vell is a ‘he’ in the comics.

Compare this to the ex-soldier scientist of the movie and the differences are pretty obvious.


Contributor
Contributor

Lover of film and comics, and (according to a comment on this very website) a pulsating sack of worthless nothing!