10 Actors From Classic Hollywood Who Could Have Played Superheroes

Wayne Wolverine Comic book movies are all the rage right now, raking in huge amounts of cash and raising actors like Robert Downey Jr. to the pinnacle of stardom. Unfortunately, since they've only been huge for about 15 years or so, many of the greatest screen actors never had a chance to play one of the larger than life heroes or heroines. So to compensate, I've re-casted , or in some cases cast for the first time, some of the most popular superheroes with actors from the glory years of Hollywood filmmaking, an era when the movie star was king. The stars were chosen based on their inherent acting abilities, charisma, and how well they fit in that particular role. While action films have come a long way since these actors were either alive or in their primes, we are going to ignore that these actors never acted in anything as remotely CGI and action driven as most superhero movies. Instead, this list pretends that we're casting a brand new incarnation of each character, with the freedom to choose any actor from classic Hollywood at the peak of their careers, and try to match the best actor possible for each role. The entries are loosely ranked according to how excited I would be if somehow, someone invented a time machine and announced that they would make each one of these movies.

10. Wonder Woman/ Ingrid Bergman

Wonder Bergman Wonder Woman has long been considered one of the most difficult superheroes to properly create onscreen. Although she got a somewhat popular TV series in the 70's, the closest someone has gotten to making a standalone movie is probably Joss Whedon, who at one point was hired by Warner Bros to write and adapt one. One of the biggest difficulties in a Wonder Woman movie would be casting the right actress. Not only would she have to be a good enough actress to carry an entire movie, she has to look the part as well and that's a rare combination that only a few actresses possess. Ingrid Bergman was one of classical Hollywood's greatest actresses; she combined incredible beauty with once-in-a-lifetime talent that resulted in three Academy Award wins. In addition, she showed a keen eye for scripts and directors, working with legends such as Alfred Hitchcock, Roberto Rossellini, and Ingmar Bergman and appearing in a bevy of classic roles such as Casablanca and Notorious. Bergman would be a perfect choice for Wonder Woman as she combined both the physical beauty and the confident screen presence needed for the character. As a bonus, Bergman's Swedish background gave her an exotic edge that perfectly mirrors Wonder Woman's Amazonian roots.

9. Iron Man/ Paul Newman

Iron Newman Although it's hard to imagine someone besides Robert Downey Jr. ever portraying Marvel's eccentric billionaire, Paul Newman would probably be more than up to the task. Combining popular appeal and talent at a level rarely reached, Paul Newman turned in some of the most iconic roles of his generation including Cool Hand Luke and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. He was known for his coolly detached sense of rebellion, often playing anti-heroes and rebels. His sense of humor, cocksure attitude, and inimitable swagger make him an ideal choice for Tony Stark, who Downey Jr. has made synonymous with wit and devil-may-care attitude. Newman would be simply brilliant as the "genius, billionaire, playboy, philanthropist", possibly equaling Robert Downey Jr's own interpretation. It wouldn't be exactly the same, but in his own way, Newman would probably become just as popular and endearing.

8. Wolverine/ John Wayne

Wayne Wolverine Wolverine is the archetypal superhero loner, someone whose rage, memory loss, and seeming immortality has isolated him from society. John Wayne might be cinema's all-time best loner and in Wolverine, he would find a character that was ideal for his personality and acting gifts. Wayne specialized in action westerns and war movies so he would be well-suited for the rigors of filming a superhero epic and although he is regarded as almost a mythical figure, people often forget just how well regarded and talented an actor he was. He was nominated multiple times for Best Actor, winning for True Grit, but it's one of his roles in John Ford's series of westerns that gave him the role that shows how good he would be as Wolverine. In The Searchers, arguably the most acclaimed western of all time, Wayne created what might be his most affecting character; his Ethan Edwards is a loner governed by his prejudices and someone with an obsessiveness that has a great deal of similarity to Wolverine. A legend of American movies, John Wayne would be more than up to the task of portraying one of the most ferocious of all comic book heroes. Just about the only drawback is that Wayne, standing well over six feet tall, is a good deal taller than the comic book incarnation but it would be a small price to pay for a perfectly realized match of actor and character.

7. Spider-Man/ James Dean

Spider Dean James Dean was one of the most enigmatic of all screen legends. He only appeared in three movies before dying in a car crash at only 24 years old but each one has become a classic and he earned significant awards recognition for all three. He specialized in portraying teenage angst and although he might be a little too charismatic for the role, he would be the best choice to play the most significant teenage superhero, Spider-Man. Dean would have to dial down his traditional persona, something he never did in his brief career but which shouldn't give him too much trouble. Although he played disenchanted youth to near-perfection, Peter Parker is more of a lonely nerd than an angry rebel but either way, Dean would likely give a memorable performance. His interpretation would probably be different from both Tobey McGuire and Andrew Garfield's outings as he would probably be more moody and withdrawn than both. Still, in an era where "dark" superhero movies are all the rage, James Dean would probably fit right in.

6. The Flash/ Charlie Chaplin

Flash Chaplin The Flash is often considered the funniest member of DC's Justice League, so why not cast the man who practically invented big-screen comedy, Charlie Chaplin? Chaplin honed his skills throughout his early life, working in music, theatre, and dance but by 1914 was appearing in short films for Keystone Studios. By 1916, with the help of his legendary "Tramp" persona, he had become one of the most famous and well paid performers in the world. By 1921, he had written, directed, and starred in The Kid, one of the most memorable silent films of the era and Chaplin subsequently pounded out classic after classic over the next 30 years of his career. Widely acknowledged as one of the founders of cinema, he remains a towering figure in moviemaking and one of the most beloved of all screen icons. While Chaplin never did anything remotely similar to a superhero film, his legendary body control, sense of comic timing, and deceptive athletic abilities might just suit a role as DC's fastest character, and how awesome would it be to see him do his trademark walk at superspeed. He showed in his later works such as Monsieur Verdoux that he was perfectly capable of turning in magnificent performances after the sound age began and although he wouldn't be able to keep his famous mustache, he'd otherwise be a perfect match.

5. Thor/ Laurence Olivier

Thor Olivier Compared to Chris Hemsworth's swaggering behemoth, Laurence Olivier looks downright puny. However, his unprecedented grasp of Shakespearean drama and unrivaled natural abilities more than make up for him probably weighing less than half what Hemsworth does. Olivier is considered by many to be the greatest actor of the twentieth century, a fact backed up by his ten Academy Award nominations and a host of legendary theater roles, and his penchant for the works of Shakespeare would make him well suited for the lofty dialogue often given to the Asgardian superhero. Thor is often a sort of hulking presence in most of his adaptions but the filmmakers could use some sort of cinematic trickery to make him more intimidating or simply portray him differently than usual. Olivier would elevate any of the dialogue given by the filmmakers and it would have been a joy to see him throw around Joss Whedon one-liners. Alas, it was never meant to be but we can always imagine just how cool it would have been to watch Olivier play Marvel's most lofty character.

4. The Hulk/Montgomery Clift

The Incredible Clift

One of the most tragic actors of Hollywood's golden period, Montgomery Clift became famous for his portrayal of quiet, brooding heroes but after only a few films he was involved in a car crash that left him disfigured both physically and emotionally. Subsequently addicted to painkillers, he became increasingly erratic and his performances began to suffer. Ten years after the accident, at only 45 years old, he died in what some consider a suicide but more likely an unintentional result of multiple health problems and drug use. Even before his accident, Clift played darker and more disturbed characters than many of his contemporaries and was very similar in acting temperament and personality to other actors who have played The Hulk such as Eric Bana, Edward Norton, and Mark Ruffalo. His entire screen persona makes him ideally suited for the loneliness and anxiety typically found in interpretations of the character but he also has the requisite charisma and sense of intelligence needed to play Bruce Banner to perfection.

3. Captain America/ Jimmy Stewart

Captain Stewart Jimmy Stewart embodies good old-fashioned values of honesty, decency, and politeness better than any other classic actor, making him an ideal choice to play the moral compass of The Avengers. Through partnerships with some of the elite Hollywood directors including John Ford, Frank Capra, and Alfred Hitchcock, Stewart established himself as one of the most accomplished actors in history with memorable roles in classics ranging from It's a Wonderful Life to Vertigo to The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. Although he seems a bit lanky to play Marvel's steroidal super-soldier, Stewart was a notable athlete in high school and had considerable success in both football and track so there is something there to work with. He would need to bulk up a little bit to play Steve Rogers but his screen persona is so ideal for the role that even if he was a little unconvincing as a super soldier, he would more than make up for it with other aspects of his performance.

2. Superman/ Cary Grant

Super Grant The most recognizable superhero in the world, Superman blends nearly unlimited power with a strong sense of morality, a character who should be an inspiration for everyone. Cary Grant was so well-regarded by fans that he once quipped that "Everyone wants to be Cary Grant€”even I want to be Cary Grant." Throughout a career that included an improbable amount of classic films, Grant became one of the most legendary stars in the world and is often seen as the archetypal Hollywood leading man. He is primarily remembered for his looks, sense of humor, and class, all of which would help him in portraying Superman. He would have to lose his famous accent for the role, but overall his acting style seems to lend itself to playing a larger than life character such as Superman, and in addition he is also more than capable of playing the bumbling Clark Kent due to the numerous comedies he appeared in. In short, Cary Grant has pretty much everything thing you'd want in an actor attempting to portray Superman.

1. Batman/ Robert De Niro

De Batman Consistently the most fascinating superhero of all, Batman deserves to be portrayed by the best Hollywood has to offer. Although he arrived after Hollywood's Golden Age, I'm going to cheat a little bit and include Robert De Niro here since the thought of a Raging Bull era De Niro channeling his abilities into DC's Dark Knight gives me chills. De Niro has long portrayed characters who don't quite fit in, most noticeably in Taxi Driver where he plays Travis Bickle, who in an almost twisted take on superhero tropes, saves people who don't necessarily want to be saved. While filming Raging Bull, De Niro showed such an aptitude for boxing that Jake Le Motta thought he could do it professionally and he actually won several amateur fights that he entered while preparing for the film. De Niro might not be quite as convincing as the playboy incarnation of Bruce Wayne as he never really played a character quite like him. However, he has consistently shown himself to be an extraordinarily versatile actor so he should be able to pull off the few scenes needed relatively easily. De Niro combines both the needed physical attributes of the character with an unparalleled ability to get inside the heads of dark, psychotic characters. De Niro's interpretation of the Caped Crusader would likely be the most introspective, and intense incarnation of the character ever and it makes me a little bit sad that his prime years didn't coincide with the Comic Book movie explosion.

Contributor

I love movies, literature, history, music and the NBA. I love all things nerdy including but not limited to Star Wars, Star Trek, Lord of the Rings, and Firefly. My artistic idols are Dylan, Dostoevsky, and Malick and my goal in life is to become like Bernard Black from Black Books. When I die, I hope to turn into the space baby from 2001: A Space Odyssey.