10 Actors Who Clearly Didn't Learn Anything From Past Mistakes

For God's sake Johnny, stop answering Tim Burton's calls!

Even the finest actors can spectacularly self-destruct at some point in their career, and the science behind it - and specifically why the cruel hand of deterioration affects only some stars - is far from precisely known. But what is clear is that there is a finite amount of good scripts out there, and also, money can often talk louder than the urge to make something unique or creatively impressive. What's amazing is how some actors still manage to have career longevity even after they have basically become walking cliches or traded in all integrity for a gigantic pile of cash. While they all may still have a robust career, most of the actors profiled in this list are currently in either the critical or commercial doldrums, and crucially who don't seem at all able to show the self-awareness to learn from their mistakes and make a run for the border back into beloved territory. To celebrate this ignominious bunch, and to present a model for other actors to avoid the almost wilfully ignorant lack of progress they adopt, we're looking at the actors who make us grown and grouse, and whose choices have made our eyes roll and our spirits sink. Why can't they just pull themselves together?

10. Helena Bonham Carter

This choice may seem a tad counter-intuitive, as since Bonham Carter's filmography is not littered with bomb after bomb, or even all that many mistakes, but it's difficult to deny that a little too much self-parody has slowly crept into the actresses' work. Similar to her frequent co-star, Johnny Depp, she frequently offers little more than whimsy, pounds and pounds of make-up, and flamboyant, bizarre hairstyles. Her professional choices haven't really been to her detriment, but they have begun to feel a little tired. Much of this can be attributed to her professional and romantic partnership with Tim Burton. One can almost see their domestic exchanges, with Burton running into her home (the pair live next door to each other) with a wild gleam in his eye. Their freakish hair styles battling for supremacy, Burton would then exclaim, "I'm going to make you a sexy ape! I'm going to make you a one-eyed witch! Did you ever want to play Mrs. Bucket? Well, now you can!" On the surface this seems innocent enough; Carter's various Burton roles even seem pretty diverse, but what unites them all is the percolating sense of whimsy, a quality that after seven "quirky" collaborations with Burton has perhaps gotten a little stale. What's even more disconcerting for the actress is how this quirky proclivity has spread to her non-Burton films, something seen with her parts in Les Miserables, The Harry Potter Franchise, Great Expectations and The Lone Ranger. These roles indicate that Bonham Carter can obviously play crazy and off-kilter characters. Yet, they also suggest that she maybe has forgotten about striking a balance with her work, only refuting this periodically with something like The King's Speech.

9. Sylvester Stallone

With his endless regurgitation of tired action routines and disturbing refusal to acknowledge his now advanced age, Sly Stallone is probably this list's least surprising entry. Despite moments of affecting brilliance, Stallone's 40+ year career has largely amounted to that of a one-trick pony, chugging out one sluggish and pedantic actioner after another - from the cartoonish Rambo sequels, to the odious Get Carter and D-Tox, right up to last year's excruciating Bullet To The Head. Unlike his Austrian peer, Stallone has never grasped that the action star is the most interesting when viewed through a subversive lens. But how much can this now wizened bruiser really be blamed? After all Sly has periodically attempted to go against his action paradigm - with mixed to catastrophic results. Audiences didn't really flock to see him in the outlandish Rhinestone, a film that has to rank as an "odd couple" pairing of the most desperate kind. Even worse were his woeful misfires Oscar and Stop! Or My Mom Will Shoot, two films were so damn bad that they probably turned audiences more than a tad suicidal. Yet, despite all of these professional stumbles, it's clear that Stallone can occasionally succeed when he makes unconventional choices. This is evident in his early, daring role in F.I.S.T, or in his more recent work like Antz, Shade and (most powerfully) Cop Land. Those films make Sly's continued reliance on cliched action (Escape Plan) and gimmicky premises (The Expendables Franchise, Grudge Match) all the more disheartening. For as indelible as his Rocky and Rambo creations were, four decades of rifting on the material has given the former champ a one-way ticket to palookaville.

8. Robert De Niro

In 2008, with the release of Righteous Kill, De Niro had irrefutably reached a critical nadir. Yes, he had made terrible movies before this, some arguably worse than John Avent's derivative snoozer, but there was something about this hammy trash that indicated how far the Raging Bull had fallen. Whatever the reason behind its poor quality, Righteous Kill proved to be a disturbing spectacle, and one that illustrated the upsetting truth that the lean, powerful force of nature who starred in Taxi Driver, Mean Streets, The Deer Hunter, and The Godfather: Part II left the building long ago. In fact, to locate a truly divine De Niro performance one would probably have to go back nearly 20 years, to the double whammy of Casino and Heat in 1995. Since then, barring a few exceptions (Flawless and Silver Linings Playbook gave us a flash of the old magic), De Niro has largely relegated himself to tired action, listless drama, and comedy that can best be described as forced. Not to say there haven't been a few good moments here and there, but for the most part the later sections of De Niro's career will (more than likely) end up being remembered for something like the Meet The Parents franchise, which he is seemingly damned to repeat forever. The once great, unpredictable actor is now little more than a harmless old crackpot, shoring up capital for his Tribeca empire.

7. Katherine Heigl

Right around 2007 Katherine Heigl seemed poised to take over the world: not only was she one of the stars of Grey's Anatomy, and became one of the leads in the Apatow opus Knocked Up. In that film the world was not only transfixed by this woman's obvious beauty, but somehow bought into the idea that her character would not only sleep with a paunchy schlub like Seth Rogen, but would stay with him to boot. Of course, the years have come and gone since that auspicious beginning and indeed much has changed. There are no more loutish manchildren paired with Heigl; films like 27 Dresses, The Ugly Truth, and Life As We Know It saw the lady trade up for a slew of more chiseled, yet ultimately more interchangeable male co-stars. On one hand this is maybe a good thing: the trope of a beautiful, fit women being paired with a slovenly, slacker idiot is as tiring, sexist and entrenched as anything in pop culture, but the stories surrounding Heigl's various pairings with Beefcake #1 or Beefcake #2 are so prescriptive to rom-com formula that any sort of creative progression for her career has been ultimately thwarted. What's worse is that after getting mauled repeatedly by the critics and ignored by audiences (Higel's latest effort, The Big Wedding, flopped predictably) the actress seems to have not learned her lesson (she has a couple of films coming up that seem hardly promising). Not a good place to be for someone with a career on life support.

6. John Travolta

John Travolta should know better by now. After his 1994 appearance in Quentin Tarantino's legendary Pulp Fiction, the actor was given an Oscar nomination and more importantly a shot at a new beginning, but, to put it simply, he squandered it. Things started off promisingly of course, with his roles in Get Shorty, Face Off and Primary Colors showcasing the swaggering charisma that attracted us to Travolta in the first place. But similar to his pre-Pulp Fiction days the actor's legendary ego seemed to get the better of him by the beginning of the 2000s. First there was Battlefield Earth - a repugnant, unholy pet project if there ever was one - which was followed by the almost equally silly Swordfish, an insipid adaptation of the The Punisher and a pair of idiotic farces (Wild Hogs and Old Dogs) by the director of Van Wilder: Party Liaison. It's easy to understand what drew Travolta to many of these projects. Pulp Fiction put him back into superstar territory, the place where actors can command insane money per film (he made $20 million for at least nine of his films since 1997). Making this type of coin would turn anyone goofy, and perhaps mar their ability to pursue artistically resonant work. Yet, it has never been clear whether Travolta wasn't simply an odd duck to begin with: this is a man who will probably continue to self destruct professionally, and this time even QT might not be able to save him.

5. Orlando Bloom

There was a time when Orlando Bloom had a novel appeal. After his bit part in Black Hawk Down, which basically amounted to him falling out of the titular helicopter (still his best role), Bloom turned himself into a global heartbreaker with his appearance as Legolas in The Lord Of The Rings. In those films Bloom rather limited repertoire served him well; he was simply one part of a large, sprawling ensemble, and both his elven genetics and the way he was directed meant he didn't act normally. Each film found Bloom being employed as a little more than a beautiful albeit vapid piece of spectacle that ran, jumped and shield surfed into movie history. The role of Legolas complimented Bloom's arid, laconic and most of all emotionless acting, and it was no surprise that his transition away from the stoic elf proved to be fraught with misfortune. Oh sure, he did power through with the mega successful Pirates series - but that was mostly due to riding Johnny Depp's flamboyantly drunken coat-tails. His other efforts were either flops or floppish (Ned Kelly, Kingdom of Heaven), or were packed with so much star power that they didn't really prove Bloom's capabilities as a leading man (Troy). These days Bloom has mostly been resigned to smaller films - which should be a reprieve after so much sword and sandaling, but his perplexing recent return to Middle Earth suggests that the lessons of Bloom's past have not stuck, not enough at least to keep that blonde wig away.

4. Johnny Depp

Some of Johnny Depp's supporters are so vehement in their adoration and so enraptured with his work, that anyone seeking to criticize the man basically merits a death sentence, but he's not learning his own lessons. Whichever way you look at his recent career evolution it's obvious that Depp patently lacks self-awareness. This criticism is applicable both in a critical analysis of his recent output - with someone needing to tell this man to stop acting like a painted fool - and in a business sense (the last three Depp vehicles arrived stillborn at the box office). One dreams of the time when this man appeared in a diverse array of smaller films (like under 100 million dollars) - films like Donnie Brasco, What's Eating Gilbert Grape, Ed Wood, and Dead Man. Hell, at this point we would even take The Ninth Gate or The Astronaut's Wife. But Depp has shown no desire to head back in that direction, instead choosing to ram another blast of Captain Jack down our throats, or continuing to persevere with the relationship with Tim Burton that has largely been responsible for his career nose-dive.

3. Adam Sandler

Nobody on this planet seems to have as little regard for the human cost associated with their product as Adam Sandler. Just take a moment and consider the past ten years of his career: it's natural to look at this man's output and feel uneasy: the thematic content of his films is also shockingly insensitive; not to mention completely incongruent with our contemporary era and Sandler's alleged age. Like a half-senile grandparent spewing racial epithets over a family dinner, Sandler hits all the wrong notes. Whether he's revelling in homophobia (I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry), or engaging in the most infantile of toilet humor (the CGI deer urination scene from Grown Ups 2), it's clear that Sandler doesn't care about what he's doing. It's also clear that he cares little about changing his ways, with each film being more stubbornly committed to an ugly, immature and utterly self-absorbed worldview than the last. Entering into a Sandler film these days is like entering the mind of a drooling, spoiled, and perhaps idiotic child. You recognize that you're encountering something so committed to its own selfish pleasures that it can't even begin to approach empathy for anyone else. While to some degree this has always been the case with the actor, his early work was infused with at least an iota of surreal imagination (such as immortal fist fight with Bob Barker from Happy Gilmore) and a modicum of feeling (The Wedding Singer) but those days are long gone.

2. Harrison Ford

There's something profoundly sad about watching an old codger jump back into the saddle that was hung up decades ago. Such was the case with the The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull; a film that essentially neutered everyone's favourite archeologist. This travesty turned one of the screen's most badass characters into something utterly embarrassing: like an old man who attempts to help out with his grandson's baseball practice and fails miserably. Most of the blame for the limp noodle adventure that is The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull does not belong to Ford however, but to the two chuckleheads who sat behind the camera: George Lucas and Steven Spielberg. One only has to watch a few minutes of the film's hilarious behind the scenes footage to recognize that the vim and vinegar that fuelled Spielberg's kinetic (and surprisingly brutal) 80s action films has completely dissipated. There's not much left of the wonderkid who exploded Nazi's heads with gleeful, macabre abandon, or heavily suggested that Indy was actually a statutory rapist. No, instead of giving us one more ride with the screen's ultimate action hero Lucas and Spielberg served up an emasculated puff piece (which should just be called The Lucas Special at this point). With such dubious (and perhaps even alarming) individuals at the helm of your film, why would you ever choose to continue working with them? That is the central question orbiting around Ford's jaw dropping decision to make yet another Indy film, and perhaps to a slightly lesser degree, his commitment to Star Wars Episode 7. Similar to Bruce Willis and his Die Hard series, Ford seems eager to not only make another final boat load of cash, but to have us all on our knees - weeping and praying for deliverance from another round with a geriatric hero. It seems vindictive; hateful really. It also suggests that its not that Ford hasn't learned from his recent mistake, but that he doesn't care to learn.

1. Christopher Walken

Christopher Walken is another actor who, like Harrison Ford, at this point has probably ceased caring about a large majority of his cinematic output, if he ever did. Walken is on record for saying that he will only turn down a role if he is already too busy with other projects, which is reflected powerfully in his filmography, where he has appeared in over 40 films since 2000. Now, one shouldn't be overly critical of of the man; he brightens most films, even if its just in a superficial, "Oh there's Christopher Walken" kind of way. Still, for as hilarious as it is to watch Walken strut about in a kimono, scream with an outrageous pair of fang-like dentures, or gracefully dance to Fat Boy Slim, one can't shake off the feeling that the actor, more often than not, is underselling himself. When he is actually not just goofing around Walken can turn in some really stellar work, work that resonates on more levels than broad, cartoonish humor. The examples from his filmography are extensive: the quiet, nuanced cello player in The Late Quartet; his absorbing if repellent drug addict from Around the Bend; and the optimistic albeit burdened father he played in Catch Me if You Can are just a few of them. For as many darts as this man throws it is not surprising that only a small portion of them hit the bullseye (movies that offer a large, meaty part to Walken only appear sporadically). You would think that because of this inconsistency Walken would have become a bit more choosy, especially as he has gotten longer in the tooth. Yet, the opposite seems to have occurred, with Walken having (on average) about three films released every year for the past decade. What this suggests is that audiences will be seeing a lot more Walken in near future, a fact that is both bad and good all at the same time. Which other actors lack the self-awareness to move on from their worst career mistakes? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Adam Mohrbacher has been afflicted with an obession for film since his earliest memories. In addition to his work with WhatCulture, Adam has been a contributor with Filmophilia.com, FilmMonthly.com and Examiner.com. You can also check out his personal blog here: adammohrbacher@wordpress.com. A devoted fan of all film genres and styles, Adam gets equally giddy over the sensitive, existential musings of Ingmar Bergman, and the brawny brilliance of Arnold Schwartzenegger. He loves fish tacos and misses the work of Heath Ledger and Jack Lemmon on a daily basis.