10 Actors Who Gave Their Best & Worst Performance In The Same Year
Those stars who have shone and sucked in quick succession.
In the movie business, all it takes is one stunning performance to launch an actor to superstardom, or one awful performance to end a career.
This most volatile of industries is a sucker for lifting its inhabitants up to the highest of highs, whilst forever being prepared to drop them like a bad habit when things get a little shaky. And for some of those involved in the glitz and glamour of Hollywood, one misstep can prove tough to ever come back from.
Such is the erratic nature of the silver screen, there have been times when an actor has shown their brilliance and their not-so-brilliance in different projects over a short space of time. In particular, the focus here is on those names who have somehow been able to show the best and the worst of themselves in pictures released in the same year as each other. For whatever reason, these stars have both shone and sucked in quick succession, often in back-to-back features.
Taking all of this into account, then, and here are ten major movie stars who managed to have both their best and their worst cinematic outings in theaters within the same calendar year.
10. Melissa McCarthy - 2018
Melissa McCarthy is an actress who clearly made her name in comedy, with roles in Gilmore Girls, Mike and Molly, Bridesmaids, The Heat, and Tammy just some of those which pushed her into the mainstream.
So, when McCarthy was announced to replace Oscar-winner Julianne Moore on Marielle Heller's Can You Forgive Me?, a fair few eyebrows were raised at the Illinois native's casting in such a serious picture.
Based on the 2008 confessional memoir of Lee Israel, Can You Forgive Me? had McCarthy star as Israel - the struggling writer who looked to reinvigorate her career by forging letters from dead authors. Mesmerising in the role, Melissa grabbed herself an Academy Award nom for her work here, with co-star Richard E. Grant likewise getting himself an Oscar nomination.
What made Can You Forgive Me? stand out even more, was the fact that it came directly after The Happytown Murders. Despite the premise of a tongue-in-cheek gritty puppet-human buddy cop picture sounding like a fun one, The Happytown Murders was brutally bad and ranks as the worst movie which McCarthy has been the star attraction on.
9. Patrick Stewart - 2017
Sir Patrick Stewart is one of the modern-day greats of the acting world.
In a career brimming with excellent turns on screens both big and small, and the stage, it could easily be argued that the greatest movie performance of Sir Patrick's is his appearance as an elderly, unstable and ill Charles Xavier in 2017's Logan.
There, audiences found a Professor X whose extreme powers had been left erratic due to his age and a brain disease. As this frail Charles, Stewart was on phenomenal form, bringing a whole array of varying emotions to this beloved character.
Somewhat bizarrely, that same year also saw Patrick Stewart take on the role of Poop in The Emoji Movie. Yes, as in the great thespian and star of stage and screen - the man who is forever immortalised as the iconic Jean-Luc Picard of Star Trek lore - was relegated to voicing a literal piece of s**t.
To his credit, Stewart was fine as Poop. It's just, y'know, this is somewhat of a low for someone of Sir Patrick's quality. As such, by default this marks the worst performance of his career, purely for how everything he's ever done is better than The Emoji Movie.
8. Sandra Bullock - 2009
It takes a most unique aligning of the stars (see: projects) for an actor to appear in films in the same year that land them an Oscar nomination and a Razzie nomination by the time it comes to awards season.
For Sandra Bullock, that was exactly what happened with her 2009 work. Whilst her stunning performance in The Blind Side saw her win the Best Actress gong at the 82nd Academy Awards, her turn in the dire All About Steve resulted in a Golden Raspberry win for Bullock.
Adapted from Michael Lewis' book of the same name, The Blind Side found Bullock playing the adoptive mother of a poverty-stricken young boy who would go onto play in the National Football League. In All About Steve, let's just say things weren't quite as emotive or poignant.
Where All About Steve is concerned, Sandra plays a lonely, desperate woman whose only friend is her hamster. The Steve of the title is played by Bradley Cooper, and Bullock's Mary ends up stalking him after an initial blind date.
Able to poke fun at how bad her performance and the movie were, Bullock actually attended the 2010 Razzies to personally accept her Worst Actress gong. Not just that, but she also gave each member of the audience a DVD of All About Steve. The following night, Sandra Bullock attended the Oscars to pick up her Best Actress award.
7. Josh Hartnett - 2001
Two 2001 movies. Both starring Josh Hartnett. Both loosely based on real-life events. Both with Hartnett playing a member of the military.
Despite those similarities, it's safe to say that Black Hawk Down and Pearl Harbor are two vastly different pictures when it comes to the quality of these '01 offerings.
As SSG Matt Eversmann, Hartnett gave the best performance of his career in Black Hawk Down... even if your writer's bias may often lean towards 30 Days of Night. Based on the US military's 1993 raid in Mogadishu, Somalia, the film itself is phenomenal and wound up taking home two Academy Awards. For Hartnett, his burgeoning reputation as one of Hollywood's hottest rising stars was solidified here, with the picture marking him out as a genuine top tier talent.
It was for being 'one of Hollywood's hottest rising stars', though, that Michael Bay was so eager to sign Josh Hartnett up for his Pearl Harbor - which released six months prior to Black Hawk Down.
Painfully long, ludicrously historically inaccurate, brimming with excruciating dialogue, bizarrely weaving a love triangle into the real 7 December 1941 bombing of Pearl Harbor, and anchored by two dismal performances from Hartnett and Ben Affleck, Bay's picture was universally panned upon its release.
Whilst Black Hawk Dawn would show Josh Hartnett as his best, his performance as Pearl Harbor's USAAC Captain Danny Walker was the actor at his worst.
6. Ewan McGregor - 1996
Having already impressed a year prior in Shallow Grave and, to a lesser degree, Blue Juice, 1996 was when Ewan McGregor launched himself to superstardom.
So much of said 'launching' was down to McGregor's career-best turn as Mark Renton in Danny Boyle's Trainspotting, whilst Brassed Off was another '96 effort for which the Scot also received praise.
Shining a spotlight on the drug addiction and poverty that was rife in certain areas of Edinburgh, Trainspotting was an engaging, entertainment, uber-cool picture that forever had a gut punch waiting around the corner. And as Renton - or Rent Boy, as his pals called him - McGregor was marvellous as the addict desperate to escape the long, long reach of that urge for your next hit.
While Trainspotting and Brassed Off made for a fantastic 1996 for Ewan McGregor - and that year's The Pillow Book was decent enough - the actor also took on the role of Frank Churchill in Douglas McGrath's adaptation of Jane Austen's Emma.
Trainspotting might have seen McGregor's Renton swimming around in sh*t at one point, but Emma saw him often spouting a sh*t-eating grin in a mixed bag of a movie. His delivery here felt extremely clunky, his chemistry with Gwyneth Paltrow's titular lead was nowhere to be seen, and even Ewan himself has since stated - such as to BBC Radio 1 (via Digital Spy) in 2004 - how he regrets doing the project because he simply wasn't very good in it.
5. Tom Cruise - 1988
While Dusting Hoffman took home a Best Actor Academy Award for his role as Ray Babbitt in Rain Man - one of an impressive four Oscar wins for the film - so much of the heavy lifting fundamentals of this 1988 picture were done by Tom Cruise as Ray's brother Charlie.
By 1988, Cruise was hot on the back of Risky Business, Top Gun, and The Color of Money - and '88 started off extremely rough with Cocktail, before Rain Man came along and delivered The Cruise's greatest performance.
Of course, an actor with the tenure and sheer variety of credits as Tom Cruise is going to cause debate when it comes to their best performance - and some may well point to one of his Ethan Hunt outings in the Mission: Impossible series - but Rain Man was a pivotal moment in the actor's career.
As alluded to, prior to Rain Man's release, 1988 also saw Cocktail hitting cinema screens. With Cruise as a New York business student 'forced' to take a job as a barman, the film is a bit, well, naff; so much so, the movie and Cruise were both nominated for a Razzie Award.
Interestingly, Tom Cruise has since told Rolling Stone how Cocktail was "not a crowning jewel" of his career - which is polite actor chatter for "it was total dogs**t, mate".
4. Uma Thurman - 1994
Cast-wise, Even Cowgirls Get the Blues is brimming with talent. While it was Uma Thurman headlining as Sissy Hankshaw in Gus Van Sant's 1994 picture, the film also featured Lorraine Bracco, Angie Dickinson, Keanu Reeves, John Hurt, Pat Morita, Roseane Barr, Crispin Glover, Ed Begley Jr., Carol Kane, Sean Young, Lin Shaye, Edward James Olmos, and even William Burroughs.
Adapted from Tom Robbins' 1976 novel of the same name, Even Cowgirls Get the Blues finds Thurman playing a hitchhiker with abnormally long thumbs. Eventually finding herself on a ranch, Uma's Sissy character becomes part of a group of cowgirls who end up in a shootout to the death with a slew of government agencies over the status of a bunch of crane birds which have nested at the ranch.
Even Cowgirls Get the Blues bombed hard, with Thurman coming in for particular criticism - to the point that she, like others on this list, was nominated for a Golden Razzie for this awful performance.
On the flip side of 1994, though, this was also the year that Uma shot to superstardom following her outing as Mia Wallace in Quentin Tarantino's Pulp Fiction. Viewed by many to this day as Tarantino's finest hour, Pulp Fiction was a pop culture phenomenon upon its release - with Thurman front 'n' centre on the poster and marketing for the film, as she put in likely the finest performance of her career.
3. Alec Baldwin - 2003
When thinking of the great Alec Baldwin movie performances, three films that immediately spring to mind are Glengarry Glen Ross, The Cooler, and The Departed.
For sure, Glengarry Glen Ross and The Departed find a Baldwin in majestic, magnetic form, but those respective roles are relatively small ones. So, if truly breaking down Alec's greatest cinematic outing - and no, it's not Beetlejuice - one has to go with his turn as Shelly Kaplow in 2003's The Cooler.
In that Wayne Kramer-helmed offering, Baldwin's Shelly is a Las Vegas casino manager obsessed with keeping his 'cooler' - the venue's resident bad luck charm - miserable in order to stop said casino from having too many winners. For his work here, the 30 Rock star picked up his only Academy Award nomination to date.
Hot the heels of this impressive outing, that November would see Baldwin as Larry Quinn, the main villain of Mike Myers' dreadful The Cat in the Hat feature. So bad was this Dr. Seuss adaptation, it failed to make its budget back at the box office, it currently has a 9% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and the widow of Theodor Seuss Geisel refused to allow a planned sequel to be made.
2. Jennifer Lawrence - 2012
Far from being one of those film snobs who turns their nose up at any and all horror movies, your writer here is actually a major horror nerd. As such, there's a strong tolerance when it comes to some of the slightly more ropey entries in the horror genre.
That said, it's tough to argue that 2012's House at the End of the Street isn't a total stinker of a movie. A generic, scare-free 'scary movie' that tries far too hard to make itself appear smarter than it really is, the film hitches itself to Jennifer Lawrence in the hope that her burgeoning megastar status could elevate the picture. Instead, the movie drags Lawrence down to its level, rather than vice versa.
In an admittedly smart move, Relativity Media pushed House at the End of the Street's release back seven months from February 2012 to that September. Why was that done, and why was that smart? Well, that's because the film was then on screens two weeks after the Lawrence-starring Silver Linings Playbook received its world premiere to huge buzz.
As a troubled young widow who has her focus on Bradley Cooper's bipolar disorder-suffering Pat Solitano Jr., Lawrence's performance as Tiffany won the then-22-year-old an Academy Award for Best Actress - with Silver Linings Playbook also receiving a further seven Oscar nominations.
1. Benedict Cumberbatch - 2021
It may be a smidge controversial, but some people came out of Spider-Man: No Way Home thinking that Benedict Cumberbatch was a little, well, off as Doctor Strange.
This latest outing for Cumberbatch as the Master of the Mystic Arts wasn't exactly awful, but it's more that this was a mild misstep in a career that's been full of great performances. Whether it was how easy Strange caved to Spider-Man's pleas to erase all knowledge of his secret identity, how extremely cold he was in certain situations, or even how some fans went into No Way Home expecting Strange to possibly even really be Mephisto in disguise... things just didn't feel right.
Released less than a month before Spider-Man: No Way Home, Cumberbatch got to take centre-stage as Phil Burbank in Jane Campion's 1925-set The Power of the Dog.
Here, the Sherlock favourite gets to dig deep into a fascinating, multi-layered character who is quick to ridicule, easy to anger, brazenly jealous, yet has a whole lot more going on under the surface. The entire cast - which includes Kirsten Dunst, Jesse Plemons and Kodi Smit-McPhee - are all fantastic in The Power of the Dog, with Cumberbatch particularly shining bright.
For those who've seen this Netflix release, it'll come as no surprise to hear The Power of the Dog and Cumberbatch already in the conversation for next year's Academy Awards.