10 Actors Who Need To Stop Flogging A Dead Horse

Does anyone really need another Beverly Hills Cop movie?

In the age of sequels, prequels, reboots and megafranchises, it's not uncommon for an actor to play the same character multiple times throughout his or her career. This gives an actor time to grow into a role, time for the character to grow as a franchise grows, and time for an audience to fall in love with a character. Naturally, it also risks that character becoming really, really annoying: after five movies of similar shenanigans, most would just wish for a fresh hero with a clean slate. Sometimes actors get so caught up in a particular character that the routine spills over into other roles, and the actor ends up trapped in a perpetual loop, doing the same shtick over and over again. There are two film genres that are inherently guilty of this: comedy and action, with stars of both drawn to sticking to their talents, and very often pulling a gag or firing a weapon in slow motion can make one character reminiscent of another. The way to escape this is to look for challenges, unorthodox and unexpected roles, to make a conscious effort to stop doing the same thing over and over. It's rare, but it does happen: Jean-Claude Van Damme broke his straight-to-DVD action mold with the metacomedy JCVD, while Bill Murray continues to challenge himself with more adult roles. Others haven't been so lucky, so to mourn these stunted talents, we're looking at 10 actors who need to branch out and stop playing the same characters again and again...

10. Johnny Depp

Done To Death: The off-colour Jack Sparrow types of Depp's recent films. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl definitely signaled a turning point in Depp's acting career - he went from appearing in one or two films a year to four or more, and nearly all of those films saw him leaping around in larger-than-life costumes and an unhealthy amount of eyeliner. He kept making Pirates movies, each of which was worse than the last, and his roles in the Tim Burton films Alice and Wonderland, Sweeney Todd and Dark Shadows seemed more focused on pale cheeks and funny accents than actual acting. A fifth Pirates film is coming soon, so clearly Depp hasn't tired of playing over-the-top just yet, though hopefully it can't be that far away thanks to his continually diminishing returns. He needs to seek out more reserved, grounded roles from films like Donnie Brasco and Blow. Sure, Depp is great in zany flicks like Edward Scissorhands, but it's easy to forget that he doesn't need to cover himself in makeup and act drunk to make a great character.

9. Arnold Schwarzenegger

Done To Death: The aging warrior, cyborg or otherwise. After a stint as Governor of California, Arnie is back and though he's not extremely elderly at age 66, he's certainly not the marble-carved hulk of the Conan and Terminator series. Even so, Arnie has returned to films with predictable action fare, including an inevitable role in the Expendables 2, and now the Governator has his sights set on revisiting his most famous franchise. Terminator Salvation was the first in the time-travelling series to not feature Schwarzenegger's T-800 bounty hunter, and it fared decently considering the Austrian-American bodybuilder had previously been inextricable from the franchise. Now, with Terminator: Genesis on the horizon, Arnie is set to reprise the role all over again. Add to that a rumored Conan sequel, a confirmed Twins sequel called Triplets (cue facepalm), and the upcoming Expendables 3, and it's clear that Schwarzenegger is content to relive the past over and over again. Total Recall and True Lies are good examples from a time when Schwarzenegger participated in fresh, original projects, and though it's unlikely he's going to be approached for roles like that, Stallone's Copland does offer hope for an actor of his type.

8. Wesley Snipes

Done To Death: Blade, and anything resembling Blade. Wesley Snipes was always an action guy, equally at home in dystopias and ganglands as long as the pace was fast, the gunfire heavy and the attitude flowing. He did appear in a handful of non-violent films, some of which are quite good, but mostly he stuck to his talents. He was sufficiently menacing as the vampiric vampire hunter Blade when the character first appeared in 1998, and soared in Guillermo del Toro's sequel, but Blade: Trinity is without a doubt the worst of the series, and it was clear the appeal was waning. Now there's talk of making that trilogy into a tetralogy, if only because Snipes wants to relive his days as Blade, which he already sort of did with 2012's pathetic Gallowwalkers, which was basically just Blade with zombies instead of vampires. But is anyone really excited about watching an ageing Snipes coming back as Blade?

7. Helena Bonham Carter

Done To Death: The insane, makeup-clad creepy lady. Basically, Tim Burton's female Johnny Depp. There's little doubt that Carter is a great actress: she's played a royal and a prostitute with equal ease, a villain and a sympathetic innocent in back-to-back performances. Mostly, though, like Depp, these performances are hard to pick out underneath the caked face paint and birds' nest of tangled hair. Given that she's married to Burton, she is perhaps obligated to show up in all of his movies in increasingly odd costumes, which might explain why she'll appear in the sequel to the horrendous Alice In Wonderland. That's sure to be an affair as cringeworthy as the first (if not more so). Subtle and effective, The King's Speech was one of Carter's deepest performances and crucially her least zany, and proved that she is a lot more than the pantomime wench she seems happy to perpetuate.

6. Harrison Ford

Done To Death: Indiana Jones. Harrison Ford is responsible for some of the greatest film heroes ever captured on screen, from Indy to Han Solo to Jack Ryan to Blade Runner's Deckard, and he's never really slowed down, even if the quality of his recent films has been somewhat lacking. There's a good reason Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull was far and away the weakest entry in the franchise, and it wasn't just the silly premise. But Ford apparently wants more Indy, and the fifth instalment is already gathering steam. Additionally, Ford will appear in Expendables 3, which almost feels like validation for anyone pointing an accusing finger at his inability to let go of his characters of the past. And then, of course he will be bringing Han Solo back in Star Wars Episode VII, while rumours of a Blade Runner sequel continue to swirl. Perhaps with the exception of Star Wars - which needs a high note after the prequel trilogy - all of these projects feel a lot more like money-grabs than actual attempts at original art, and the over-riding feeling is that all will feel a little tragic.

5. Bruce Willis

Done To Death: John McClane, the ultimate "one final mission" hero. Like Harrison Ford, Bruce Willis seems to want to resurrect the characters that made him famous rather than create new ones. Frustratingly of course, despite being an action hero, Willis chooses some interesting projects to fill the gaps between Die Hard movies, like The Sixth Sense and Moonrise Kingdom, but those roles have been few and far between. Still, that doesn't negate the fact that Willis continues to drive the Die Hard franchise deeper and deeper into the ground: his performance in the latest entry, last year's A Good Day to Die Hard, barely resembled the original John McClane at all. And curiously, he seems only to be motivated when he's playing McClane (even under other names), as, aside from his palette-cleansing indie roles, everything else draws a half interested, pay-check performance out of him. Sooner or later, it has to be made a lot easier for McClane to die.

4. Michael Cera

Done To Death: The awkward teen. Perhaps it's unfair to call guys like Michael Cera out on their boyish looks, but there are plenty of actors who pull off mature roles and successful careers despite a young face. Cera hasn't quite managed to bridge that gap yet, although he's tried in a few recent roles, but if there's a lesson from Superbad, Juno, and Scott Pilgrim vs. the World it's that Michael Cera is cast as same character in all of these, and that character is Michael Cera. Jonah Hill, Cera's Superbad counterpart, has made the move into different roles, despite his capacity for type-casting, having now appeared alongside the likes of Brad Pitt and Leonardo DiCaprio in roles that were nominated for Academy Awards. This could just be a disparity in career choice - maybe Cera wants to be forever young - but the awkward teenager shtick is only going to last so long. Fun as it may be to appear in every comedy that comes along, Cera should take a page out of the Hill playbook and start sprinkling some serious roles in with the goofball ones.

3. Drew Barrymore

Done To Death: The air-headed love interest of Adam Sandler. Is there any onscreen couple as overdone as Barrymore and Sandler? The Wedding Singer worked because it was new, but that was in 1998; 2004 saw the release and tepid reaction to 50 First Dates, which again starred Barrymore in the second-fiddle love interest role, and after that you'd think all interest would be lost in that particular experiment. But that's not the case, as Blended, due out this month, features Barrymore and Sandler as a couple stumbling into love in an achingly familiar way. The films where Barrymore has played something other than the love interest of the main character are few and far between. By no means is a different kind of movie an automatic success for Barrymore (see Charlie's Angel's: Full Throttle), but any change of pace would be welcome at this point.

2. Adam Sandler

Done To Death: Sandler's crude and whiny man-child routine turned out to be his only trick after all. Sure, the Sandler-Barrymore films are becoming an overdone genre all their own, but Sandler's got a whole slew of film performances that are just rehashes of his career-making turns in Billy Madison and Happy Gilmore. He's done a few noteworthy films that don't focus on childish humor and physical gags, but they're pretty hard to come by nowadays. By 2010, Sandler had locked himself into a string of pretty reprehensible performances: Grown Ups (basically the comedy version of The Expendables), the absolutely awful Jack And Jill, That's My Boy and Grown Ups 2 preceded the Barrymore reteam Blended. All of these pander to the exact same people who thought Billy Madison and Happy Gilmore were brilliant, but seem to forget that those people are now twenty years older. Frustratingly, in Punch-Drunk Love, Funny People and Reign Over Me indicate Sandler has it in him to break his own mold, but it just doesn't look like he cares enough to pursue those roles.

1. Eddie Murphy

Done To Death: Beverly Hills Cop (and playing multiple roles in the same movie). There was a time when Eddie Murphy was the most hilarious thing in Hollywood: he was handsome, fast-talking, and above all he was a pretty good actor, killing it on Saturday Night Live for four straight years. And by the time he was cast in his first leading role in Beverly Hills Cop in 1984 he was a force to be reckoned with in the world of big-budget comedy. Then, in the mid-'90s, Murphy's roles became increasingly ridiculous. In the wake of Beverly Hills Cop III came Vampire In Brooklyn, which replicated the gimmick of Murphy's earlier film Coming To America, in which he played multiple characters at the same time, but failed laughably. His next film was The Nutty Professor, which was built entirely around that gimmick, and movies like Norbit kept right on going without any self-awareness. With Triplets upcoming, it's recently been announced that Murphy is going back to Beverly Hills Cop to reinvigorate another old comedy franchise, and it's hard not to think that Murphy isn't even the best man for his own old job. After more than a decade of no success, it would be far better to see Axel Foley rebooted, rather than him hanging on to an old success story, and it's hard to see the film working, unless someone like Shane Black is brought in. Which other actors do you think need to stop flogging a dead horse? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor

Matt is a writer and musician living in Boston. Read his film reviews at http://motionstatereview.wordpress.com.