10 Actors Who Keep Getting Miscast

Someone please give these actors better roles!

Jared Leto Morbius
Sony Pictures

Casting is a weird business. There isn’t an exact science to it. It usually involves agents and backdoor deals and sacrifices to Kthulu who, in its free time, obviously heads a major Hollywood studio.

But seriously, there’s an old saying in Hollywood that an actor is only as good as their last performance. Therein lies the problem: what if an actor keeps landing the wrong roles?

When this happens, an actor runs the risk of being pigeonholed into playing the same roles over and over again, even if they have already proven they have the chops to do something completely different.

So the following are examples of actors who keep getting handed the wrong roles, along with suggestions for what kinds of roles they might be better suited for.

Casting directors take notes!

10. Halle Berry

Halle Berry Kingsman
20th Century Fox

Halle Berry made a splash in the 90s and early 2000s. In between performances as Storm in the first two X-Men films, she won an Academy Award for the drama Monster’s Ball. It seemed like her career would just keep going hirer as she landed the lead in the standalone Catwoman film—then it turned out to be the cinematic equivalent of kitty litter.

Berry’s career never fully rebounded from that disaster. Although she returned as Storm for two more X-Men sequels, she has appeared mostly in universally lauded films like Cloud Atlas, Movie 43, and Kidnap. In 2018 she turned up in Kingsman: The Golden Circle, but was criminally underutilized.

For the last 15 years or so the roles she has been given just don’t showcase what made her appealing at the beginning of her career. She has unmistakable charm coupled with intelligence and toughness. Given her Oscar win for Monster’s Ball, she can bring on the dramatic feels when she wants to as well.

There is a glimmer of hope for Berry, though, as with last year’s John Wick Chapter 3: Parabellum she nabbed a stunt-heavy role that she trained for furiously alongside costar Keanu Reeves. Her appearance in John Wick 3 was a return to what makes her one of the greatest actresses of her generation. More of this, please!


9. Charlie Hunnam

Charlie Hunnam King Arthur: Legend Of The Sword
Warner Bros. Pictures

The TV series Sons of Anarchy was a hit for Charlie Hunnam, but so far his big screen credits are a string of duds, including Guy Richie’s wannabe-300 King Arthur flick and a remake of Papillon that nobody asked for. The only popular film on his resume thus far has been Pacific Rim, but he did not return for the sequel, reportedly so he could focus on Papillon—big mistake, Chuck!

Hunnam’s wheelhouse is playing antiheroes and psychopaths, like his role on Sons of Anarchy. He turned down 50 Shades of Grey, which in retrospect, his take on the role of Christian Grey might have been what was missing from those films.

We’ll see how he does in Guy Richie’s upcoming The Gentlemen, playing the right-hand man to Matthew McConaughey’s gangster character [editor's note: our UK team has seen the movie already and it's great... check out our review HERE).

Hunnam also has a new TV series in the works, in which he will play a prison escapee who changes his identity.


8. Ryan Reynolds

Ryan Reynolds Free Guy
Fox

Aside from Deadpool, what is your favorite Ryan Reynolds movie? We’ll wait while you think of an answer. In films like Life, Criminal, and the Woman in Gold his performances can best be described as “Wait, he was in those movies?” Reynolds just isn’t good at playing the everyman character. He does best when he’s playing over-the-top. Not just over-the-top comic relief like he’s done in action flicks like The Hitman’s Bodyguard and R.I.P.D. all the way back to Blade: Trinity. No, Reynolds does best when he is the over-the-top guy caught up in a world that is equally over-the-top.

The upcoming film Free Guy will see Reynolds playing a man who becomes aware that he is an NPC in a Grand Theft Auto-type video game where innocent bystanders like himself are completely expendable. Now that sounds exactly like the kind of Ryan Reynolds role we should see more of.

Of course we will still see more of him playing Wade Wilson aka Deadpool, but after his Deadpool tenure ends, Reynolds would literally smash if he stepped into full-on comedic roles like Jim Carrey or Robin Williams used to inhabit. Enough with trying to be the tough-guy, Ryan. Go back to your comedy roots. Never forget you were once on a sitcom called 2 Guys, A Girl, and a Pizza Place!


7. Hugh Jackman

The Greatest Showman Poster Hugh Jackman
20th Century Fox

Hugh Jackman suffers from the same curse as Ryan Reynolds in that he’s had terrible luck breaking away from the superhero role he was born to play. Jackman has tried nearly every possible type of leading man role. He can do musicals like Les Miserables and The Greatest Showman. He can do gritty dramas like Prisoners. What he fails at are obvious award-baiting roles like in last year’s The Frontrunner and 2008’s Baz Lurhman catastrophe, Australia.

Jackman rose to the occasion in The Prestige playing an immoral fame-seeking magician opposite on-screen foil Christian Bale. He was great in Eddie the Eagle playing a has-been Olympic skier. He was even great in Real Steel playing a similar role.

If Jackman truly wants to win awards, then maybe instead of films like The Front Runner he should find more reluctant father-figure roles like he played in Eddie the Eagle, Real Steel, and Logan?


6. Dane Dehaan

Valerian And The City Of A Thousand Planets Dane DeHaan
Europacorp

Dane Dehaan isn’t quite a household name, but a handful of stellar performances prove that he should be. Only as it currently stands, the casting gods have not been kind to Dehaan. He followed up a powerful performance in Chronicle with the high stakes role as Harry Osborn/the Green Goblin in Amazing Spider-Man 2. Although the film did well at the box office, audiences and critics alike did not care for the direction this series was taking, and so further sequels were scrapped. It didn’t help his career that Dehaan’s rather pointless role in the film being one of the main nitpicks people had (and that misguided design to his supervillain).

After ASM2, Dehaan starred in Gore Verbinski’s psychological horror film, A Cure for Wellness. In that he played a skeevy Wall Street type, which he is actually fit for. Then, in a major step backwards, he starred in Luc Besson’s Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets. While Dehaan turns in a fine performance in the titular role, he didn’t have quite the right energy to be a swashbuckling smartass star pilot. The role called for someone with a little more swagger, a Chris Pratt-type, which Dehaan is anything but.

What Dehaan excels at is playing creeps and douchebags. His attempts to leap over into leading man are a bit premature. He needs a good 5 or 10 more years of playing baddies before he can make that crossover. Dane, look at Ben Foster’s career. Take notes.


5. Jennifer Garner

Peppermint Jennifer Garner
STXfilms

Jennifer Garner’s breakout role was as the star of the early 2000s espionage television show Alias. Ever since, Garner has been reduced to roles as worried girlfriends (as in Draft Day), worried moms (in Love, Simon), just worried women in general. She’s basically the girl-next-door type, which was part of the appeal of Alias as she played a normal college student by day, Black Widow-type ass-kicking spy by night.

In 2018 Garner tried to go back to her Alias roots in the revenge movie Peppermint. It was a total flop. Garner doesn’t necessarily have to play action star for the rest of her life, but she shouldn’t be relegated to worried girlfriend of the male lead, either.

There have to be roles out there that meet somewhere in the middle for her. Maybe she’s just waiting for Julia Roberts to retire so she’ll quit taking roles she could play just as easily?


4. Denzel Washington

The Equalizer 2 Denzel Washington
Sony

Denzel Washington has two freaking Academy Awards for his acting but you wouldn’t know it from the posters of his last um-teen movies where he points guns in every direction. Nothing’s more sad than when a bonafide actor like Washington keeps saying yes to action movies (unless they’re good, but let’s face it, the Equalizer is his Taken series, and they aren’t anywhere near as fun).

Mr. Washington hasn’t been in anything good since the 2012 Robert Zemeckis film Flight where he played an airline pilot who also happened to be a falling-down drunk. He was incredible in it, and he was nominated for pretty much every major award for it. Why didn’t his agent immediately follow up Flight with more scripts like it instead of setting him off to the world of Taken ripoffs (which has become the defacto retirement package for Baby Boomer actors).

Here’s an idea: how about playing a grandpa? We know, Training Day was great, but it was also like 20 years ago. You’re 66 dude. It’s time to put the guns down and pick up a cardigan; maybe less equalizing and more sitting on a rocking chair doling out words of wisdom?


3. Adam Sandler

Adam Sandler Uncut Gems
Netflix

Two words: Uncut Gems! Every 10 years or so Adam Sandler reminds us that he can actually act. In between, he insists on cranking out awful comedies derivative of his early hits like The Wedding Singer and Billy Madison (but let’s face it, nothing he has done lately can match the unbridled hilarity of his first 5 or 6 films).

Supposedly these days Sandler picks a location to film his next movie, then takes his costars and crew to the location, as well as any family members they want, and the whole production is a working vacation for everyone. That’s cool and all, but who suffers from this arrangement are the viewers who have to watch yet another weak attempt at comedy.

Then from out of nowhere the Safdie brothers, who were responsible for 2017’s Good Time (which pretty much got Robert Pattinson the gig to play Batman) reached out to Sandler to star in their next film, Uncut Gems. The film went on to become a darling among critics and it is considered by many to be the best performance of Sandler’s long career.

After his success this year, it would be nice if Sandler became more picky about the projects he takes on. Hopefully after his performance in Uncut Gems, more visionary directors will ask Sandler to join their films. He could become the Bill Murray of his generation!


2. Jared Leto

Morbius Jared Leto
Sony Pictures

Jared Leto has to be the most perplexing leading man of our time, in that, why the hell is he even getting leading man roles? He won Best Supporting Actor at the Academy Awards for playing a transgendered person suffering from AIDS in 2013’s Dallas Buyers Club. Leto, normally known for playing heart-throbby roles in his early years before moving onto douchey guys in films like American Psycho and Panic Room, does just fine in those types of supporting roles.

Right after his Oscar-win for Dallas Buyers Club, Leto was given one of the most coveted roles in Hollywood: that of the new Joker in 2016’s Suicide Squad. His take on the character was met with, we could say, maybe 25% approval and 75% outright hatred. Now he’s playing yet another comic book villain, Morbius the Living Vampire? By the looks of the trailer the role could have been played better by a loaf of white bread.

Since Dallas Buyers Club, the best use of Mr. Leto onscreen was undoubtedly in Blade Runner 2049. In that film he played a corporate CEO with a god-complex; in other words, he played a creep—which was what he always did so well before vying for lead roles.

Prognosis: Mr. Leto needs something to take his mind off his quest to playing heroic types. How about a 30 Seconds to Mars world tour? That oughta keep him busy.


1. Eddie Murphy

Eddie Murphy Norbit
Paramount Pictures

Eddie Murphy was on fire all throughout the 80s and 90s as an actor and a comedian. But for the last two decades he’s had a run of mostly forgettable family films like Meet Dave and Norbitt. This turn in his career came at the end of the 90s when took on the role of The Nutty Professor, which then spawned a sequel and several films which followed the formula of Murphy playing multiple roles under heavy prosthetics and makeup. Hollywood was spitting out Eddie Murphy family movies at the rate of about one per year until about 8 years ago.

Perhaps it was career fatigue, but Murphy decided to call it quits on family films, although it has proven to be a tough rut to get himself out of. Murphy has been slowly returning to the fold of more mature work, first in 2006’s musical-drama Dreamgirls, then again in 2011’s crime-comedy Tower Heist. Then there was the 2016 drama Mr. Church which failed at the box office. For years he and Lee Daniels have been trying to get a biopic of Richard Pryor off the ground, in which Murphy would play Pryor’s father.

2019 was the year when hope for an Eddie Murphy comeback started to finally seem possible. Dolemite Is My Name, in which he played the title role of the real life hard-on-his luck comedian Rudy Ray More who became a blaxspoitation star, proved to be just the right material to herald Murphy's comeback. Next up will be a sequel to the raunchy 1988 film Coming to America, a fourth Beverly Hills Cop is in the works, and there are rumors that Murphy is planning a new standup comedy special.


Contributor

Kyle Mustain hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.