10 Action Movie Flops That Deserve A Second Chance
Flop movies are not bad movies.
The trouble with living in a world where everything is about now is that nothing is ever afforded a second chance. If one huge-scale action movie disappoints the audience, everyone shrugs and prepares for the next one the following week.
There is, as we all know, no “best” of anything and time is the only critic whose opinion matters. Some movies that disappoint on their initial viewing may, if given the chance, become future favourites, while movies that stunned in their day become clunkier as time goes by.
Who would’ve thought that a movie like Big Trouble In Little China, which didn’t even crack the US top ten on its original release, would enjoy an afterlife (and a mooted remake starring Dwayne Johnson) while Top Gun, the same year’s biggest hit, becomes campier with each viewing?
In the name of posterity, every movie needs to be given an even break. Well, okay, maybe not Platinum Dunes’ remake of The Hitcher because that was a soulless abomination whose name shall not be spoken above a whisper for the love of God. The offer is good only for movies not produced by Michael Bay.
Here are 10 to consider.
10. Barb Wire
It's the not too distant future - well, 2017 - the Second American Civil War is underway and the last safe place in the country is Fort Steel Harbor, but if you want to get there alive, you’ll require the services of Barb Wire (Pamela Anderson), a nightclub owner who moonlights as a bounty hunter in a slow month and will kill any man that calls her “babe.”
While it’s easy to mock Anderson, her character is basically a dominatrix with a machine gun, in which respect she’s well cast and with her in the lead you know there won't be any long and boring speeches. Even Roger Ebert conceded that the movie “has a high energy level and a sense of deranged fun”, and who are you to argue with a Pulitzer Prize winning critic?
Taking its visual cues from previous comic book adaptation The Crow, Barb Wire knows it's not Richard III and never attempts to take itself too seriously. It promises a fun time and delivers it. What’s not to like?
9. The Marine
Watching The Marine is like eating a box of chocolates by yourself, except you’ll be compelled to share the guilt by recommending the movie to friends… who subsequently remove you from their Christmas card list.
Backed by World Wrestling Entertainment, the picture tries to make an action star out of wrestler/rapper John Cena, which guarantees there'll be more action than dialogue. Discharged from the marines because he “disobeyed a direct order”, Cena makes the mistake of pulling into the same gas station as lead villain Robert Patrick, who kidnaps his wife and turns the station into a fireball with him inside. Cena survives (of course), then steals a car and heads off in pursuit.
At its core, The Marine is basically a good old 80s action movie, right down to its running time - it gets everything said and done (and blown up and sent flying through a window) in 90 minutes instead of 3 hours. It’s fast-paced and funny (if Terminator and Deliverance gags are your thing) and stuff blows up real good. What more do you want?
8. The Tournament
Every 7 years, the world’s top assassins congregate in an unsuspecting locale to duke it out with each other for a $10m prize, unaware they’re being monitored by smarmy Liam Cunningham, who invites rich assholes to bet on the outcome.
The contest must be decades old, with all the romantic locations having played host to previous ventures, because this is Middlesborough’s year, meaning that, in trying to kill each other, the likes of Ving Rhames, Kelly Hu and Ian Somerhalder read tabloid newspapers, drink tea in greasy spoon cafes and complain about the bad food.
Rhames is in it not for the cash but to find whoever’s responsible for killing his old lady, even if it means stealing a tanker and mowing down some innocent people. He flips the tanker, causing a motorway conflagration that’d do James Cameron proud, and emerges with a few cuts and bruises. That’s right – it’s that kind of movie.
A trashy, ridiculous, cartoonish, silly, over-the-top, in-your-face movie, sure, but it’s also a ton of indefensible fun. Disengage brain and enjoy.
7. Demolition Man
In the wake of Cliffhanger, Sylvester Stallone could do no right and turned out one flop after another (Judge Dredd, The Specialist, Assassins etc) before returning to the Rocky and Rambo franchises. Not only is Demolition Man the pick of the flops, it’s the movie that predicted life in George W Bush’s America.
In the film, Stallone wakes up after 36 years of deep-freeze hibernation to find himself in a society torn in half by Dr Raymond Cocteau (Nigel Hawthorne), a charismatic yet cold-hearted man of deep spiritual beliefs who takes a my-way-or-the-highway attitude to his flock. If you don’t want to live in a society where profanity, pornography and rock music are illegal, and you think the Doc is too conservative, you can starve in a sewer with the rest of the “scraps”.
While this group organizes, Cocteau awakens Simon Phoenix (Wesley Snipes), Stallone’s long-ago nemesis, and sends him to kill their leader, Edgar Friendly. Friendly is played by comic-turned-actor Denis Leary, which is ironic – a decade after the film’s release, Bush’s harshest critic was Michael Moore, a comic-turned-filmmaker who won the Palme d’Or for Fahrenheit 9/11.
6. Warrior King 2
Tony Jaa returns in this sequel to 2005’s Warrior King (aka The Protector), delivering his most exciting film since the original Ong Bak.
Once again, Jaa encounters some villains who’ve been poaching elephants, which eventually leads to a martial arts showdown with RZA, who’s so evil he attaches a bomb to an elephant in one scene. This sits none too well with our hero who, along with a sidekick, decides to wipe out the supporting cast in a series of effects-heavy action sequences.
In fact, the unconvincing CGI was the biggest bone of contention among critics, but if you can put that kind of action movie snobbery aside, there’s plenty of fun to be had, particularly during the rousing finale. Packing in more chases, explosions and fight scenes than the original, this was clearly the astonishingly athletic Jaa's dry run for his part in Furious 7.
5. Legion
The moment Paul Bettany, portraying an archangel who arrives in the Mojave desert on a secret mission, picks up a machine gun and starts kicking !*$%, you know Legion is going be to pure no-think escapism.
Bettany’s on Earth to battle the forces of darkness that’ve descended on a truck stop in the desert to kill waitress Charlie (Adrianne Palicki), who’s about to give birth to the future saviour of mankind. When the first soldier in this conflict – a potty-mouthed senior citizen who can spider walk across ceilings – fails in its mission, along comes a zombie horde, unaware that Bettany has just armed his troops with enough guns to take down The Wild Bunch.
Legion is every bit as much fun as it sounds, a delirious combination of horror, action and religious thriller that once it gets going never lets up - a model for others to follow. One day, all movies with religious themes will be this much fun.
4. Machete Kills
Every movie Robert Rodriguez makes has the same mission: it just wants to give you a good time. Alas, the simple act of enjoying Danny Trejo face off against none other than Mel Gibson proved too much for audiences, and Machete Kills had one of the worst theatrical openings ever.
Rodriguez writes, scores, edits and shoots his own films, so you’re seeing one man’s vision on the screen. You might care for it, you might not, but if you don’t, at least have the courtesy not to give him grief for it in a world where Transformers: Age Of Extinction exists.
Besides, there’s a ton of crazy stuff to enjoy: Sofia Vergara and her machine gun bra, a hitman known as El Camaleon (who disguises himself as Walt Goggins, Cuba Gooding, Lady Gaga and Antonio Banderas) and best of all, Madman Mel as a Bond villain with a nice line in hardware (check out his “not perfected yet” molecule blaster).
3. White House Down
White House Down gave yours truly the most fun he’s ever had with a Roland Emmerich movie, but when the picture made only $73 million in the US (after costing $150 million to make), it sent its director scurrying off to make an Independence Day sequel.
Hissable villain James Woods has taken over 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue for….oh, some reason. Look, you don’t watch this kind of film for its intricate plotting, nuanced characters and Shakespearean dialogue but to see stuff blow up, which it often does.
A car smashes through the wall of the Oval Office, a villain who (intentionally?) looks like the bad guy in Commando turns out to be a hair-trigger psycho (what’re the odds?) and just like President Harrison Ford in Air Force One, Foxx isn’t afraid to afraid to take on his enemies with both fists. Oh, and there’s a car chase on the White House with helicopter gunships and rocket launchers and whatnot. That’s fun, too.
If you still need convincing about the film’s merits, try sitting through a double bill of Olympus Has Fallen and London Has Fallen instead.
2. Terminator Salvation
Terminator Salvation is the sequel that dared to be different: it’s the first movie whose plot doesn’t revolve around two naked people sent through time, and the only instalment where Arnie doesn’t say “I’ll be back!” But all anyone remembers is that it was also the first Terminator to “underperform” at the box office.
The reason for that is simple – after two “more of the same” sequels, people who wanted to see the same movie for the fourth time were aghast at a film that darkened the tone, changed the setting and was rated PG-13. And the director was McG, the auteur behind 2 Charlie’s Angels movies.
Anyone who was sick of the formula, however, especially after the Lovecraftian horror that was Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines, got a really cool action movie with Harvester Terminators, HK-Aerials and Moto-terminators. Kudos to McG for not taking the easy way out and making the “Greatest Hits” package that Terminator Genisys turned out to be.
1. The Incredible Hulk
The Marvel Cinematic Universe first reached screens in May 2008, when Iron Man enjoyed a $98 million opening weekend before going onto gross $318 million domestically. In cinemas a month later was The Incredible Hulk, which failed to repeat its predecessor’s success, earning only $134 in the domestic market.
Failure makes you a marked man, and in the wake of this “flop” neither the movie’s star, director or screenwriter were ever employed by Marvel Studios again.
Marvel must be a mean taskmaster because The Incredible Hulk is a solid action movie, eschewing the psychobabble of Ang Lee’s 2003 version in favour of a thriller plotline similar to Peter David’s run on the comic. Director Louis Leterrier orchestrates the slam bang stuff with gusto, keeps the pace fast and furious throughout and has a terrific supporting cast that includes William Hurt, Tim Roth and Tim Blake Nelson. It’s too bad we never got to see them return in a sequel – it couldn’t have been as drab as Iron Man 2.
Even if you consider TIH to be the ginger-haired stepchild of the MCU, you have to admit that it offers more fun than non-MCU movies like Elektra, X-Men: The Last Stand and Spider-Man 3.