10 Actors Who Rightly Turned Down Iconic Roles

They passed on great characters, but thankfully their replacements made them legendary.

Hugh Jackman Bond
Eon

We’ve looked previously at actors who missed out on iconic roles in both film and television, but this time it’s slightly different. Then, there were a plethora of reasons involved. Tom Selleck couldn’t play Indiana Jones because of scheduling conflicts with Magnum, PI for example.

Elsewhere, Chris Rock was a front runner for George Constanza In Seinfeld, before one of the executives decided he’d be wrong for the part. Richard Lewis even lost out on Mork because he couldn’t do a Martian accent without sounding like he was speaking Danish.

This time though, it’s actors who were specifically offered roles or even cast in parts, before they personally turned it down. There were some on the previous two lists which fall under this category (Matt LeBlanc as Phil Dunphy in Modern Family, for example), but all ten included here with be brand new.

Casting and recasting is a part of showbiz after all, but with these ten it definitely worked out for the best. These roles are so iconic it’s difficult to imagine them being played by anyone else. Turns out though, they all almost were.

10. Leonardo DiCaprio - Patrick Bateman (American Psycho)

Leonardo DiCaprio American Pyscho
Lionsgate

Leonardo DiCaprio and Christian Bale have both established themselves as two of the best character actors of the 21st Century, either as standout supporting characters or as the stars. Despite DiCaprio’s good looks, he’s more than willing to get his hands dirty in movies like Django Unchained, The Revenant and The Departed.

However, back in the late ‘90s, DiCaprio had just become one of the biggest stars on the planet thanks to Titanic, a role which made him a major heartthrob. He was all set to take that momentum with him into American Psycho, before his entourage encouraged him to drop out.

It didn’t really do to have the world’s biggest teen dream chasing around murdering girls with chainsaws after all, did it?

After Leo left, Christian Bale stepped up and made the role his own, inhabiting the truly twisted mind of Patrick Bateman better than anyone could have. Two years later in 2002, DiCaprio starred in Gangs Of New York and began shedding his heartthrob image to take on more serious, gritty parts.

Skipping American Psycho seems to have worked out well not only for him, but for Christian Bale too.


9. Emma Watson - Mia (La La Land)

Emma Watson La La Land
Warner Bros/Summit Entertainment

Emma Stone’s role as Mia in La La Land will forever be iconic, if for nothing more than the fact the envelope containing her Oscar win was mistakenly reused for Best Picture, leading to Warren Beatty incorrectly announcing that La La Land had won the award. It eventually went to Moonlight, although no one seems to remember that.

That all may have been avoided if the Emma originally offered the role, Emma Watson, had taken the part. Not that Watson definitely wouldn’t have secured an Oscar win, but based on their careers so far it appears Watson is a bigger box office draw while Stone has displayed more talent.

Not just in La La Land, but projects like The Help, Maniac and Birdman.

Watson’s reasons for turning Mia down seem reasonable enough. After several months practising her horse riding and singing for Beauty & The Beast, Watson didn’t want to pick up another rehearsal and routine heavy role at the same time.

La La Land was hugely hyped upon release, and like many films its reception has since been soured, either because of oversaturation or just because it failed to live up to that hype. Still, it’s an iconic movie in its own right.


8. Will Smith - Neo (The Matrix)

Will Smith Neo Matrix
Warner Bros.

Tied arguably with John Wick, playing Neo in The Matrix was probably the biggest role of Keanu Reeves’ career. However, Will Smith was very nearly the one, not Keanu.

Will Smith has awesome staying power as well as star power, managing to be one of the biggest names in Hollywood for over a decade. He still draws a crowd these days, but from the mid ‘90s to the late ‘00s, there wasn’t really anyone bigger.

So when the Wachowski’s went to Warner Brothers with The Matrix, Warner Brothers went straight to Smith. Unfortunately for him (but fortunately for those of us who love Keanu in the role), he didn’t understand the script at all, and so gave it a hard pass.

In Smith’s defence, the script was originally more complicated, so much so that Warner Brothers didn’t even get it. Neo was originally supposed to gender flip outside the matrix (the whole movie is a transition parable), and the ‘humans as batteries’ was originally a harder to grasp but more logical ‘human synapses running a super computer’ angle.

By rejecting The Matrix, Smith instead picked up the messy Wild Wild West, although that disaster didn’t damage his career any.


7. Thomas Jane - Don Draper (Mad Men)

Thomas Jane Mad Men
AMC

These days, Jon Hamm is a much bigger name than Thomas Jane. Things definitely weren’t always that way though. In fact, when Hamm walked into the room to audition for Mad Men lead Don Draper, he apparently got the feeling most of the AMC executives didn’t even recognise him.

Had Thomas Jane not turned down the part first though, he likely would’ve never even been in that room. It’s fitting that this is the only TV entry on the list, given Jane’s (or at least Jane’s peoples’) dismissive view of the format.

Speaking on the WTF podcast, Jon Hamm claimed Jane’s agent had turned the role down, telling AMC curtly ‘Thomas Jane doesn’t do television’. However, in 2009, just two years after Mad Men premiered, Thomas Jane did indeed to television with Hung, which was far less successful than Mad Men. Following that, he featured in Texas Rising and The Expanse, also on television.

‘Now starring in Hung, by the way’, Hamm added on WTF, recalling his brilliant ‘I don’t think about you at all’ zinger on Mad Men. Given how everything has worked out since, he’s got a right to be smug about it.


6. Reese Witherspoon - Sidney Prescott (Scream)

Reese Witherspoon Scream
Dimension Films

Scream might look a little campy and dated now, but back in 1996 it was revolutionary for the horror genre. Part of that was casting a huge name like Drew Barrymore, then killing her off in the opening scene.

Barrymore was originally slated to play lead character Sidney Prescott, but it was her who suggested recasting her as the first scene victim, to keep audiences on their toes. Director Wes Craven loved this idea, but it meant he had to cast another actress as Sidney at the last minute.

A then relatively unknown Reese Witherspoon was sought, but she turned it down as she didn’t want to do a horror film. 23 years later, she still hasn’t been in one.

The role of Sidney Prescott eventually went to Neve Campbell, who’s appeared in all four instalments of the franchise and has pretty much been known as ‘that Scream girl’ since 1996.

Though she’s been in other things as well, arguably her biggest non-Scream role came even earlier, in The Craft, which came out just a couple of months prior. Given how iconic she made Sidney and how well Witherspoon’s career has done since, this decision seems like it worked out best for all concerned.


5. Mel Gibson - Maximus Decimus Meridius (Gladiator)

Mel Gibson Gladiator
Universal Pictures

Mel Gibson cuts a very controversial figure these days, his name in tatters after his strange drunken tirade about Jewish people and domestic abuse filings by then wife Oksana Grigoreiva in 2010. This also led to a rather nasty phone call being unearthed, where Gibson suggested if Grigoreiva was ‘raped by n*****s’ it would be her own fault.

His career tanked for a while but has since recovered, somehow. Leaving aside what you can and can’t get away with in Hollywood though, it’s undeniable that Gibson was once very hot property. So much so that Ridley Scott sought him out specifically for the lead role as Maximus in 2000’s Gladiator.

Gibson had fairly recently impressed audiences in Braveheart, and so did tick a lot of the boxes. Gibson himself though disagreed, turning the role down graciously, citing his age.

Gibson would have been between 42 and 43 when Gladiator was filming, and with the movie more action heavy than Braveheart, he simply didn’t feel he was up do it. When you look at how magnificent Russell Crowe was in the role, it’s hard to have any regrets.


4. Gwyneth Paltrow - Rose (Titanic)

Gwyneth Paltrow Titanic
Paramount Pictures

This one is a little bit strange, though given that it’s Gwyneth Paltrow, that shouldn’t come as a surprise. From unique names for her children to her Goop brand and even forgetting she’d been in Spider-Man, Paltrow is a little bit kooky underneath her classic Hollywood glamour.

During an interview with Howard Stern, Paltrow discussed some of the biggest roles of her career, including a couple she missed out on. Paltrow claimed to have been offered the female lead in Boogie Nights, as well as Rose in Titanic. Ironically enough, Titanic star DiCaprio turned down a role in Boogie Nights too, which might have made the cut here were he not already here for Patrick Bateman.

The reason Paltrow turned down the part though remains unclear. When pressed, she simply said her mother (actress Blythe Danner) wouldn’t want her discussing it, as turning down roles is ‘unladylike’. If nothing else, this gives us quite the insight into Paltrow’s upbringing.

Considering the role was Kate Winslet’s big break and how passionately the Brit had campaigned for the part, she definitely seems a better fit for Rose. Besides, it clearly didn’t damage Paltrow’s career, regardless of what her mother might think.


3. Sean Connery - Gandalf (The Lord Of The Rings)

Sean Connery Lord Of The Rings
Eon/New Line Cinema

Sean Connery turning down the role of Gandalf in The Lord Of The Rings was definitely right for audiences, as it meant we got to enjoy the brilliant performance of Sir Ian McKellen. Surprisingly, Connery himself still feels it was the right decision too, even after it cost him $450 million dollars.

‘I read the book, I read the script, I saw the film. I still don’t understand it. Ian McKellen, I believe, is marvellous in it’, Connery said of the casting. Very gracious, considering the bumper pay day he missed out on.

How exactly was he offered so much though? Well, as well as a large (but fairly standard for an actor of his standing) salary of $6 million per movie, Connery was further enticed by Peter Jackson offering him a whopping 15% of the trilogy’s gross.

With huge ticket sales, that 15% would’ve meant an eye watering amount of cash in Connery’s pocket.

Of course, you could make the argument that with Connery tagged in for McKellen, The Lord Of The Rings wouldn’t have grossed as much. Still, good luck telling Sean Connery the movie would’ve done worse with him aboard.


2. John Krasinski & Emily Blunt - Captain America & Black Widow (MCU)

John Krasinski Captain America
Marvel Studios

Recent rumours have been swirling that husband and wife duo John Krasinski and Emily Blunt could be joining the MCU in the not too distant future, playing on screen couple Reed Richards and Sue Storm. They seem perfect for the Fantastic Four, but both have previously turned down MCU roles.

Krasinski got as far as a wardrobe test for Captain America, but it was after seeing himself in the costume that Krasinski turned it down. Despite his all American good looks and ability to bulk up (13 Hours and Jack Ryan prove as much), Krasinski felt he didn’t look like a Captain America and left the project.

Emily Blunt, meanwhile, was offered Black Widow at the same time she was offered Gulliver’s Travels, and apparently felt it was too soon in her career to move into action. Sicario and Edge Of Tomorrow show that’s no longer the case.

Eventual castees Chris Evans and Scarlett Johansson had been friends for years prior to their MCU team up. That chemistry was clear to see on screen. Even the real life marriage of Blunt and Krasinski might not have bettered it. Hopefully it’s kept the Krasinski-Blunts clear for the Fantastic Four roles they seem made for.


1. Hugh Jackman - James Bond (Casino Royal)

Hugh Jackman Bond
Eon

There’s been plenty of talk about who the next James Bond might be, but in another reality, it wouldn’t be Daniel Craig they’d be replacing, but Hugh Jackman.

The Australian actor was approached about playing the super suave spy, and would have been the first non-Brit to play Bond had he accepted. Clint Eastwood was once in the running too in his Dirty Harry days, although that fell through as well.

Daniel Craig, despite being frequently scathing about the role of Bond, has been key to the character’s renaissance. Bond has been rebooted for the 21st Century with a much grittier aesthetic, and as interesting as Jackman’s Bond might have been, it’s probably best not to tinker with the formula.

Jackman turned down Bond as he felt it would limit his options, as he didn’t want to feel boxed in. That’s a fair enough reason on the face of it, considering Jackman has an eclectic filmography including Les Miserables, Chappie, Happy Feet, The Greatest Showman, The Fountain and Eddie The Eagle (and many more besides), plus a plethora of stage work.

However, considering he’s done all that while being universally known as Wolverine, James Bond might not have been as restrictive as he feared.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)