10 Actors Who Originally Turned Down Their Most Iconic Roles
Arnold Schwarzenegger didn't wanna play no Terminator.
For any jobbing actor, the thought of turning down a role - no matter how small - is likely to be deemed "unwise," but turning down a large part in a major blockbuster? Well, that's just madness! And yet it does happen - actors turn down huge roles all the time. It's part and parcel of the motion picture business.
In Hollywood, though, minds are easily swayed; offers of more money, advice from friends or family, or a famous director's careful persuasion... it's always possible for an actor to come around to a role that they originally rejected.
If somebody makes it known that they want and believe in you, then it's a lot easier to envision yourself in a part, after all; in addition to a hefty sum of money, getting an actor to accept a role requires a lot of ego work on the part of a filmmaker or studio - a small price to pay, perhaps, if they're convinced it'll make for a better film... or larger profits.
The following 10 actors initially turned down some of their most famous roles, only to discover that it wasn't that easy for them to refuse. In retrospect, most of these guys are probably appreciative for the perseverance that followed their decision to turn down said parts, because these roles went on to become insanely iconic...
10. Robert Shaw Turned Down Quint Because He Hated The Novel - Jaws
There are three pillars of greatness that ensure Jaws still stands as a masterful slice of filmmaking brilliance: Steven Spielberg's pitch-perfect direction, John Williams' iconic score, and Robert Shaw's unforgettable performance as grizzled shark hunter Quint.
Originally, though, Shaw turned down Spielberg's request that he play Quint, because he hated the original novel!
Shaw wasn't the only one who had a problem with Peter Benchley's book, though; it's a well-held belief that Spielberg's real genius was turning an entertaining but ultimately trashy pulp novel into something more artful, so it's not all that surprising that Shaw thought the work was beneath him.
The actor was eventually won around on the insistence of his wife and secretary, and on the basis that he was able to rewrite some of his dialogue, which ultimately led to Shaw penning a large portion of the infamous U.S.S. Indianapolis speech - perhaps the greatest segment of the entire film.
So we have Shaw's wife and secretary to thank for making Jaws into a classic.
9. Arnold Schwarzenegger Thought The T-800 Was A "Sh*t" Part - The Terminator
When the studio started thinking about who to cast in the lead role of the T-800, an emotionless robot murderer who will stop at nothing to kill a woman and her unborn child, they originally envisioned O.J. Simpson.
Rather chillingly, James Cameron later decided that O.J. was way too likeable and that nobody in their right mind would ever believe him as a killer (uh...). Then Arnold Schwarzenegger's name came up as a possible choice for the role of Kyle Reese, but Cameron deemed him ill-fit due to his size.
Still, Arnie ended up in a meeting with Cameron and - after explaining how he thought O.J. should play the role of the Terminator - Schwarzenegger became the director's top choice for the part of the T-800 instead.
Arnie refused, deeming the part to be "a step backwards." Despite Arnie's obvious acting limitations, he had still managed more interesting parts than "a robot" by 1984, after all - he'd been an barbarian and, heck, he'd played Hercules. He also wanted to focus on playing more heroic roles, and the very evil T-800 was absolutely not the way to do that.
Still, Cameron ultimately managed to convince the actor. Schwarzenegger didn't think much of the role even after signing on (he referred to it as "sh*t"), but - upon seeing the final film - was won over by its genius.
8. Bill Murray Ignored Requests To Play Bob For Five Months - Lost In Translation
For her dreamy romantic comedy Lost in Translation, Sofia Coppola wrote the part of melancholic film star Bob Harris with Bill Murray specifically in mind.
In fact, the filmmaker even said that, had Murray refused to part, she would have scrapped the film entirely. Coppola having such a definitive position on the matter sounds a little over the top, but there is a high chance that the film simply wouldn't have worked without Murray in the lead role.
Though he didn't actively turn down the role of Bob in the same way that many of the other actors on this list did, he might as well have, given that he ignored Coppola's calls, emails and letters for an insane period of five months as she frantically attempted to enlist him for the part.
Murray is known for the fact that he doesn't have an agent; he has an answering machine where anybody who wants to offer him a role leaves a message and hopes and prays that the actor gets back to him. In the case of Lost in Translation, he didn't call back Coppola for almost half a year.
To the director's joy, Murray eventually got in touch, as he ultimately decided that he couldn't face letting her down on her dream project, and - without actually signing a contract - verbally agreed to fly Tokyo a few weeks later.
No contract? Coppola must've been a nervous wreck waiting for him!
7. Daniel Day-Lewis Thought His Playing Lincoln Was "Preposterous" - Lincoln
"It's preposterous."
Those were the words uttered by the man who is Oscar-bait incarnate, Daniel Day-Lewis, upon hearing that Steven Spielberg wanted him to play Abraham Lincoln. Deeming himself to be totally and utterly wrong for the part in every way, the legendary actor turned down the world's most famous director (not something that happens every day, I'm sure) and went on his merry way.
For a while, Liam Neeson, who had worked with Spielberg on Schindler's List to great success, was a forerunner for the part, but Neeson drifted from the project as the years went by and ultimately bailed out when he figured he was too old to play the 19th century President.
When he began mounting the project again in 2009, Spielberg once again went back to Day-Lewis, who, once again, said no. It was at this point that Spielberg decided to enlist the help of a friend - some guy named Leonardo DiCaprio - who, himself having worked with Spielberg on Catch Me If You Can, proceeded to call up Day-Lewis and convince him that he was making a huge mistake.
The rest, as they say, is history. Literally. 'Cause it's a period piece.
6. Ben Affleck Was Afraid To Play Batman After Daredevil - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice
After the 2003 movie adaptation of Daredevil was met with such critical distain, Ben Affleck became the laughing stock of Hollywood. Though he was by no means the worst thing about the film, he was at the centre of the massacre, so to speak; when Daredevil failed, so did Affleck (Bennifer didn't help).
You can understand why he was anxious to play another iconic superhero - the most iconic superhero of all, even - in the wake of such of disaster, which is why Affleck originally turned down Warner Bros.' offer to play the Dark Knight in Batman V Superman, claiming he didn't see himself in the role.
The studio, however, were convinced that Ben - following his recent successes as an actor, director, writer and producer - was the right man for the job and feverishly pursued the star of (ahem) Gigli as their leading man. Eventually, they wore him down, and Affleck - despite the objections of millions of fans - was announced as the new Bruce Wayne/Batman.
Though the film was ultimately panned by critics and received mixed reviews from fans, Affleck did not: many deemed him to be the best thing about the film, with some even declaring him to be the best Batman to have graced the big screen.
5. Timothy Dalton Thought He Was Too Young To Play Bond - The Living Daylights
Timothy Dalton's name will be forever synonymous with that of James Bond. Which is surprising, really, given how he only played the part twice. Oh, and also as the actor showed a hefty amount of resistance when it came to, you know, agreeing to play the part.
Dalton was first offered the role of James Bond almost twenty years before he actually signed on for The Living Daylights, you see, in the wake of Sean Connery's departure as the iconic British secret agent. Whilst any normal person would have presumably said yes to such an offer and got stuck into filming On Her Majesty's Secret Service, Dalton turned down the part on account of his age.
"I was about 24 or 25, which is too young," Dalton said. "But when you've seen Bond from the beginning, you don't take over from Sean Connery."
A fair point, especially when you consider that the next Bond - George Lazenby - only played the character once before he was booted out.
In 1980, Dalton was asked to play Bond again, but he refused on the grounds that the franchise had taken a silly turn. It would not be until six years later that the actor would finally relent. With Roger Moore retired and the producers' first choice, Pierce Brosnan, unable to commit, Dalton agreed to play 007. What a journey.
4. Henry Fonda Wasn't Comfortable Playing A Villain - Once Upon A Time In The West
When Once Upon A Time in the West went into production, Henry Fonda was renowned as a typical nice guy, having played a good number of strong-willed, moral gentlemen across the span of a successful Hollywood career.
Most famously, he appeared as Juror No. 12 in Sidney Pollack's 12 Angry Men, which pretty much cemented his reputation as "the heroic type."
Trust Italian filmmaker Sergio Leone to want to shake things up by casting Fonda in the role of the ruthless and cold-blooded killer Frank in his western magnus opus, having envisioned a scene in which a man shoots a child, only for the camera to pan up and reveal the face of Henry Fonda. Gasp!
Naturally concerned for his nice guy image, however, Fonda turned down Leone's request for him to play the villain, but that didn't stop him: the director flew to Hollywood to meet with Fonda, and explained his idea for the character's reveal. Fonda still wasn't sure, but - at the insistence of Eli Wallach, who played Tuco in The Good, the Bad and the Ugly - he eventually agreed. So we have Tuco to thank.
3. Tom Hanks Turned Down Josh Baskin Due To Scheduling Conflicts - Big
Before Tom Hanks did comedy-drama, he did outright comedy, and his most famous role from those early years is probably that of Josh Baskin in Big.
Big tells the story of a kid who is transformed into an adult to hilarious consequences, and it's one of the roles that - despite having played tons of iconic characters across the years - Tom Hanks fans always seem to go back to.
Hanks wasn't actually the first choice for the part of Josh, believe it or not. Before he was cast, the studio considered everyone from Clint Eastwood (?) to Robin Williams (makes sense). What they really wanted, however, was for Harrison Ford to star in a film directed by Steven Spielberg, but both men were uninterested in the idea and passed.
When the film eventually came around to Tom Hanks, he immediately signed on, convinced that the project would be a hit. Just kidding: he was forced to turn it down due to a scheduling conflict, and the project moved in Robert De Niro's direction. When DeNiro asked for too much money, it eventually came back around to Hanks, who agreed to play Josh Baskin for the sum of $2 million.
Big was the movie that made Hanks a star in Hollywood, so good thing that De Niro was being greedy, or we might have missed out a lot of amazing '90s films.
2. Richard Harris Didn't Want To Be Remembered For Playing A Wizard - Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone
There are some who think that Michael Gambon was the better Dumbledore, but true Harry Potter fans know that Richard Harris was born to play the part of the greatest wizard who ever lived. Gambon was far too aggressive for the role, while Harris brought the appropriate amount of wisdom and heart.
However, the actor at first never envisioned himself in the place of Harry's confidant and mentor, turning turned down the role a number of times due to his fading health... and because he didn't want to be purely remembered for playing a wizard in a franchise he thought to be a bit silly.
Harris eventually decided to sign on for one simple, sentimental reason: his granddaughter. As a huge Potter fan, she was (rightly) peeved that her grandfather was continually turning down the opportunity to play Albus freakin' Dumbledore and pushed him to do it. Which he did, of course - though sadly Harris only got to feature as Dumbledore twice. He died before shooting on the third film commenced, and was replaced by Gambon.
Still, hell of a final role, and - against his wishes - probably the one he'll be most remembered for.
1. Leonardo DiCaprio Didn't Believe He Could Pull Off Jack Dawson - Titanic
Part of what made Titanic such a success at the box office probably stemmed from the fact that females of all ages went back to see it a bunch of times. You know, on account of Leonardo DiCaprio's Jack Dawson. As the embodiment of "gorgeous," Titanic might never have soared to such heights had they cast, like, Steve Buscemi in the lead role of the charming vagabond.
It might well be shocking to discover that Leonardo DiCaprio originally turned down the part of Jack, however, because he wasn't convinced he had the acting ability to pull it off. Given that he's regarded as one of the best actors of his generation nowadays, that seems kind of funny in retrospect.
Just as was the case with Arnold Schwarzenegger and the T-800, though, James Cameron wasn't taking no for an answer: he obviously realised that casting DiCaprio would be important to the success of Titanic, and set about convincing the actor to play his leading man.
At Cameron's insistence, DiCaprio was eventually won around to the idea, and - when the film finally came out - he shot to stardom. Posters of his face adorned the walls of every home with a teenage girl living in it, and DiCaprio was rendered a Hollywood heartthrob of the highest order. Bet he's glad he agreed to it now.
Which other actors took serious convincing to take on iconic roles? Share an we missed down in the comments.