10 Actors Who Admit To Bombing Big Auditions
Sometimes movie stars suck too.
It’s always fun to hear about actors who were almost cast in big roles - like Sean Connery turning down Lord of the Rings because he didn’t understand it - but sometimes there's a more straight forward, probably devastating reason. Because sometimes, actors miss out not because of scheduling conflicts or a lack of interest, but rather because they just aren’t good enough.
Most actors will tell you that the audition process is a pretty horrible experience. They're nerve-wracking, awkward and can bring down the self-confidence of even the most charismatic movie stars. And movie stars are people too. Some days they win awards and make millions of dollars. Some days they have terribly embarrassing auditions that haunt them forever.
This list includes some of today’s biggest stars, Oscar winners and, yes, some actors of questionable talent, but they all have audition horror stories brutal enough to make us actually feel sorry for them.
Bad accents, forgotten lines and even some song and dance - all these factors contributed to these painful experiences. So get ready to sympathize with some beautiful rich people as we look at the actor’s terrible auditions for big movies.
10. Bradley Cooper - Green Lantern
The movie: The 2011 attempt to bring the greenest DC hero to the big screen and finally make Ryan Reynolds a star. Neither dream was realized as the film tanked miserably. Warner Bros. will give it another try in 2020 and Reynolds has to settle for being a Marvel hero in Deadpool.
The actor: Before Reynolds made the mistake of donning the CGI super-suit, Bradley Cooper was given a shot.
At this point, Cooper was not the Oscar nominated superstar he is today. He was more known as the jerk in The Hangover, the jerk in Wedding Crashers or the audience member in Inside the Actor's Studio.
The audition: Cooper's excitement about playing a DC hero got the best of him and he picked an unfortunate inspiration for his performance:
“I couldn’t not do Christian Bale's Batman when I was doing the audition. I don’t know what it was! I put a mask on and the director was like, ’Okay Bradley, be regular and talk.’ And I was like, ’Yeah, got it… [in a deep, gravely Batman voice] listen, Sally, we’re going to have to take your family away if you don’t listen to me!’"
9. Nicholas Hoult - The Chronicles Of Narnia: Prince Caspian
The movie: The first of Chronicles of Narnia film was a big hit in 2005 but the subsequent sequels performed significantly worse. This first sequel featured Ben Barnes as the titular prince.
The actor: Nicholas Hoult's career began at a young age when he was cast in About A Boy. Since then he has gained fame for films like Mad Max: Fury Road and the X-Men prequels. But somewhere in the middle, he auditioned as the dashing prince in this forgettable Lord of the Rings ripoff.
The audition: Accents can be really hard, especially when you're asked to do one on the spot. It probably didn't help that the casting director had a decidedly cartoonish example for Hoult:
“They asked if I could do a Hispanic accent. I was like, ‘What would I base that on?’ They were like, ‘Have you seen Shrek? Puss in Boots.’ I was doing the scene, but in my head before saying each line, I was trying to do my Antonio Banderas impression, saying ‘I am Prince Caspian!’ It was horrendous. It sounded more like Borat.”
To be complete fair, it's surprisingly easy for any accent attempt to default to a Borat impression.
8. Michael Cera - The Sixth Sense
The movie: The 1999 thriller was to auspicious debut of M. Night Shyamalan and is still regarded today as having one of the greatest twist endings ever. It also introduced the world to the considerable talent of young Haley Joel Osment, who, like Shyamalan, NEVER lost favor with the movie-going public.
The actor: Michael Cera became everyone's favorite awkward goof thanks to roles in Arrested Development and Superbad. Unfortunately, Cera has yet to break out of that mold in later years. The closest he came was, ironically, playing himself in This Is the End. Perhaps an early role in a massively successful ghost story would have changed his path.
The audition: Let this be a lesson for all young auditioning actors; context is very important.
"I auditioned for The Sixth Sense, which I didn't know was about seeing dead people. They didn't mention that in the breakdown. After seeing the movie, and remembering the scene they had me read... It was the scene with the penny. Bruce Willis is saying, 'I can't be your doctor anymore,' and Haley Joel Osment starts crying and slides the penny over to him. It's a very emotional scene. And I did not do it that way. I did it upbeat. I said 'Some magic's real'".
7. January Jones - Coyote Ugly
The movie: A 2000 comedy (?) about a bar run by a bunch of hot girls who occasionally dance on the bar for their drooling male customers. It starred Piper Perabo, Maria Bello and John Goodman (no, he did not play one of the sexy dancers).
The actor: January Jones had never been considered one of the great thespians of out time. She gave a heavily derided performance as Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class, but she's shown genuine talent on television projects like Mad Men. But she's also very attractive so of course she had to audition for "sexy girls dancing" movies.
The audition: It's gotta be pretty intimidating and awkward for your audition to consist of table dancing for one of Hollywood's most powerful figures. I'm sure it would be even worse if you sucked at dancing.
"I'd done the reading for the acting part and then Jerry Bruckheimer wanted me to come in and dance … on top of the table. They said, “You’re going to dance to Prince’s ‘Kiss.’ You’re going to pole dance, but there is no pole.” (Laughter.) And I just turned beet red. It was awful, and he said something like, “Honey, you did a great reading, but you’ve got no rhythm.”
6. Channing Tatum - The Fast And The Furious: Tokyo Drift
The movie: Before the Fast and Furious franchise reached a level of success that no one could have predicted, it was an alright movie with two forgettable sequels. The most forgettable of the bunch was 2006's Tokyo Drift.
The actor: Speaking of unpredictable success, Channing Tatum's meteoric rise was hard to see coming back when he was a bland pretty-boy actor. Now he stars in films by Steven Soderbergh and the Coen Brothers, but back then he would have fit right at home in the Fast and Furious franchise.
The audition: The number one rule they tell young actors about the audition process is DO NOT forget you lines. Tatum must have missed that acting class.
"I stopped in the middle of the audition. I blocked it out mainly, so I don't remember the specifics. I think it was a combination of probably me being just bad, not remembering the lines, like totally freaked out, probably sweating a lot. They didn't even try to stop me—they were like. 'Alright, it's probably a good idea.'"
Forgot your lines? Really Tatum? It's Fast and Furious. How complicated could the dialogue be? Did you mix up Honda and Hyundai? How you handled Tarantino dialogue, I'll never know.
5. Chris Klein - Mamma Mia!
The movie: The Meryl Streep-led musical was based on the long-running Broadway show, which focuses on a young woman's search to find her real father before her wedding day. But really it's just an excuse to listen to ABBA songs.
The actor: Chris Klein got his acting career off to a pretty great start with Election and American Pie back-to-back. Since then he's sort of been relegated to the outskirts of Hollywood. He had his time in the spotlight but, sadly, will probably be best remembered for this audition. You can find it on YouTube if you have a strong enough stomach.
The audition: The whole thing is an unmitigated disaster. The fear in Klein's eyes during his off-key performance is a hard image to shake. But credit to him, he's owned up to the travesty.
"I took a chance — I can’t sing! I don’t know why I was in there. But I took a chance! It’s a musical — let’s see if I can give it a shot. And, you know, the way that they put it out there, it gets taken out of context and all that kind of thing. It was really a dreadful audition. Talk about a reason that I didn’t get a part, man! I mean [laughs], oh my God. What a terrible thing!"
4. Chris Evans - Gone Baby Gone
The movie: The 2007 directorial debut of Ben Affleck which marked a comeback for the much-ridiculed superstar. The film takes place in Boston and follows an elaborate investigation into the kidnapping of a young girl. It also features Boston accents.
The actor: He's Captain America, for god's sake! While Evans hasn't really made much of an impact outside of the stars and strips costume, he's currently sitting pretty with the massive success of Captain America: Civil War. But back in 2007, he was just a young actor excited to meet Matt Damon's buddy.
The audition: Remember in school, when you tried to act cool talking to the girl you had a crush on. Cap knows the feeling too:
"...I passed a room I heard 'There he is.' In my head I was like, 'That's Ben.' I turned around and it was, and for some reason I instantly was nervous. I went in and shook his hand, and the first thing I said was 'Hey, how ya doing—am I gonna be okay where I parked?' And he said, 'Where'd you park?' And I said, 'At one of the meters.' And he said, 'Did you put money in it?' And I said, 'Yeah.' And he said, 'I think you'll be all right.' From that moment, I just wanted to get the f*** out of the room."
3. Leonardo DiCaprio - Moulin Rogue!
The movie: Baz Luhrmann's early 1900s-set musical extravaganza about a love affair between a poet and a courtesan who sing Madonna and Nirvana for some reason.
The actor: Leonardo DiCaprio is one of the biggest stars currently working in Hollywood and a recent Oscar winner (finally). He's starred in films from directors like Steven Spielberg, Clint Eastwood, Martin Scorsese and even Baz Luhrmann. So it makes sense that his Romeo + Juliet director would want Leo to try-out for his new film.
The audition: There's a lot of things Leo can do, but apparently singing isn't one of them. Something essential for most musicals:
"To be honest, I’m not really prepared to do a musical, simply because I think I have a pretty atrocious voice. But we had a friendly thing where it was me and him and a piano player, and we tried to sing a song together. It didn’t go too well. I think it was ‘Lean on Me,’ and when I hit the high note, he just turned to me. ‘Yes, D, I don’t know if this conversation should continue.’ ”
It seems like a more humane audition than most of the others on the list. But it could explain why it was 17 years until his next collaboration with Luhrmann.
2. Chris Pine - Avatar
The movie: Despite its surprising lack of cultural relevancy, Avatar remains the highest grossing film of all time. It's a sci-fi take on the classic Pocahontas tale while throwing in elements like in Unobtainium , blue aliens and bland ol' Sam Worthington.
The actor: Chris Pine is no stranger to sci-fi himself with his role as the rebooted Captain Kirk in the Star Trek films. He's a endlessly charismatic actor with good looks to boot. Surely he would have brought a little more life to the role of Avatar's Jake Sully.
The audition: You may be asking yourself, "How do you audition for a movie that is primarily CGI?" Evidently, very awkwardly:
"[Y]our back is sweating and you’re thinking about the laundry that you have to do and somehow seamlessly you can then pretend to be a man in a loincloth standing in front of blue people saying lines like, ‘Come follow me! I’ll save you!’ And sometimes you just can’t buy it. I walked into that room absolutely not believing myself. How dare I put that poor casting director through the experience of watching me? Halfway through, I just stopped; she was maybe smiling or laughing at me."
Usually you want the casting director laughing with you, not at you.
1. Jake Gyllenhaal - Lord Of The Rings
The movie: Movies, actually - three to be precise. The trilogy was the ambitious undertaking of Peter Jackson to adapt J.R.R. Tolkien's epic series. They became the one of the most successful (and longest) trilogies in film history.
The actor: Jake Gyllenhaal is an actor of considerable talent and has steadily risen to become one of the most popular movie stars out there. He has excelled in films like Brokeback Mountain, Nightcrawler, End of Watch and occasionally dabbles in genre work like Source Code. But he has generally avoided the big spectacle films like the LOTR series. I wonder why.
The audition: It's best to go into an audition as prepared as possible. Surely, Gyllenhaal had his lines memorized and gave it his all, but he probably should have checked with Peter Jackson before deciding to make the character of Frodo an American:
"He literally turned to me and said, ‘You are the worst actor that I have ever seen.’ He said, ‘Did anyone tell you you were supposed to have an accent?’ I was like, ‘No!’ And he said, ‘Well, fire your agents.’"
Ouch. That's a bit harsh, Pete.