10 Actors Who Could Replace Ezra Miller As The Flash

If Warner Bros. pulls the plug on Ezra, these ten stars could step in as the Scarlet Speedster.

The Flash Grant Gustin Ezra Miller
Warner Bros.

Like the mythological Icarus, some stars get burned when they fly too close to the sun. Such is the case with Justice League star Ezra Miller. Months of speculation ended when Miller was cast in the primo role of Barry Allen, aka The Flash. Miller's take on Flash was well-received by fans and critics alike, even almost-kinda winning an Academy Award.

The scene in Justice League, when Flash enters the speed force, won an award for most "cheer-worthy" moment. Everything was coming up aces for Ezra before a string of bizarre, even criminal behaviour, began raising eyebrows. First, a video surfaced, showing Miller choking a woman and throwing her to the ground. Two years later, Ezra was arrested and charged with disorderly conduct and harassment. Soon after, Miller was again taken into custody for second-degree assault after allegedly throwing a chair at a woman, leaving a cut on her head.

No doubt, Warner Bros. executives have already devised a short list of potential replacements for Miller.

If it's up to your writer, these ten actors have what it takes to step in as the Scarlet Speedster.

10. Théodore Pellerin

Théodore Pellerin there's someone inside your house
Netflix

He may be a longshot, but if Warner Bros. opts to cast a relative unknown, they may want to consider Théodore Pellerin. The Canadian actor has only been on the scene since 2014, but has recently starred in the Netflix slasher film There's Someone Inside Your House.

Aside from having the appropriate "fit nerd" look, Pellerin has some legitimate acting credibility to back him up. In Canada, Pellerin is best known for his performance in the 2018 movie Family First. For this, he was awarded the Prix Iris (imagine a Best Actor Oscar, but only for the Quebec movie industry) and the Canadian Screen Award for Best Actor at the 7th Canadian Screen Awards.

Pellerin, a native French speaker, has improved his English-speaking skills to the point where he has convincingly portrayed American characters. His malleability as an actor could also broaden The Flash's emotional range in the DCEU. Ezra Miller can pull off being a brilliant but affable Barry Allen, but Pellerin's depth may be a bit better at taking the audience on a more satisfying emotional journey. Considering the narrative of the Flashpoint Paradox, it's going to take any actor more than looking good in the suit to really make it work.


9. Finn Wolfhard

Ghostbusters Afterlife Finn Wolfhard
Sony Pictures Releasing

Another native Canadian, Finn Wolfhard is a little young to step in as Barry Allen. A decade younger than Ezra Miller, making this move would require a little narrative tweaking. Of the actors in this list, Wolfhard is the one who most resembles a young Ezra Miller. Since the Flash movie will be heavily influenced by the comic book Flashpoint Paradox, any age-related logic gaps are easily filled. Besides, he's the kid from Stranger Things.

Now is the time for Wolfhard to capitalize on his momentum. Stranger Things is still one of the biggest shows on Netflix. He stole the show as Richie Tozier in the remake of Stephen King's IT, and he is also now forever a part of the Ghostbusters canon.

Wolfhard already excels at being the nervy, frenetic guy in an ensemble cast, and he already has name recognition with huge intellectual properties. More importantly, he's been good in everything he's been in. They say timing is everything. While superhero movies (except Morbius) are still ruling the box office, this would be the time to snag this rising star and make him a franchise player.


8. Tanner Buchanan

He's All That
Netflix

Cobra Kai star Tanner Buchanan's career is at a point where it's ripe for a breakout role like The Flash. Buchanan's career started in 2010 and has mostly consisted of television roles, both in episodic TV and TV movies. It was his performance as Leo Kirkman in the Kiefer Sutherland-led series Designated Survivor that brought a new level of attention to the actor.

In 2021, Buchanan got his first real taste of being a leading man in the forgettable remake of She's All That (titled He's All That). Luckily for him, this all led to Tanner being cast as Robbie Keene in the Netflix series Cobra Kai. As the estranged son of Karate Kid antagonist Johnny Lawrence, Buchanan convincingly portrays the struggle of a teenager hating his father, yet desperately seeking his approval through karate. Buchanan not only plays a major role in the show, but had to physically prepare for the part of a karate champion.

Buchanan has shared his gruelling Cobra Kai workouts online. It's clear that he's not afraid to work hard, and he looks legitimate in action scenes. Onscreen, he can fight and he can emote-ingredients for a quality Flash.


7. Barry Keoghan

Eternals Druig
Marvel Studios

Historical precedent tells us that playing a hero for one company doesn't necessarily mean you can't also wear the other company's cape. Keoghan's turn as Druig in The Immortals was one of the brightest spots in an otherwise mediocre entry into the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

The Irish-born Keoghan garnered critical acclaim for his performance in the 2017 psychological horror film The Killing of a Sacred Deer, alongside Colin Farrell. The performance earned Keoghan an Irish Film and Television Award and a nomination for the Independent Spirit Award, both for best supporting actor.

In Marvel's Eternals, Keoghan stood his ground among an ensemble that included Lara Croft, Jon Snow, Robb Stark and Santanico Pandemonium (Angelina Jolie, Kit Harrington, Richard Madden and Salma Hayek). With such a strong cast, the relatively unknown Irishman managed to become the heart of the movie.

Now, the potential fly in the ointment: Keoghan is technically already a member of the DC Extended Universe. He appeared briefly as the Joker in Matt Reeves' The Batman. Since his Joker appeared with "Patt-Man" instead of "Bat-fleck", we know that Joker and Flash are from two different worlds in DC's multiverse. No retconning needed.


6. Jonah Hauer-King

jonah hauer-king world on fire
BBC

This British actor is set to make his big break in 2023 as Prince Eric in the live-action version of The Little Mermaid. Disney may have some thoughts regarding their new leading man jumping over to work with Warner Bros., but Hauer-King would be a solid long shot for the role of Barry Allen.

Jonah has only been on the scene since 2014, and his credits included only film shorts until he was cast in Danny Huston's 2017 British drama, The Last Photograph. Eight feature films, two BBC mini-series, a TV movie and a recurring show role later, Hauer-King is set to truly make his name when The Little Mermaid releases. At that point, the 26-year-old would be ripe for the casting of the Sultan of the Speed.

Hot off the heels of a major Disney property, Warner Bros. could scour the gild off of that particular lily by giving Hauer-King a crack at the red and yellow. He may have a little less experience than others on this list, but he carries himself with both a boyish charm and dramatic intensity that could make him a real contender.


5. Austin Butler

Austin Butler Shannara Chronicles
Sonar Entertainment

Austin Butler started his career in live-action Nickelodeon and Disney Channel shows. As he has matured, so have his roles. Austin's career started when a representative from a background acting management company approached him at the Orange County fair in 2004. During the first few years, Butler cut a swath through the Disney Channel line-up. He appeared on Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide, Hannah Montana, iCarly and Zoey 101 among others.

Butler got his first taste of the superhero world when he appeared as club DJ/assassin Chase in three episodes of Arrow. Since then, the actor's career has expanded into a much more interesting body of work. He appeared with Bill Murray and Adam Driver in the Jim Jarmusch comedy/horror gem The Dead Don't Die, and he then found himself a long way from The Disney Channel when he portrayed Manson family member Tex Watson in Quentin Tarantino's classic Once Upon a Time... In Hollywood.

Butler's star is still only growing. He will soon appear as the titular character in Elvis (Presley, not Costello) and will also be in the sequel to 2021's Dune. When Ezra Miller was cast as Flash, he also was on his way up. It very well could be Austin Butler he bumps into on his way back down.


4. Aaron Taylor-Johnson

Avengers Age Of Ultron Quicksilver
Marvel Studios

One thing that Aaron Taylor-Johnson has over every other actor on this list is that he as already portrayed a costumed hero twice, and one was a super-speedy hero in a major franchise.

It's been over a decade since Taylor-Johnson broke onto the hero scene in the film adaptation of underground comic favorite Kick Ass. Cast as Quicksilver in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the Brit was criminally underutilized. After packing on a few years and several pounds of muscle, Taylor-Johnson was spot on in his portrayal of Pietro Maximoff.

In the MCU, Quicksilver was written mostly to add weight to his sister Wanda's story arc. When Pietro was killed by gunfire while protecting Hawkeye and a young boy, fans of the comics were let down by his early, unceremonious demise. When considering that the multiverse has already given fans plenty of crossover action between Sony and Marvel properties, Taylor-Johnson could have interacted with Magneto (his father within the pages of Marvel Comics). Since they didn't go that route, the Godzilla star should have no issue trading in the grey tights for red.

Between Kick Ass and Quicksilver, Aaron Taylor-Johnson has proven that he can play a super-fast hero and one with a biting sense of humor. Put them together, stir vigorously, and you get The Flash.


3. Dylan O’Brien

Maze Runner Scorch Trials Thomas
20th Century Fox

Maze Runner alum Dylan O'Brien's star status has been steadily rising over the last eight years. His first notable job in acting was in 2010 as Clever Trevor in the high school drama Sweety High. The following year, O'Brien made the most of an opportunity when he was cast as Stiles in the MTV series Teen Wolf. He then took the wacky sidekick role and transformed Stiles into an emotionally investable character.

This led to O'Brien's biggest role to date, that of Thomas in the Maze Runner trilogy. Dylan is another example of a young actor who can flow seamlessly between moments of grave intensity to moments of stammering silliness... kind of like Ezra Miller's Flash. For a great example of this, see his performance as lead character Joel in 2020's Love and Monsters.

After starring in Maze Runner and voicing Bumblebee, O'Brien could score a franchise hat trick with the DC Extended Universe. There is also one major advantage that he has over the other entrants in this list. Reports have already been circulating that Dylan O'Brien is on the Warner Bros./DC short list of actors to replace ,Ezra Miller as The Flash.


2. Timothée Chalamet

Dune Timothee Chalamet
Warner Bros.

Oscar nominee Timothée Chalamet has both the look and the acting chops to slide seamlessly into the red and yellow. The native New Yorker began acting early in life. As a child, he appeared in several commercials and two horror shorts: Sweet Tooth and Clown. In 2012, Chalamet was in eight episodes of the acclaimed Showtime series Homeland.

Timothée worked consistently from 2012 to 2020, appearing in 17 films (including Interstellar, Ladybird and The Adderall Diaries). His breakout role in 2017's Call Me by Your Name earned Chalamet an Oscar nomination for Best Actor.

2021 was the year of Timothée Chalamet when he starred in the remake of the 1984 epic Dune, as well as the Adam McKay satire Don't Look Up (where he ocassionally upstaged Jennifer Lawrence and Leonardo DiCaprio). Chalamet appears to still be on an upward trajectory. He is being brought back for Dune: Part Two and recently wrapped production on Wonka, where he will play a young Willy Wonka who meets the Oompa-Loompas for the first time.

If DC does choose to replace Ezra Miller, it wouldn't be until after the upcoming Flash movie. With Dune: Part Two currently in pre-production, the Hollywood stars may align just right...


1. Grant Gustin

Grant Gustin The Flash
DC

Although Aaron Taylor-Johnson may have experience playing a costumed speedster, Grant Gustin is the only person on this list (or in the world) who can say he has played the actual Flash for a decade. When Gustin was introduced as Barry Allen on The CW's Arrow, he quickly became a fan favorite. Gustin's popularity carried over to his own "Berlantiverse" series, The Flash.

The Flash became the most popular and highest-rated of all six DC shows on the CW network, and Gustin appeared in five of the six shows in crossover events throughout the seasons. When Ezra Miller was cast as The Flash for the DCEU, fans online were outraged that the studio didn't find a way to keep Gustin in the role. Understandably so. Although Gustin isn't the first actor to play the Scarlet Speedster, he has arguably done it best. He's certainly had the most success with it.

More-so, Grant Gustin is undeniably likable. He hasn't been at the center of any abhorrent criminal behavior or controversies, and appears to be as nice of a guy as the one he plays on TV.

The concept of a multiverse has been at the heart of major storylines for both Marvel and DC comics. The Flashpoint Paradox gives DC an easy out to bring Gustin in.


Contributor
Contributor

George is a life-long fan of genre, wrestling and guitars. He is an actor, writer, CrossFit trainer and former WWE storyline writer. He currently works as talent development for PWX wrestling and resides in the birthplace of the zombie movie, Pittsburgh, PA.